Delphine  ^1*, Patrick Witte¹, Thomas Hartmann², Tejo Spit¹, Annelies Zoomers¹

Show more
¹ Department of Human Geography and Planning, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
² Faculty of Environmental Sciences, Wageningen University and Research, Wageningen, The Netherlands.
Show less

Abstract: Investing in large transport projects affects the (potential) economic development of metropolitan areas. Yet, very little critical research has been performed to understand how to assess these effects. The relationship between infrastructure investments and regional economic development is complex and indirect, and many theoretical and methodological difficulties remain. On the one hand, the assumption that investing in infrastructure is important to sustain economic growth is sometimes doubted. On the other hand, it is argued that investments in infrastructure enhance the accessibility of urban regions and that in the slipstream of such investments, social problems in urban regions can be tackled as well. Despite these contrasting views, there is at least a consensus that transport infrastructure development depends on economic development and vice versa. Yet, in many cases, the method of assessing economic impacts highly affects the results. Therefore, this paper focuses on a critical reflection of methods for estimating economic effects of infrastructure investments. A critical evaluation is made based on Indonesian and Japanese cases. After conducting in-depth desk research on both cases, we found that the broader effects on affected group of people tend to be overlooked due to the problems of time and space dimensions, the chain reaction of effects, and inappropriate data practices. The assessment on the appraisal processes tends to overlook the broader economic implication due to narrow focus and the concept of efficiency of economic theory.

Keywords: Large Infrastructure Projects, High-Speed Railways, Economic Effects, Transport Investment, Economic Assessment

Cite this paper: Delphine, Witte, P., Hartmann, T., Spit, T. and Zoomers, A. (2019) For the Greater Good?—A Critical Reflection on Assessing Indirect Economic Effects Caused by Large Transport Projects. Open Journal of Civil Engineering, 9, 135-156. doi: 10.4236/ojce.2019.92010.

References

[1]   Flyvbjerg, B., Bruzelius, N. and Rothengatter, W. (2003) Megaprojects and Risk: An Anatomy of Ambition. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781107050891

[2]   Oliomogbe, G. and Smith, N. (2013) Value in Megaprojects. Organization, Technology & Management in Construction: An International Journal, 4, 617-624.
https://doi.org/10.5592/otmcj.2012.3.5

[3]   Yu, N., De Jong, M., Storm, S. and Mi, J. (2012) The Growth Impact of Transport Infrastructure Investment: A Regional Analysis for China (1978-2008). Policy and Society, 31, 25-38.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polsoc.2012.01.004

[4]   Lakshmanan, T.R. and Anderson, W.P. (2002) Transport Infrastructure, Freight Services Sector and Economic Growth. A White Paper for the US Department of Transportation, Washington DC.

[5]   Summerhill, W.R. (2005) Big Social Savings in a Small Laggard Economy: Railroad-Led Growth in Brazil. The Journal of Economic History, 65, 72-102.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050705050035

[6]   Vickerman, R.W. (2008) Cost Benefit Analysis and the Wider Economic Benefits from Mega-Projects. In: Flyvbjerg, B., et al., Eds., Decision-Making on Mega-Projects: Cost-Benefit Analysis, Planning and Innovation, Edward Elgar Publishing Inc., Northampton, 352.

[7]   Lakshmanan, T.R. (2007) The Wider Economic Benefits of Transportation. Joint Transport Research, OECD and International Transport Forum.

[8]   De Bruijn, H. and Leijten, M. (2007) Megaprojects and Contested Information. Transportation Planning and Technology, 30, 49-69.
https://doi.org/10.1080/03081060701208050

[9]   Cohen, J.P. (2010) The Broader Effects of Transportation Infrastructure: Spatial Econometrics and Productivity Approaches. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 46, 317-326.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tre.2009.11.003

[10]   Frick, K.T. (2008) The Cost of the Technological Sublime: Daring Ingenuity and the New San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge. In: Flyvbjerg, B., et al., Eds., Decision-Making on Mega-Projects: Cost-Benefit Analysis, Planning and Innovation, Edward Elgar Publishing Inc., Northampton, 239.
https://doi.org/10.4337/9781848440173.00020

[11]   Pereira, A.M. and Pereira, R. (2015) Is All Infrastructure Investment Created Equal? The Case of Portugal. College of William and Mary Department of Economics Working Paper 156.

[12]   Altshuler, A.A. and Luberoff, D.E. (2004) Mega-Projects: The Changing Politics of Urban Public Investment. Brookings Institution Press, Washington DC.

[13]   Bristow, A.L. and Nellthorp, J. (2000) Transport Project Appraisal in the European Union. Transport Policy, 7, 51-60.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0967-070X(00)00010-X

[14]   Samset, K. (2013) Strategic and Tactical Performance of Mega-Projects—Between Successful Failures and Inefficient Successes. In: International Handbook on Mega-Projects, Edward Elgar Publishing, Northampton, 11-33.
https://doi.org/10.4337/9781781002308.00008

[15]   Spit, T. (1999) Cities and the Assessment of Economic Effects of Infrastructure Development. In: Wever, E., Ed., Cities in Perspective I. Economy, Planning and the Environment, Van Gorcum, Assen, 129-145.

[16]   Jonkhoff, W. and Rustenburg, M. (2011) Indirect Effects in European Transport Project Appraisal. In: Infrastructure Productivity Evaluation, Springer, New York, 79-94.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4419-8101-1_6

[17]   Boarnet, M.G. (1996) The Direct and Indirect Economic Effects of Transportation Infrastructure. The University of California Transportation Center, University of California, Berkeley.

[18]   Lami, I.M. (2014) Evaluation Tools to Support Decision-Making Process Related to European Corridors. In: Analytical Decision-Making Methods for Evaluating Sustainable Transport in European Corridors, Springer International Publishing, Berlin, 85-101.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-04786-7_6

[19]   Oosterhaven, J. and Elhorst, J.P. (2003) Indirect Economic Benefits of Transport Infrastructure Investments. In: Across the Border: Building upon a Quarter Century of Transport Research in the Benelux, De Boeck, Antwerpen, 143-162.

[20]   Steg, L. and Gifford, R. (2005) Sustainable Transportation and Quality of Life. Journal of Transport Geography, 13, 59-69.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2004.11.003

[21]   Pollack, J.B., Fahri, J., Biesenthal, C. and Sankaran, S. (2015) Understanding Megaproject Success beyond the Project Close-Out Stage. Construction Economics and Building, 15, 48-58.
https://doi.org/10.5130/AJCEB.v15i3.4611

[22]   Meurs, H., van Wee, B., Perdok, J. and Hoogendoorn, S. (2013) Quick-Scan Appraisal Method to Determine Cost-Effectiveness of Traffic and Demand Management Measures. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2359, 36-43.
https://doi.org/10.3141/2359-05

[23]   Buitelaar, E., Witte, P. and Spit, T. (2014) Understanding the Costs and Revenues of Land Development. In: Witte, P., Ed., The Corridor Chronicles: Integrated Perspectives on European Transport Corridor Development, Eburon Academic Publishers, Delft, 111-126.

[24]   McCutcheon, R. (2001) An Introduction to Employment Creation in Development and Lessons Learned from Employment Creation in Construction. Urban Forum, 12, 263-278.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12132-001-0006-6

[25]   Wardman, M. (1988) A Comparison of Revealed Preference and Stated Preference Models of Travel Behaviour. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 22, 71-91.

[26]   Zamparini, L. and Reggiani, A. (2007) The Value of Travel Time in Passenger and Freight Transport: An Overview. In: Policy Analysis of Transport Networks, Ashgate, Aldershot, 145-162.

[27]   Metz, D. (2008) The Myth of Travel Time Saving. Transport Reviews, 28, 321-336.
https://doi.org/10.1080/01441640701642348

[28]   Bates, J. (2007) History of Demand Modelling. In: Handbook of Transport Modelling, 2nd Edition, Emerald Group Publishing Limited, Bingley, 11-34.
https://doi.org/10.1108/9780857245670-002

[29]   Van Wee, B. (2009) Self-Selection: A Key to a Better Understanding of Location Choices, Travel Behaviour and Transport Externalities? Transport Reviews, 29, 279-292.
https://doi.org/10.1080/01441640902752961

[30]   Buliung, R.N., Roorda, M.J. and Remmel, T.K. (2008) Exploring Spatial Variety in Patterns of Activity-Travel Behaviour: Initial Results from the Toronto Travel-Activity Panel Survey (TTAPS). Transportation, 35, 697-722.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11116-008-9178-4

[31]   Rodrigue, J.P., Comtois, C. and Slack, B. (2013) The Geography of Transport Systems. Routledge, Abingdon-on-Thames.

[32]   Rietveld, P. and Bruinsma, F. (2012) Is Transport Infrastructure Effective? Transport Infrastructure and Accessibility: Impacts on the Space Economy. Springer Science & Business Media, Berlin.

[33]   Africani, A., Delpiano, R., Drewello, H., Fontanili, A., Huschebeck, M. and Taake, D. (2016) Comparative Analysis of Accessibility for Freight Transport in Corridor Regions: Results of Two Case Studies. In: Integrated Spatial and Transport Infrastructure Development, Springer International Publishing, Berlin, 133-146.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-15708-5_8

[34]   Graham, D.J. (2007) Agglomeration, Productivity and Transport Investment. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 41, 317-343.

[35]   Leitham, S., McQuaid, R.W. and Nelson, J.D. (2000) The Influence of Transport on Industrial Location Choice: A Stated Preference Experiment. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 34, 515-535.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0965-8564(99)00030-0

[36]   Fowkes, A.S., Firmin, P.E., Tweddle, G. and Whiteing, A.E. (2004) How Highly Does the Freight Transport Industry Value Journey Time Reliability—and for What Reasons? International Journal of Logistics: Research and Applications, 7, 33-43.
https://doi.org/10.1080/13675560310001619259

[37]   Anas, A., Arnott, R. and Small, K.A. (1998) Urban Spatial Structure. Journal of Economic Literature, 36, 1426-1464.

[38]   Fujita, M. and Thisse, J.F. (2013) Economics of Agglomeration: Cities, Industrial Location, and Globalization. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[39]   Witte, P. and Spit, T. (2014) Sectoral Drawbacks in Transport: Towards a New Analytical Framework on European Transport Corridors. In: Analytical Decision-Making Methods for Evaluating Sustainable Transport in European Corridors, Springer International Publishing, Berlin, 47-61.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-04786-7_4

[40]   Baum, H.S. (1977) Toward a Post-Industrial Planning Theory. Policy Sciences, 8, 401-421.
https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01727407

[41]   Sunstein, C.R. (2016) Cost-Benefit Analysis and Arbitrariness Review.
https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2752068

[42]   Grant-Muller, S.M., Mackie, P., Nellthorp, J. and Pearman, A. (2001) Economic Appraisal of European Transport Projects: The State-of-the-Art Revisited. Transport Reviews, 21, 237-261.
https://doi.org/10.1080/01441640119423

[43]   Campbell, H.F. and Brown, R.P. (2015) Cost-Benefit Analysis: Financial and Economic Appraisal Using Spreadsheets. Routledge, Abingdon-on-Thames.

[44]   Jones, H., Moura, F. and Domingos, T. (2014) Transport Infrastructure Project Evaluation Using Cost-Benefit Analysis. Procedia—Social and Behavioral Sciences, 111, 400-409.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2014.01.073

[45]   Lami, I.M. (2014) Analytical Decision-Making Methods for Evaluating Sustainable Transport in European Corridors (Vol. 11). Springer, Berlin.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-04786-7

[46]   Hensher, D.A. and Button, K.J. (2008) Handbook of Transport Modelling. Emerald Group Publishing Limited, Bingley.

[47]   Lehtonen, M. (2014) Evaluating Megaprojects: From the “Iron Triangle” to Network Mapping. Evaluation, 20, 278-295.
https://doi.org/10.1177/1356389014539868

[48]   Fayyad, U., Piatetsky-Shapiro, G. and Smyth, P. (1996) From Data Mining to Knowledge Discovery in Databases. AI Magazine, 17, 37.

[49]   Kusayanagi, S. and Niraula, R. (2013) Megaprojects in Asia in the 21st Century. Advice from Those Who’ve Been There, Done That. 291-312.
https://doi.org/10.1061/9780784412381.ch15

[50]   Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs (2011) Masterplan for Acceleration and Expansion of Indonesia Economic Development.

[51]   Notohadiprawiro, T. (1999) Performance of Central Kalimantan Wetland Mega-Project: A Critical Review. International Conference and Workshop on Tropical Peat Swamps Safeguarding a Global Natural Resource, Penang, 27-29 July 1999, 27-29.

[52]   Delinom, R., Lubis, R.F., Martosuparno, S., Bakti, H. and Taniguchi, M. (2014) Water-Food Nexus: Impact of Rapid Urbanization on Fishery Production in Jakarta Bay Area, Indonesia. In: AGU Fall Meeting Abstracts, San Francisco, Vol. 1, 0992.

[53]   JIC Japan International Consultans for Transportation (2012) Feasibility Study for Promotion of International Infrastructure Projects in FY2011. Study on the High Speed Railway Project (Jakarta-Bandung Section), Republic Indonesia. Final Report, Japan International Consultants for Transportation Co., Ltd., Yachiyo Engineering Co., Ltd., Jakarta.
https://www.jetro.go.jp/jetro/activities/contribution/oda/model_study/infra_system/pdf/h23_ result03_en.pdf

[54]   Hood, C.P. (2006) Shinkansen: From Bullet Train to Symbol of Modern Japan. Routledge, Abingdon-on-Thames.
https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203180389

[55]   Smith, R.A. (2014) The Shinkansen—World Leading High-Speed Railway System. Japan Railway & Transport Review, 64, 38-49.

[56]   Okada, H. (1994) Features and Economic and Social Effects of the Shinkansen. Japan Railway and Transport Review, 3, 9-16.

[57]   Murakami, J. and Cervero, R. (2012) High-Speed Rail and Economic Development: Business Agglomerations and Policy Implications (No. UCTC-FR-2012-10). University of California Transportation Center, Berkeley.

[58]   Han, J., Hayashi, Y., Jia, P. and Yuan, Q. (2012) Economic Effect of High-Speed Rail: Empirical Analysis of Shinkansen’s Impact on Industrial Location. Journal of Transportation Engineering, 138, 1551-1557.
https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)TE.1943-5436.0000467

[59]   Banister, D. and Berechman, J. (2000) Transport Investment and Economic Development. UCL Press, Taylor and Francis Group, Abingdon-on-Thames.

[60]   Banister, D. and Berechman, Y. (2001) Transport Investment and the Promotion on Economic Growth. Journal of Transport Geography, 9, 209-218.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0966-6923(01)00013-8

[61]   Lakshmanan, T.R. (2011) The Broader Economic Consequences of Transport Infrastructure Investments. Journal of Transport Geography, 19, 1-12.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2010.01.001

[62]   Esteves, A.M., Franks, D. and Vanclay, F. (2012) Social Impact Assessment: The State of the Art. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 30, 34-42.
https://doi.org/10.1080/14615517.2012.660356

[63]   Archibugi, F. (2006) Pitfalls in Planning and Plan-Evaluation. In: Urban and Regional Planning and Development Series, Ashgate, Aldershot, 73-84.

[64]   Gunton, T. (2003) Megaprojects and Regional Development: Pathologies in Project Planning. Regional Studies, 37, 505-519.
https://doi.org/10.1080/0034340032000089068

[65]   Salling, K.B. and Leleur, S. (2015) Accounting for the Inaccuracies in Demand Forecasts and Construction Cost Estimations in Transport Project Evaluation. Transport Policy, 38, 8-18.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tranpol.2014.11.006

[66]   Immers, L.H. and Stada, J.E. (2004) Basics of Transport Economics. Faculty of Engineering, Katholieke Universiteit, Leuven, 6.

[67]   Morrison-Saunders, A., Pope, J., Gunn, J.A., Bond, A. and Retief, F. (2014) Strengthening Impact Assessment: A Call for Integration and Focus. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 32, 2-8.
https://doi.org/10.1080/14615517.2013.872841

[68]   Xu, M., Grant-Muller, S. and Gao, Z. (2015) Evolution and Assessment of Economic Regulatory Policies for Expressway Infrastructure in China. Transport Policy, 41, 42-49.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tranpol.2015.03.007

[69]   Korytárová, J. and Hromádka, V. (2014) The Economic Evaluation of Megaprojects-Social and Economic Impacts. Procedia—Social and Behavioral Sciences, 119, 495-502.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2014.03.055