Back
 OJGas  Vol.10 No.4 , April 2020
Therapeutic Route of Patients with Cirrhosis in Bangui
Abstract: Introduction: Cirrhosis is the final stage in the development of any chronic liver disease. The objective of our study was to determine the therapeutic route of patients with cirrhosis. Patients and Methods: This was a one-year cross-sectional study of consenting patients of both sexes with cirrhosis who were hospitalized for the first time. The study took place from October 1, 2013 to September 30, 2014. The diagnosis of cirrhosis was based on clinical, biological and morphological arguments. Results: In total, 1028 patients were hospitalized, including 202 for cirrhosis (19.6%). One hundred and four patients (10.1%) met our inclusion criteria. These were 70 men (67.3%) and 34 women (32.7%). The sex ratio was 2.05. The average age was 43.74 ± 13.74 years. In 68 cases (65.4%), cirrhosis was considered a supernatural disease and in 36 cases (34.6%) was a natural disease. At the first signs, 88 patients (84.6%) had consulted (traditional healer in 34 cases, pastor in 25 cases, marabout in 16 cases and general practitioner in 13 cases). The pastor prayed to 25 patients (24%). The traditional healer made the patients ingest herbal preparations (n = 18), associated or not with scarification (n = 4) and/or enema (n = 28). The marabout recited Quranic verses written on a board, then washed and ingested in 16 cases (15.4%). The general practitioner prescribed treatment to the 13 patients (12.5%). The various treatments received had led to hepatic encephalopathy (21 cases), digestive hemorrhage (15 cases), abdominal pain (3 cases), jaundice (3 cases), increased abdominal bloating (21 cases). The patients had consulted the specialist within an average of 74 ± 15.3 days. The average time to hospital was 21 days ± 13. Conclusion: Cirrhosis is diagnosed at the complication stage due to inappropriate treatment by pastors, marabouts and the general practitioner. The population must be made aware of the early use of health care facilities.

1. Introduction

Cirrhosis is a public health problem due to its frequency and severity. It is one of the leading causes of death from liver disease. In France, the prevalence of cirrhosis is estimated at 2000 to 3300 cases per million inhabitants, with an annual incidence of 150 to 200 cases per million inhabitants [1]. In the USA, the prevalence in the general population is 0.27% [2]. In Africa, hospital prevalence is variable. It was 7.06% in Lomé in Togo [3], 5.9% in Ouagadougou in Burkina Faso [4]. In Bangui, in our department, cirrhosis represents 19.7% of hospitalizations and in 19.1% of cases, the diagnosis of cirrhosis is established at the decompensation stage [5]. This study has focused on understanding why cirrhosis is diagnosed late in our department. For this, we have set ourselves the goal of determining the therapeutic route of patients with cirrhosis admitted for the first time in our department.

2. Patients and Methods

We carried out in the department of hepato-gastroenterology and internal medicine of Bangui “Amitié Sino-Centrafricaine” University, Hospital Center, a cross-sectional study of a duration of 12 months going from October 1, 2013 to September 30, 2014. During this study, we included, consenting patients of both gender hospitalized for the first time for cirrhosis whatever the etiology. The diagnosis of cirrhosis was established on the existence of clinical and biological signs of hepatocellular insufficiency, clinical, ultrasound and endoscopic signs of portal hypertension and the characteristics of the liver (firm or hard, regular, painless liver, thin lower edges or sharp in case of hypertrophic liver). Liver biopsy puncture for pathology analysis and/or non-invasive fibrosis tests has not been performed. Patients already followed in the department for cirrhosis and those admitted for the first time for cirrhosis, but not consenting was not included. Data collection was done using an individual direct administration survey form. The variables studied were the socio-demographic characteristics (age, sex, marital status, religion), the knowledge of patients and those around them on cirrhosis, the course of care, the motivations for care, types of care, development under the former care, the cost of care. Our sample was for convenience of all cases meeting the inclusion criteria. The data was captured and analyzed using Epi Info 2008 software. It obtained frequencies, averages and standard deviation. In case of comparison, the Chi2 test will be used with a significance threshold p < 0.05.

3. Results

During the study period, 1028 patients were hospitalized in the department, including 202 (19.6%) for cirrhosis. Among the patients with cirrhosis, we included 104 patients (10.1%). Cirrhosis was due to the hepatitis B virus in 74 cases (71.2%) including 11 cases associated with alcohol, the hepatitis C virus in 12 cases (11.5%), alcohol in 18 cases (17.3%). Among the 104 patients with cirrhosis, there were 70 men (67.3%) and 34 women (32.7%). The sex ratio was 2.05. The average age of the patients was 43.07 ± 13.82 years. Patients with cirrhosis and their parents did not know about cirrhosis, but claimed in 87 cases (83.6%) that patients with signs of cirrhosis eventually died. Figure 1 shows the distribution by age group.

The religion of cirrhosis patients is shown in Figure 2.

The main clinical signs were abdominal bloating and lower extremity edema in 75 cases (72.1%), jaundice in 18 cases (17.3%), hematemesis in 11 cases (10.6 %). The presence of these signs had led patients to believe in a supernatural origin in 68 cases (65.4%) and a natural origin in 36 cases (43.6%). The supernatural origin was witchcraft in 42 cases (40.4%) and the spell in 26 cases (25%).

Figure 1. Breakdown by tranche of patients with cirrhosis.

Figure 2. Distribution of patients by religion.

As soon as signs of cirrhosis appear, 88 patients (84.6%) should be seen. While 16 patients (15.4%) did not immediately consult due to lack of financial resources in 12 cases (11.5%) and lack of guidance in 4 cases (3.9%). Among the 88 patients who had consulted before arriving at the hospital, 51 (59.8%) were at stage C of Child-Pugh and 37 (40.2%) at stage B. On the other hand, the 16 patients (15.4%) who had not done any consultation before arriving at the hospital were all at Child-Pugh stage C. Table 1 shows the Child-Pugh stages according to the people consulted by the patients.

During the consultation, the pastor, the traditional healer and the marabout stated that the cirrhosis was serious and that healing could only be obtained through prayer respectively; taking traditional plants, scarifying and washing and ingesting black ink from the Quran. Prayer was the only treatment received by the 25 patients who had consulted the pastor. The traditional healer had administered oral herbal teas to patients in 18 cases, by rectal enema in 28 cases and by scarifications in 4 cases. The marabout wrote the prayer on the quanaric table which the patient repeated seven times during the day. Then the prayer on the board is washed and given to each patient to drink. The 75 patients (72.1%) who had not seen the doctor at the first sign, were taking their medication for self-medication with street drugs. These were nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) in 52 cases (69.3%) sometimes associated with diuretics in 37 cases. Fifteen of 75 patients (20%) were only taking diuretics. The course of the disease in patients treated with the traditional healer was stationary in 9 cases and marked by the appearance of complications in 25 cases. Complications were in order of frequency hepatic encephalopathy in 13 cases (53.3%), digestive hemorrhage in 9 cases (36.7%), abdominal pain in 3 cases (10%). Among the 16 patients treated with marabout, 2 (12.5%) had a stationary course and 14 (87.5%) had presented complications which were hepatic encephalopathy in 7 cases (50%), digestive hemorrhage in 5 cases (35.7%), jaundice in 2 cases (14.3%). The 25 patients treated by the pastor’s prayer had a stationary state in 4 cases, while 21 had presented complications including hepatic encephalopathy in 10 cases (47.6%), digestive hemorrhage in 6 cases (28.6%), worsening ascites in 5 cases (23.8%). Among the 25 patients who were taking non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs at the same time, 22 patients (88%) had experienced digestive hemorrhage. The failure of different treatments and/or the occurrence of

Table 1. Distribution of patients by people consulted.

complications led patients to consult within an average of 74 ± 15.3 days. Hospital consultations were motivated by the lack of improvement in 55 cases (52.9%), the parents’ decision in 41 cases (39.4%) and the healer’s advice in 8 cases (7.7%). After hospital care, 47 patients (45.2%) believed that they had noticed a marked improvement in their condition. In contrast, 57 patients (54.8%) had seen no improvement. The average length of hospital stay was 21.5 ± 13 days. The average cost of hospital care was 149,175 CFA francs (227.41?. The average cost of care at the pastor or marabout was 106,575 FCA (162.47? not including payments in kind (kid, chicken, valuables such as mobile phones, costumes, luxury watches, jewelry in gold…).

4. Discussion

However, our study has some limitations. Patients arriving at an advanced stage of the disease would certainly not have given all the information about their care pathway. We did not perform the liver biopsy puncture for histological analysis, which in our context should only be done, by the transcutaneous route. The presence of ascites in our patients was a contraindication to liver biopsy puncture. The presence of clinical and biological signs of hepatocellular insufficiency, clinical, ultrasound and endoscopic signs of portal hypertension and in the case of a large firm or hard, regular, painless liver with a thin or sharp lower edge or a liver of normal size of an altered echostructure or an atrophic liver on ultrasound, it was easy for us to remember the diagnosis of cirrhosis. The French High Authority for Health recommends that in the event of concurring epidemiological, clinical and morphological arguments, the diagnosis of cirrhosis can be accepted without resorting to liver biopsy puncture [1]. It was also difficult for us to accurately assess the cost of care. However, this study, the first in Bangui, allowed us to contribute to improving the management of cirrhosis by understanding why our patients reach a complicating stage.

The hospital frequency of cirrhosis of 19.6% in our study is similar to that already reported in the department, which was 19.7% [4]. Our frequency is lower than that observed in Cotonou which is 22.6% [6]. Cirrhosis is the most common liver disease in hospitals in sub-Saharan Africa. The primary cause of cirrhosis in our study is the virus in hepatitis B (71.2%). The authors in Lomé in Togo [3], in Ouagadougou in Burkina Faso [4], in Cotonou in Benin [6], in Pointe Noire in Congo Brazzaville [7] and in Kindia in Guinea [8] also reported that HBV is the number one cause of cirrhosis. While in France [1] and the USA [2], cirrhosis is caused by HCV and alcohol. The etiological difference of cirrhosis between the West and Sub-Saharan Africa is explained by the fact that Sub-Saharan Africa is in the zone of high endemicity for HBV. Men had twice as much cirrhosis as women in our series. The predominance of men in our study corroborates the data in the literature [3] [4] [6] [7] [8] [9]. The average age of our patients was 43.07 ± 13.82 years. It is similar to that reported by the authors in Bamako which is 43.7 ± 15.3 years [10], but lower than that of patients in Lomé [3] and in Cotonou [6] who is 49 years and in Tunis 58 years old [11]. In France, the average age at the time of diagnosis of cirrhosis is 55 years [1]. Patients aged 40 or less made up half the sample in our series. These results show that cirrhosis is more common in young adults in sub-Saharan Africa. The patients were Christians in 49% of the cases, animists in 35.6% of the cases and Muslims in 15.4 of the cases. The high proportion of Christians in our work would probably be linked to the fact that, the Central African Republic is a country with a Christian majority and that the patients orient themselves according to their religious affiliation. The most frequent clinical signs presented by the patients were abdominal bloating reflecting ascites in 75 cases (72.1%), jaundice in 18 cases (17.3%), hematemesis in 11 cases (10.6%). Ascites and jaundice were the main symptoms reported by the authors in Lomé in Togo [3], in Ouagadougou in Burkina Faso [4], in Cotonou in Benin [6] and in Bamako in Mali [9]. These signs led patients to believe in a supernatural origin (65.4%) due to witchcraft (40.4%) and bewitchment (25%). These beliefs had led patients to resort to non-medical care (pastor, traditional healer, marabout), thus delaying treatment in a hospital environment. The various treatments received by patients before arrival at the hospital were responsible for complications, notably hepatic encephalopathy and digestive hemorrhage. Hepatic encephalopathy was the formidable complication observed in 74.6% among cirrhotics in Bamako [12]. It was observed in 31.2% in Lomé in Togo [3]. It could certainly in our series related to digestive hemorrhage, delay in consultation and traditional treatment. In our study like those of other authors [6], the majority of patients arrived at stage B and C of Child-Pugh. It reflects the advanced stage at which the diagnosis is made in our communities. The average duration of out-of-hospital care was 74 days ± 15.3. While the average length of hospital stay was 21.5 ± 13 days. In Lomé, 78.1% of patients consulted one year after the development of cirrhosis [3]. These patients would certainly seek other care before arriving at the hospital. The population should be made aware of the early use of health care facilities in order to minimize the cost of care. Patients arrive at the hospital after spending too much on healers, marabouts or pastors. This could explain the fact that patients were no longer able to manage themselves in hospital. The average cost of hospital care was 149,175 CFA francs (227.41?. This cost is lower than that already estimated in the service, which was 194,170 f CFA (236? [13]. In Brazzaville, the hospital cost of hospital treatment for uncomplicated cirrhosis is 205,615 CFA francs (313.9? and varies depending on the mode of decompensation [14]. The difference is explained by the financial difficulty experienced by patients to perform certain additional examinations.

5. Conclusion

The late diagnosis of cirrhosis in our context is linked to prejudices, in particular witchcraft and bewitchment, which push patients first to non-medical care, sources of complications leading them later to consultation in hospital. It is important to raise awareness among the population about the early use of health care structures in the event of illness and also to set up a system of health cover making it possible to facilitate access to quality care for the population.

Investigation Sheet on Therapeutic Route of Patients with Cirrhosis in Bangui

Cite this paper: Police, S. , Guérendo, P. , Service, G. , Elowa, B. , Adouaka, G. , Mofini, E. , Kalebanga, A. , Boua-Akelelo, N. , Bessanguem, B. and Molowa Kobendo, J. (2020) Therapeutic Route of Patients with Cirrhosis in Bangui. Open Journal of Gastroenterology, 10, 88-96. doi: 10.4236/ojgas.2020.104009.
References

[1]   Haute Autorité de Santé (2008) Guide affection longue durée: cirrhoses 2008.
http://www.conf-plus.com/1011/fichiers/CS_GASTRO_10_d1.pdf

[2]   Scaglione, S., Kliethermes, S., Cao, G., et al. (2015) The Epidemiology of Cirrhosis in the United States: A Population-Based Study. Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology, 49, 690-696.
https://doi.org/10.1097/MCG.0000000000000208

[3]   Bouglouga, O., Bany, A., Djibril, M.A., et al. (2012) Aspects épidémiologiques, diagnostiques et évolutifs de la cirrhose hépatique dans le service d’hépato-gastro-entérologie du CHU Campus de Lomé. Journal de Recherches Scientifiques de l’Université de Lomé (Togo), Série D, 14, 1-7.

[4]   Serme, A.K., Ilboudo, P.D., Bougouma, A., et al. (2002) Cirrhosis in a National Teaching Hospital Yalgado Ouedraogo (CNHYO): Epidemiological and Clinical Aspects. Médecine d’Afrique Noire, 49, 481-486.

[5]   Camengo Police, S.M., Koffi, B., Boua-Akelelo, N.P., et al. (2014) Complications of the Cirrhosis to the University Hospital “Amitié” of Bangui. Médecine d’Afrique Noire, 61, 537-542.

[6]   Sehonou, J., Kodjoh, N., Sake, K., et al. (2010) Liver Cirrhosis in Cotonou, Republic of Benin: Clinical Aspects and Factors Related to Death. Médecine Tropicale, 70, 375-378.

[7]   Bossali, F., Koumou Okandze, L., Katende, S., et al. (2011) Seroprevalence of Hepatitis B in Patients with Cirrhosis and Patients with Hepatocellular Carcinoma in Pointe-Noire 2005-2008. Journal Africain d’Hépatologie Gastroentérologie, 5, 2-5.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12157-010-0224-4

[8]   Diallo, A.A.S., Meliho, C., Sylla, A.I., et al. (2018) Cirrhosis of the Liver: Epidemiological, Diagnostic and Progressive Characteristics in the Service of General Medicine at Kindia Regional Hospital (Guinea). Journal of African Clinical cases and Reviews Africa, 2, 240-250.

[9]   Diarra, M., Maïga, M.Y. and Konaté, A. (2010) Aspects évolutifs des malades cirrhotiques dans un service d’Hépato-gastroentérologie au Mali. Mali Médical, XXV, 42-46.

[10]   Maïga, M.Y., Dembele, M., Traoré, H.A., et al. (2002) Upper Digestive Endoscopy in the Diagnosis of Cirrhosis. Acta Endoscopica, 32, 211-218.
http://hdl.handle.net/2042/7506
https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03016657


[11]   Ennaifer, R., Cheikh, M., Romdhane, H., et al. (2016) L’hyponatrémie au cours de la cirrhose: Facteurs de risque et valeur pronostique. La Tunisie Médicale, 94, 401-405.

[12]   Katilé, D., Dicko, M.Y., Doumbia Samake, K., et al. (2017) Hepatic Encephalopathy in Cirrhosis in Bamako. Journal Africain d’Hépatologie Gastroentérologie, 11, 78-80.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12157-017-0709-5

[13]   Camengo Police, S.M., Mbeko Simaleko, M., Boua-Akelelo, N.P., et al. (2013) The Cirrhosis and Her Complications to the Academic Hospital of the Friendship of Bangui: Survey of the Financial Cost of the Old in Charge. Journal Africain d’Hépatologie Gastroentérologie, 7, 78-81.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12157-013-0454-3

[14]   Atipo-Ibara, B.I., Ondele-Ngoli, A., Deby-Gassaye, et al. (2004) Cost of Managing Cirrhosis and Related Complications at the University Hospital in Brazzaville, Congo. Médecine Tropicale, 64, 50-52.

 
 
Top