JBM  Vol.7 No.6 , June 2019
Comparison of Models for Excess Mortality of Influenza Applied to Japan
Abstract: To elucidate the social effects of an influenza outbreak, the World Health Organization recommends a concept for excess mortality attributable to an influenza outbreak. However, because several models exist to estimate excess mortality, we would like to ascertain the most appropriate of three models: the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) model, the seasonal autoregressive integrated moving average (SARIMA) model, and the National Institution of Infectious Diseases (NIID) model. Excess mortality is defined as the difference between the actual number of deaths and the epidemiological threshold. The epidemiological threshold is defined as upper bound of 95% confidence interval (CI) of the baseline. The actual number of deaths might be less than the baseline, which implies inconsistent with the definition of baseline. Especially, actual deaths fewer than the lower bound of 95% CI of baseline suggest the inappropriateness of a model of excess mortality. Among 123 months during epidemic periods, the NIID model found excess mortality in 56 months, CDC model in 31 months, and SARIMA model in 35 months. Conversely, the NIID model found negative excess mortality in only 2 months, but the CDC model and SARIMA model found it respectively for 10 and 33 months. Negative excess mortality represents the logical inconsistency of the model. Therefore, NIID model might be the best among the three models considered.
Cite this paper: Sugawara, T. and Ohkusa, Y. (2019) Comparison of Models for Excess Mortality of Influenza Applied to Japan. Journal of Biosciences and Medicines, 7, 13-23. doi: 10.4236/jbm.2019.76002.

[1]   Lin, H.C., Chiu, H.F., Ho, S.C. and Yang, C.Y. (2014) Association of Influenza Vaccination and Reduced Risk of Stroke Hospitalization among the Elderly: A Population-Based Case-Control Study. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 11, 3639-3649.

[2]   Asghar, Z., Coupland, C. and Siriwardena, N. (2015) Influenza Vaccination and Risk of Stroke: Self-Controlled Case-Series Study. Vaccine, 33, 5458-5463.

[3]   Riedmann, E.M. (2013) Influenza Vaccination Reduces Risk of Heart Attack and Stroke. Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics, 9, 2500.

[4]   Kwok, C.S., Aslam, S., Kontopantelis, E., Myint, P.K., Zaman, M.J., Buchan, I., Loke, Y.K. and Mamas, M.A. (2015) Influenza, Influenza-Like Symptoms and Their Association with Cardiovascular Risks: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Observational Studies. International Journal of Clinical Practice, 69, 928-937.

[5]   Muhammad, S., Haasbach, E., Kotchourko, M., Strigli, A., Krenz, A., Ridder, D.A., Vogel, A.B., Marti, H.H., Al-Abed, Y., Planz, O. and Schwaninger, M. (2011) Influenza Virus Infection Aggravates Stroke Outcome. Stroke, 42, 783-791.

[6]   Assad, F., Cockburn, W.C. and Sundaresan, T.K. (1973) Use of Excess Mortality from Respiratory Diseases in the Study of Influenza. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 49, 219-233.

[7]   Serfling, R.E. (1963) Methods for Current Statistical Analysis of Excess Pneumonia-Influenza Deaths. Public Health Reports, 78, 494-506.

[8]   Choi, K. and Thacker, S.B. (1981) An Evaluation of Influenza Mortality Surveillance, 1962-1979. I. American Journal of Epidemiology, 113, 215-226.

[9]   Tachibana, T., Kawanami, K. and Minowa, M. (1999) Influenza Outbreak and Excess Mortality. Japanese Journal of Public Health, 46, 263-273.

[10]   Tachibana, T. and Minowa, M. (1999) Excess Mortality Due to Influenza. Journal of National Institution of Public Health, 48, 291-297. (In Japanese)

[11]   Takahashi, M. and Tango, T. (2001) A Proposal of New Definition and Estimation Procedure for Excess Mortality Due to Influenza. Japanese Journal of Public Health, 48, 402-408. (In Japanese)

[12]   Aiger, A.D., Lovell, K. and Schmitidt, P. (1977) Formulation and Estimation of Stochastic Frontier Production Function Models. Journal of Econometrics, 6, 21-37.

[13]   Jondrow, J., Lovell, K., Materov, S. and Schmidt, P. (1982) On the Estimation of Technical Inefficiency in the Stochastic Frontier Production Function Model. Journal of Econometrics, 19, 233-239.

[14]   Li, T. and Rosenman, R. (2001) Cost Inefficiency in Washington Hospitals: A Stochastic Frontier Approach Using Panel Data. Health Care Management Science, 4, 73-81.

[15]   Newhouse, J.P. (1994) Frontier Estimation: How Useful a Tool for Health Economics? Journal of Health Economics, 13, 317-322.

[16]   Shelton, B.H. (2003) Managed Care and Technical Efficiency. Health Economics, 12, 149-158.

[17]   Jacobs, R. (2001) Alternative Methods to Examine Hospital Efficiency: Data Envelopment Analysis and Stochastic Frontier Analysis. Health Care Management Science, 4, 103-115.

[18]   Rosko, M.D. (2001) Cost Efficiency of US Hospitals: A Stochastic Frontier Approach. Health Economics, 10, 539-551.

[19]   Jackson, M.L., Peterson, D., Nelson, J.C., Greene, S.K., Jacobsen, S.J., Belongia, E.A., Baxter, R. and Jackson, L.A. (2015) Using Winter 2009-2010 to Assess the Accuracy of Methods Which Estimate Influenza-Related Morbidity and Mortality. Epidemiology & Infection, 143, 2399-2407.

[20]   Goldstein, E., Viboud, C., Charu, V. and Lipsitch, M. (2012) Improving the Estimation of Influenza-Related Mortality over a Seasonal Baseline. Epidemiology, 23, 829-838.

[21]   Wu, A., Peng, Y., Du, X., Shu, Y. and Jiang, T. (2010) Correlation of Influenza Virus Excess Mortality with Antigenic Variation: Application to Rapid Estimation of Influenza Mortality Burden. PLOS Computational Biology, 6, e1000882.

[22]   Nielsen, J., Mazick, A., Glismann, S. and Molbak, K. (2011) Excess Mortality Related to Seasonal Influenza and Extreme Temperatures in Denmark, 1994-2010. BMC Infectious Diseases, 11, 350.

[23]   Muscatello, D.J., Newall, A.T., Dwyer, D.E. and Macintyre, C.R. (2013) Mortality Attributable to Seasonal and Pandemic Influenza, Australia, 2003 to 2009, Using a Novel Time Series Smoothing Approach. PLoS ONE, 8, e64734.

[24]   Park, M., Wu, P., Goldstein, E., Joo, K.W. and Cowling, B.J. (2016) Influenza-Associated Excess Mortality in South Korea. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 50, e111-e119.