High blood pressure or hypertension is one of the most important risk factors for cardiovascular disease and a leading cause of premature adult deaths worldwide  . Uncontrolled hypertension causes 50% of the total coronary heart disease (CHD) deaths globally  . An analysis of global data reveals that of the deaths from CHD approximately 80% will occur in low and middle-income countries,  and this is particularly common among people of low socioeconomic status   . Regardless of race or ethnicity, the disease also accounts for the death of one in three women globally  with an estimated 3.4 million women dying from CHD every year worldwide  .
Among all the WHO regions, the prevalence of hypertension is highest in the African Region (46%) and lowest in the region of the Americas (35%)  . One in three adults in the South East Asia region has hypertension  . Findings from recent studies also indicate a higher prevalence of hypertension in middle-aged and older women compared to men in developing countries    and CHD causes significant morbidity and mortality in women during childbearing years  .
In developed countries, strong public health policies, multi-sectored preventive action and widely available diagnosis and treatment have led to an appreciable reduction in the prevalence of high blood pressure (BP)  . As little as 2 mmHg population-wide decrease in BP can prevent 151,000 strokes and 153,000 CHD deaths globally  . Despite the availability of over a hundred different effective drugs for hypertension treatment, the reported rates of blood pressure control are very disappointing  . Between 2000 and 2013, the number of deaths attributable to hypertension rose from 7.6 to 9.4 million  . A systematic review of the studies published from 2001 to 2007 revealed that BP was poorly controlled in developing countries, the mean proportion of control of hypertension among all hypertensive patients being only 13%  . Poor medication adherence is one of the leading causes of failure to achieve BP control  . In developing countries, the degree of non-adherence is assumed to be higher particularly due to the shortage of health resources and difficulties in access to healthcare  .
The WHO defines adherence to long term therapy as “the extent to which a person’s behaviour―taking medication, following a diet, and, or executing lifestyle changes corresponds with agreed recommendations from a healthcare provider”  . The term compliance to medicine is defined as “the extent to which a patient acts in accordance with the prescribed interval and dose of the dosing regimen” reported as a percentage of prescribed doses taken at the prescribed time interval   . Despite these variations, these terminologies have been used interchangeably in most studies  . Most of the studies on adherence have been undertaken in developed countries. However, healthcare access, cultural beliefs, education about chronic illnesses and the functions of medication, the nature of patient-physician interactions and social support, among many other factors, are very different in developing countries compared to developed countries and may profoundly affect rates of medication adherence   .
Over the past decade, though some studies have been conducted in developing countries to explore the factors influencing medication adherence among hyper- tensive patients, little has been documented about MNA and its determinants of hypertensive patients. This systematic review was conducted to address this gap and examine the prevalence of MNA among hypertensive patients as well as investigate factors affecting MNA in this population.
Literature search was conducted using the electronic databases: Proquest, PubMed, JSTOR and Science Direct for articles published during 2000-15. The online search engine, Google Scholar was also used to search for and identify likely papers. The search strategy included the following terms:
・ adherence, non-adherence, compliance, persistence (related to medication adherence).
・ hypertension, high blood pressure (Blood pressure ≥140/≥90 mm of Hg).
・ belief, perception of hypertension and
・ developing countries (the World Bank classifies all low- and middle-income countries as developing countries-however, this term is not intended to imply that all economies in the group are experiencing similar development or that other economies have reached a preferred or final stage of development).
2.1. Study Selection
The inclusion criteria for the review were clinical research:
Figure 1. Results of screening process.
1) Measured adherence to antihypertensive medications in developing countries.
2) Identify factors related to medication adherence with the antihypertensive treatment.
3) Enrolled hypertensive adults (18 years and older).
4) Published in English as a peer-reviewed full-text article.
We excluded studies that measured adherence of other chronic diseases or were conducted in developed countries and published in a non-English language.
2.2. Data Extraction and Analysis
The total number of relevant articles meeting the above criteria was 47, consisting of 45 peer-reviewed journal articles and two thesis papers: 40 were on quantitative studies, five on qualitative studies and two were mixed methods studies.To check the quality of quantitative studies the National Collaborating Centre for Methods and Tools’ quality assessment tool for quantitative studies was used  . Qualitative studies were checked based on NICE guidelines  .
A standardised data extraction form was used to record the citation details, methodology and objectives, and main findings of each paper. The following information was extracted and tabulated by the first reviewer and verified by the second and third reviewers: author name, date of publication, the country in which research was conducted, sample size, sampling method, study design, sex (% female), the adherence measure used, key findings and any statistical information (odd ratios, 95% CI p-value, correlation coefficients). A summary of the studies reviewed was provided in Table 1. A meta-analysis of the findings was not possible due to the heterogeneity in important aspects of methodology of the
Table 1. Summary of variables under the domain of demographic factors investigated by the studies.
selected studies including sampling procedure (random/purposive) population ages, study settings (hospital/clinic/community), study design (cross-sectional/ longitudinal/qualitative) and measurement procedure of medication adherence. Descriptive analysis of studies examining similar variables and any association observed were considered to offer a simple indication of the level of evidence. Summary ranges of quantitative proportions and measures relating to prevalence and factors associated with MNA were compiled and presented. The evidence from the studies was synthesised and presented in a narrative review. The review followed the PRISMA reporting guidelines  .
3.1. Description of the Studies
The selected studies were conducted in developing countries in Asia (22) Africa (17), the Middle East (4), South America (2), and Europe (1). Among the 42 quantitative studies, the majority (33 studies [78.57%]) were conducted in urban hospital or clinic settings, with only nine studies were carried out in community settings (five in India and one each from Bangladesh, Nepal and Nigeria). Most of the studies (34 studies) were cross-sectional quantitative in type. A study from Nigeria was mixed methods in type, comprising both quantitative and qualitative methods for data collection  . A summary of the characteristics and the aim of each study are shown in Table A1.
The five qualitative studies were from India (1), Pakistan (1), Congo (1), Malaysia (1) and Nigeria (1). Three studies used one-to-one qualitative interviews, one study used focus group discussion, and one used a combination of these methods. Further details of the study designs and results are presented in Table A1. In all of the studies, the study population included both males and females. Overall women comprised 55.98% of study participants.
3.2. Reported Adherence to Antihypertensive Treatment
To measure medication adherence, 21 (50%) of the quantitative studies used the Morisky Medication Adherence Scale’. Other scales used in the four different studies were: Medicines Team Questionnaire-Qualiaids (QAM-Q) (1); Beliefs about Medicine Questionnaire (BMQ) (1); Hill-Bone Adherence to Blood Pressure Therapy Scale (1); Drug Attitude Inventory (DAI-10) (1); One study used Medication Event Monitoring System (MEMS) and one used pill count to measure adherence. The remaining studies used questionnaires. Among them, eleven studies used structured questionnaires with established reliability and or validity, while eight studies (33%) did not cite information on their reliability or validity. The rate of MNA among hypertensive population ranged from 23% - 6.76% with the mean being 47.34%.
3.3. Factors Impacting on Adherence
The identified factors related to MNA in the reviewed studies could be categorised into seven domains: demographic; psychosocial; perceptions regarding hypertension and its severity; perceptions regarding antihypertensive treatment; perceived barriers to treatment adherence; treatment and disease related factors; and health care services.
3.3.1. Demographic Factors
Sixteen studies reported significant associations between demographic variables (such as age, sex, level of education, types of family, household income, employment, type of family, co-morbidities and use of herbal preparations)and MNA to hypertensive therapy (Table 1).
The effect of age on medication adherence showed conflicting results. Youn- ger age was found to be significantly associated with MNA to hypertensive me- dications in India (≤57 years) [OR (odd ratio) 3.348; 95% Confidence Interval (CI): 1.665 - 6.732]  , Palestine (<45 years) (OR = 0.40; 95% CI: 0.157 - 0.99)  and Pakistan (≤51 years) (OR = 1.0; 95% CI: 1.00 - 1.04). The mean age of hypertensive patients who were not adherent to medications was 54.5 ± 13.2 years while those who were adherent had a mean age of 60.9 ± 12.1 years (𝑃 < 0.001) in Ghana and Nigeria  . On the other hand, a significantly lower level of adherence was identified in a study with elderly patients in Serbia. In this study patients less than 65 years were found to be more likely to adhere to their prescribed treatment, compared to older patients (AOR = 6.0; 95% CI: 2.76 - 13.04)  .
Being female was independently and significantly associated with poor adherence in a study in India (AOR = 2.95; 95% CI: 1.39 - 6.24) with hypertensive women 2.95 times more likely to be non-adherent to their medications than men  . A study in Iraq also revealed that female hypertensive patients (61.7%) were more non-adherent than male (30.3%) patients  . On the other hand, MNA was significantly associated with male gender in Pakistan (𝑃 = 0.008)  , Tanzania (𝑃 = 0.044),  and Bangladesh (AOR = 1.67; 95% CI: 1.42 - 1.97)  . However, several studies      found no significant association between gender and MNA among hypertensive patients. Thus, the effect of gender on MNA showed conflicting results across countries.
Hypertensive patients in Nepal who were illiterate almost five times less likely to be adherent to medications than those who were literate (AOR = 5.34, 95% CI: 1.23 - 23)  . Similarly, lower level of education was significantly associated with MNA among hypertensive patients in Bangladesh (OR = 6.34; 95% CI: 1.65 - 24.41)  . On the other hand, formal education was associated with MNA (𝑃 = 0.001) in Ghana and Nigeria  . A study in India found that educational level was not a significant contributing factor to non-adherence  . From these results, it seems that educational level may not always be a good predictor of MNA.
Hypertensive patients with low monthly income (AOR = 11.60; 95% CI: 3.77 - 35.65) in Bangladesh  and Ethiopia (𝑃 = 0.04)  were more non-adherent to their medications. In Pakistan,  the likelihood of MNA was also found to be higher among unemployed persons (𝑃 = 0.002) and people with low socioeconomic status (𝑃 = 0.046). Hypertensive patients who had private businesses were 72% less likely to adhere to medication compared to government employees (AOR = 0.28, 95% CI: 0.130 - 0.606) in Ethiopia  . Hypertensive patients living in a nuclear family setup in India were more likely to have lower adherence to medication as compared to staying in the extended family (OR = 2.67; 95% CI: 1.378 - 5.175)  .
Hypertensive patients with co-morbidities were 50% less likely to be adherent to their medications compared to patients with no co-morbidity (AOR = 0.50: 95% CI: 0.290 - 0.893) in Ethiopia  . In Bangladesh, hypertensive patients with cardiovascular co-morbidity were significantly associated with MNA (AOR = 0.79; 95% CI: 0.64 - 0.97)  . A study in north-west Ethiopia  also found that patients with no and one co-morbidity were more likely to adhere to their treatment than those with two (AOR = 2.50, 95% CI: 1.01 - 6.21) or more than two co-morbidities (AOR = 2.68, 95% CI: 1.07 - 6.71). However, having no other chronic disease (𝑃 = 0.009) was a significant factor influencing MNA among hypertensive patients in Palestine  .
In Ghana and Nigeria, patients who used herbal preparations for the treatment of hypertension were more likely to show MNA (𝑃 = 0.014)  . In a qualitative study in Pakistan,  almost all the hypertensive patients surveyed firmly supported the utilisation of traditional or herbal remedies for the control of their high BP and confirmed that usually only in the case of failure of these therapies would they seek help from modern or biomedical health care providers. A qualitative study in Nigeria found some patients with low medication adherence substituted or complemented prescribed pills with herbal remedies on their own without informing their doctor  .
3.3.2. Psychosocial Factors
Seven studies reported significant associations between psychosocial variables (such as family support, depression and use of social drugs) and MNA to hypertensive treatment (Table 2).
An absence of household support had a strong negative effect on adherence among hypertensive patients in Ethiopia (AOR = 0.170, 95% CI: 0.030 - 0.905)  and Nigeria (p < 0.05)  . Likewise, studies   in Congo reported that patients who received no support from family members regarding reminders about taking their medications were likely to be more non-compliant than the others. A qualitative study in Congo  found that there was a perception among some family members that the hypertensive patient had brought the condition upon him-/herself by being a bad person: “They say I developed hypertension because I killed her sister’ (through witchcraft).” Though family cohesion is very high in Bangladesh, lack of an accompanying person to go to the physician/hospital was a significant factor in determining non-adherence to antihypertensive treatment (OR = 3.54; 95% CI: 1.04 - 11.99)  . This lack of
Table 2. Summary of variables under the domain of psychosocial factors investigated by the studies.
support may be due to lack of knowledge of the family members about the disease process. When patients are depressed, they are less likely to follow health care providers’ treatment plan for hypertension. In Ghana and Nigeria  MNA occurred in patients who had varying degrees of depression (r = −0.208, P < 0.001) (r = Pearson’s correlation coefficient).
A World Health Organization report observed that alcohol abuse and tobacco smoking were important modifiers of compliance behaviour. Patients’ habit of alcohol consumption,   tobacco chewing,  and smoking    were strongly associated with poor adherence to anti-hypertensive treatment in studies in India, Iran and Ethiopia. In contrast, a study in Nepal did not found any significant association between tobacco use and alcoholism with MNA among hypertensive study participants  .
3.3.3. Perceptions Regarding Hypertension and Its Severity
Four studies reported significant associations between variables related to perceptions of hypertension and MNA to hypertensive medications. These factors included: awareness, knowledge and belief of hypertension and knowledge of the severity of hypertension.
Researchers found that poor understanding and belief in high blood pressure were significant factors associated with MNA in Bangladesh (AOR = 12.90; 95% CI: 1.65 - 100.63)  and in Ethiopia (P < 0.01)  . A qualitative study in Pakistan  revealed that once patients achieved control of their high BP, they tended to discontinue their medications. Those patients with an inadequate knowledge of hypertension related complication were also more likely to be non-adherent with the treatment regimen, as found in a study in Bangladesh (OR = 23.71; 95% CI: 3.38 - 166.46)  and Congo (OR = 2.9; 95% CI: 1.61 - 5.29)  . Diagnosed hypertensive patients who lacked knowledge regarding the severity of hypertension were also more likely to be non-adherent to medications in Congo (AOR = 0.34: 95% CI: 0.13 - 0.94)  and Bangladesh (AOR = 23.71; 95% CI: 3.38 - 166.46)  .
3.3.4. Perceptions Regarding Antihypertensive Treatment
Eight studies found significant associations between variables related to antihypertensive treatment and MNA (Table 3).
Studies in Congo (AOR = 0.36; 95% CI: (0.15 - 0.83),  Bangladesh (AOR = 24.50; 95% CI: 6.28 - 95.58),  and Ethiopia  (P < 0.01) reported that patients’ lack of knowledge about hypertension management was significantly associated with non-adherence to therapy. A significant correlation between beliefs about medication and MNA was found among hypertensive patients in Ghana and Nigeria  with patients who were worried about the adverse effects of antihypertensive drugs less likely to be adherent to their medications (r = −0.0347, P = 0.002). Qualitative studies in Pakistan  and Malaysia  also found patients hesitated to take medications continuously due to their lack of belief in medications. As one hypertensive patient in Pakistan commented: “Medications are hot (warm) in nature. They enter the stomach and increase temperature which interferes with digestion.” A study in Palestine found that patients with hypertension were not adhering to their medication due to the fear of dependent on medicines (AOR = 8.00; 95% CI: (2.44 - 26.19)  . Similarly avoiding side effects of drugs (AOR = 3.0; 95% CI: 1.4 - 6.7) was an important reason for non-adherence to their treatment regimen among hypertensive patients in Nigeria  .
Hypertensive patients who did not understand their drug regimen well were poorly adherent to their prescribed medications (AOR = 4.06, 95% CI: 1.01 - 16.32) in India  and Ethiopia (AOR = 0.12, 95% CI = 0.258 - 0.583)  .
Table 3. Variables summarised under the domain of perceived barriers to antihypertensive treatment and MNA investigated by studies.
Gelaw et al.  found that insufficient information about the consequence of non-adherence to hypertension treatment contributed to the non-adherence of the hypertensive patients in Ethiopia. In Nigeria, a qualitative study also found ignorance about regular use of medication was an important contributor to medication non-adherence  .
3.3.5. Perceived Barriers to Adherence
Sixteen studies found significant associations between aspects related to perceived barriers and MNA. These perceived barriers were: the cost of medications, the number of pills that needed to be taken on a daily basis, forgetfulness, side effects of medications, duration of therapy, satisfaction with the treatment and health services provided, and distance from health care centre (Table 4).
Table 4. Variables investigated under the domain of perceived barriers and MNA.
In non-adherent patients surveyed in Nepal, a significantly greater proportion of patients considered the price of medications to be too high (AOR = 5.14; 95% CI: 1.1 - 23.9)  and for which they missed taking their medications (AOR = 0.143; 95% CI: 0.02 - 0.78). The cost of medicine was also a significant factor associated with MNA among patients in Congo (OR = 1.84; 95% CI: 0.93 - 3.64)  . Similarly, the inability to buy medications (P < 0.001) was positively and significantly related to MNA in Sudan  . Even being able to afford only some of the prescribed antihypertensive drugs (AOR = 3.70, 95% CI: 1.81 - 7.59) was also significantly related with MNA in India  .
In Nepal, non-adherence was significantly associated with therapy requiring more than one pill per day (AOR = 5.33; 95% CI: 1.19 - 23.7) compared to patients prescribed only one pill per day  . MNA was also greater among patients with higher pill burden in India,  Nigeria,  and Malaysia  (P < 0.05). On the other hand, a couple of studies   found that when patients had to take multiple medications, perhaps, they were less likely to fail to remember to take them, compared to having only one pill. A study in Pakistan  found non-adherence was higher among those patients who were on mono- therapy and di-therapy compared to patients using 3 or >3 drugs (P = 0.02).
Patients also often forget to take even once daily medications. Studies in Nigeria (OR = 14.8; 95% CI: 3.9 - 54.8)  and Palestine (AOR = 5.12; 95% CI: 3.12 - 8.41)  found significant correlation between forgetfulness and non- adherence among hypertensive patients.
Hypertensive patients who experienced side effects of their medications were less adherent to their medication than those who did not experience side effects in Palestine (AOR = 4.58; 95% CI: 1.87 - 11.25) and Serbia (OR = 7.95; 95% CI: 1.48 - 42.6)   . Qualitative studies in Malaysia  and Nigeria  also found perceived side effects were inhibitors of antihypertensive medication adherence. However, Praveen et al.  in India did not find a correlation between adverse drug events and non-adherence.
Patients who had had a diagnosis of hypertension of five or more years were less likely to adhere to treatment than those who had been diagnosed for less than five years in Nepal  (OR = 2.98; 95% CI: 1.73 - 5.14) and Ethiopia (AOR = 0.11, 95% CI: 0.013 - 0.955)  . Lower levels of adherence in elderly patients with longer duration of antihypertensive therapy were also found in Serbia  . On the other hand, patients with shorter duration of hypertension were less likely to be adherent to treatment in Pakistan (<5 years) (AOR = 0.11, 95% CI: 0.013 - 0.955)  and China (<3 years) (AOR = 3.31; 95% CI: 1.91 - 5.72; P < 0.001)  .
Distance from health care facilities was a significant barrier for adherence to treatment. Longer distance from medical centres contributed to MNA of hypertensive patients in Ethiopia  . In the same way, those living in rural areas had poorer adherence to hypertensive medications in Palestine than those living in urban areas (AOR = 1.79; 95% CI: 1.10 - 2.92)  . As the remoteness from the hospital decreased, adherence to hypertension treatment improved (AOR = 2.02; 95% CI: 1.19 - 3.43) in Ethiopia  .
3.3.6. Treatment and/or Disease Related Factors
Eleven studies found a number of treatment or disease related factors associated with MNA. These included absence of disease symptoms, complication, irregular follow-up, family history of hypertension and poor BP control (Table 5).
The absence of symptoms significantly contributed to poor compliance to hypertensive therapy in Nigeria (AOR = 3.3; 95% CI: (1.3 - 8.0)  and India (OR = 0.414; 95% CI: 0.192 - 0.892)  . Qualitative studies in Congo  and India  also found hypertensive medications were more likely to be taken when the patient experienced symptoms of hypertension.
The presence of hypertension-related complications such as heart diseases (AOR = 21.73, 95% CI: 1.568 - 418.42 P = 0.000) was found to be associated with decreased medication adherence among patients in Ethiopia  . In contrast, a study in Pakistan found that cases suffering from hypertension-related complications were more likely to be adherent to medications  .
In Nepal, those with no family history of hypertension were less adherent to their medications compared to those with a family history of high BP (OR =
Table 5. Variables summarised under the domain of treatment and/or disease related factors investigated by the studies.
4.46; 95% CI: 1.21 - 16.4, P = 0.024)  . Frequent meetings/appointments provide better monitoring of blood pressure levels, as well as the opportunity to have more access to information and can serve as the basis for adherence to antihypertensive medication management  . Irregular follow-up (AOR = 6.39; 95% CI: 1.22 - 33.3),  was significantly associated with MNA in Nepal. Similarly, an Indian study reported that a longer time since the last visit to a doctor for advice (AOR = 7.26, 95% CI: 2.65 - 19.86) was significantly related with non- adherence to hypertensive medications  .
Poor BP control was significantly associated with MNA in Ghana and Nigeria (P = 0.006)  . BP values over 140/90 mmHg were also reported in 59.1% of non-adherent patients and 21.4% of adherent patients, [Chi Square (χ2) = 19.84; P < 0.01; OR = 5.30 95%, CI: 2.39 - 11.85] in Serbia  . Similarly, the average systolic and diastolic blood pressure for non-adherents was significantly higher (P = 0.05) than that in adherents in Malaysia  . In contrast, a study in Northern Ethiopia  found that patients at the pre-hypertension level (BP values below 140/90 mmHg) (AOR = 0.026; 95% CI: 0.003 - 0.242) were less adherent to their medications.
3.3.7. Health Care Services
Four studies found dissatisfaction with the health services and treatment provided’ influenced MNA significantly among hypertensive patients (Table 6). A study conducted in Brazil confirmed the high correlation between MNA and dissatisfaction with health services  . Hypertensive individuals who were dissatisfied with the care received in primary public health services (such as reception service, scheduling appointment and care received from the health team) were more likely to not adhere to the proposed medication treatment. Inconve-
Table 6. Variables summarised under the domain of health care services investigated by studies.
nient clinic operating hours, long waiting time and under-dispensing of medications were found to be inhibitors of adherence in a qualitative study in Nigeria. Studies in Congo  and Delhi  found that antihypertensive medication were sometimes not readily available at health care centers. Patients waited for long periods to receive medications once they had been prescribed. Rude or unsympathetic behavior and attitudes by staff members at the health clinics was the other reason found for the dissatisfaction of the patients in Congo  .
In Bangladesh, inadequate information from health care professionals about hypertension and its treatment (AOR = 5.16; 95% CI%: 1.13 - 23.66) were significantly associated with MNA  . Also in Palestine, patients dissatisfied with treatment were less likely to adhere to prescribed hypertensive medications than those satisfied with their treatments (AOR = 2.93; 95% CI: 1.22 - 7.02)  . Due to fewer interactions with the physicians, those receiving treatment at government hospitals had a 30 times greater chance of being non-adherent than those treated at private hospitals or clinics (AOR = 35.29; 95% CI 9.76 - 127.63) in Bangladesh  .
3.4. Summary of the Result
The results of the review provide insight into factors influencing MNA of hypertensive patients. Factors related to demography, barriers for adherence and treatment and disease related factors were the most commonly examined among the studies reviewed while factors related to perceptions regarding hypertension and its severity were the least examined. Associations of MNA with demographic and psychosocial factors such as age, gender, ethnicity, level of education, co-morbidities, duration of therapy, the number of medicines, use of social drugs, were often varied and not consistent. Factors affecting MNA consistently were: low socioeconomic status and low monthly income; family support; the use of traditional herbal preparations; knowledge and belief regarding hypertension and its management; cost of medications, avoiding side effect of medications; forgetfulness; absence of symptoms; distance from health facilities; irregular follow-up; and dissatisfaction with the treatment and health services provided.
Though non-adherence to antihypertensive treatment is a significant problem in CHD management few studies on medication adherence have been conducted in developing countries  . Moreover, the majority of these studies were conducted in hospital and clinical settings. Studies carried out in low-income community settings are extremely limited.
Our review found that although there was substantial heterogeneity in methods and populations across studies, approximately half of the participated hypertensive population both male and female 18 years and older did not adhere properly to the treatment for hypertension as prescribed by their doctors. Despite the higher prevalence of hypertension and its poor control among women in developing countries, we did not find any studies that focused specifically on this vulnerable population.Women in developing countries living with chronic non-communicable diseases such as hypertension experience particular challenges in accessing cost-effective prevention, early detection, diagnosis, treatment and care. The lack of knowledge and information regarding health, poor access to healthcare, family responsibilities, and poor economic, legal and political status further worsen their situation  .
From 25 studies, we identified significant factors associated with MNA. A limitation of the selected studies was the fact that factors associated with MNA were not examined for gender differences. However, a study in Brazil reported reasons for non-adherence to medication and non-medication regimen in patients’ opinion according to gender  . Considering the magnitude of inadequately treated or controlled hypertension among women in developing countries, studies that explore factors affecting MNA in this vulnerable population areurgently needed.
4.1. Implications for Hypertension Management and Research
The present review reveals that gender may not be a good predictor of non-ad- herence because of inconsistent conclusions. However, it is conceivable that women with low socioeconomic status and lower level of education are more vulnerable. Their lack of adherence might be due to their inability to buy medicines, and lack of access to free health facilities as governments in developing countries spends comparatively less of their budgets on health than developed countries. The importance of cost-related factors should be considered against the background of the relatively high out-of-pocket payments for most treatments in developing countries especially in South Asia and Africa.
The review also found that fear of side effects make some hypertensive patients stop their medications or reduce their daily doses without consulting their health care providers. Therefore, information tailored to patient’s literacy level about the side effects of prescribed medications and how to manage these should be provided to all patients. From the review, it appears that educational level may not be a good predictor of MNA. However, sceptical attitudes towards antihypertensive treatment even among educated participants necessitate the health education on hypertension and its treatment to all hypertensive patients irrespective of the patients’ educational status. Understanding potential complications of hypertension could be a motivating factor for adherence to treatment. For this to happen, patients need to be aware of the seriousness of their condition and all risks involved without being worried unnecessarily  . To better deal with these problems, educational interventions are required that recognise patients’ apprehension and perceptions. In particular, patients should be provided an explanation of the benefits and adverse effects of treatment. The safety of long-term use of drugs needs to be discussed, including the information that treatment does not cause physical dependence irrespective of the length of treatment.
The review indicated that adherence to antihypertensive medication treatment would be improved if patients experience positive encounters with their doctors or health care providers regarding adequate and accurate advice on achieving control of their high blood pressure  . Among the selected studies, there was a general lack of assessment of individual risk perceptions of hypertension complications such as CHD. This is an unfortunate omission given the importance of such risk perceptions in medication adherence. Earlier studies in developed countries have shown that patients who accurately perceive their risk of cardiovascular disease are more likely to be adherent to medications and guidelines compared to those who do not perceive themselves to be at risk     . Women’s perceptions of their risk for heart disease can significantly influence their decision-making process concerning healthcare choice  .
The studies in the review did not examine in depth cultural and psychological issues, in particular those relating to self-efficacy (i.e. the belief that one can perform a particular behavior under differing conditions which can greatly impact on medication adherence. Cultural restrictions make it difficult for women to seek medical care from male health care providers,  but there is, at the same time, a shortage of female health professionals  . These issues are compounded by health systems that often fail to respond to the particular needs of women with NCDs such as hypertension  . Weak health systems have been identified as a major obstacle in effectively responding to the rising burden of chronic conditions such as hypertension in developing countries. Studies are required that recognise and analyse the intricate associations between health systems and their effects on hypertension management in developing countries  . In spite of the need for research on health systems, little attention has also been given to the role of local health systems in the delivery of care for the control of hypertension. Moreover, belief-laden factors including confidence in the physician’s knowledge or ability, belief of control over one’s health and illness perception were all found to be significantly related to medication adherence in developed countries  . Studies in developing countries especially at community settings on these factors influencing adherence would be helpful to address the knowledge gap and contribute to global strategies for addressing non-com- pliance among hypertensive patients.
4.2. Strengths and Weaknesses of the Review
We have included studies from 20 developing countries (27.40% of all developing countries). Having the study population from less than one third of the developing countries incorporated in the analysis, the conclusions of this review might not be extrapolated to the whole population of the developing countries.
Most of the studies in our review that met inclusion criteria were quantitative in type. Only half of the quantitative studies (20) chose study participants using simple or systematic random sampling techniques. Eight studies used purposive sampling method, thus their results may not be necessarily generalisable to the wider population. The remaining studies selected all eligible hypertensive patients from clinics/hospitals or communities as their study participants.
The review followed the PRISMA reporting guidelines for identifying, reporting, and synthesising research. The results of the review are robust. Most of studies selected for the review were judged to be of moderate to strong quality in terms of research rigour, reliability and validity. A large number of MNA related factors were consistently identified across different countries. However, this review was subject to a few limitations. This study included only English peer-re- viewed journal articles. The majority of the studies relied solely on self-reported adherence, which may be subject to self-presentation and recall bias. Moreover, heterogeneity in important aspects of methodology of the selected studieslimits the results that can be drawn from the synthesis of the data.MNA may also be influenced by the time in which the study was performed.Among the selected quantitative studies, only two prospective cross-sectional studies were found. Longitudinal assessment is desirable to differentiate between chronic and occasional non- adherence and related barriers that may contribute to non-adherence.
This systematic review examined the prevalence of MNA among hypertensive population as well as investigated factors affecting MNA. Approximately half of hypertensive men and women were found to be non-adherent to their medications. Among the selected studies, very few studies were conducted in low-in- come community settings. MNA was influenced by a range of factors including socio-economic status, knowledge of hypertension and its management, medication side effects, costs of medication, and dissatisfaction with the treatment and health services provided. There was a general lack of consideration of cultural barriers, role of health system in health care delivery, self-efficacy, and perceived individual risk of hypertension complications. Policymakers and health service providers should take these factors into account to tailor culturally appropriate intervention strategies to enhance adherence among hypertensive patients. There is also a lack of gender-specific research which is necessary given the social and economic vulnerabilities faced by women in developing countries that may affect adherence to antihypertensive medications.
LD would like to acknowledge the Australian Postgraduate Award and Curtin University Research Scholarship for supporting her research that formed part of her PhD study.
LD, JD, MA designed the study. LD Carried out the search, selected papers and extracted data. LD, JD, MA participated in data analysis and drafted the manuscript. All authors approved of the final version of the manuscript.
Table A1. Overview and statistics details of the included studies.
Note: MNA = medication non-adherence; BP = Blood pressure; OR = odds ratio; AOR = adjusted odd ratio; 𝑟 = Pearson’s correlation coefficient. aPatient population comprised of both male and female.