In generalized measure and integral theory, there are several kinds of important nonlinear integrals, the Choquet integral  , the Sugeno integral  , the pan-integral  and the concave integral introduced by Lehrer  , etc. (see also  ). The pan-integral with respect to monotone measure μ relates to a commutative isotonic semiring , where is a pan-addition and is a pan-multiplication related by the distributivity property (see also  ). This integral generalizes the Lebesgue integral and the Sugeno integral. When considering a σ-additive measure m and the commutative isotonic semiring , the Lebesgue integral coincides with the pan-integral; when considering a monotone measure μ and the commutative isotonic semiring , the Sugeno integral is recovered by the pan-integral with respect to . The more details on the pan-integrals can be also found in  -  .
In classical measure theory  , given measure space and a nonnegative measurable function f on , the set function , defined by the Lebesgue integral of f,
is a measure, i.e., is σ-additive and , and is absolutely continuous with respect to m.
For the Sugeno integral and the Choquet integral, the issue above has also been discussed respectively in  and  . Given a measurable space , a monotone measure μ, and a nonnegative measurable function f on , the Sugeno integral (or the Choquet integral) with respect to μ determines a new monotone measure (or ). In general the monotone measures lose additivity, and they appear to be much looser than the classical measures. This new construction raises an important question: Do structural features of the original monotone measure μ still hold for these new monotone measures? It has been shown that the new monotone measures inherit almost all desirable structural characteristics of μ, such as, subadditivity, continuity from below, continuity from above, null-additivity, weak null-additivity and autocontinuity (see    ).
In this paper we discuss the above-mentioned issue for the pan-integrals. Given a pan-space and a nonnegative measurable function f on , the pan-integral of f with respect to μ and pan-operation determines a new monotone measure on . Such the monotone measure is absolutely continuous with respect to μ. We are going to show that reserves some important structural characteristics of μ, which is similar to the cases of the Choquet integral and the Sugeno integral. We are also going to show that if monotone measure is subadditive, then the pan-integral with respect to the monotone measure is a monotone superadditive functional. Since the pan-integral covers the Sugeno integral, while the Shilkret integral, the previous related results for the Sugeno integral become special cases of the results presented here, in the meantime, some special results related the Shilkret integral are shown.
Let X be a non-empty set, a σ-algebra of subsets of X. As usual the pair denotes a measurable space. Denotes , . Unless stated otherwise, all subsets mentioned are supposed to belong to .
Definition 1. (  ) An extended real valued set function is called a monotone measure defined on , if μ satisfies the following two conditions:
1) and ; (vanishing at )
2) , implies . (monotonicity)
When μ is a monotone measure, the triple is called a monotone measure space (  ).
In many literature, a monotone measure is also known as “non-additive measure”, “capacity”, “fuzzy measure”, “non-additive measure” or “non-additive probability”, etc. (see      ).
In this paper we restrict our discussion on fixed measurable space . Let the set of all monotone measures defined on .
A monotone measure is said to be: continuous from below  , if whenever ; continuous from above  , if whenever and ; continuous, if it is continuous both from below and from above; subadditive  , if whenever ; superadditive, if whenever , ; null-additive (  ), if for any A whenever ; weakly null-additive  , if , for any such that .
Obviously, the subadditivity of μ implies the null-additivity, and the later implies weak null-additivity. The converse implications may not be true.
Definition 2 (   ) Let . We say that
1) μ is absolutely continuous of Type I with respect to ν, denoted by , iff whenever ;
2) μ is absolutely continuous of Type VI with respect to ν, denoted by , iff whenever .
Obviously, implies . The inverse statement may not be true.
3. Pan-Operation and Integrals
In  Yang introduced the concept of pan-integral (see also  and  ), which is a type of nonlinear integral with respect to fuzzy measure. These integrals involve two binary operations, the pan-addition and pan-multiplication of real numbers. We recall a commutative isotonic semiring  (see also      ).
Definition 3. A binary operation on is called a pseudo-addition on if and only if it satisfies the following requirements:
(PA3) for any t;
(PA5) and .
From associativity (PA2), we may write as , and denote .
Definition 4. A binary operation on is called a pseudo-multiplication (with respect to pseudo-addition ) on if and only if it fulfills the following conditions:
(PM4) for any t;
(PM6) there exists , which is called the unit element, such that for any ;
(PM7) , and .
When is a pseudo-addition on and is a pseudo-multiplication (with respect to ) on , the triple is called a commutative isotonic semiring on (  ), and is called a pan-space (  ).
Next we recall the concept of pan-integral. denotes the set of all finite nonnegative -measurable functions on X. A finite partition of is a finite disjoint system of sets such that for and .
Definition 5. (   ) Let be a pan-space. For any , , the pan-integral of f over A with respect to μ, is defined by
where is the set of all finite partitions of X.
When , is written as .
The pan-integral of f over A with respect to μ can be expressed by pan-simple functions, as follows:
where is the pan-characteristic function of A, i.e.,
is pan-simple function (  ) and is the set of all finite partitions of A.
Note. A related concept of generalized Lebesgue integral based on a generalized ring was proposed and discussed (see  ).
The following is some basic properties of the pan-integrals (see   ).
Proposition 6. Let and . Then we have the following:
1) if , then ;
2) if a.e. on A, i.e., , then . Further, if μ is continuous from below, then if and only if
a.e. on A;
4) if , then ;
5) if , then
6) . In particular, for ,
The following is the Monotone Convergence Theorem of the pan-integral (   ).
Proposition 7. Let μ be continuous from below, , . If , then
Proposition 8. Let . We have the following:
1) , where ;
2) If μ is null-additive and a.e. on A, i.e., , then
Proof. Noting that , from Proposition 6 3), we can get 1).
2). Let , then and for any subset B of A we have . Thus, for any , . Moreover,
which implies that . In a similar way, we have , and thus 2) holds.
The following is three kinds of important nonlinear integrals    , see also  . Consider a nonnegative real-valued measurable function and , i.e., .
The Choquet integral  of f on X with respect to μ, denoted by , is defined by
where the right side integral is Riemann integral.
The Sugeno integral  of f on X with respect to μ, denoted by , is defined by
The Shilkret integral  of f on X with respect to μ, is defined by
For , if (resp. ), we say that f is Choquet integrable (resp. Sugeno integrable).
Note that in the case of commutative isotonic semiring , the Sugeno integral is recovered, while for , the Shilkret integral is covered by the pan-integral in Definition 5, i.e.,
4. Monotone Measures Defined by Pan-Integral
Given a pan-space and , we define a new set function by
From Definition 5 and Proposition 6 (v), we know that is a monotone measure on , too, i.e., .
The new monotone measure is said to be monotone measure defined by pan-integral.
In the following we discuss some properties of on the given pan-space . We denote by .
Proposition 9. (  ) We have the following: , ,
Proposition 10. We have the following:
1) , i.e., ,
Furthermore, if , i.e., , then for any ,
2) If , then , i.e., , as ,
Proof. 1) From definition of the pan-integral, the (3.2) is obvious.
Let , then , if , then
Therefore , and noting that , we get .
The proof of 2) is similar.
The following is an alternative statement of Proposition 6 2).
Proposition 11. Let μ be continuous from below and . Then a.e. on A if and only if .
Proposition 12. Let . If μ is null-additive, then so is .
Proof. For any and , by Proposition 10 1), we have . Noting that a.e. on X, from Proposition 6 3) and 8 2) we have
Similarly, we can get the following result.
Proposition 13. Let . If μ is weakly null-additive, then so is .
Proposition 14. If μ is continuous from below, then so is .
Proof. From Proposition 7, i.e., the Monotone Convergence Theorem of the pan-integral, and Proposition 6 3), we can obtain the desired conclusion.
We consider the Sugeno integral and Shilkret integral.
Proposition 15. 1) If μ is sub-additive, then so is , that is, ,
2) If μ is sub-additive, then so is , that is, ,
The following result was obtained in  .
Proposition 16. We have the following:
1) If μ is Ú-additive (it is also called to be fuzzy additive, i.e., for any ), then so is , that is, ,
2) If μ is fuzzy multiplicative ( for any ), then so is , that is, ,
Similar to Proposition 16 we can get the following result for the Shilkret integral.
Proposition 17. We have the following:
1) If μ is Ú-additive, then so is , that is, ,
2) If μ is fuzzy multiplicative, then so is , that is, ,
Definition 18. Let , and be a pan-space. The monotone measure μ is said to be
1) sub-Å-additive, if whenever ;
2) super-Å-additive, if whenever , ;
3) Å-additive, if for any , ;
4) σ-Å-additive, if for any disjoint sequence of sets ,
Proposition 19. Given the pan-space and . If μ is sub-Å-additive, then so is .
Proof. For any , we assume that without loss of generality. From Definition 5, we notice that μ is sub-Å-additive, thus
The proof is complete.
We also have the following results (see  ).
Proposition 20. Given the pan-space and .
1) If μ is Å-additive, then so is .
2) If μ is σ-Å-additive, then so is .
Given the pan-space , the pan-integral
determines a monotone functional on .
In the following we show that if μ is sub-Å-additive, then the monotone functional is super-Å-additive.
Proposition 21. Given the pan-space . If μ is sub-Å-additive, then for any , it holds
Proof: Let . For any
where , we have
On the other hand,
Noting that , it follows
Since μ is sub-Å-additive, we have
The proof is complete.
In the special case of the usual addition + and multiplication, the following results have been obtained in  :
Proposition 22. Given the pan-space and . If μ is subadditive, then so is , i.e., any ,
Proposition 23. Given the pan-space If μ is subadditive, then for any , it holds
We have discussed the monotone measures defined by the pan-integral (with respect to monotone measure μ and operations ). As what has been discussed above, this construction inherited almost all desirable structural characteristics of the original monotone measure μ. They are continuity from below, Å-additivity, Å-subadditivity, null-additivity, weak null-additivity, etc. We have also shown that the pan-integral with respect to the subadditive monotone measure is monotone superadditive functional.
In general, monotone measures lose additivity, they appear to be much looser than the classical measures. Thus, it is quite difficult to develop a general theory of monotone measures and nonlinear integral without any additional condition. The concepts mentioned above replace additivity play important roles in generalized measure theory (see       ). So, the results we obtained here are significant when applying monotone measure theory to expert systems, decision making, pattern recognition, image processing, risk analysis, and other areas.
The concave integral is a type of important nonlinear integral (with respect to capacity)   . In further research, we will investigate properties of monotone measures defined by concave integral.
We point out that there are three important structural characteristics of monotone set function: strong order continuity  (see also  ), the property (S) and the condition (E)  . It has been shown that Lebesgue’s theorem, Riesz’s theorem and Egoroff’s theorem in classical measures theory (   ) hold in the case of monotone measures if and only if the monotone measures possess strong order continuity    (see also  ). We state these three concepts in the following:
Definition 24. (  ) A monotone measure is said to be strongly order continuous, if whenever with .
Definition 25. (  A fuzzy measure μ is said to have property) (S), if for any with , there exists a subsequence of such that
Definition 26. (  ) A fuzzy measure μ is said to fulfill the condition (E), if for every double sequence satisfying the conditions: for fixed ,
there exist increasing sequences and of natural numbers, such that
We don’t know whether the monotone measure defined by the pan-integral with respect to monotone measure μ and operations can inherit these three important structural characteristics of monotone measures (even in special cases of or , it is not clear). We will further investigate these problems.
This research was partially supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 11571106).
 Benvenuti, P., Mesiar, R. and Vivona, D. (2002) Monotone Set Functions-Based Integrals. In: Pap, E., Ed., Handbook of Measure Theory, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1329-1379.
 Li, J., Mesiar, R. and Zhang, Q. (2010) Absolute Continuity of Monotone Measure and Convergence in Measure. Communications in Computer and Information Science, 80, 500-504.
 Wang, Z., Klir, G.J. and Wang, W. (1996) Fuzzy Measures Defined by Fuzzy Integral and Their Absolute Continuity. Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, 203, 150-165.
 Benvenuti, P. and Mesiar, R. (2004) Pseudo-Arithmetical Operations as a Basis for the General Measure and Integration Theory. Information Sciences, 160, 1-11.
 Ouyang, Y., Li, J. and Mesiar, R. (2017) On Linearity of Pan-Integral and Pan-Integrable Functions Space. International Journal of Approximate Reasoning, 90, 307-318.
 Li, J. (2003) Order Continuity of Monotone Set Function and Convergence of Measurable Functions Sequence. Applied Mathematics and Computation, 135, 211-218.