Hypertensive states during pregnancy remain one of the three direct causes of maternal death globally  and a leading cause of early neonatal death in developing nations   . This disease affects 3% - 14% of all pregnancies worldwide and 5% - 8% in the USA  . Hypertensive disorders of pregnancy include chronic hypertension, which arises prior to pregnancy and gestational hypertension, a pregnancy-specific health event  . Gestational hypertension can induce an accelerated risk for developing preeclampsia  , which is a life-threatening condition compromising the progression of normal human gestation  . Preeclampsia remains one of the leading causes of maternal morbidity, as premature delivery and/or uteroplacental insuﬃciency which causes a compromise of blood ﬂow to the fetus, and neonatal mortality and morbidity worldwide     .
The clinical presentation of preeclampsia presents as a multi-system disorder  characterized by hypertension with   or without proteinuria   and edema    . It can be preceded by co-morbid conditions  and metabolic syndrome    prior to overt presentation  ; nevertheless, it is devastating when presented earlier in pregnancy  . However, the clinical diagnosis of preeclampsia is about 20 weeks of gestation     and can persist up to 4 weeks postpartum  , beyond delivery of the placenta  .
A preeclamptic pregnancy is a high-risk disease of population disparity, affecting underserved areas of the world  and ethnic minorities in the USA  . Although its etiologic events vary, there are studies indicating that it is associated with comorbid disorders of obesity  , nulliparity    , multiple gestation   or with a family history of preeclampsia  . Preeclampsia is also more common in pregnancies resulting from egg donation, donor insemination, or in vitro fertilization  , supporting the argument for immunologic tolerance of the mother. Interestingly, most patients with preeclampsia present with no identified risk factors  and preeclampsia recurrence risk increases with subsequent pregnancies   . The sum of social, economic and ethnic disparities, comorbid medical conditions, fertility, genetic and environmental factors facilitate the development of preeclampsia.
Because the underlying pathology of preeclampsia predates its overt clinical presentation  ; the concept for intervention focuses on early events. There are numerous reports that Vitamin D deficiency during pregnancy is a strong  and independent correlate to the development of early onset preeclampsia     . Since preeclampsia is phenotypically multifactorial and vitamin D deficiency potentiates hypertension (renin-angiotensin system), immunologic competence (cytokine and immunoglobin regulation) and cell differentiation/proliferation (gene regulation), this suggests that Vitamin D deficiency potentiates hypertensive states of pregnancy via an underlying mechanism that is not fully understood.
Despite intense and numerous years of research, the etiology of preeclampsia remains obscure; its pathogenic mechanisms remain unresolved and awaits deciphering and intervention. Current knowledge confirms the primary pathophysiologic event is structural endothelial dysfunction during placental vascular development at the time of implantation  . Placental ischemia results in interferences to the normal adaptive responses to pregnancy. This pathology causes upstream triggers that perpetuates a generalized maternal systemic vasospasm, poor tissue perfusion and damage to many vital organs. This results in organ dysfunction. The disease severity relates to progressive maternal systemic vascular compromise  . It is well accepted that Vitamin D deficiency plays a role in a mother’s risk to acquire early and severe preeclampsia     . Current literature establishes that the relationship between shared common pathways of both Vitamin D and preeclampsia are more causal than casual. A review of the common and shared pathways is interpreted to hypothesize a mechanism that links early pathologic events beginning at implantation that involves vitamin D deficiency to clinical onset of preeclampsia. This review also seeks to identify and create “focal hot spots” for additional research and medical intervention.
2. Placental Invasion, implantation and Vasculogenesis
The mammalian placenta is a vital organ of pregnancy, accepting the fetus as a semi-allogeneic product and functioning as the interface between maternal and fetal environments. This provides essential nutrients that regulate maternal-fetal hemodynamics. Normal pregnancy is associated with adaptive responses providing significant hemodynamic restructuring (physiologic) to ensure normal fetal growth. This restructuring process results in a decrease in total peripheral vascular resistance at the level of the placenta with an associated increase in maternal cardiac output, up to 30% to 45%, without elevations in systemic blood pressure  .
A. Normal implantation development (Figure 1): It is well established that normal pregnancy progresses in a series of sequential chronological events represented by inflammation (implantation), anti-inflammation (gestation) and inflammation (parturition)  . Signals from maternal uterine endometrium allow the invasion of fetal trophoblasts into the uterine decidua during the process of implantation    . This requires that the mother recognize the newly developing embryo as immunological “self” in order to accept the fetal trophoblast  as an anergic, semi-allogeneic product. This becomes the initial role of the mother’s innate immune system  .
Fetal cytotrophoblasts within the placenta differentiate into extravillous trophoblasts (EVT), which have an invasive phenotype  . A unique leukocyte subpopulation of maternal decidual Natural Killer (dNK) cells (uniquely identified as CD56 bright CD16−), key components of the innate immune system, are massively recruited at the site of embryonic implantation (decidua basalis)  . dNK cells function is determined by the balance between inhibitory and activating receptors. Expression of inhibitory killer-cell immunoglobulin-like receptors (KIR2DL4) on dNK cells, which are capable of recognizing and binding to both
Figure 1. Events of normal implantation and placentation. Nutrigenomic role Vitamin D and common pathways of placental invasion, implantation, immune tolerance and vasculogenesis. Bioavailable Vitamin D is generated by conversion from D2 to D3 [1, 25 (OH)2 D3] within decidua and trophoblastic cells and bound to VDBP. Ligand-bound VDR transcriptionally activates expression of HLA genes within EVT cells to mediate anergy. Vitamin D regulates expression of mitogenic and pathfinding genes in dNK cells that mediate trafficking within the decidua. Activated VDR in CD56br dNK cells mediates anergy by upregulating CD16 gene expression to produce the characteristic CD56+ 16+ immune modulator phenotype. VDR bound ligand mediates repression of IFN γ gene expression to confer dNK induced tolerance. Th-2 expression of IL-10 is modulated by bioactive Vitamin D which mediates Th2 proliferation, clonal expansion, and anti-inflammatory cytokine production.
the classical HLA-class I and non-classical HLA-C and HLA-G receptors  expressed by and presented on fetal-EVT  , are necessary to establish the maternal-fetal interface. Ligand bound-KIR2DL4 receptor on dNK cells transduces signaling that confers inhibition of pathways which activate death effectors  . This promotes immune tolerance by the dNK cells to the invading semi-allogeneic trophoblasts. This mechanism of dNK-mediated anergic trophoblast is critical to successful implantation   enabling progressive anchoring and invasion into the maternal decidua.
After acceptance by the maternal immune system, adequate spiral artery remodeling at the maternal-fetal interface  occurs, involving a highly choreographed cross-talk necessary for development of utero-placental perfusion  . Perfusion enables flow of nutrients to the developing fetus. The adaptive immune system plays a role in activating placental cell expression of chemokines and cytokines in a redundant manner  and growth factors that together modulate the implantation process  . Thereafter, a series of cytokine influxes are involved in angiogenesis and vascular stability, in particular VEGF, PlGF and angiotensin II (Ang-II)  , leading to progressive placental perfusion    .
Implantation in preeclampsia (Figure 2): Normal fetal EVT express increasing amounts of HLA-G with advancing invasive phenotype  . Genetic data have
Figure 2. Events of implantation and placentation leading to preeclampsia. Nutrigenomic role of Vitamin D in pathologic pathways of placental invasion, implantation, immune tolerance and vasculogenesis. Loss or reduction of bioavailable Vitamin D caused by reduced conversion from D2 to D3 [1, 25 (OH)2 D3] within decidua and trophoblastic cells and/or binding to VDBP is an early mechanism in hypertensive associated preeclampsia. Reduced concentration of D3 leads to insufficient activation of VDR transcriptional activity and therefore reduced expression of HLA genes within EVT cells which induce immune intolerance. Lack of bioavailable Vitamin D leads to reduced mitogenic proliferation of dNK cells. Non-activated VDR in CD56br dNK cells do not produce expression of CD16 gene which mediates immune activation of death effect or gene expression in dNK cells. Loss of Vitamin D3 inhibition of IFN- gene leads to expression and immune-induced destruction of EVT cells. Th-2 expression of IL-10 is reduced by insufficient bioactive Vitamin D which confers increased IL-6 expression and up regulation of CD4+ Th1 induced cytokine mediated inflammation and immune intolerance.
shown that mutations which inhibit proliferation, trafficking, or expansion of dNK cells   or a combination of defects in expression of maternal KIR2DL4 and/or fetal HLA-G and HLA-C receptors  can challenge the mother’s immunogenic tolerance for a successful implantation process, influencing the risk for preeclampsia  . Most preeclamptic placentae have absent or reduced HLA-G mRNA and protein expressions  on their trophoblasts making them vulnerable to attack by the maternal immune system. This results in decreased anchoring and invasive capability necessary to effectively form structurally stable and expansive maternal spiral arteries, this may be an etiologic mechanism for shallow placental invasion and penetration that initiates a cascade of systemic events associated with preeclampsia   .
Role of Vitamin D in implantation: Studies have demonstrated that Vitamin D receptors (VDR) are expressed on both placental decidua and fetal trophoblast cells in humans   . Synthesis of 1, 25 (OH) 2D (3) is higher in first trimester decidual cells (41 +/− 11.8 fmoles/h/mg protein) compared to third trimester cells (8 +/− 4.4 fmoles/h/mg protein; P < 0.05). This suggest that Vitamin D may influence implantation by regulating expression of key target genes; as well as, modulating pleiotropic cross-talk of paracrine dialogue involving soluble HLA-G  . Chan et al. demonstrated intracrine VDR, in-vitro, responds to both precursor and metabolites of Vitamin D in a dose-dependent manner on human EVT from first trimester human pregnancies. There was a significantly increased EVT invasion with Vitamin D supplementation (maximal effect at 1 nM 1, 25-D3, 1.9-fold; p < 0.01 and 100 nM 25-D3, 2.2-fold; p < 0.05) compared to untreated controls. These characteristic EVT expressed HLA-G markers of invasion were independent of cell viability. They concluded that dysregulated bioactivity of Vitamin D in uteroplacental tissues in combination with attenuated EVT invasion could be one of the mechanisms causing malplacentation, suggesting that Vitamin D deficiency modulates risk for pre-eclampsia  .
3. Immune System in placentation
Locally, decidualmonocytes, dendritic cells (DCs) and C CD4+ lymphocytes further modulate maternal immune tolerance, promoting myometrial invasion of trophoblast and subsequent vascular bed remodeling necessary for a successful implantation   .
Immune system in normal placental development: The maturation and activation of specific monocytes have various functions in implantation such as phagocytosis, antigen presentation and cytokine production. A state of induced immune tolerance of the mother for the fetus occur as: 1) DCs promote CD4+ helper 2 (Th2) dominance, therefore decreasing the Th1/Th2 ratio; 2) increased numbers of regulatory T cells (Tregs) which produce anti-inflammatory cytokines like Interleukin 10 (IL-10) help regulate the adaptive immune system’s response to placental ischemia  ; and 3) an increase Treg/Th17 ratio which is favorable for immune tolerance  . This prevents vasoconstricting effects of endothelin-1 (ET-1) and reactive oxygen species (ROS) which are produced in response to ischemic conditions   . Interestingly, interleukin 17 (IL-17) which is up regulated in many autoimmune disorders  is offset when this ratio is elevated.
Immune system in preeclampsia: The balance between Th1/Th2 is critical for healthy fetal implantation and pregnancy development. Th2 expressing cytokines (IL-4, IL-10 and TGF-β) are favorable for the maintenance of mammalian pregnancy  ; whereas, Th1 cytokines (IL-2, IFN-, TNF-α) are unfavorable since they are associated with rejection of the fetal allograft at the feto-maternal interface  . Placental ischemia in preeclampsia is associated with an immune imbalance where proinflammatory states are upregulated. There is a ratio bias between the two subpopulations of CD4+ T cells, Tregs and Th17s, where a reversal of the Treg/Th17 ratio prevail due to Th17 upregulation. This results in an uncontrolled proinflammatory environment which causes unfavorable immunogenic responses to the fetal allograft  . The anti-inflammatory cytokines of Tregs (IL-10 and Th2 cells) that help regulate healthy immune response loses their protective function, stimulation and proliferation during inflammation  . In addition, Th17 produces IL17, a proinflammatory cytokine. Both Th17 and neutrophil migration increase TNF-α and IL-6 in the myometrium, inducing massive inflammation that generate increased oxidative stress and ROS. These effects are additive when producing endothelial damage/dysfunction; and as such, studies have shown that decrease in Treg populations is directly proportional to the severity of preeclampsia  . It has been shown that this cascade of events resemble inflammation similar to autoimmune diseases and other immunologic conditions that ultimately result in the maternal loss of immune tolerance for the fetus during pregnancy  .
The immune imbalance from placental ischemia, its resulting proinflammatory circulating CD4+ cells and their cytotoxic cytokines cause an excessive maternal humoral intravascular inflammatory response involving intravascular leukocytes traveling into the maternal systemic circulation, further injuring the vascular endothelial cell barrier  . Also, monocytes of the preeclamptic pregnancy are of different subpopulations. They produce increase amounts of oxygen free radicals and different cytokines (IL-12 and TNF-α)  which contribute to the down regulation of T-cell activity   . This further activates and recruits activated monocytes and, in combination, with activation of other inflammatory cells, such as granulocytes and endothelial cells, induce the full blown syndrome of preeclampsia  . A reduction in the supply of oxygenated blood to the uteroplacental unit (Placental ischemia) not only causes a robust oxidative stress response but also stimulates hypoxia-factors which produce vaso-occlusive and/or vasoconstrictive substances, such as soluble fms-like tyrosine kinase-1 (sFlt-1) and soluble endoglin (sEng) that contribute to the development of hypertension  . There is also decreased vasodilator nitric oxide (NO) and involvement of the adaptive immune pathway with B-cell production of autoantibodies that activate angiotensin II type I receptor (AT1).
Zenclussen et al.  showed a relationship between decidual expression of the Heme Oxygenase (HO) and NO in pregnant mice, along with a relationship to Th1/Th2 cytokine production. NO’s vasodilatory role decreases systemic vascular resistance  . Previous observations suggested that regulation of the HO system is dependent on NO activity―both endothelial NO (eNO) and inducible NO (iNO)  . Purcell et al. described that increases in NO concentration during implantation could be necessary for developing adequate spiral artery structure within the myometrium and thus facilitating attachment  . Zenclussen et al. confirmed down-regulation of HO system in mice undergoing abortion accompanied by augmented Th1/Th2 cytokine ratio in a manner of pregnancy-incompatibility. This suggests that HO up-regulation is pregnancy-protective via decreasing the Th1/Th2 ratio or by protecting tissues from apoptosis  . Furthermore, sEng induction by hypoxia, impairs binding of TGF-β to its receptors which leads to dysregulated TGF-β signaling in the vasculature; this mechanism was shown to inhibit formation of capillaries, in vitro, and induce vascular permeability and hypertension, in vivo  . Additionally, sEng has a downstream effect on e NOS activation and vasodilation  .
In summary, lack of vascular remodeling produces placental ischemia, which induces shallow trophoblast invasion and expansion that contributes to an increase in uterine artery resistance over time. A reduced placental blood flow causes low oxygen and nutrient delivery that have the potential to restrict intrauterine fetal growth   . We postulate that upregulation of anti-inflammatory cytokines at early stages of implantation will induce essential immune response(s) to the placental semi-allograft, preventing non-phagocytic oxidative burst from neutrophil mediated degradative/necrotic mechanism and facilitate placental implantation.
Vitamin D in Immune effect of placentation: The interaction of 1, 25 (OH) 2D (Calcitriol) with its nuclear receptor (calcitriol receptor) is an active holo-transcription factor. It influences activation or repression of gene transcription. Nuclear receptors for 1, 25 (OH) 2D (3) are present in a range of tissues including the placenta   . Placental and decidual tissues synthesize 1, 25 (OH) 2D in dose-dependent concentration to reduce the proliferation of allogeneically stimulated lymphocytes and cytotoxic cell generation  during early gestation. A functional Vitamin D enzyme system is present on dNK cells, making them more sensitive to calcitriol than their peripheral blood counterparts  .
Vitamin D experiments have suggested that it modifies uncontrolled proinflammatory environments manifested during hypoxia-induced preeclampsia  . Through transcriptional activation of mitogenic genes in Th2 cells, bioavailable Vitamin D modulates the balance between Th1/Th2 cell ratio in favor of Th2 proliferation   . Vitamin D also increases the transactivation of IL-10 and transrepresses the expression of Th1 mediated proinflammatory cytokines such as IFN-, IL-2 and TNF-α  . One study illustrated that the proportion of TNF-α-expressing Th cells was significantly higher during Vitamin D deficiency  . IL-10, produced by Tregs  in response to ischemia, can limit oxidative stress, and with the presence of calcitriol at the feto-maternal interface, modulates the immunological milieu to prevent rejection of the fetal allograft.  .
Smith et al. observed that deficiency in Vitamin D causes a cascade of changes in cytokine expression that closely mirrors the changes of inadequate trophoblastic invasion  . Proinflammatory cytokines are commonly elevated during preeclampsia  . In an experiment conducted by Diaz et al., proinflammatory conditions were mimicked in cultured trophoblastic cells inducing elevated cytokines; TNF-α stimulated increases in IL-6 and INF- concentration as well as their gene expressions. The presence of calcitriol resulted in a dose-dependent inhibition of expression of TNF-α and IL-6, down-regulating their proinflammatory nature in the preeclampsia placental cultures. Calcitriol treatment also resulted in a decreased concentration of mRNA and protein of all three cytokines (TNF-α, stimulated IL-6, INF-) and that the highest calcitriol concentration resulted in reduced gene expression with values similar to those observed in control experiments  . Other studies also report that calcitriol suppressed inflammatory IFN-γ RNA expression on in uterine NK (uNK) cells by seven-fold  .
Other immune modulatory roles of Vitamin D include: 1) potent regulation of antibacterial cytokine production by uNK cells including cathelicidin antimicrobial peptide (CAMP) (Evans, Nguyen et al. 2006)  ; 2) suppresses adverse inflammatory adaptive responses to successful implantation  ; 3) plays a pivotal role in B cell immunity, which down regulates B-cell proliferation, plasma cell differentiation and IgG secretion; 4) Calcitriol is also known to additionally induce TGF-β  ; and 5) it is an important mediator of innate immune response affecting peripheral blood monocytes. Monocyte expression of toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) are modulated by Vitamin D. When Vitamin D deficiency or insufficiency showed a tendency to increase the percentage of peripheral blood B cells, this could be partially restored with 1, 25 (OH) 2D supplementation with improved cellular immunity and placentation  . In instances when another macrophage produced cytokines, TGF-β interacts with NK cells to inhibit cytotoxicity of fetal trophoblasts. In the absence of Vitamin D, TLR4 becomes proinflammatory. Monocytes from preeclampsia patients express significantly increased levels of TLR4 and produce high concentrations of proinflammatory cytokines: TNF-α, IL-6 and IL-1. In a study conducted by Qian et al., 2000 IU calcitriol supplementation for 12 consecutive weeks to preeclamptic women showed a significant lowering of both the mean fluorescence intensity and the positive percentage of monocytes expressing TLR4 compared to the placebo group, as well as reducing the concentrations of secreted TNF-α, IL-6, and IL-1, yet the concentration of IL-10 was higher. By inhibiting the expression of peripheral blood TLR4 through Vitamin D3 supplementation, the incidence of preeclampsia lowered  . There is a link between CYP 27 B1 and immune function in the decidua which correlates with expression of TLR4 could indicate that Vitamin D may act in an autocrine/paracrine fashion in its regulation of both acquired and innateimmune responses  .
4. Heme Oxygenase-1 in placentation
Heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1) is expressed in the placenta    at a level comparable to that of the normal spleen, a tissue known for having high heme-oxygenase activity  . HO-1 is an inducible ~32 kDa protein which participates in breakdown of the heme-complex to generate equimolar amounts of biliverdin, free iron and carbonmonoxide. The degradation of hemoglobin by HO-1 can occur in virtually every cell  . Cell free heme-complexes can be generated from hemolysis, myolysis, ischemia/reperfusion, and other pathologic states. We postulate that cell free heme is a product of residual differentiation, shedding, and apoptosis from normal processes of placentation and implantation. Hence, concentration expected to increase in pathological states of inflammation and immune intolerance during abnormality of implantation. Studies have shown that HO-1, a rate limiting enzyme in hemoglobin degradation, is important in the regulation and maintenance of placental vascular development (angiogenesis and matrix remodeling of placental vessels) in early pregnancy  . Under physiologic conditions, these metabolic byproducts result in the following biological properties: antioxidants, vasodilatory, anti-thrombotic, anti-inflammatory, antiapoptotic and cytoprotective   . The vasodilatory properties of heme catabolism is mediated mainly through endogenous carbon monoxide production that contributes significantly to the reduction of maternal peripheral vascular resistance and blood pressure  . Carbon monoxide can influence vascular tone independently  or influence other cytoprotective (anti-apoptotic, anti-inflammatory, antioxidant), vasoregulatory  or inhibitory effects in platelet aggregation pathways synergistic to NO  , further protecting vascular integrity. HO-1 expression is also induced by oxidative stress  to protect against vascular ischemia-reperfusion injury  during spontaneous vasoconstriction  ; and, its induction depends on gene transcription and protein synthesis  . The cellular protective function of HO-1, when expressed in endothelial cells, inhibits inflammatory responses which leads to graft acceptance  . HO-1 catabolizes heme to avoid toxic intracellular accumulation of free heme, preventing oxidative damage  .
HO-1 and preeclampsia: In humans, HO-1 polymorphisms have been associated with a spectrum of compromise to placental development   including placental spiral artery remodeling  . Any genetic polymorphism of HO-1 affects placental development with similar pathological, biochemical and clinical changes as preeclampsia   . Most tissues express HO-1 at relatively low levels under homeostatic conditions; however, when stimulated by stress, transcriptional activation of the HO-1 gene is rapidly induced. HO-1 gene expression is induced by a variety of stimuli besides stress, to include proinflammatory mediators such as interleukins (IL-1 α, IL-1 β, IL-6 and IL-11) and cytokine (tumor necrosis factor-α)  . Studies have shown that HO-1-deficiency is associated with reduced stress defense and a proinflammatory tendency with susceptibility to vascular damage  . Stressed mammalian cells up regulate HO-1 during hypoxia-ischemia-reperfusion vascular injury as an adaptive mechanism to protect cells from oxidative damage. Its presence is a sensitive and reliable indicator of cellular oxidative stress. When oxidative stress occurs, high levels of oxygen free radicals are produced causing lipid peroxidation and endothelial lining damage  . The presence of cellular antioxidants, like HO-1, become crucial to reduce oxidative stress and prevent free radicle damage to blood vessels  . It is proposed that complications of pregnancy, such as recurrent miscarriages, intrauterine growth retardation and preeclampsia are associated with HO-1 deficiency  .
Vitamin D and HO-1 regulation: Hypoxia/oxidative stress, characteristic of placental trophoblastic dysfunction in preeclampsia, is also associated with imbalance between two cyclooxygenase metabolites, arachidonic acid thromboxane (TXA) and prostacyclin (PGI). A state of hypoxia/oxidative stress manifests increased TXA (a potent vasoconstrictor and facilitator of platelet aggregation) and a decreased prostacyclin production (a potent vasodilator)  . Experimental results published by Sun et al., pretreatment of 1, 25 (OH) 2D (3) to their hypoxia/oxidative stress model resulted in a significantly reduced TXA and reduced ratio of TXA to PGI, suppressing hypoxia/oxidative stress. Although there was no effect on HO-1 upregulation, its effect on prostacyclin dominance could promote circulation and retard thrombosis in the placenta  . Although Vitamin D has been shown to reduce oxidative stress by lowering the plasma oxidative stress marker and reducing inflammation during pregnancy-induced hypertension  , its direct role on HO-1 pathways remain to be clarified  .
5. Angiogenic Balance
Normal: The invasion of trophoblast into the placenta bed occurs as it adopts an endothelial phenotype with adhesion molecules for subsequent angiogenesis to evolve  . The ideal vascular endothelium becomes a critical barrier and the primary sensor of physical and chemical changes in the bloodstream  . It has the following complex roles: 1) to control the passage of fluid into tissue, 2) for cellular trafficking that prevents damage from ROS, 3) as an inhibitor of coagulation and 4) to regulate vascular smooth muscle tone (blood pressure) through the release of vasodilatory (NO working synergistically with prostacyclin) and vasoconstricting agents (like ET-1, Ang-II and thromboxane A2)  . Excess shedding of cellular debris by the syncytiotrophoblast (syncytial apoptosis) cause the release of microparticles  into the maternal circulation as part of a normal process of turnover and repair  .
Preeclampsia and angiogenic imbalance (Figure 3): Poorly developed blood supply through the placental vascular bed results in progressive placental hypoperfusion  and its resultant ischemia  . Lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) production has been used as an early clinical marker of anaerobic metabolism; progressive LDH elevation reflects the severity of the hypoxic condition  .
The pathologic hallmark of preeclampsia is endothelial cell injury and dysfunction. It is associated with altered regulatory vascular responses that lead to pathologic consequences of dysregulated systemic and placental immunity   . There is upregulation of adhesion molecules, generation of chemokines such as macrophage chemoattractant peptide-1)  , production of pro-coagulative circulating markers of endothelial cell injury, [plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 (PAI-1)]    , cellular fibronectin, factor VIII antigen  and vasoconstrictive cytokine (ET-1)  . This prothrombotic state is seen in women as progressive symptoms of preeclampsia. Endothelial dysfunction is an encompassing term resulting in a shift from a normal, healthy endothelium to a stressed/damaged endothelium that acquire a proinflammation, pro-coagulation and pro-vasoconstriction phenotype   . This phenotype is characterized by reduced NO availability, which may stem from either decreased NO production or from increased NO inactivation  ; there is free radical damage causing detachment and apoptosis of endothelial cells  .
Figure 3. Schematic progression to preeclampsia following abnormal EVT invasion.
During preeclampsia, there is a non-physiologic increase in syncytiotrophoblast apoptosis   results in an increased syncytial debris (and knot formation) released into the maternal circulation  in an unscheduled manner. Candidate substances of excessive syncytial shedding into the maternal plasma during endothelial dysfunction act to provoke a maternal syndrome; they may serve to elevate antiangiogenic  substances. This pathophysiology is associated with upstream triggers of antiangiogenic promoters when angiogenic promoters   are down regulated. The down regulation may involve other proangiogenic pathways, such as nitric oxide, heme oxygenase and hydrogen sulfide. Imbalances due to upregulated antiangiogenic promotors are evident when oxidative stress cause evolution of autoantibodies  .
The angiogenic imbalance favors the presence of several highly circulating antiangiogenic factors  of various sizes, shed from damaged placental endothelium   , that can be detected as early as 11 - 14 week of gestation  prior to the onset of preeclampsia. The circulating antiangiogenic factors which have been used as predictive biomarkers of preeclampsia are: high levels of sFlt-1, sEng   and tissue transglutaminase (tTG)  and decreased circulating levels of free vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF)   . There are other circulating levels of cellular microparticles that are elevated during preeclampsia    .
Angiogenic pathways allow free VEGF to bind to PlGF activating VEGF receptor type 2 (VEGFR 2) that supports vascular growth. SFlt-1, a unique receptor for VEGF, is produced primarily by the syncytiotrophoblast syncytial knots of the placenta  . Although the placenta produces sFlt-1 during normal pregnancy, higher amounts of sFlt-1 are produced from the hypoxic preeclamptic placentae  . Elevated sFlt-1 binds to free VEGF and PlGF in the maternal circulation, reducing each’s binding affinity for their membrane receptor  , there by inhibiting the effects of VEGF binding to PlGF on maternal endothelial cells and podocytes  . This reduces endothelial integrity and function  as well as placenta vascular growth  . Findings suggest that concentrations of sFlt-1 increases steeply about five weeks before the onset of clinical preeclampsia compared to controls; although, sFlt-1 normally increase in late gestation  .
The relationship of sFlt-1 to angiogenic PlGF has been clinically studied in ethnic population with preeclampsia. African-American women with preeclampsia (means gestational age of 32.3 weeks and with high BMI) were found to have significantly lower levels of PlGF (90.3 ± 8.9 pg/ml versus 172.8 ± 20.2 pg/ml; p < 0.01), higher sFlt-1 (2087.3 ± 200.1 pg/ml versus 1546.5 ± 91.9 pg/ml; p < 0.01) and a higher sFlt-1/PLGF ratio (66.8 ± 18.7 versus 22.3 ± 2.9; p < 0.01) compared to racially-matched normotensive controls  . This increase sFlt-1/P1GF ratio paralleled a decrease in the free VEGF and free PlGF levels, suggesting a decrease in these angiogenic factors attributed to binding by sFlt-1. Low concentrations of PlGF during early gestation have been associated with greater risk of early-onset preeclampsia. Although low PlGF has not been shown to be a predictive marker for onset of preeclampsia at ≥37 weeks  , it has high sensitivity and negative predictive value for preeclampsia manifesting within 14 days of preeclamptic symptoms before 35 weeks’ gestation  . Therefore, using PlGF-based tests for patients with suspected preeclampsia at 20 - 37 weeks could provide diagnostic accuracy and cost-effectiveness  . Other studies have shown that circulating antiangiogenic factor have played major roles for predicting the severity of preeclampsia, either alone or in combination, with other clinical parameters and chemical markers      early in gestation. It also has the potential to predict restricted fetal growth in advanced gestation   .
6. Vitamin D and vasculogenesis
Vitamin D and angiogenic imbalance: Experimental findings that Vitamin D regulates VEGF production remain unclear. Nevertheless, studies have associated low Vitamin D levels to markers of antiangiogenic factors; and that, in combination, are predictive of preeclampsia from midgestation with some degree of severity. A study by Wei et al. associated significantly lower PlGF levels in women with 25 (OH) D < 50 nmol/L as early as 12 - 18 weeks gestation (median, 449.5) vs. 25 (OH) D > 50 nmol/L (507.9 pg/mL), p = 0.04) with a significantly lower intercellular Adhesion Molecule-1 (ICAM-1) level. Both soluble vascular adhesion Molecule-1 (VCAM-1) and ICAM-1 levels have interaction involving trophoblastic angiogenesis. ICAM-1 is important in stabilizing cell-cell interactions and facilitating leukocyte endothelial transmigration. In this study, both low maternal 25 (OH) D and low PlGF levels were inversely associated with risk of preeclampsia; this risk was independent of each other. Also, although low Vitamin D was associated with elevated ICAM-1, there was no correlation to impaired angiogenesis since the risk for preeclampsia was associated with elevated VCAM-I which did not correlate with low Vitamin D level. Another study showed a composite of both 25 (OH) D level along with sFlt-1/PlGF ratio at midgestation (15 - 20 weeks) were more predictive than either one alone (area under curve: 0.83 versus 0.74 and 0.67, respectively) for the development of severe preeclampsia  . In a recent experimental work published by Song, et al., they induced preeclampsia (PE) in a rat model. The PE group had lower VEGF (p < 0.01) and higher plasma sFlt-1 and TNF-α (p < 0.01 for both) compared to pregnant controls. Vitamin D supplementation to the PE cohort on gestation days 14 - 19 restored angiogenic balance by a significant increase in VEGF, reduced sFlt-1 and reduced TNF-α compared to the untreated PE group. Vitamin D supplementation was also shown to reduce oxidative stress by lowering the plasma oxidative stress marker and reducing inflammation during pregnancy-induced hypertension  .
VEGF is an endothelium-specific growth factor. Its angiogenic activity promotes vascular smooth muscle proliferation. The bio-active form, 1, 25-(OH) 2D (3) has functional synergism to stimulate VEGF expression in rat vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMC), based upon the presence of a Vitamin D response element(s) (VDRE) located within VEGF promoter regions. Low serum 25 (OH) D or minimal binding to promoter regions may be associated with diminished VEGF production, leading to preeclampsia  .
Vitamin D and endothelial cell development and repair: Endothelial colony forming cells (ECFCs), a sub-population of late growth endothelial progenitor cells, have proliferative and migratory properties at sites of vessel damage. They possess the ability to differentiate into mature endothelial cells; hence, participating in vessel repair and de novo development of the vascular endothelium. Fetal ECFCs possess the ability to transmigrate across the placenta and participate in de novo maternal vessel formation in the pregnant uterus when damaged during preeclampsia  . In vitro studies of ECFCs by Brodowski et al., umbilical cord blood serum from preeclamptic women exhibited inhibition to vascular tubule formation and migration as compared to uncomplicated controls. ECFCs also were inhibited during states of hypoxia or hyperoxia but not with normoxia. The addition of exogenous Vitamin D3 (1, 25 (OH) 2D), showed reversal of the adverse effects of ECFCs, with improved tubule formation and migration even after blocking the VDR (p = 0.049). Exogenous Vitamin D also enhanced ECFC function during hypoxia or hyperoxia; these effects were dependent on VDR activation. Blocking of the VEGF pathway impaired ECFC function during exogenous Vitamin D administration. However, it was noted that there was no significant relationship between maternal serum Vitamin D concentration and fetal ECFC response to the patient serum in cell culture (p = 0.45)  .
7. Review of angiotensin ii Type 1 receptor antibodies (At1-aa)
Preeclampsia: Placental ischemia promotes an immunological loss of self-tolerance which results in B cell secretion of AT1-AA. Additionally, trophoblastic factors released into the maternal circulation can lead to an excessive inflammatory response  which elevates Flt-1 (VEGF-inactivating) and promotes the production of AT1-AA   . AT1-AA are IgG mediated agonistic, stimulatory autoantibodies that act directly on AT1  . It is associated with suppression of both circulating renin and aldosterone levels. This disturbs the RAAS regulation via aldosterone during normal pregnancy, which provides a delicate balance by increasing intravascular volume at no expense to cardiac output  .
AT1-AA are associated with increased angiotensin II (ANG-II) sensitivity during PE with a tendency to increase blood pressure at lower ANG-II stimulation  with vascular smooth muscle constriction  . These antibodies can be associated with greater severity of disease when present at midgestation  . The production of AT1-AA has been shown to mediate a path towards chronic inflammation  . Although AT1-AA may occur early, at the initial time of placental hypoxemia, its utility as a sensitive biomarkers to predict progression of preeclampsia needs more clarity  .
Vitamin D: There are studies that argue a beneficial role of Vitamin D on various hypertensive disorders of pregnancy related to AT1-AA. Studies investigating double-transgenic rats with excess Ang-II production fed Vitamin D-depleted (experimental group) chow for 3 weeks (short-term) showed higher mean systolic BP and upregulated angiotensin metabolites, including Ang-II, and its counter-regulatory breakdown product. This aggravated hypertension lead to target-organ damage  . They concluded that even a short-term severe Vitamin D deficiency may directly promote hypertension and impact the RAAS system that could contribute to target-organ damage  . Another study revealed that after 8-weeks of cholecalciferol therapy in hypertensive patients with hypovitaminosis D, there was a significant reduction in circulating renin-angiotensin-aldosterone and improved vascular function compared to controls  . Recently, it was confirmed that AT1-AA associated preeclampsia was reduced with Vitamin D supplementation in the RUPP rat, model of PE. The mechanism could have either lowered mean arterial pressure (MAP) in the hypertensive model without PE features or it was through downstream factors of AT1-AA  .
8. Candidate Hot spots
Pregnancy presents a challenging period when Vitamin D availability becomes essential to utero-placental sufficiency   , especially to deter early-onset pathophysiologic events of preeclampsia  . Clinically, Vitamin D sufficiency correlates with its “bioavailability”, defined as the amount of 25 (OH) D bound to vitamin-D binding protein (VDBP) in the serum     . A deficiency or insufficiency could impact its steroidal and/or anti-inflammatory response to mitigate this illness associated with systemic inflammation. The focus is to identify candidate genes and/or pathway that prevent endothelial dysfunction.
We have presented review of the relationships between vitamin D bioavailability, gene expression and pathways involved in placentation, implantation and vasculogenesis during early stages of pregnancy. The metabolic pathway of Vitamin D is extensive and intricate with several challenging candidates that modulate risk of progressive gestational hypertension leading to preeclampsia  . They range from 1) vitamin D bioavailability: this involves seasonal changes  , dietary factors   , environmental and/or genetic factors   and ethnically related low affinity for VDBP  . Additionally, production and secretion of 1, 25 (OH) 2D 3 during pregnancy by both the kidneys and placenta play a role in availability  ; 2) polymorphism within kinetic and dynamic pathways of molecular activation   and transport  ; and/or 3) any dysfunctional alleles of the VDR   that can influence the function of transcriptional activation of responsive genes     .
This argues a need for research analyzing vitamin D bioavailability to assess mothers at risk for these hypertensive disorders. There is growing evidence that VDBP also plays a role in immune modulation. Candidate genetic/phenotypic variants of group-specific globulin component (GC genes) of VDBP need further exploration for encoding protein that could modulate intervention(s) in pathophysiologic pathways of diseases  . Baca et al. have linked the combination of common genotypic allelic variants using single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP) in VDR, GC genes of VDBP or cytochrome p450 27B1 (CYP27B1) as candidate markers, along with 25 (OH) D concentration to identify pregnant women at risk for vitamin D bioavailability  . Another attractive area of focus as a biomarker of risk is the pathways for protecting against Vitamin D intoxication. Individual risk for bioavailable Vitamin D deficiency when uteroplacental demand is elevated may involve phenotypes that are “efficient” processors for converting pre-Vitamin D3 and Vitamin D to inactive metabolic products, potentially increasing one’s risk for deficiency. Bioavailable Vitamin D3, that which is bound to VDBP and transported to cells, must be released at target cells, where unbound vitamin D3 diffuses across the membrane to bind VDR (mediate transcriptional regulation of responsive genes) or bind to calicitriol-VDR-complex (mediate non-transcriptional for modulating cellular functions such as survival, differentiation and proliferation). This suggests that further inquiry into the mechanism promoting uncoupling of ligand (Vitamin D) from binding protein at the cell surface may reveal mechanisms of pathogenesis. It is reasonable to speculate there may be a concentration gradient between bound and unbound Vitamin D3 or a ratio between any combination between 25 (OH) D, 1, 25 (OH)2 D, and/or 24, 25 (OH)2 D at the uteroplacental tissue that drives exchange in specific cells. Individuals insufficient in producing proper “exchange” ratios may display reduced cell response to adequate concentration of bioavailable Vitamin D in the presence of normal genes and gene products of VDBP, VDR and metabolic enzymes in the uteroplacental tissue.
Further research into the pathophysiology should seek to validate the role of hypovitaminosis D in inflammation mediated malplacentation. This has the potential to differentiate clinical events specific to Vitamin D insufficiency. We postulate that in the presence of normal levels of Vitamin D, at-risk individuals phenotypically have inadequate metabolism of bioavailable product, especially when its demand is high. This argues that Vitamin D dysregulation may be an early event in the pathway leading to gestation hypertension. Hence, future investigation analyzing the relationship between Vitamin D insufficiency and concentration of soluble HLA-G (sHLA-G) potentially could resolve biochemical link and association between Vitamin D, gestational hypertension, preeclampsia and uterine growth restriction. We hypothesize that inadequate placental metabolism of, and cell response to, Vitamin D could reduce expression of HLA-G and sHLA-G resulting in reduced activation of KIR2DL4 inhibitory signal transduction of UNK and dNK cells-mediating inflammatory process.
We recommend research to establish diagnostic toolkit to detect these high-risk pregnancies during early gestation. This should involve standardized measurement of Vitamin D levels by Mass Spectrometry (the gold standard). Genotyping VDBP and its common pathway allele variant to establish “bioavailability”     , as well as VDR associated with phenotypic low binding protein(s) need careful assessment. Markers of cell apoptosis should be developed such as Cell free DNA and Fluorescence Activated Cell Sort (FACS analysis) to detect apoptotic events of endothelial dysfunction.
From our review, we have demonstrated numerous causal relationships between preeclampsia and Vitamin D. As we tracked the events from inception of implantation (time of fetal EVT invasion) up to the third trimester of pregnancy, Vitamin D deficiency has remained a single nutritional condition that shares most of the adverse pathophysiology of preeclampsia (Table 1). The “Molecular Concept of Low Vitamin D” has been shown to potentiate preeclampsia through numerous and common pathways via both intracrine and/or paracrine mechanism(s). Many studies have used Vitamin D to reverse molecular and pathophysiologic changes of preeclampsia to a major extend. Research publications have documented that Vitamin D supplementation can promote a healthy pregnancy from inception, and prevent early insidious events leading to preeclampsia.
Table 1. Established common pathways shared with preeclampsia and Vitamin D.
We speculate there is an evolutionary significance that low affinity of VDBP for D2/D3 Vitamin D as an adaptation to prevent toxic levels of Vitamin D in the body; however, this may also be an environmental risk for individuals with hypertension. Hence, we postulate that minorities homozygous for specific GC allele of the VDBP may require personalized higher amount of Vitamin D in their prenatal care to reduce the risk of gestational hypertension, preventing preeclampsia.
Considering the complicated pathways resulting in preeclampsia, we have identified many hot spots associated with a central molecular concept. Vitamin D remains an early identifiable nutrigenomic substance that has the potential to prevent progression to preeclampsia. Randomized controlled clinical studies involving more high-risk ethnic populations (with comparable genotyping) is most desired to understand these pathologic candidate markers of Vitamin D. A scientific approach will decipher personalized Vitamin D dosing and serum levels, along with any preventable pathway polymorphism that have the potential to compensate for any dysfunctionality. Translational research is highly desired to identify key candidate genes/markers contributing to abnormalities in the Vitamin D pathway, in order of early relevance for diagnosis and monitoring vulnerable pregnancies at risk for preeclampsia. Early and sensitive tools are most desired to be used prior to 14 weeks of pregnancy. A robust advocacy is immediately needed for all pregnant women to have early access to prenatal care as well as provider awareness to make early diagnosis and corrective management of risk factors that develop into preeclampsia during pregnancy.
AT1―angiotensin II type I receptor
AT1-AA―Angiotensin II type 1 receptor antibodies
BMI―body mass index
CAMP―cathelicidin antimicrobial peptide
CD56―cluster of differentiation molecule [NCAM (neural cell adhesion molecule)]
CD16―cluster of differentitaion molecule (Fc receptor for IgG)
CYP27B1―cytochrome P450, family 27, subfamily B, polypeptide 1 (25 hydroxyvitamin D3-1-alpha hydroxylase)
dNK―decidual Natural Killer
ECFCs―endothelial colony forming cells
eNO―endothelial nitric oxide
FACS―Fluorescence Activated Cell Sorter
GC genes-group―specific globulin component
HLA-G―Human leukocyte antigen (major histocompatibility antigen, alpha chain G)
HLA-C―Human leukocyte antigen (major Histocompatibility Complex, Class I, C)
ICAM-1―intercellular Adhesion Molecule-1
IgG―immunoglobulin, class gamma
IL-2―interleukin-2 (T cell growth factor)
IL-4―interleukin-4 (LSF1, Lymphocyte Stimulatory Factor 1)
IL-6―interleukin-6 (Interferon Beta-2)
IL-10―interleukin-10 (CSIF, Cytokine Synthesis Inhibitory Factor)
IL-17―interleukin-17 (CTLA-8, cytotoxic T lymphocyte antigen)
iNO―inducible nitric oxide
KIR2DL4―inhibitory killer-cell immunoglobulin-like receptors
PAI-1―plasminogen activator inhibitor-1
PlGF―phosphatidylinositol glycan anchor biosynthesis class F
ROS―reactive oxygen species
SNP―single nucleotide polymorphisms
TGF-β―transforming growth factor beta 1
Th1-CD4+ T―helper cell, IL-1 producing population
Th2 - CD4+ T―helper cell, IL-2 producing population
Th17-CD4+T―helper cell, IL-17 producing population
TNF-α―tumor necrosis factor-alpha
TLR4―toll-like receptor 4
Tregs―regulatory T cells
TXA―arachidonic acid thromboxane
VCAM-1―vascular adhesion Molecule-1
VDR―Vitamin D receptor
VDRE―Vitamin D response element
VEGF―vascular endothelial growth factor
VEGFR2―VEGF receptor type 2
uNK―uterine Natural Killer