AS  Vol.8 No.7 , July 2017
The Use of High Tunnels to Produce Fruit and Vegetable Crops in North America
Abstract: High tunnels have been used in the United States for more than 50 years, and growers are encouraged to use them more frequently through government cost-share programs. Research on fruits and vegetable production systems has focused on high value crops such as tomato, salad greens, and several fruit crops. Maintaining soil quality and controlling insects and diseases are all issues that growers face. This review looks at current research on these issues as well as economic considerations addressed in the scientific literature. Global statistics and reports are also reviewed that complement the North American studies. Gaps in our understanding are identified, and directions for future research are suggested.
Cite this paper: Janke, R. , Altamimi, M. and Khan, M. (2017) The Use of High Tunnels to Produce Fruit and Vegetable Crops in North America. Agricultural Sciences, 8, 692-715. doi: 10.4236/as.2017.87052.

[1]   National Agricultural Statistics Service (2014) US Department of Agriculture. Census of Agriculture; Horticultural Specialties.

[2]   Lamont, W. (2009) Overview of the Use of High Tunnels Worldwide. Horttechnology, 19, 25-29.

[3]   Lamont, W.J.J., Mcgann, M.R., Orzolek, M.D., Mbugua, N., Dye, B. and Reese, D. (2002) Design and Construction of the Penn State High Tunnel. Horttechnology, 12, 447-453.

[4]   Lamont, W.J.J. (2013) High Tunnel Construction and Production in a Large Metropolitan City. Acta Horticulturae, 987, 45-47.

[5]   Lamont, W.J.J., Orzolek, M.D., Holcomb, E.J., Demchak, K., Burkhart, E., White, L. and Dye, B. (2003) Production System for Horticultural Crops Grown in the Penn State High Tunnel. Horttechnology, 13, 358-362.

[6]   Hecher, E.A.D.S., Faluk, C.L., Enfield, J., Guldan, S.J. and Uchanski, M.E. (2014) The Economics of Low-Cost High Tunnels for Winter Vegetable Production in the Southwestern United States. Horttechnology, 24, 7-15.

[7]   Jiang, W., Qu, D., Mu, D. and Wang, L. (2004) Protected Cultivation of Horticultural Crops in China. Horticultural Reviews, 30, 115-162.

[8]   Jensen, M.H. and Malter, A.J. (1995) Protected Agriculture: A Global Review. World Bank Publications, Washington DC.

[9]   Balliu, A. and Sallaku, G. (2008) Microclimate Control in Protected Cultivation. In: Abbasi, N.A. and Habib, U., Eds., Protected Horticulture, Department of Horticulture, University of Rawalpindi, Rawalpindi, 81-96.

[10]   Orzolek, M.D. (2013a) Increasing Economic Returns to High Tunnels with Specialty Crops. Acta Horticulturae, 987, 83-88.

[11]   Kratky, B. (1983) PVC Greenhouses for Non-Windy Conditions in Hawaii. Hawaii Agricultural Experiment Station, Honolulu.

[12]   Wittwer, S.H. (1993) World-Wide Use of Plastics in Horticultural Production. Horttechnology, 3, 6-19.

[13]   Emmert, E.M. (1955) Low-Cost Plastic Greenhouses. Agricultural Experiment Station Progress Report 28. University of Kentucky, Lexington.

[14]   Orzolek, M.D. (2013b) Status of High Tunnels in the US. Acta Horticulturae, 987, 29-32.

[15]   Wells, O.S. (1996) Rowcover and High Tunnel Growing Systems in the United States. Horttechnology, 6, 172-176.

[16]   Wittwer, S.H. and Castilla, N. (1995) Protected Cultivation of Horticultural Crops Worldwide. Horttechology, 5, 6-23.

[17]   Wells, O.S. and Loy, J.B. (1993) Rowcovers and High Tunnels Enhance Crop Production in the Northeastern United States. Horttechnology, 3, 92-95.

[18]   Blomgren, T. and Frisch, T. (2007) High Tunnels: Using Low-Cost Technology to Increase Yields, Improve Quality, and Extend the Season. Cornell University Cooperative Extension, Regional Farm Food Project, New York.

[19]   Wiediger, P. and Wiediger, A. (2003) Walking to Spring. Au Naturel Farm, Smith Grove.

[20]   Kansas State University Research and Extension & the University of Nebraska, Lincoln (2013) Hightunnels.

[21]   Everhart, E., Hansen, R., Lewis, R.D., Naeve, L. and Taber, H. (2010) Iowa High Tunnel Fruit and Vegetable Production Manual. Iowa State University, Ames.

[22]   Kacira, M. (2011) Greenhouse Production in US Status, Challenges, and Opportunities. Proceedings of GIGR International Symposium 2011 Sustainable Bioproduction-Water, Energy, and Food, Tokyo, 19-23 September 2011.

[23]   Tuzel, Y. and Oztekin, G.B. (2015) Protected Cultivation in Turkey. International Society for Horticultural Science, 55, 21-26.

[24]   Scarascia-Mugnozza, G., Sica, C. and Russo, G. (2011) Plastic Materials in European Agriculture: Actual Use and Perspectives. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research, 42, 15-28.

[25]   Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (1983) Research and Demonstration on Protected Vegetable Production—Bahrain: The Study and Improvement of Soil Productivity under Plastic Tunnels and Open Field Conditions. Based on the Work of Amer, S.A., FAO Soil Fertility Specialist. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome, 169.

[26]   National Agriculture Information System, Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan.

[27]   National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition (2016) Environmental Quality Incentives Program: EQIP Seasonal High Tunnel Initiative.

[28]   Carey, E.E., Jett, L., Lamont, W.J., Nennich, T.T., Orzolek, M.D. and Williams, K.A. (2009) Horticultural Crop Production in High Tunnels in the United States: A Snapshot. Horttechnology, 23, 37-43.

[29]   Spaw, M. and Williams, K.A. (2004) Full Moon Farm Builds High Tunnels: A Case Study in Site Planning for Crop Production Structures. Horttechnology, 14, 449-454.

[30]   Bachmann, J. (2005) Season Extension Techniques for Market Gardeners. National Sustainable Agriculture Information Service, Washington DC.

[31]   Knewtson, S.J.B., Carey, E.E. and Kirkham, M.B. (2010) Management Practices of Growers Using High Tunnels in the Central Great Plains of the United States. Hort-technology, 20, 639-645.

[32]   Brandle, J.R., Hodges, L. and Zhou, X.H. (2004) Windbreaks in North American Agricultural Systems. In: Nair, P.K.R., Rao, M.R. and Buck, L.E., Eds., Anonymous New Vistas in Agroforestry, Springer, Berlin, 65-78.

[33]   Waterer, D. (2003) Yields and Economics of High Tunnels for Production of Warm-Season Vegetable Crops. Horttechnology, 13, 339-343.

[34]   Ward, M.J. and Bomford, M.K. (2013) Row Covers Moderate Diurnal Temperature Flux in High Tunnels. Acta Hort, 987, 59-66.

[35]   Kadir, S., Carey, E. and Ennahli, S. (2006) Influence of High Tunnel and Field Conditions on Strawberry Growth and Development. Hortscience, 41, 329-335.

[36]   Wien, H.C. (2009) Microenvironmental Variations within the High Tunnel. Hort-science, 44, 235-238.

[37]   Kumri, P., Ojiha, R.K., Abhivyakti, A.W. and Rajesh, R.P. (2014) Microclimatic Alteration through Protective Cultivation and Its Effect on Tomato Yield. Journal of Agrometeorology, 16, 172-177.

[38]   Krizek, D.T., Clark, H.D. and Mirecki, R.M. (2005) Spectral Properties of Selected UV-Blocking and UV-Transmitting Covering Materials with Application for Production of High-Value Crops in High Tunnels. Photochemistry and Photobiology, 81, 1047-1051.

[39]   Adam, A., Kouider, S.A., Youssef, B., Hamou, A. and Saiter, J.M. (2005) Studies of Polyethylene Multi-Layer Films Used as Greenhouse Covers under Saharan Climatic Conditions. Polymer Testing, 24, 834-838.

[40]   Gimenez, C., Otto, R.F. and Castilla, N. (2002) Productivity of Leaf and Root Vegetable Crops under Direct Cover. Scientia Horticulturae, 94, 1-22.

[41]   Luthria, D.L., Mukhopadhyay, S. and Krizek, D.T. (2006) Content of Total Phenolics and Phenolic Acids in Tomato (Lycopersicon exculentum Mill.) Fruits as Influenced by Cultivar and Solar UV Radiation. Journal of Food Composition and Analysis, 19, 771-777.

[42]   Zhao, X., Carey, E.E., Young, J.E., Wang, W.Q. and Iwamoto, T. (2007) Influences of Organic Fertilization, High Tunnel Environment, and Postharvest Storage on Phenolic Compounds in Lettuce. Hortscience, 42, 71-76.

[43]   Ordidge, M., Garcia-Macia, P., Battey, N., Gordon, M., Hadley, P., John, P., Lovegrove, J., Vysini, E. and Wagstaff, A. (2010) Phenolic Contents of Lettuce, Strawberry, Raspberry, and Blueberry Crops Cultivated under Plastic Films Varying in Ultraviolet Transparency. Food Chemistry, 119, 1224-1227.

[44]   Montri, A. and Biernbaum, J. (2009) Management of the Soil Environment in High Tunnels. Horttechnology, 19, 34-36.

[45]   Sarrantonio, M. (1994) Northeast Cover Crop Handbook. Rodale Institute, Kutztown.

[46]   Gaskell, M., Fouche, B., Koike, S., Lanini, T., Mitchell, J. and Smith, R. (2000) Organic Vegetable Production in California—Science and Practice. Horttechnology, 10, 699-713.

[47]   Rudisill, M.A., Bordelon, B.P., Turco, R.F. and Hoagland, L.A. (2015) Sustaining Soil Quality in Intensively Managed High Tunnel Vegetable Production Systems: A Role for Green Manures and Chicken Litter. Hortscience, 50, 461-468.

[48]   Knewtson, S.J.B., Kirkham, M.B., Janke, R.R., Murray, L.W. and Carey, E.E. (2012) Soil Quality after Eight Years under High Tunnels. Hortscience, 47, 1630-1633.

[49]   Altamimi, M.E. (2016) Evaluating Organic and Conventional Management and Nitrogen Rate for Effects on Yield, Soil and Plant Nutrient of Tomato and Pac Choi Grown under High Tunnel and in the Field. Ph.D. Thesis, Kansas State University, Manhattan.

[50]   Reeve, J. and Drost, D. (2012) Yields and Soil Quality under Transitional Organic High Tunnel Tomatoes. Hortscience, 47, 38-44.

[51]   Bonanomi, G., D’ascoli, R., Antignani, V., Capodilupo, M., Cozzolino, L., Marazaioli, R., Pupolo, G., Rutigliano, F.A., Scelza, R., Scotti, R., Rao, M.A. and Zoina, A. (2011) Assessing Soil Quality under Intensive Cultivation and Tree Orchards in Southern Italy. Applied Soil Ecology, 47, 187-194.

[52]   Both, A., Reiss, E.J., Sudal, J., Holmstrom, K., Wyenandt, C., Kline, W. and Garrison, S. (2007) Evaluation of a Manual Energy Curtain for Tomato Production in High Tunnels. Horttechnology, 17, 467-472.

[53]   Rader, H.B. and Karlsson, M.G. (2006) Northern Field Production of Leaf and Romaine Lettuce Using a High Tunnel. Horttechnology, 16, 649-654.

[54]   Marshall, K.S., Erich, S., Hutton, M., Hutchinson, M. and Mallory, E. (2016) Nitrogen Availability from Compost in High Tunnel Tomato Production. Compost Science and Utilization, 24, 147-158.

[55]   Lamont, W.J. (1999) Vegetable Production Using Plasticulture. Extension Bulletin. Asian and Pacific Council, Food & Fertilizer Technology Center, Saint Paul.

[56]   O’connell, S., Rivard, C., Peet, M.M., Harlow, C. and Louws, F. (2012) High Tunnel and Field Production of Organic Heirloom Tomatoes: Yield, Fruit Quality, Disease, and Microclimate. Hortscience, 47, 1283-1290.

[57]   Powell, M., Gunderson, B., Cowan, J., Miles, C.A. and Inglis, D.A. (2014) The Effect of Open-Ended High Tunnels in Western Washington on Late Blight and Physiological Leaf Roll among Five Tomato Cultivars. Plant Disease, 98, 1639-1647.

[58]   Warren, N.D., Sideman, R.G. and Smith, R.G. (2015) Performance of High Tunnel Tomato Cultivars in Northern New England. Horttechnology, 25, 139-146.

[59]   Zhao, Y., Gu, M.M., Bi, G.H., Evans, B. and Harkess, R. (2014) Planting Date Effect on Yield of Tomato, Eggplant, Pepper, Zinnia, and Snapdragon in High Tunnel in Mississippi. Journal of Crop Improvement, 28, 27-37.

[60]   Rogers, M.A. and Wszelaki, A.L. (2012) Influence of High Tunnel Production and Planting Date on Yield, Growth, and Early Blight Development on Organically Grown Heirloom and Hybrid Tomato. Horttechnology, 22, 452-462.

[61]   Villiers, D.S.D., Wien, H.C., Reid, J.E. and Albright, L.D. (2011) Energy Use and Yields in Tomato Production: Field, High Tunnel and Greenhouse Compared for the Northern Tier of the USA (Upstate New York). Acta Horticulturae, 893, 373-380.

[62]   Martin, C.A. and Sideman, R.G. (2012) Survival and Yields of Fall-Planted Winter Sprouting Broccoli Grown in High Tunnels for Spring Harvest in the Northeastern United States. Horttechnology, 22, 345-352

[63]   Borrelli, K., Koenig, R.T., Jaeckel, B.M. and Miles C.A. (2013) Yield of Leafy Greens in High Tunnel Winter Production in the Northwest United States. Hortscience, 48, 183-188.

[64]   Zhao, X. and Carey, E.E. (2009) Summer Production of Lettuce, and Microclimate in High Tunnel and Open Field Plots in Kansas. Horttechnology, 19, 113-119.

[65]   Wallace, R.W., Wsszelaki, A.L., Miles, C.A., Cowan, J.S., Martin, J., Roozen, J., Gundersen, B. and Inglis, D.A. (2012) Lettuce Yield and Quality When Grown in High Tunnel and Open-Field Production Systems under Three Diverse Climates. Horttechnology, 22, 659-668.

[66]   Rowley, D., Black, B. and Drost, D. (2010) High Tunnel Strawberry Production. Utah State University Cooperative Extension, Logan.

[67]   Jett, L.W. (2009) Growing Short Day Strawberries within High Tunnels. West Virginia University Extension, Morgantown.

[68]   Medina, Y., Gosselin, A., Desjardins, Y., Gauthier, L., Harnois, R. and Khanizadeh, S. (2011) Effect of Plastic Mulches on Yield and Fruit Quality of Strawberry Plants Grown under High Tunnels. Acta Hort, 893, 1327-1332

[69]   Riza, M.T., Soria, C., Medina-Minguez, J.J. and Martinez-Ferri, E. (2012) Incidence of Misshapen Fruits in Strawberry Plants Grown under Tunnels Is Affected by Cultivar, Planting Date, Pollination and Low Temperatures. Hortscience, 47, 1569-1573.

[70]   Gaskell, M., Cantliffe, D.J., Stoffella, P.J. and Shaw, N.L. (2004) Field Tunnels Permit Extended Season Harvest of Small Fruits in California. Acta Hort, 659, 425-430.

[71]   Dorais, M., Gaudreau, L., Bordeleau, M., Gosselin, A., Medina, Y., Gauthier, L., Desjardins, Y. and Khanizadeh, S. (2012) High Tunnel Production of Organic Ras-pberries. Proceedings of the Canadian Organic Science Conference and Science Cluster Strategic Meetings, Winnipeg, 21-23 February 2012, 125.

[72]   Spalholz, H., Kelly, M.J. and Pritts, M. (2006) Using High Tunnels to Extend the Raspberry Season into Late Fall. Hortscience, 40, 493.

[73]   Demchak, K. (2009) Small Fruit Production in High Tunnels. Horttechnology, 19, 44-49.

[74]   Hanson, E., Von Weihe, M., Schilder, A.C., Chanon, A.M. and Scheerens, J.C. (2011) High Tunnel and Open Field Production of Floricane- and Primocane- Fruiting Raspberry Cultivars. Horttechnology, 21, 412-418.

[75]   Rom, C.R., Friedrich, H., Mcafee, J., Garcia, M.E., Johnson, D., Popp, J., Vincent, C. and Van Iersel, M. (2008b) Potential for High Tunnel Organic Berry Production for Extended and Alternative Season. Hort Science, 43, 610.

[76]   Johnson, S.N., Young, M.W. and Karley, A.J. (2012) Protected Raspberry Production Alters Aphid-Plant Interactions but Not Aphid Population Size. Agricultural and Forest Entomology, 14, 217-224.

[77]   Thompson, E., Strik, B.C., Finn, C.E., Zhao, Y. and Clark, J.R. (2009) High Tunnel versus Open Field: Management of Primocane-Fruiting Blackberry Using Pruning and Tipping to Increase Yield and Extend the Fruiting Season. Hortscience, 44, 1581-1587.

[78]   Hanson, E. (2012) Primocane-Fruiting Blackberry Performance in High Tunnels in Cold Regions. Acta Hort, 946, 397-401

[79]   Rom, C.R., Friedrich, H., Mcafee, J., Garcia, M.E., Johnson, D. and Popp, J. (2008a) Early Performance of Organic Managed Floricane and Primocane Blackberries and Raspberries Grown in High Tunnels for Extended Season. Hort Science, 43, 1228.

[80]   Ogden, A.B. and Van Iersel, M.W. (2009) Southern Highbush Blueberry Production in High Tunnels: Temperatures, Development, Yield, and Fruit Quality during the Establishment Years. Hortscience, 44, 1850-1856.

[81]   Lang, G.A. (2009) High Tunnel Tree Fruit Production: The Final Frontier? Horttechnology, 19, 50-55.

[82]   Lang, G.A. (2013) Tree Fruit Production in High Tunnels: Current Status and Case Study of Sweet Cherries. Acta Horticulturae, 987, 73-81.

[83]   Fruit Growers News (2008) English Growers Love Their High Tunnels.

[84]   Heidenreich, C., Pritts, M., Demchak, K., Hanson, E., Weber, C. and Kelly, M.J. (2012) High Tunnel Raspberries and Blackberries. Cornell University, New York.

[85]   Galinato, S.P. and Miles, C.A. (2013) Economic Profitability of Growing Lettuce and Tomato in Western Washington under High Tunnel and Open-Field Production Systems. Horttechnology, 23, 453-461.

[86]   Sydorovych, O., Rivard, C.L., O’connell, S., Harlow, C.D., Peet, M.M. and Louws, F.J. (2013) Growing Organic Heirloom Tomatoes in the Field and High Tunnels in North Carolina: Comparative Economic Analysis. Horttechnology, 23, 227-236.

[87]   Vescera, M. and Brown, R.N. (2016) Effects of Three Production Systems on Muskmelon Yield and Quality in New England. Hortscience, 51, 510-517.

[88]   Conner, D.S., Waldman, K.B., Montri, A.D., Hamm, M.W. and Biernbaum. J.A. (2010) Hoophouse Contributions to Economic Viability: Nine Michigan Case Studies. Horttechnology, 20, 877-884.

[89]   Rodriguez, H.G., Popp, J., Thomsen, M., Friedrich, H. and Rom, C.R. (2012) Economic Analysis of Investing in Open-Field or High Tunnel Primocane-Fruiting Black-Berry Production in Northwestern Arkansas. Horttechnology, 22, 245-251.

[90]   Pottorff, L.P. and Panter, K.L. (2009) Integrated Pest Management and Biological Control in High Tunnel Production. Horttechnology, 19, 61-65.

[91]   Scotti, R., Bonanomi, G., Scclza, R., Zoina, A. and Rao, M.A. (2015) Organic Amendments as Sustainable Tool to Recovery Fertility in Intensive Agricultural Systems. Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition, 15, 333-352.

[92]   Tremlett, G. (2005) Spain’s Greenhouse Effect: The Shimmering Sea of Polythene Consuming the Land.

[93]   Ali, M.A. and Ahmad, C.S. (2008) Role of Government Sector in the Development of Protected Horticulture in Pakistan. In: Abbasi, N.A. and Habib, U., Eds., Protected Horticulture, Department of Horticulture, University of Rawalpindi, Rawalpindi, 1-124.

[94]   In Paper Magazine (2012) Tunnel Farming Losing Momentum.

[95]   Byczynski, L. (2008) The Flower Farmer: An Organic Grower’s Guide to Raising and Selling Cut Flowers. 2nd Edition, Chelsea Green Publishing, Chelsea, 284.

[96]   Wien, H.C. (2008) Floral Crop Production in High Tunnels. Horttechnology, 19, 56-60.