JEP  Vol.10 No.10 , October 2019
Study the Changes in Soil Organic Carbon of Rice-Maize Cropping System in the Top Layer of Alluvisol Soil in Dan Phuong: A Study of C-13 Stable Isotope Composition (δ13C)
Abstract: In this study, the experiments on field were conducted to examine the change in the content of soil organic carbon (SOC), its C-13 stable isotope composition (δ 13C) and some main physical, chemical parameters (soil moisture, pH, soil density, content of humic, fulvic, total N, total P, total K) in alluvial soil of Dan Phuong region—Vietnam at a depth of 0 - 30 cm when we changed the regime from 2 maize -1 rice crop to 2 rice - 1 maize crop per 1 year. In addition to analyzing the main parameters in soil, C content and its δ 13C value in parts of rice and maize (root, stem and leaf) were also analyzed to assess the contribution of plant residues on soil organic carbon content after harvest. The experiment was carried out in 2016-2017 on the field with the traditional farming method of local farmers along with the tropical monsoon weather conditions of the North-Vietnam. The results showed that SOC had positive correlation with total N, total P parameters and negative correlation with δ 13C values of soil samples at two layers (0 - 15 cm and 15 - 30 cm). The average of total dry biomass (stem, stump + roots and leaf parts) per 1 rice and 1 maize crop was 10.64 Mg/ha and 9.09 Mg/ha, respectively. The average of δ 13C value of rice (C3 plant) was -29.78‰ and its value of maize (C4 plant) was -12.61‰. The new plant (rice) contributes to the total soil organic carbon content from 11.31% to 44.14% at the 0 - 15 cm layer and from 6.55% to 11.31% at the 15 - 30 cm layer in one-year experiment period.

1. Introduction

In soil science, soil organic carbon (SOC) plays a very important role in soil structure, soil chemical and physical characteristics and soil fertility [1] [2] . In soil-crop ecosystems, SOC storage reflects the net balance between ongoing carbon (C) accumulation resulting from inputs of crop biomass (aboveground, belowground) and/or exogenous organic matter (e.g., manure, straw) and soil C decomposition processes due to microbial oxidation [3] [4] .

Stable isotope ratio of 13C/12C in SOC expressed in the delta notation (δ13CSOC)—a natural tracer, is interested in many areas of research on environmental processes such as carbon sinks and photosynthetic mechanisms of plants [5] [6] , assessing the carbon reservoir turnover times and soil carbon dynamic in agroforestry ecosystems, methods of fixation and storage of carbon dioxide in soils [1] [6] [7] [8] [9] or exploring soil mineralization processes [10] . Plant species (C3, C4 and CAM plants) differ in their isotopic 13C values due to isotopic discrimination by their photosynthetic enzymes and the regulation of the diffusion resistance of their stomata. C3 plants (rice, wheat, soybean …) have δ13C average value of −27‰ (−35‰ to −20‰), C4 plants (sugarcane, corn …) have δ13C average value of −13‰ (−15‰ to −7‰) [11] [12] . For topsoil calculations, SOM has stable carbon isotopic composition comparable to that of the source plant material and changes in the proportion of C3 and C4 plants will result in a corresponding change in the δ13CSOC. Therefore, δ13C value of SOM can be used to study C turnover in soils in areas where C3 vegetation was replaced by C4 plants or vice versa [11] .

Furthermore, the cultivation models such as intensive farming, intercropping, crop rotation (C3, C4 plant) and agricultural practices will affect the total SOC budget, nutrient cycling, soil-water relationships, erosion processes and carbon sequestration. Such information is important to determine impacts of land use on the sustainability of cropping systems, and its feedbacks to future climate changes.

The use of stable 13C isotope techniques to study above issues is not new in the world but it is still quite new in Vietnam. Therefore, in this paper, we applied the 13C stable isotope technique to study changes in soil organic carbon at 0 - 30 cm depth from maize-rice-maize crop system to rice-rice-maize crop system of alluvial soil in Dan Phuong area. This is a type of soil that accounts for a large proportion of Vietnam agricultural soil which has high C sequestration potential and reduces greenhouse gas (CO2, CH4) in agro-ecosystem.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Crop Management

The experimental site was implemented on agricultural soil at Dan Phuong district (21˚06'21.0''N, 105˚39'45.0''E)—a suburban area of Hanoi city, Vietnam for 2 years (2016 and 2017). This area has been growing crop sequence of maize - maize-rice for approximately 10 years.

The experiment site has a tropical monsoon climate with an average annual precipitation of 1721 mm, an average annual temperature of 25.14˚C, atmosphere humidity of 75.58% and a mean annual sunshine hour of 1207 h (according to the Report of Center for Agricultural Meteorological Research, Institute of Hydrometeorology and Climate Change). The soil profile of the experimental site was classified as alluvial soil of the Red river or Eutric Fluvisol (FAO, 1990). Rice-rice-maize or maize-rice-maize cropping system was the most important cropping system in the region.

Briefly, rice (Khang Dan 18 variety) and maize (HN88 variety) rotation were planted in plots of 120 m2 each with 3 replicates. The experiment included 3 treatments in 2017: 1) initial soil condition: maize-rice-maize cropping system no plant return; 2) rice-rice-maize cropping (RRM-NR) no plant return; and 3) rice-rice-maize (RRM-R) with plant return during a 1-year cultivation.

Each cropping season took around 3.5 months. Leaves, stems and roots of maize and rice from the previous crops were ploughed into the soil after harvest. Maize (HN88 variety) was grown with a plant spacing of 25 cm and a row spacing of 75 cm. The chemical fertilizer 16-16-8 (16%N; 16%P2O5; 8%K2O content) was applied for maize at the rate of 500 kg/ha (divided in three times), the 166 kg/ha single fertilizer P2O5 was used 3 days after planting and the single fertilizer K2O was applied 45 days after planting at the rate of 166 kg/ha. Rice seedlings (Khang Dan 18 variety) were transplanted by hand with three plants/hill and a spacing of 20 cm × 25 cm. Fertilizer was applied 3 times with total 416 kg/ha chemical fertilizer 16-16-8; broadcast application at the rate of 139 kg/ha 1 - 3 days after transplanting (DAT), 165 kg/ha at 12 - 15 DAT and 122 kg/ha at 40 - 45 DAT. Weed eradication was made at 20 and 50 DAT. Pesticide management of both rice and maize seasons was in accordance with the conventional.

2.2. Sampling and Sample Preparation

Soil samples were collected at the beginning and before harvesting crops. Soil samples were taken using a core sampler (6 cm i.d.) to a depth of 30 cm and then it was divided into two layers: 0 - 15 cm and 15 - 30 cm depth. This depth was chosen because it contains most of the root apparatus of rice and maize species. For each crop, three replicates were taken according to a completely randomized experimental design. Each replicate was composed of three subsamples, which were combined. Then, the soil samples were sieved (<4 mm), visible plant debris was removed, and the soils were then air-dried. On the same date, separate samples (50 mm diameter) of undisturbed soil were taken for a bulk density analysis. The samples are spread on stainless steel trays with the use of a stainless-steel spatula, air-dried at room temperature or dried at 40˚C - 50˚C in a ventilated oven for two days. Dried soils were homogenized in ceramic mortar and sieved through 1 mm mesh sieve to remove bricks, stones, gravel and roots. Samples were then ground and sieved through 100 μm mesh sieve, dried the specimen at 50˚C for 24 hours. Finally, samples were subdivided into subsamples for determination pH, soil organic carbon, total N, total P, total K, and carbon stable isotope components in SOC (13C/12C ratio - δ13CSOC).

The plant samples were collected at harvesting time for each crop. Random choosing of 10 maize plants or 10 rice clusters of each treatment, rinse and subdivide into 4 parts: root, stem, leave and seeds. Each plant part was cut into 0.5 - 1.0 cm, dried at 40˚C - 50˚C in a ventilated oven until unchanged weight. Dry mass of each part was determined by weight. The dried plant samples were then grounded and sieved through 100 μm mesh sieve for carbon stable isotope ratio and percent of C.

2.3. Physiochemical Soil Annalysis

The soil samples were characterized using common methods. The content of clay, silt and sand in the fine soil samples (grains < 2 mm in diameter) was quantified by sedimentation after removing the organic matter in a 30% H2O2 solution (the H2O2 treatment was conducted at 80˚C in a water bath until no further reaction). Soil pH was examined using 1 M KCl (1:2.5, w/v); The soil bulk density (g·cm−3) of the 0 - 15 cm and 15 - 30 cm soil layers was measured by collecting undisturbed soil samples using steeless metal cores of known volume (5-cm internal diameter and 5-cm length). Three core samples were taken at random from each plot. The total nitrogen (TN) and organic carbon (OC) content of the bulk soil were measured by Elemental Analyzer (EA, EuroVector, Italy); we removed inorganic carbon in soil samples by HCl 1N before determination of soil organic carbon. The humic acid and fulvic acid content were determined based on Walkley-Black method—These organic acids were oxidized with excess K2Cr2O7 solution in sulfuric acid then the excess potasium bicromate content were titrated by FeSO4(NH4)2SO4·6H2O solution, thereby deducing humic and fulvic acid content. Based on the acid insoluble nature of humic acid to separate humic acid and identify humic acid content, and then fulvic acid content was calculated. For determining total phosphorus (TP), we used sulfuric acid and perchloric acid to break down and dissolve phosphorus compounds in the soil samples. After that, we measured of phosphorus content in solution by colorimetric method. The total potasium content in soil was digested by a mixture of hydrofluoric acid and pecloric acid. Determination of potassium content in solution by Atomic Absorption Spectrometric (AAS) method, all analytical measurements were performed in triplicate.

2.4. Isotope Analysis of δ13C in Soil and Plants by EA-IRMS

Stable carbon isotopic composition—δ13C values (the proportion of 13C with respect to 12C), measured for soil and plant samples were used to determine the contribution of plant carbon source to soil organic carbon. The rice and maize plant samples and those of the soil samples were dried at 60˚C, ball-milled, passed through a 100-μm sieve, and fumigated with 12 N HCl overnight to remove carbonates [13] [14] . The δ13C of plant and soil samples were analyzed using isotope ratio mass-spectrometer (IRMS, Micromass GV Instrument, UK) equipped with an elemental analyzer (EA, EuroVector, Italy) at the Isotopes Hydrology Laboratory, Institute for Nuclear Sciences and Technology, Vietnam.

The 13C/12C isotope ratio is expressed in the delta notation (δ13C) that was expressed as:

δ 13 C ( ) = ( R sample R standard 1 ) 100 (1)


Rsample is the mole ratio of the [13C]/[12C] in the sample;

Rstandard is the mole ratio of the [13C]/[12C] in the standard.

The standard was Vienna Pee Dee Belemnite (VPDB this is biogenic calcite found in PeeDee fromation in South Carolina (USA) and it was prepared and supplied by IAEA in Vienna, Austria.

With respect to the different cropping treatments, the δ13C values of the SOM were used to calculate the proportion of new C (fnew, i.e., the C derived from current maize/rice residues) and old C(fold = 1 − fnew, soil C present prior to tillage, i.e., C in the initial soil) using a mass balance equation [11] :

f new = δ new δ old δ veg δ o l d 100 % (2)


δnew represents the δ13C values of organic C in soil fractions after 1years of tillage,

δold represents the δ13C values of organic C in the initial soil, i.e., the soil samples prior to tillage,

δveg represents the δ13C values of the mixed samples, including plant materials (maize and/or rice leaves, stems and roots) in both cropping treatment.

2.5. Statistical Analysis

Pearson’s test was used to evaluate the correlation coefficient and differences in means of the soil characteristics: soil humidity, bulk density, pH, humic, fulvic, SOC, TN, TP, TK and δ13C from two depths (0 - 15 and 15 - 30 cm) among three treatments. The statistical analyses were done with SPSS 20.0 software.

3. Results and Discussions

3.1. The Yield and Carbon Content of the Crops and δ13C Values in Plants Samples

Results of seasonal analysis of maize and rice samples (stump + roots, stem and leaf parts) in the study area for 2 years from 2016 to 2017 were showed in Table 1. The average of total dry biomass (stem, stump + roots and leaf parts) per 1 rice crop of 3 models was 10.64 Mg/ ha for 2 years. The average of total dry biomass (stem, root and leaf parts) per 1 maize crop of 3 models was 9.09 Mg/ha for 2 years. The average of δ13C values of rice and maize parts were −29.78‰ and −12.61‰, respectively. These results are completely suitable with the world research on the δ13C value of C3 plants—rice and C4 plants—maize. The different in δ13C value of these plants is the signature for carbon sequestration study.

3.2. Soil Properties of Two Layers

We conducted sampling and analyzing some soil properties according to the depth before and after harvest of some maize-maize-rice and rice-rice-maize cultivation models. The average analysis results of soils in 2016 and 2017 at 2 depths (0 - 15 cm and 15 - 30 cm) of the MRM, RRM-NR and RRM-R models were presented in Table 2 and Table 3. Results showed that there were minor changes in the parameters of pH, SOC, TN, TK and δ13C between 2016 and 2017 of MRM model. In 2017, for the 0 - 15 cm soil layer, the soil organic carbon content increases gradually when shifting from maize-rice-maize and rice-rice-maize cultivation in both forms of no plant return and plant return on the fields (increase from 0.702% to 0.748% and 0.855%, respectively). For the 15 - 30 cm soil layer, the SOC content increased insignificantly from 0.36% to 0.40%. The results also showed that, when shifting to 2 rice crops in a year, the soil pH decreased (5.12 - 5.07 - 4.75) and the isotopic component δ13C of SOC decreased relative to the amount of straw left in the field (−24.43‰, −24.70‰, −26.00‰). In other words, the value of δ13C in the SOC is correlated with the isotopic value δ13C of the plant grown on that soil (the average value of δ13C of maize and rice grown in Dan Phuong were −12.61‰ and −29.78‰, respectively).

Table 1. The average results of rice and maize samples in 2016-2017 of 3 models.

Table 2. The annual average results of 0 - 15 cm soil layer in Dan Phuong.

Table 3. The annual average results of 15 - 30 cm soil layer in Dan Phuong.

Using SPSS 20.0 software for statistical analysis of the correlation between soil moisture content, density, pH, humic, fulvic, SOM, TN, TP, TK and δ13C. Results of soil analysis at a depth of 0 - 15 cm (Table 4) showed that the OC content was positively correlated with the parameters of TN, TP, and fulvic and inversely correlated with δ13C and pH parameters. The results in Table 5 also showed the positive correlation between OC and TN, TP parameters, and inversely correlated with the δ13C parameter. This correlation was consistent with the trend of shifting crops from cultivating of 2 corn crops + 1 rice crop/1 year to cultivating of 2 rice crops + 1 corn crop/1 year.

3.3. The Soil Organic Carbon and Its Relation with δ13C Values

The variation of SOC content of 3 models (MMR, RRM-NR, RRM-R) in 2 soil layers in 2017 was presented in Figure 1 and Figure 2. The results showed that the SOC content tends to decrease during the time of winter-spring season in both depths 0 - 15 cm and 15 - 30 cm and gradually increase during summer-autumn season and reach the highest value in September. Figure 1 and Figure 2 also showed that the content of SOC changes significantly mainly in the soil layer 0 - 15 cm. This was the topsoil that contains most of the plant residues after harvest.

The SOM content and its relation with δ13C in SOM was shown in Figure 3 in. The results showed that SOM content in the 0 - 15 cm soil layer was higher from 2 to 2.5 times than SOM content of the 15 - 30 cm layer and the δ13C value of upper layer was depleted than the δ13C value from 2‰ to 3‰. The depleted δ13C value and the increasing SOC content of the topsoil were due to SOC being decomposed from rice straw and rice roots after harvest (the average δ13C value of rice was −29.78‰). At a depth of 15 - 30 cm, the concentration of SOC was lower than that of the surface layer and the δ13C value of SOC was enriched because this layer was not replenished regularly with plant matter except deep plant roots. In addition, many published works on SOC kinetics show that δ13C values tend to be enriched at deeper layer due to the natural isotope fractionation of the microbial decomposition process of microorganisms and the evaporation process of 12C light isotope of gases such as CO2 and CH4.

Table 4. Pearson Correlations of soil parameters at 0 - 15 cm layer of 3 treatments.

**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed). *. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).

Figure 1. The change in SOC content in 0 - 15 cm layer of 3 models: MMR, RRM-NR, RRM-R in 2017.

Figure 2. The change in SOC content in 15 - 30 cm layer of models: MMR, RRM-NR, RRM-R in 2017.

Figure 3. Relation of SOC & δ13C in 3 treatments of the Dan Phuong alluvial soil in 2017.

3.4. Carbon Sequestration Potential of Rice-Maize Crop Systems

Applying the formula (2) to calculate the amount of C accumulated in the soil layers when shifting the 2 maize - 1 rice crop model to 2 rice - 1 maize crop model with no plant return and plant return in Dan Phuong alluvial soil, the results are obtained in Table 6.

Table 6. Results of SOM sequestered in 0 - 30 cm layers of Rice-rice-maize crop model with no plant return and plant return in 2017.

The δ13CSOMnew value decreased from 1‰ to 1.5‰ when we changed from 2 maize - 1 rice cultivation to 2 rice - 1 maize cultivation in 2017. For the RRM-NR model, the results showed that the average contribution rate of new plants (rice) was about 11.31% at 0 - 15 cm depth, and 6.55% at 15 - 30 cm depth and the total amount of SOM accumulated after 1 year of cultivation on both layers was 2.259 MgC/ha. When leaving rice straw in the field (RRM-R), the average contribution rates of new plants to the total amount of SOM of 0 - 15 cm and 15 - 30 cm layers were accounted for 44.14% and 16.46%, respectively. The average cumulative amount of SOM in the 0 - 30 cm layer was 9.505 MgC/ha at the RRM-R model. This value was 4 times higher than that of the RRM-NR model (2.259 MgC/ha). Thus, if farmers leave plant residues (straw) after each harvest on the field, the amount of C from new plants accumulated in the soil in the form of SOM will increase significantly. This is a way to get more CO2 from the air into plant tissues and store CO2 as SOC in farmland.

4. Conclusion

Our research on soil organic carbon, C-13 stable isotope and some main characteristics of the alluvial soil at Dan Phuong district—Vietnam was conducted in 2016-2017 when we changed from 2 maize + 1 rice crop model to 2 rice + 1 maize crop model. The annual average of total dry biomass of rice and maize samples (stem, root, leaf parts) was 10.64 Mg/ha and 9.09 Mg/ha, respectively. The average δ13C value of Khang Dan rice was −29.78‰ (C3 plant) and that value of HN88 maize (C4 plant) was −12.61‰. The amount of C accumulated in the soil in the form of SOM increases with time, the OC content is positively correlated with the parameters of TN, TP, fulvic and inversely correlated with δ13C parameter (0 - 30 cm layer). The top soil layers were regularly provided plant residues, so the δ13C value of SOM was changed corresponding to the δ13C value of plant. The average cumulative amount of SOM in the 0 - 30 cm layer was from 2.259 MgC/ha to 9.505 MgC/ha. This is a nature stable isotope method that can be used to relatively accurately quantify the C sequestration ability of the popular agricultural farming models in Vietnam and around the world. We need to conduct long-term and deeper research for many years to estimate SOC sequestration in some popular agricultural farming models and find the ways to minimize the number of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere.


This work was supported by Ministry of Science and Technology (MOST), Vietnam through the ministerial project code ĐTCB.02/16/VKHKTHN. We would like to express our great appreciation for the financial support that allowed us to implement this study.

Cite this paper: Thinh, N. , Hoai, V. , Anh, H. , Anh, V. , Chau, T. , Giap, T. and Tien, T. (2019) Study the Changes in Soil Organic Carbon of Rice-Maize Cropping System in the Top Layer of Alluvisol Soil in Dan Phuong: A Study of C-13 Stable Isotope Composition (&delta;13C). Journal of Environmental Protection, 10, 1361-1372. doi: 10.4236/jep.2019.1010080.

[1]   Accoe, F., Boeckx, P., Van Cleemput, O. and Hofman, G. (2003) Relationship between Soil Organic C Degradability and the Evolution of the δ13C Signature in Profiles under Permanent Grassland. Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry, 17, 2591-2596.

[2]   Carter, M.R. (2002) Soil Quality for Sustainable Land Management: Organic Matter and Aggregation Interactions That Maintain Soil Functions. Agronomy Journal, 94, 38-47.

[3]   Mazzilli, S.R., Kemanian, A.R., Ernst, O.R., Jackson, R.B. and Piñeiro, G. (2015) Greater Humication of Belowground than Aboveground Biomass Carbon into Particulate Soil Organic Matter in No-Till Corn and Soybean Crops. Soil Biology and Biochemistry, 85, 22-30.

[4]   Tian, K., Zhao, Y., Xu, X., Hai, N., Huang, B. and Deng, W. (2015) Effects of Long-Term Fertilization and Residue Management on Soil Organic Carbon Changes in Paddy Soils of China: A Meta-Analysis. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 204, 40-50.

[5]   Baisden, W.T., Amundson, R., Cook, A.C. and Benner, D.L. (2002) Turnover and Storage of C and N in Five Density Fractions from California Annual Grassland Surface Soils. Global Biogeochem. Cycles, 116, 1117-1122.

[6]   Yakir, D., da L. and Sternberg, S.L. (2000) The Use of Stable Isotopes to Study Ecosystem Gas Exchange. Oecologia, 123, 297-311.

[7]   Freudenthal, T., Wagner, T., Wenzhofer, F., Zabel, M. and Wefer, G. (2001) Early Diagenesis of Organic Matter from Sediments of the Eastern Subtropical Atlantic: Evidence from Stable Nitrogen and Carbon Isotopes. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 65, 1795-1808.

[8]   Garten Jr., C.T. and Hanson, P.J. (2006) Measured Forest Soil C Stocks and Estimated Turnover Times along an Elevation Gradient. Geoderma, 136, 342-352.

[9]   Saree, S., Ponphangnga, P., Sarobol, Ed., Limtong, P. and Chidthaisong, A. (2012) Soil Carbon Sequestration Affected by Cropping Changes from Upland Maize to Flooded Rice Cultivation. Journal of Sustainable Energy & Environment, 3, 147-152.

[10]   Whalen, J.K., Gul, S., Poirier, V., Yanni, S.F., Simpson, M.J., et al. (2014) Transforming Plant Carbon into Soil Carbon: Process-Level Controls on Carbon Sequestration. Canadian Journal of Plant Science, 94, 1065-1073.

[11]   Balesdent, J. and Mariotti, A. (1996) Measurement of Soil Organic Matter Turnover Using 13C Natural Abundance. In: Boutton, T.W. and Yamasaki, S.I., Eds., Mass Spectrometry of Soils, Marcel Dekker, New York, 83-111.

[12]   Boutton, T.W., Archer, S.R., Midwood, A.J., Zitzer, S.F. and Bol, R. (1998) δ 13C Values of Soil Organic Carbon and Their Use in Documenting Vegetation Change in a Subtropical Savanna Ecosystem. Geoderma, 82, 5-41.

[13]   Harris, D., Horwath, W.R. and Van Kessel, C. (2001) Acid Fumigation of Soils to Remove Carbonates Prior to Total Organic Carbon or Carbon-13 Isotopic Analysis. Science Society of America Journal, 65, 1853-1856.

[14]   Ramnarine, R., Voroney, R.P., Wagner-Riddle, C. and Dunfield, K.E. (2011) Carbonate Removal by Acid Fumigation for Measuring the δ13C of Soil Organic Carbon. Canadian Journal of Plant Science, 91, 247-250.