Continuous gradient temperature Raman spectroscopy (GTRS) has proven to be a simple, rapid technique for determining the unique structures of the unsaturated fatty acids     . While conventional Raman analysis can be useful, to first order the long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (LC-PUFA) appear nearly identical, with the vibrational modes of most moieties degenerate, redundant or very broad      . But logically this cannot be the case, because the LC-PUFA are so vastly different biochemically. Collecting spectra in a temperature gradient provides information not readily available in constant temperature measurements, because the dynamic nature of the vibrational structure can be observed in real time as the molecule changes conformation. Thus, GTRS can identify and differentiate specific carbon chain sites, finally allowing Raman analysis to explain why the LC-PUFA exhibit such extreme functional differences. Recently we applied GTRS to oleic acid (OA, 18:1n-9), linoleic acid (LA, 18:2n-6), arachidonic acid (AA, 20:4n-6), N-3 docosapentaenoic acid (N-3DPA, 22:5n-3), N-6 docosapentaenoic acid (N-6DPA, 22:5n-6), docosahexaenoic acid (DHA, 22:6n-3), and AA and DHA stearic acid phosphatidylcholines, resulting in complete vibrational assignments and new three dimensional (3D) structures for each molecule     . Readers are referred to these published texts for the full datasets, contour plots and vibrational mode assignments for each of these molecules.
The importance of the LC-PUFA to biological and pharmaceutical sciences cannot be overstated. In particular, the emerging field of specialized pro-resolving mediators provides promising and exciting targets for new anti-inflammatory, neuroprotective and anti-infective drugs and natural products      . Specialized pro-resolving mediators are highly interesting in that metabolites of not just DHA and EPA, but also n-3DPA and n-6DPA can actively resolve inflammation at very low concentrations, proving new insight into the numerous health benefits epidemiologically associated with diets high in fish and/or total LC-PUFA     .
All five of the PUFA we present are metabolized by cyclooxygenase and lipoxygenase enzymes into an extensive suite of oxylipin metabolites  -  . While tremendous work has been accomplished on the structure and function of the various enzymes, it remains largely empirical: there is no systematic explanation as to why conversion rates vary at least 10-fold among PUFA species  . One reason for this is that the structure of substrates has been taken for granted beyond the obvious distinction of n-6 vs. n-3. We believe that a better understanding and visualization of the 3D lipid structures will allow increased refinement of the substrate and enzyme interactions that produce the pro-resolving mediators, and lead to improvements in synthetic pathways. Herein we present a detailed, comprehensive vibrational analysis of six fatty acids with 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 double bonds (OA, LA, alpha-linolenic acid (ALA, 18:3n-3), AA, N-3DPA, and DHA. With the improved GTRS spectroscopic technique, second derivatives can be utilized to resolve and identify vibrational modes which previously were not completely assigned. We show that individual sites on the LC-PUFA chain are nonequivalent although they are technically identical moieties.
2. Materials and Methods
The GTRS system utilizes a 785-nm laser module (I0785MM0350MF-NL, Innovative Photonic Solutions, Monmouth Junction, NJ) as the excitation source. A fiber optic Raman probe (RPB, InPhotonics, Norwood, MA) is used to focus the laser and acquire the Raman signals. A bifurcated fiber bundle with a 16-bit CCD camera (1024 × 256 pixels; Newton DU920N-BR-DD, Andor Technology, South Windsor, CT) delivers the laser radiation to the probe and transmits the Raman signals to the spectrometer at 0.2˚C increments. The spectrometer detects a Raman shift range of 102.2 to 2538.1 cm−1 with a minimum spectral resolution of 3.7 cm−1.
OA (cis-9 octadecenoic acid), LA (cis-9, 12 octadecadienoic acid), ALA cis-9, 12, 15 octadecatrienoic acid), AA (cis-5, 8, 11, 14 eicosatetraenoic acid) and DHA (cis-4, 7, 10, 13, 16, 19 docosahexaenoic acid) > 99% purity were purchased from Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO. N-3DPA (cis-7, 10, 13, 16, 19 docosapentaenoic acid) 98% purity was purchased from Santa Cruz Biotechnology Inc., Dallas, TX. Materials were stored sealed in a freezer until immediately prior to use. Samples were placed in aluminum pans which were then placed on large copper heat sinks with a sample platform on the upper surface. The heat sink and sample holder are chilled in a LN2 bath, but the sample itself does not come in direct contact with LN2 or atmospheric water vapor condensate. A ceramic hotplate is used for controlled heating of samples and as stable insulating platform for analysis. The copper heat sinks are placed directly on the ceramic heat surface and serve to buffer the rate of temperature increase. Two K-type thermocouple probes (range −200˚C to 1350˚C) are attached to two sides of the sample area and connected to a dual-input thermometer (Easy View EA15, Extech Instruments, Nashua, NH). The sample temperature is defined as the average value of the two probes. The thermocouple calibration based on test resistance provided by the manufacturer was utilized as well as calibration in LN2. The Raman probe, hotplate, and sample materials are placed in a closed black box to avoid ambient light. Raman spectra can be acquired from −180˚C to 320˚C. The heating gradient was approximately 1˚C∙min−1 for these mainly cryogenic investigations. We did not use a set time schedule for spectral acquisition, but rather acquired spectra each time the sample temperature increased either 1˚C or 0.2˚C, depending on the analysis. System software was developed using Lab VIEW (National Instruments, Austin, TX) to fulfil functions such as camera control, data acquisition, temperature measurement, signal/noise threshold and synchronization  . All Raman samples were run in triplicate and each dataset analyzed independently to ensure reproducibility.
Sigma Plot 13 (Systat Software, Inc.) generated three-dimensional contour plots (frequency, temperature, signal intensity). Software counting statistics ensure that only data with 99% certainty of true signal are utilized. First derivative intensity contour plots were calculated using a three-point running average, i.e. the first and last points calculate the slope of the middle point. The contour plots for the second derivative intensity were calculated using the three-point running average data from the first derivative spectra. Relative intensity is normalized to C=C stretch region circa 1650 cm−1. Maximum to minimum intensity colors are red > orange > yellow > green > blue > black. Each contour data array contains about 20 Mb.
GTRS collects Raman spectra continuously in an applied thermal gradient without the discontinuity in temperature intrinsic in steady state experiments. In the gradient, the contour plot signal is greatest for molecular sites which are the most elastic and respond most quickly to thermal stress. Figure 1 shows an example (ALA) of how the contour plot data are generated for each molecule. Each contour plot contains hundreds of measurements. Figure 2 shows details of the
Figure 1. Composite overlay line spectra for ALA detailing how stacked spectra are transformed to generate contour plots. Selected temperatures are shown for clarity. The discontinuity circa −3˚C represents melting.
Figure 2. Details of the second derivative data contour plots for the six fatty acids from 1750 to 1425 cm−1. (a) OA, LA, ALA; (b) AA, n-3DPA, DHA.
second derivative data contour plots for the six fatty acids. In two ranges given all six would be expected to have nearly identical vibrational spectra under steady-state conditions, but with the refined spectroscopy of GTRS this is clearly not the case. The temperature ranges are chosen to provide a clear comparison of the six lipids―not all ranges can accommodate the huge variation in melting temperatures that exists―but vibrational modes are not restricted to this range.
The frequency range 1450 to 1200 cm−1 includes CH2 bending and twisting; the range 1750 to 1425 cm−1 includes the C=C-C moiety: C=C stretching and C-C stretching plus H-C in-plane rocking. The ranges include 1450 cm−1 to 1425 cm−1 twice to show the vibrational modes that occur close to 1425 cm−1. Structures of the double bond regions and frequency assignments for their carbon sites are given in Figure 3.
Figure 3. Structures of the double bond regions and frequency assignments for their carbon sites. (a) OA, LA; (b) ALA, AA; (c) n-3DPA, DHA.
The 1489 ± 5 cm−1 frequency is observed in all the lipids analyzed except LA and is the most important in understanding PUFA lipid conformations. This essential vibrational mode can be generated from OA data: (1658 cm−1 + 1321 cm−1)/2 = 1490 cm−1. The 1650 ± 7 cm−1 frequency, assignable to the (H-C= C-H)-CH moiety in which all atoms are co-planar, is observed in all the lipids presented except ALA. The Raman frequency 1690 ± 10 cm−1 is observed in only half the lipids: AA, ALA and OA. The average of the two C-C and C=C stretching modes in OA [(1678 cm−1 + 1639 cm−1/2 = 1658 cm−1)] is similar to the 1655 cm−1 mode in LA.
Despite having a different number of double bonds, OA, ALA and AA do have three critical vibrational modes in common: 1486 ± 3, 1413 ± 5, and 1323 ± 4 cm−1. The assignments are three H-C in-plane rocking on the C=C-C moiety; CH2 bending on the Ca end of the CaH2-(H-C=C-H)-CbH2 moiety, and CH2 twisting at the Cb end of this same moiety. A difference is that ALA has two other CH2 twisting frequencies (1243 and 1223 cm−1) whereas OA has only the one (1223 cm−1) and AA has only the other (1243 cm−1). An unusual assignment in ALA is 1601 cm−1, which corresponds to a difference of two H-C in-plane rocking frequencies, whereas 1695 cm−1 equals a difference of four.
The CH2 bending assignment in OA at C8 (1408 cm−1) is similar to the C8 assignment in ALA (1413 cm−1). Twisting at C8 in OA and C14 in ALA occurs at the same frequency. This shifts the CH2 bending assignment from C8 in ALA to C7 in OA; both are at 1410 cm−1.
LA has four discrete vibrational modes arising from two double bonds and three CH2 sites adjacent to C=C sites. C8H2 bending occurs at 1448 cm−1 and is nearly the same frequency as straight chain aliphatic CH2 bending at 1450 cm−1. The bending torsion from the six other CH2 groups on the carbonyl ended aliphatic chain (C2-C7) is minimal. Since C11H2 twisting near 1327 cm−1 is not observed, torsion from adjacent CH2 groups in the H-C9=C10-H moiety is minimal. Torsion due to the C14H2 site results in the twisting modes at 1266 and 1237 cm−1. In the first case, Ha-C twisting is relative to the C14-C13=C12 plane. In the second case, Hb-C twisting is relative to the C14-C13=C12 plane. The aliphatic C14-C15-C16-C17-C18 moiety can be twisted to the right or twisted to the left relative to the planar C9=C10-C11-C12=C13 moiety. No net twist from CH2 sites adjacent to either the C12=C13 or the C9=C10 moiety was found; LA in this temperature range is flat.
AA has the identical structural moieties as LA but twice the number of double bonds with five CH2 sites adjacent to C=C sites. Unexpectedly, six (not three) vibrational modes are detected. The three that are not observed in the LA data can be assigned to a conformational change at C10. The relative broadness of the LA contour plots reflects a more diffusely distributed elasticity over non-localized molecular conformations. In contrast, the sharp peaks at C4, C10, and C16 in AA are that evidence elasticity is localized at these three sites: i.e. at the beginning, middle and end of the repeating five carbon atom moieties.
In AA, the three frequencies (1651, 1489, and 1327 cm−1) are not independent variables. The middle one is the average of the other two [(1651 cm−1 + 1327 cm−1)/2 = 1489 cm−1]. The difference between the first two results in a constant [(1651 cm−1 − 1487 cm−1) = 164 cm−1]. From the three CH2 between the double bonds, three in plane H-C rocking modes can occur with a frequency shift of 55 cm−1 per each H-C in-plane rocking site between the double bonds. H-C in plane rocking vibrational modes, depending upon how they add or subtract in relationship to each other, can correspondingly increase or decrease C=C and C-C stretching.
For DHA, twisting towards the methyl-ended chain (1266 cm−1) occurs at site C14, at the same frequency as C14Ha in LA. DHA with six double bonds has two CH2 twisting/bending modes whereas AA with four double bonds has three. In AA, these are assignable to CH2 sites adjacent to the beginning (C4), end (C16) and middle (C10) of the double bond region. In DHA, the beginning site (C3) is shifted about 50 cm−1 lower that the corresponding site in AA (C4). The second site (C14) is shifted about 25 cm−1 higher than from that in AA (C16). A vibrational mode at C12H2 in DHA would be near its center of mass. C14H2 is however three carbon atoms past its center of mass.
Four double bonds equal one loop from C6 to C18; the geometry of a self- consistent twist in the same relative direction from C6 to C18 (with no twist at C12) would result in such a loop forming  . For DHA (labeling each pattern Ca=Cb), all Ca= sites could be 1653 cm−1 and all =Cb sites could be 1484 cm−1. This would explain why for DHA, only two vibrational modes in this spectral region (neither three nor one) are observed.
The bending modes correspond for the CH2 adjacent to the first double bonds in N-3 DPA and in ALA are at C6 (1360 cm−1) and at C8 (1420 cm−1); twisting modes adjacent to the last double bonds are at C21 (1208 cm−1) and C14 (1225 cm−1). Further, N-3DPA and DHA both include similar CH2 bending modes at C3 (1380 cm−1 versus 1375 cm−1) despite the fact that in DHA, the C4=C5 double bond is present. N-3DPA is unique among the six: it is the only one that has vibrational modes in the region 1575 and 1500 cm−1 but no vibrational mode near 1250 cm−1.
The C-CH2-C=C-CH2-C moiety occurs in all six of these lipids, once in OA, but six times in DHA. Over all six lipids this moiety is repeated 21 times, and the question is which of these are actually identical structurally? The Fisher projections (Figure 4) at these moieties explain the critical larger 3D structure present in OA and the LC-PUFA.
Figure 4. Fischer projections of the double bond regions. (a) OA, LA; (b) ALA; (c) AA; (d) n-3DPA; (e) DHA.
The backbone geometry in LC-PUFA structures C8-C9=C10-C11-C12=C13- C14 is a non-repeating moiety because C11 does not repeat twice. The critical structural question of such lipids is redundancy versus symmetry. Symmetry in reference to a molecular site means a conformation and its mirror images are identical. For lipids with an even number of double bonds, the CH2 group in the middle of them is reference site. For those with an odd number of double bonds, the middle of the C=C bond is the reference site. Overall symmetry means that C8-C9=C10-C11 is indistinguishable from C11-C12=C13-C14 or C8-C9= C11- C12.
Redundancy arises from the same structural moiety having identical properties regardless of symmetry. C8-C9=C10 and C11-C12=C13 would be the same and C9=C10-C11 and C12=C13-C14 would be the same; but C8-C9=C10 and C9=C10-C11 (or C11-C12=C13 and C12=C13-C14) need not be.
In LA with two double bonds (C9=C10 and C12=C13), only four spectral lines are observed. All frequencies containing the C-C= and =C-C moiety overlap (1655 cm−1). C8H2 bending before C9= is a single vibrational mode whereas C14 torsion after =C13 has two modes. The CH2 structure at the carbonyl end of LA is symmetrical; the C14 sites towards the methyl end of the lipid are not equally elastic. The eclipsed conformation of the Fisher projection indicates that C8 to C13 are coplanar and C14 twisting above this plane is unequal to C14 twisting below the plane.
In AA with four double bonds (C5=C6, C8=C9, C11=C12, and C14=C15), only six vibrational modes are observed. Despite five CH2 sites adjacent to a C=C, only three CH2 bending/twisting modes are detected and symmetrical about C10: C4H2 before C5, C16H2 after C15 and C10H2. The three spectral lines cannot be divided symmetrically among four sets of two double bonds. The Fisher projection resolves this dilemma: the sequence C5=C6-C7-C8 is not planar; C7-C8=C9-C10 is planar; the sequence C9-C10=C11-C12 is not planar and is in a conformation different than the first one. Moreover, C6 to C11 is the same conformation as C9 to C14, and the conformations C3 to C8 and C12 to C17 are similar. Thus, AA is symmetrical about C12H2 and clearly not symmetrical about either C8=C9 or C11=C12.
In DHA with six double bonds (C4=C5, C7=C8, C10=C11, C13=C14, C16=C17, and C19=C20), the four vibrational modes observed can only occur because of redundancy. The absence (above −6˚C) of a C12H2 twisting mode precludes the symmetry observed in AA. In the DHA Fisher projection, the identical gauche (left) cis conformations occurs in three locations (C2 to C7, C11 to C16, and C17 to C22) whereas the other three (C5 to C10, C8 to C13, and C14 to C19) occur as trans conformations. The co-addition curvature at three structurally equivalent cis double bond sites plus the symmetrical trans conformation at the remaining three double bond sites results in a planar “C” shaped molecular structure composed from redundancy in two forms of the C=C-C moieties. The Fisher projections for the gauche (right) cis double bonds in AA are also not identical to the gauche (left) double bonds in DHA.
Figure 5. Comparison of energy minimized 3D structures for n-3DPA, n-6DPA and DHA based on    . The position of Fe-O-O-H within the C17 oxidation site can be assumed constant, however the Fe-O-O-H site could equally be towards the inside of the C17 site as towards the outside of the lipid chain. N-6DPA has the cleanest fit at C17 of the three lipids (see purple area). Since n-6DPA has no C19=C20 bond, torsion is due only to previous double bond sites―especially C13=C14. For the C18H2 site, the hydrogen inside the U-shape of the lipid (purple) is in a spatially very different conformation as the hydrogen on the outside (white).
Previously we noted that biochemical energy is more than sufficient to not only recognize, but actually induce nonequivalence among CH and CH2 groups  . Our improved lipid spectroscopy and 3D structures likely have bearing on the enzymatic oxidation processes which form specialized pro-resolving mediators. For example, at 0˚C soybean 15-lipoxygenase oxidizes C17 to its hydroperoxy derivative with 100% efficiency for n-6 DPA, 85% for n-3DPA and 50% for DHA  . Figure 5 gives a view of these LC-PUFA in the critical area. While full analysis is beyond the scope of this spectroscopic contribution, we hope that this visualization will promote further understanding of the enzymatics involved. The high degree of specificity of lipoxygenase and cyclooxygenase enzymes  -  should be reevaluated in light of the fact individual sites on the polyunsaturated fatty acid chain are nonequivalent, and each LC-PUFA molecule has an individual, specific structure incorporating torsion.