Back
 JWARP  Vol.11 No.8 , August 2019
Irish Water and Scottish Water: A Comparison
Abstract: Rising costs of production and the need for capital investment in the public water supply network in Ireland, has placed a strong emphasis on the need for water conservation and tackling the current high levels of leakage (Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government, 2015) [1]. Consequently, Irish Water which is Ireland’s national water utility has had to consider various business models and supply frameworks to demonstrate value for money. This has included those successfully implemented by Scottish Water. Therefore, the aim of this study was to compare both national utility providers in terms of structure and financial performance. The results of this study showed that both utility providers differed significantly. The Utility has, indeed, tried to achieve “too much too soon” (O’Leary, 2018 [2]; Donegal Now, 2016) [3]. Therefore, the initial results of this study suggest that, continuing to consider Scottish Water as the benchmark may generate unrealistic targets and expectations which in all probability may not be achieved.
Cite this paper: McDermott, R. , Solan, B. , McCord, S. and Littlewood, K. (2019) Irish Water and Scottish Water: A Comparison. Journal of Water Resource and Protection, 11, 1064-1089. doi: 10.4236/jwarp.2019.118063.
References

[1]   Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government (2015) Paper 1—Overview of the Water Sector in Ireland.
https://www.cso.ie/en/media/csoie/newsevents/documents/irishwater/1overviewofthewater
sectoriireland.pdf


[2]   O’Leary, J. (2018) How (Not) To Do Public Policy: Water Charges and Local Property Tax. Whitaker Institute. NUI Galway.

[3]   Donegal Now (2016) Donegal TD Says Irish Water Is “a Failed Entity”.
https://www.donegalnow.com/news/donegal-td-says-irish-water-is-a-failed-entity/88716

[4]   Scottish Government (2018) Scotland: The Hydro Nation Annual Report 2018.
https://www.gov.scot/publications/scotland-hydro-nation-annual-report-2018/

[5]   Scottish Water (2015) Annual Report and Accounts 2014/15. Scottish Water, Dunfermline, UK.

[6]   Price Waterhouse Coopers (PWC) (2011) Irish Water: Phase 1 Report.
https://www.housing.gov.ie/sites/default/files/migrated-files/en/Publicati-ons/Environment/Water/FileDownLoad%2C29193%2Cen.pdf

[7]   Northern Ireland Assembly (NIA) (2014) An Examination of Models within the Water and Sewerage Industry in the UK and Republic of Ireland. Northern Ireland Assembly.

[8]   Irish Water (2014) Scottish Water Executive & Irish Water Management Team, Meeting Agenda.
https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/249964/response/623677/attach/html/4/Untitled.
pdf.html


[9]   O’Regan, M. (2016) Irish Water Splashes €5m on Expert Advice.
https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/irish-water-splashes-5m-on-expert-advice-35284262.html

[10]   Commission for Regulation of Utilities (CRU) (2019) Irish Water’s Household Water Conservation Proposal (Excess Use Charges) CRU Consultation Paper (CRU/19/024). Dublin.

[11]   Citizens Information (2016) Household Water Conservation Charge.
http://www.citizensinformation.ie/en/environment/water_services/water_charges.html

[12]   Finn, C. (2016) Water Meters Are Not the New e-Voting Machines: They Cost a Lot More.
https://www.thejournal.ie/e-voting-machines-water-meters-3114507-Dec2016/

[13]   Scottish Water (2019) Unmetered Charges 2018-2019.
https://www.scottishwater.co.uk/you-and-your-home/your-charges/2018-19-charges/2018-19
-umc


[14]   Utility Week (2018) Home Truths: Scots Mark Decade of Water Competition. Faversham House Ltd., Wood St, East Grinstead.

[15]   Water Industry Commission for Scotland (WICS) (2010) Competition in the Scottish Water Industry. Achieving Best Value for Water and Sewerage Customers.
https://www.watercommission.co.uk/UserFiles/Documents/Competition%20report%20-%20final.pdf

[16]   RPS & Veolia Water (2010) The Plan. Water Supply-Project Dublin Region.
https://www.dublincity.ie/sites/default/files/content/WaterWasteEnviron-ment/WaterSupplyProjectDublinRegion/WaterSupplyProjectDublinRegion/Documents/The%20
Plan.pdf


[17]   Blacklocke, S., Bruen, M., Earle, R., Kelly-Quinn, M., O’Neill, E., O’Sullivan, J. and Purcell, P. (2014) Dublin Ireland: A City Addressing Challenging Water Supply, Management, and Government Issues. Ecology and Society, 19, 10.
https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-06921-190410

[18]   Fitzgerald, J. (2018) Irish Water Split from Ervia Inevitable to Protect Government Accounts.
https://www.irishtimes.com/business/economy/irish-water-split-from-ervia-inevitable-to-protect
-government-accounts-1.3570472


[19]   Scottish Water (2017) Annual Report and Accounts 2016/17. Scottish Water, Dunfermline, UK.

[20]   Cuthbert J.R. (2018) Inter-Generational Equity and the Strategic Review of Water Charges in Scotland. Fraser of Allander Economic Commentary, 42, 27-35.

[21]   Kennelly, J. (2018) Transforming the Water Industry in Ireland: A Local Authority Perspective. Engineers Journal.
http://www.engineersjournal.ie/2018/10/02/transforming-water-industry-ireland-local-authority-
perspective/


[22]   Irish Water (2013) Irish Water. County Council Service Level Agreement.
https://www.housing.gov.ie/sites/default/files/migrated-files/en/Publicati-ons/Environment/Water/FileDownLoad%2C35140%2Cen.pdf

[23]   Brennan, M. (2016) Irish Water Workers Cost Twice as Much as Staff in NI. Sunday Business Post.
https://www.businesspost.ie/news/irish-water-workers-cost-twice-as-much-as-staff-in-ni-336348

[24]   NERA (2016) IW IRC2 (2017-2018) Look forward Submission Assessment. Prepared for the Commission of Energy Regulation (CER).
https://www.cru.ie/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/CER16269-NERA-Review-of-Irish-Water-costs-
2017-to-2018.pdf


[25]   Finn, C. (2017) Irish Water: We Did Not Waste €70m on Consultants. The Journal.
https://www.thejournal.ie/irish-water-consultants-3183868-Jan2017/

[26]   Duffy, R. (2014) Fianna Fáil Attacks “Gold-Plated Bonus Culture” at Irish Water as Costs Are Revealed. The Journal.
https://www.thejournal.ie/irish-water-uk-comparison-1613268-Aug2014/

[27]   Hutcheon, P. (2019) Trio of Scottish Water Executives Take Home £225,000 in Bonuses. The Herald.
https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/17523139.trio-of-scottish-water-executives-take-home
-225000-in-bonuses/


[28]   Commission for Energy Regulation (CER) (2017) Irish Water’s Capital Investment Outputs 2016.
https://www.cru.ie/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/CER17120-Irish-Waters-Capital-Investment-
Outputs-2016.pdf


[29]   Irish Water (2015) Irish Water Business Plan. Transforming Water Services in Ireland to 2021.
https://www.water.ie/docs/Irish-Water-Business-Plan.pdf

[30]   Scottish Government (2018) Investing in and Paying for Your Water Service from 2021. An Invitation to Provide Your Views.
https://www.gov.scot/publications/investing-paying-water-services-2021/

[31]   Dublin City Council (2010) Environmental Report of the Dublin City Development Plan 2011-2017: Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA). Dublin City Council, Dublin, Ireland.
http://www.dublincity.ie/sites/default/files/content//Planning/DublinCityDevelop-mentPlan/Documents/Dev_PlanEnvironmentalReport.pdf

[32]   Central Statistics Office (2018) Census 2016 Report: Population Classified by Area. Central Statistics Office, Dublin, Ireland.
https://www.cso.ie/en/csolatestnews/presspages/2017/census2016profile2-populationdistribution
andmovements/


[33]   Audit Scotland (2005) Overview of the Water Industry in Scotland.
https://www.audit-scotland.gov.uk/docs/central/2005/nr_051013_water_overview.pdf

[34]   Commission for Energy Regulation (CER) (2016) Irish Water Second Revenue Control 2017-2018. Consultation Paper.
https://www.cru.ie/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/CER16267-Consultation-on-Irish-Water-Revenue
-for-2017-to-2018.pdf


[35]   Utility Week (2017) Chief Executive’s View: Douglas Millican, Scottish Water. Faversham House Ltd., Wood St, East Grinstead.

[36]   Water & Wastewater Treatment (W & WT) (2019) Transient Detection Helping Scottish Water Prevent Bursts.
https://wwtonline.co.uk/news/transient-detection-helps-scottish-water-predict-bursts

[37]   O’Brien, C. (2016) Irish Water to Spend €370m Replacing Lead Pipes in Areas across the Country. The Liberal.
https://theliberal.ie/irish-water-to-spend-e370m-replacing-lead-pipes-in-areas-across-the-country/

[38]   European Commission (EC) (1998) Council Directive 98/83/EC of 3 November 1998 on the Quality of Water Intended for Human Consumption. Official Journal of the European Communities, L330, 32-53.
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:1998:330:0032:0054:EN:PDF

[39]   European Commission (EC) (1991) Council Directive 91/271/EC of 21 May 1991 Concerning Urban Waste Water Treatment. 40-52.
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex:31991L0271

[40]   EPA (2018) Drinking Water Report for Public Supplies 2017. Environmental Protection Agency, Wexford, Ireland.

[41]   EPA (2018) Urban Waste Water Treatment in 2017. Environmental Protection Agency, Wexford, Ireland.

[42]   Brady, J. and Gray, N.F. (2017) Reform of the Irish Water Sector: Opportunities and Challenges. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Water Management, 170, 165-174.
https://doi.org/10.1680/jwama.15.00106

[43]   Dickie, V.A. and Sawkins, J.W. (2001) Affordability of Scottish Water and Sewerage Charges. Quarterly Economic Commentary, 26, 39-47.

[44]   Byatt, I. (2012) The Regulation of Water Services in the UK. Utilities Policy, 24, 3-10.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jup.2012.07.003

[45]   Hendry, S. (2016) Scottish Water: A Public-Sector Success Story. Water International, 41, 900-915.
https://doi.org/10.1080/02508060.2016.1212961

[46]   KPMG (2018) Annual Audit Report to the Members of Scottish Water and the Auditor General for Scotland.
https://www.audit-scotland.gov.uk/uploads/docs/report/2018/aar_1718_scottish_water.pdf

[47]   OFX (2019) Yearly Average Rates.
https://www.ofx.com/en-gb/forex-news/historical-exchange-rates/yearly-average-rates/

[48]   Irish Water (2017) Irish Water Financial Statements as at 31 December 2016.
http://www.ervia.ie/site-files/docs/who-we-are/iw_financial_statements_2016.pdf

[49]   Scottish Water (2018) Annual Report and Accounts 2017/18.
https://docs.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=www.scottishwater.co.uk/-/media/ScottishWater/
Document-Hub/Key-Publications/Annual-Reports/230718ScottishWaterAnnualReport1718.pdf


[50]   IFRS Foundation (2017) Who Uses IFRS Standards?
https://www.ifrs.org/use-around-the-world/use-of-ifrs-standards-by-jurisdiction/#profiles

[51]   National Records of Scotland (NRS) (2019) Population of Scotland.
https://www.nrscotland.gov.uk/statistics-and-data/statistics/scotlands-facts/population-of-scotland

[52]   Worldometers (2019) Ireland Population Live
http://www.worldometers.info/world-population/ireland-population/

[53]   Statista (2017) Ireland: Urbanisation from 2017 to 2017.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/455844/urbanization-in-ireland/

[54]   National Statistics (2011) Rural Scotland Key Facts 2011. People and Communities, Services and Lifestyle, Economy and Enterprise.
https://www.webarchive.org.uk/wayback/archive/20170105172301/http://www.gov.scot
/Publications/2011/09/29133747/7


[55]   Scottish Water (2018) Delivery Plan 2015-2021.
https://www.scottishwater.co.uk/en/Help-and-Resources/Document-Hub/Key-Publications/www.scottishwater.co.uk/-/media/ScottishWater/Document-Hub/Key-Publications/Delivery-and-Business-Plans/1604192019DeliveryPlanUpdateVersionForPublication.pdf

[56]   MarketLine (2018) Company Profile: Scottish Water.
https://www.researchpool.com/provider/marketline/scottish-water-strategy-swot-and-corporate-finance-report/

[57]   Irish Water (2016) Interim Revenue Control 2017-2018. Investment Plan 2017-2021.
https://www.cru.ie/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/CER16274-Irish-Water-IRC2-Submission-Executive-Summary-2017-to-2018.pdf

[58]   Irish Water (2018) Irish Water Annual Report and Financial Statements 2017.
http://www.ervia.ie/ervia-annual-report/19843_Irish_Water_AR_2017_Full_V16.pdf

[59]   European Commission (EC) (2000) Council Directive 2000/60/EC of 23 October 2000 Establishing a Framework for Community Action in the Field of Water Policy. L327, 1-73.
https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32000L0060

[60]   EPA (2019) EPA Drinking Water Remedial Action List Q4 of 2018.
http://epa.ie/pubs/reports/water/drinking/drinkingwaterralq42018.html

[61]   Irish Water (2018) Leakage Reduction Programme. First Fix Leak Repair Scheme for Domestic Water Customers. Quarterly Report. Q4 2017.
https://www.water.ie/for-home/first-fix/Quarter-4-report-2017.pdf

[62]   Water Industry Commission for Scotland (WICS) (2013) Scottish Water’s Performance 2012-13.
https://www.watercommission.co.uk/UserFiles/Documents/WICS%20Performance%202012-13.pdf

[63]   Water Industry Commission for Scotland (WICS) (2014) Scottish Water’s Performance 2013-14.
https://www.watercommission.co.uk/UserFiles/Documents/Performance%20Report%202013-14%20(final%20web%20version).pdf

[64]   Water Industry Commission for Scotland (WICS) (2015) Scottish Water’s Performance 2014-15.
https://www.watercommission.co.uk/UserFiles/Documents/Performance%20Report%202014-15.pdf

[65]   Water Industry Commission for Scotland (WICS) (2016) Scottish Water’s Performance 2015-16.
https://www.watercommission.co.uk/UserFiles/Documents/2015-16%20Performance%20Report%20FINAL%20PDF.pdf

[66]   Water Industry Commission for Scotland (WICS) (2017) Our Initial Expectations: Note 7 for the Customer Forum. Financial Tramlines.
https://www.watercommission.co.uk/UserFiles/Documents/CustomerForumNote7.pdf

[67]   Water Industry Commission for Scotland (WICS) (2018) Scottish Water’s Performance 2017-18.
https://www.watercommission.co.uk/UserFiles/Documents/2017-18_Performance%20Report.pdf

[68]   Scottish Water (2019) Delivery Plan 2015-2021. Delivery Plan Update 2019. March 2019.
https://docs.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=www.scottishwater.co.uk/-/media/ScottishWater/Document-Hub/Key-Publications/
Delivery-and-Business-Plans/1604192019DeliveryPlanUpdateVersionForPublication.pdf


[69]   Irish Water (2016) Irish Water Financial Statements as at 31 December 2015.
http://35.189.110.21/site-files/docs/who-we-are/Financial%20Statements%20for%20Ervia%20Group%20Companies/2015/Irish-Water-Financial-Statements-2015.pdf

[70]   Irish Water (2018) Strategic Funding Plan 2019-2024.
https://www.housing.gov.ie/sites/default/files/publications/files/irish_water_strategic_funding_plan
.pdf


[71]   Scottish Water (2016) Annual Report and Accounts 2015/16.
https://www.scottishwater.co.uk/en/Help-and-Resources/Document-Hub/Key-Publications/www.scottishwater.co.uk/-/media/ScottishWater/Document-Hub/Key-Publications/Delivery-and-Business-Plans/1604192019DeliveryPlanUpdateVersionForPublication.pdf

[72]   Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General (2017) Report on the Accounts of the Public Services 2016. Chapter 1 Exchequer Financial Outturn for 2016.
https://www.audit.gov.ie/en/Find-Report/Publications/2017/Chapter1-Exchequer-Financial-Outturn-for-2016.pdf

[73]   Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General (2018) Report on the Accounts of the Public Services 2017. Chapter 1 Exchequer Financial Outturn for 2017.
https://www.audit.gov.ie/en/Find-Report/Publications/Report%20on%20the%20Accounts%20of%20the%20Public%20Services/
Report-on-the-Accounts-of-the-Public-Services-2017.pdf


[74]   Scottish Water (2014) Business Plan 2015-2021.
https://docs.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=www.scottishwater.co.uk/-/media/ScottishWater/Document-Hub/Key-Publications/Delivery-and-Business-Plans/040419SWBusinessPlan2015to21.pdf

[75]   Rodriguez-Sanchez, C., Schuitema, G., Claudy, M. and Sancho-Esper, F. (2018) How Trust and Emotions Influence Policy Acceptance: The Case of the Irish Water Charges. British Journal of Social Psychology, 57, 610-629.
https://doi.org/10.1111/bjso.12242

[76]   Water Industry Commission for Scotland (WICS) (2013) Note 18 for the Customer Forum. Scottish Water’s Draft Business Plan: Base Expenditure.
https://www.watercommission.co.uk/UserFiles/Documents/CustomerForumNote18(B).pdf

[77]   Water Industry Commission for Scotland (WICS) (2017) Scottish Water’s Performance 2016-17.
https://www.watercommission.co.uk/UserFiles/Documents/WICS_PerformanceReport2016-17_12.10.pdf

[78]   CH2M Hill (2014) IW Interim Review 2014-2016 Assessment of Capital Expenditure. Final Report. Prepared for NERA.
https://www.cru.ie/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/CER14371-C3-Halcrow-Report-on-Irish-Water-Interim-Review-2014-2016-Assesment-of-Capital-Expenditure.pdf

[79]   Commission for Regulation of Utilities (CRU) (2018) Irish Water Revenue Control 2019 Revenue Control 2 (2017/2018) One-Year Ex-tension (CRU/18/211).
https://www.cru.ie/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/CRU18225-Update-to-Irish-Water-Revenue-Sources-in-CRU-Decision-CRU-18-211.pdf

[80]   Irish Water (2016) Interim Revenue Control 2017-2018. Investment Plan 2017-2021. Irish Water, Dublin.

[81]   Scottish Water (2014) Always Serving Scotland. Business Plan 2015 to 2021. Appendices.
https://docs.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=www.scottishwater.co.uk/-/media/ScottishWater/Document-Hub/Key-Publications/Delivery-and-Business-Plans/040419SWBusinessPlan2015to21Appendices.pdf

[82]   Population Pyramid (2019) Population of Ireland 1950 to 2050.
https://www.populationpyramid.net/ireland/2050/

[83]   Tret-siakova-McNally, S., Solan, B., Currie, R., Akinsanmi, O., Arnscheidt, J., McDermott, R. and Heather, C. (2019) A Ligno-Cellulosic Bio-Adsorbent Derived from Sawdust Waste for the Removal of Meropenem Antibiotic Dissolved in Water. Proceedings of the European Waste Water Management Conference, Birmingham, 15-17 July 2019.

[84]   McDermott, R., Strong, A. and Griffiths, P. (2019) Solid Transfer in Low Flow Sewers, the Distance Travelled So Far Is Not Enough. Journal of Environmental Protection, 10, 164-207.
https://doi.org/10.4236/jep.2019.102011

[85]   Kelly, F. (2018) Cabinet Set to Approve Water Supply Referendum Outline. The Irish Times.
https://www.irishtimes.com/news/politics/cabinet-set-to-approve-water-supply-referendum-outline-1.3703483

[86]   Irish Water (2019) Safe Guarding Our Water for Our Future. Advertisement of Sky One Television.

[87]   Brennan, M. (2019) Bloated Irish Water Ordered to Cut Costs by €100 Million. The Business Post.
https://www.businesspost.ie/news/bloated-irish-water-ordered-cut-costs-e100-million-449944

 
 
Top