The financial reporting system has been evolving in the world; detailed and demanding accounting principles and standards are augmented by extensive disclosure requirements. When FASB and IASB set standards for financial reporting, they make many judgments and they formulate standards by keeping in mind the objective of financial reporting. The objective of financial reporting is “to provide information that is useful to present and potential investors and creditors and others in making investment, credit and similar resource allocation decisions”. For accounting information to be useful for decision making it is essential that it is relevant for decision making. It should also truly capture the economic substance of the transactions, events, or circumstances it describes and the information needs to be complete, neutral and free from material errors  . IASB (2001, p. 26) considers financial statement information to be relevant when it has the ability of influencing user’s economic decision by helping them to evaluate past, present and future events and correcting their past evaluation.
Research that examines the relationship between financial statement information and capital markets is referred to as capital markets research; it originated from seminal work of  . The voluminous published research in this area is an indication of the demand for capital markets research. As per  during 1980s and 1990s the source of the demand for capital markets research was from five areas i.e. methodological capital markets research, evaluation of alternative accounting performance measures, tests of market efficiency, valuation and fundamental analysis and value relevance.
Value relevance studies are designed to assess whether particular accounting amounts reflect information that is used by investors in valuing equity  . There are four categories of Value relevance studies identified by  , 1) fundamental view, as per this the stock price changes as the accounting information reflected in financial statements change; 2) prediction view accord relevance to financial information as it helps in predicting the future accounting variables; 3) information view; here the premise is that the accounting information is value relevant if it is used by investors for setting prices; 4) measurement view which does not assume that investors use the information; it works on the notion that if an accounting variable has a relation with market price; then it is believed that it is capturing information that is used by the investors.
Close to half of the annual report comprises of financial statements and related information, for an investor it is essential to identify the relevant information to assess the business performance and position and to evaluate the ability of the business to generate future earnings  . Accounting information is used as a major means of communication between listed companies and existing shareholders  . To increase the level of transparency the Standard setters and market regulators carry out the improvements in the quality of accounting information presented in financial statements  . Value relevance research is considered to be important also because it operationalize key dimensions of the FASB’s theory to assess relevance and reliability of accounting amounts and that is the motivation behind this study. Several studies  -  have empirically examined value relevance of accounting information in Indian context with emphasis on the accounting information reported in the balance sheet, income statement and cash flow statement, few studies    gave more emphasizes on accounting information reported in the cash flow statement. None of these studies focused on value relevance comparison within the banking sector i.e. public and private sector banks in India, this study fills this gap in literature by doing the investigation in this direction. More so banking sector does play a vital role in the economy  , forms the core of the money market  and is the main participant of the financial system  .
For conducting the analysis so as to compare the value relevance accounting information between private and public sector banks, the study used the list of Indian banks listed in Indian stock market; and to test the relative association study used a set of nine independent accounting variables. Many of these accounting variables are unique to banking sector and users of financial statements use them for evaluating past and future financial performance and position of the banks. This study not only adds to the value relevance literature by comparing value relevance of accounting information between Indian private and public sector banks but also has considered additional variables not considered by other studies and as per the findings few of the additional variables are significant too.
The findings of our study indicated that, out of nine independent variables used, four variables are significant of which two are common for public and private sector banks. Overall empirical findings reported that accounting information in public sector banks is more relevant than that of private sector banks and this supports the hypothesis of the study that there is significant difference in the value relevance of accounting information between public sector banks and private sector banks.
The structure of this paper is organized as follows. The review of empirical literature is covered in Section 2, methodology used is discussed in Section 3. Section 4 focuses on empirical findings and analysis, conclusion and recommendation of the study are reflected in Section 5, and Section 6 is for limitation and suggestion for future research.
2. Review of Empirical Literature
The literature examining the association between stock price and accounting information extends back over 50 years    the first study which used the term “value relevance” to describe this association is  . The work done by   endorsed the information approach of value relevance; this approach focused on usefulness of accounting information for investors and it did not paid much attention to specific structure of the relation between market value and accounting information
The theoretical framework of equity valuation originated from the Ohlson model  , as per this model value of the firm can be expressed as a linear function of earnings, book value and other relevant information; this framework was based on the measurement approach. Large proportion of the studies reviewed in this paper use the measurement approach of value relevance. The research design varies among different studies, depending on the matter of the investigation. Three categories of research design have been used in the studies  , namely relative association, incremental association and marginal information content studies. The relative association studies   associate the stock market values with alternative accounting measures, these studies use R2 measure of regression to arrive at conclusions. Incremental association studies  examine whether a particular variable can explain stock market value given other accounting variables; the variable is considered to be relevant if the regression coefficient is significantly different from zero. Marginal information content studies  are typically event studies which enquires whether an accounting variable adds to the information available to the stakeholders. Most of the value-relevance studies perform association studies (relative and/or incremental).
 enquired about association of earnings with stock prices for German corporations and findings suggested that there is significant association between the two. This study used R2 as a measure of value relevance. Study by  examined the association between comprehensive income and net income with stock prices and concluded that the association between net income and stock prices is stronger than the association between comprehensive income and stock prices.  compared value relevance of accounting information of two countries namely Czech Republic and Sweden. The value relevance of accounting information in Czech Republic reported to be low than in Sweden. In addition,  examine value relevance of earnings under three accounting regimes including German GAAP, US GAAP and IAS. The value relevance of earnings reported to high in US GAAP and IAS, than in German GAAP. Also,  investigated value relevance of accounting information by considering a sample of six countries including Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippine, South Korea, Taiwan and Thailand. In all countries accounting information used reported to be statistically significant.
An incremental association study by  examined the difference between fair value estimates and the historical cost of banks investment securities. The results show that fair value estimates of investments securities provide a significant explanatory power compared to historical costs. As per  banks valuation of equity is impacted by unique bank variables and economic variables and asset quality is of high importance. For banking sector studies have focused on linking disclosures norms with that stock returns    . As per study based on banks in Sri-Lanka  investors based their investment decisions on the basis of aggregated accounting information in financial statements and Earnings per share and Return on equity are significantly related with the share price. Another study on banks in Nigeria  concluded that the earnings and change in earnings are value relevant.
In Indian context few value relevance studies have been conducted.  is amongst the first few Indian study that explored value relevance; though the data set has been small the findings were that the accounting information provided in cash flow statement has insignificant impact on share price.  examined value relevance by using price model and the findings were that earnings per share and book value per share significantly influence stock prices. As per  dividend per share is more relevant in private sector and public sector companies while book value per share is relevant in private sector only and earnings per share is insignificant in public sector companies.  examined value relevance of accounting information between IT sector and Steel sector. The study used six set of accounting variables, and out of six variables used only returns on net worth, cash flow from operation to total assets and debt to equity ratio are positive and statistically significant in IT sector and investment to total assets and debt to equity are positive and statistically significant in steel sector. As per study by  return on net worth is significant for equity investors. Others studies based in India    concluded that accounting information reported in cash flow statement is not relevant. Study on FMCG sector of India by  concluded that investment expenditure and dividend influence the stock price significantly.  carried out value relevance study of reported financials of NSE listed companies and found that accounting information is relevant in explaining stock prices and stock returns, the variables considered by the study was EPS and BVPS and this study did not consider banking sector.
As evident from the literature no empirical study in Indian context compared value relevance of accounting information between private and public sector banks, therefore this present study aimed to fill the gap in literature.
3. Research Methodology
3.1. Research Questions
1) Do accounting numbers have any relation with stock price of private and public sector banks of India?
2) Is there any significant difference in the relative association of accounting information and stock price between private and public sector banks?
3.2. Research Design
3.2.1. Sample and Data
The data required for the study is sourced from three sources, 1) the annual financial reports, 2) prowess database maintained by the Center for Monitoring the Indian Economy (CMIE) and 3) Reserve Bank of India official website. There are 40 banks listed on Bombay Stock Exchange and/or National Stock Exchange, we had to drop three banks as the relevant information was missing for these banks. The constituents of the study are given in Table 1(a) and Table 1(b).
To test the relationship, market shares prices regressed against nine set of accounting variables. Description of the variables is given in Table 2. The empirical model to be estimated is presented below.
Table 1. (a): Constituents of the study; (b): Constituents of the study.
3.2.2. Description of Independent Variables Used in the Study
1) Earnings per share: Earnings per share is the portion of a company’s profit allocated to each outstanding share of common stock and used as an indicator of firms’ profitability  . This is considered to be the most important accounting variable impacting the stock market; thus is used in many value relevance studies and found to be significant in varied stock market across the globe.
2) Book value per share: Book value per share is considered as a very important accounting information in measuring amount of assets the company has on behalf of each equity share  . Company is considered to have good performance if its book value is high  .
3) Return on equity: It is measure of profitability and is an indicator of firms’ efficiency and focused on measuring amount of profit generated by the company using amount of money invested by a shareholder in the company  .
4) Assets turnover ratio: Assets turnover ratio used as independent variable in this study, the ratio defined as part of efficiency ratio aimed in measuring ability
Table 2. Description of dependent and independent variables used.
of the company in utilizing its assets for the purpose of generating company’s sales. According to  efficient utilization firm’s assets and proper generation of sales is found when the ratio reported to be high, very few studies examined value relevance of this ratio for equity valuation.
5) Current ratio: Current ratio is a part of liquidity ratio which is mostly used in measuring ability of the companies to meet is short term obligation  . The ratio used as independent variable in this study, consistent with other researchers including    .
6) Net interest margin: Business of banks is primarily concerned with expected returns  . The net interest margin (NIM) considered as a very important ratio in banking sector and is in measuring efficient utilization of bank’s funds in generating income from investment and credit operations  .
7) Capital adequacy ratio: The capital adequacy ratio (CAR)also known as Capital to risk weighted assets ratio (CRAR) used in measuring amount of bank’s capital in relation to the amount of its credit exposures. The ratio expressed as a percentage of bank’s capital to its risk weighted credit exposures and used as a measure of bank’s financial strength and stability. Banks with high capital adequacy ratio are considered to be safe, in case its loans are not going well they can make up for it from its net worth.
8) Net non-performing assets ratio: Non-performing assets (NPA) considered as the major concern for the Indian banks because the ratio used as indicator of the financial health of the banking sector and credit risk  . High level of NPAs indicates that there are large number of credit defaulters which impacts bank’s profit ability adversely, and also impacts the value of the assets and net-worth and this can result in bank failures.
9) Current account and saving account ratio: It is used to show the amount of deposits a bank has in form of current account and savings account of the total amount of deposits. For the banks with higher ratio of current deposits and savings deposits, it is considered to be a good signal as funds available through these two deposits have very low cost. As far as our knowledge none of the previous studies considered this variable, but the stock market analysts have always accorded high value to this ratio of banking industry. Therefore we have included it in our study.
3.2.3. Research Models
This study uses Fixed effect model (FEM) and Random effect model (REM) to conduct the analysis, as it considers the effect of systematic differences between the firms as compared with OLS which assumes that model parameters are constant across all firms  . These two panel data regressions models are applied to get accurate estimates and also to control unobserved heterogeneity and the problem of endogeneity  . In order to choose the appropriate model between FEM and REM based upon the consistency of estimated results  , specification test was also conducted. The test normally assumes the null hypothesis, that there is no correlation between error term and explanatory variables and hence, REM should be used. Alternatively FEM is appropriate assuming there is correlation between error term and explanatory variables. Decision rule is under 5% significant level if Hausman test statistic has probability less than 0.05 then it is possible to reject null hypothesis meaning FEM is appropriate. The results of the Hausman test in our study reject (accept) the null hypothesis at 5 per cent significance level, thereby supporting the use of FEM (REM) for analysis in private (public) sector banks. The results are of the view that fixed (random) effect model is the most appropriate and consistent model for analysis in private (public) sector banks.
4. Results and Analysis
4.1. Descriptive Statistics
Table 3 presents the descriptive statistics; it can be observed that public sector banks reported the highest mean value of MSP with standard deviation followed by BVPS. The mean value of MSP as reports by public sector banks is 546.4 with standard deviation of 1247.1 and 416.4 reported as the mean value of BVPS with standard deviation of 678.2. While the lowest mean value found in CR under both sectors. The corresponding estimates for both sector also reveal that, indicated that the minimum value of 0.05 and 0.01 perceived in ATR and CR in public sector banks while in private banks stock the minimum value of −25.23 and −66 perceived in EPS and ROE respectively.
Table 3. Descriptive statistics of the dependent and independent variables.
4.2. Correlation Matrix Analysis and Multi-Collinearity
The relationship between accounting variables and market share prices was measured by using the Pearson’s Correlation analysis. As indicated in Table 4, the highest and strong positive correlation of 0.932 is reported between MSP and EPS followed by BVPS (0.911) in public sector banks; this is inconsistent with  . Other accounting variables like ROE, ATR, NIM and CASA showing low positive correlation with market share prices whereas CR, CAR and NPA showing low negative correlation with market share price.
In private sector, MPS is positively correlated with all accounting variable except NPA have negative correlation with MSP. The highest and strong positive correlation of 0.699 is reported between CASA and MPS followed by BVPS (0.631). The results from Pearson’s correlation coefficient in Table 3 also indicated that none of variables except EPS and BVPS have correlation above 0.9 under both sectors. Highpair wise correlation is not a foolproof guide to collinearity due to interaction between several independent variables  . In addition, Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) was performed to check if the effect of multicollinearity between predictors variable exists. The value of VIF for all independent variables is below the value of 10 except for EPS and BVPS, VIF above 10 is normally considered to be a problem  . As our model is using closely related measures of bank’s performance which results in interaction between several regressors this kind of result is expected  . The variables that depicted high level of colinearity were not dropped from the model because these are important variables to investors as well as to banking industry.
4.3. Regression Analysis
Table 4. Correlation matrix between variables.
Note: **Significant at p < 0.01; *Significant at p < 0.05.
1) Earnings per Share:
- Coefficient of EPS is positive and significant at 1% level for public sector banks. These results indicate that there is positive association between the performance of the business as measured by earnings per share and market share price.
- The regression coefficient of EPS in private sector banks is significant at p < 0.10 and depicts a positive association with market share prices.
The findings are in line with the findings of       .
2) Book Value per Share
- The beta coefficient of BVPS is significant at p < 0.05 and have positive coefficient. The value signifies that there is direct relationship between BVPS and market share prices of public sector and this implies that a unit increase in BVPS will leads to 0.348 increases in market share prices.
- In private sector banks, the coefficient of book value per share is also positive and significant.
Table 5. (a) Regression results; (b) Regression model summary.
These results are consistent with the findings of  and are contrary to  .
3) Return on Equity
The coefficient of ROE in our study is positive but significant at 10% in public sector banks, which indicates that there is positive and significant relationship between ROE and market share prices. The findings are consistent with the results of previous research    .
For private sector banks, the regression coefficient of ROE has been positive and statistically not significant, which indicates that ROE is not statistically significant in explain market share price. The reason for the insignificance of return on equity could be that, perhaps most of investors depend on BVPS and other accounting variables used in this study rather ROE. These results are consistent with the findings of  .
4) Assets Turnover Ratio
Assets turnover ratio is insignificant in case of public sector banks. Our results are consistent with the findings of with  .
For private sector banks, regression coefficient of ATR is positive at significance of p < 0.10 level, this indicates that ATR is highly significant at 10% level in explaining market share price.
5) Current Ratio
For public sector banks, CR reported as insignificant variable, the results are consistent with the findings of   .
In the study conducted by  current ratio reported as significant variable in influencing market share prices. The coefficient of CR in our study is positive at significance of p < 0.10 level in private sector.
6) Net Interest Margin
Net interest margin reported as insignificant which indicates that the NIM is not relevant factor in deciding market share price of private and public sector banks.
7) Capital Adequacy Ratio
The beta coefficient of capital adequacy ratio is insignificant and depicts a negative association with market share prices of private and public sector banks.
8) Net Non-Performing Assets Ratio
- For public sector banks, the coefficient of NPA is negative at a significant of p < 0.05 level. This indicates that at 5% level of significance NPA is relevant in influencing market share price.
- Net non-performing assets ratio in this study found as insignificant variable in private sector banks. This implies that NPA are not relevant in deciding market share prices.
9) CASA Ratio
CASA reported as insignificant variable in public and private sector banks.
Further, the estimated regression results also shows that for public sector banks, the value of adj.R2 is 0.866 and indicates that accounting numbers explain about 86.6% of the variations in market share prices and this is greater than the adj.R2 of 0.787 found in private sector banks. Given the respective value of adj.R2 reported under both sectors, it is posit to note that the value relevance of accounting information in the public sector banks is more relevant than that of the private sector banks and this supports the hypothesis of the study that: there is significant difference in the value relevance of accounting information between public sector banks and private sector banks listed under BSE 500. Table 6 presents summary of all significant and insignificant variables
5. Discussion and Concluding Remarks
This study compared value relevance of accounting information on the market share price of Indian banks listed in BSE. In particular, it attempts to identify relevant accounting information in influencing market share price and see whether there is significance difference in the value relevance of accounting information between private and public sector banks. The study uses panel data regression methodology (FEM and REM) in testing the relationship accounting information and market share price of listed Indian banks for a period of 10 years.
The empirical results from the regression output provide evidence that EPS, BVPS, ROE and Net NPA ratio significantly influence market share price of public sector banks while ATR, CR, NIM CAR and CASA were reported as insignificant variables in influencing market share price. Out of four accounting variable reported as significant variables in influencing market share price in public sector banks, EPS, BVPS and ROE positively and significantly influence market share price and Net NPA ratios negatively influence market share price; the rest of accounting variables are not significant.
In private sector banks, EPS, BVPS, ATR and CR were reported as significant variables in influencing market share price and all these variables have positive association with stock prices. Other accounting variables like ROE, NIM, CAR, NetNPA and CASA in this study were found as insignificant variables in influencing market share price of private sector banks. Given the respective value of adj.R2 reported under both sectors in Table 5(b), it is posit to note that accounting information in the public sector banks is more relevant than that of the private sector banks and this supports the hypothesis of the study that: there is significant difference in the value relevance of accounting information between public sector banks and private sector banks.
Table 6. Relationship between market share prices and accounting variables.
6. Limitation and Suggestions for Future Research
Empirical findings of this study have important implication to Indian investors under banking sector and other users of financial statements and also subjected to several limitations. First, the study compared only value relevance of few selected accounting information from the balance sheet and income statement. Future researchers may add more variables relevant to banking sectors.
Second, the conclusions are based on the analysis of banking sector for the period 10 years from 2005-2014 for better generalization of results; the period covered can be extended to 15 years and other sectors like Oil and Gas, Manufacturing sectors, Service sectors and other non-financial sector should be considered.
Lastly, it will be more important and interesting to see more empirical comparative studies on the value relevance of accounting information between countries like in the study of  and  .
 Barth, M.E., Beaver, W. and Landsman, W. (2001) The Relevance of the Value Relevance Literature for Financial Accounting Standard Setter: Another View. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 31, 77-104.
 Vijitha, P. and Nimalathasan B. (2014) Value Relevance of Accounting Information and Share Price: A Study of Listed Manufacturing Companies in Sri Lanka. Merit Research Journal of Business and Management, 2, 1-6.
 Vishnani, S. and Shah, K. (2008) Value Relevance of Published Financial Statements with Special Emphasis on Impact of Cash Flow Reporting. International Research Journal of Finance and Economics, 17, 84-90.
 Mulenga, M. and Bhatia, M. (2017) The Review of Literature on the Role of Earnings, Cash Flow and Accruals in Predicting Future Cash Flows. Accounting and Finance Research, 6, 59-70.
 Varun, D. (2014) Earnings Persistence and Stock Prices: Empirical Evidence from an Emerging Market. Journal of Financial Reporting and Accounting, 12, 117-134.
 Bhatia, M. and Mulenga, M (2019) Value Relevance of Accounting Information: A Review of Empirical Evidence across Continents. Jindal Journal of Business Research.
 Bhatia, M. and Mulenga, M. (2019) Value Relevance of Accounting Information: Comparative Study of Indian Public and Private Sector Banks. International Journal of Indian Culture and Business Management, 18, 12-33.
 Srinivasan, P. and Narasimhan, M.S. (2010) An Evaluation of Value Relevance of Consolidated Earnings and Cash Flow Reporting in India. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Corporate Governance.
 Amir, E., Harris, T.S. and Venuti, E.K. (1993) A Comparison of the Value-Relevance of U.S. versus Non-U.S. GAAP Accounting Measures Using form 20-F Reconciliations. Journal of Accounting Research, 31, 230-264.
 Holthausen, R.W. and Watts, R.L. (2001) The Relevance of the Value-Relevance Literature for Financial Accounting Standard Setting. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 31, 3-75.
 Dhaliwal, D., Subramanyam, K.R. and Trezevant, R. (1999) Is Comprehensive Income Superior to Net Income as a Measure of Firm Performance? Journal of Accounting & Economic, 26, 43-67.
 Harris, T.S., Lang, M. and Moller, H.P., (1994) The Value Relevance of German Accounting Measures: An Empirical Analysis. Journal of Accounting Research, 32, 187-209.
 Hellstrom, K. (2006) The Value Relevance of Financial Accounting Information in a Transition Economy: The Case of the Czech Republic. European Accounting Review, 15, 325-349.
 Bartov, E., Goldberg, S.R. and Kim, M. (2005) Comparative Value Relevance among German, U.S. and International Accounting Standards: A German Stock Market Perspective. Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance, 21, 95-119.
 Graham, R.C. and King, R.D. (2000) Accounting Practices and the Market Valuation of Accounting Numbers: Evidence from Indonesia, Korea, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan and Thailand. The International Journal of Accounting, 35, 445-470.
 Brewer, E. and Lee, C.F (1986) Time Aggregation, Specification, and Bank Stock Rates of Returns Determination. College of Commerce and Business Administration, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Chicago, IL.
 Siyanbola, A.A. (2016) The Value Relevance of Earnings in the Return-Earnings Relation in the Nigerian Deposit Money Banks. Congent Business & Management, 3, Article ID: 1210276.
 Alam, H.M., Ali, L., Rehman, C.A. and Akram, M. (2011) Impact of Working Capital Management on Profitability and Market Valuation of Pakistani Firms. European Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Sciences, 32, 48-54.
 Shehzad, K. and Ismail, A. (2014) Value Relevance of Accounting Information and Its Impact on Stock Prices: Case Study of Listed Banks at Karachi Stock Exchange. Journal of Economic Info, 3, 40-48.
 Worthington, A.C. and Tracey, W. (2001) The Usefulness of Economic Value-Added (EVA) and Its Components in the Australian Context. Accounting, Accountability and Performance, 7, 73-90.
 Ghosh, P.K. and Ghosh, S.K. (2015) Stock Price Adjustment to Corporate Accounting Disclosure: A Quantitative Study on Dhaka Stock Exchange (DSE), Bangladesh. International Journal of Accounting and Financial Reporting, 5, 122-132.
 Thompson, S. (2012) Stock Market Crisis and Value Relevance of Accounting Information: Impact on Quoted Cement Manufacturing Firms in Nigeria. International Journal of Research in Commerce & Management, 3, 16-20.
 Olugbenga, A. and Oyerinde, A. (2014) The Relationship between Financial Accounting Information and Market Values of Quoted Firms in Nigeria. Global Journal of Contemporary Research in Accounting, Auditing and Business Ethics, 1, 22-39.