It is well established that the two-dimensional Ising model is one of the leading non-trivial models, which divulge an exact solution and is widely used for describing physical phenomena in statistical physics. The problems of disordered systems can be studied through the early formulation considered, particularly the perfect Ising lattice by employing the technique. On the other hand, the frustration plays a vital role as a key element to study the disordered system, the so- called spin-glass problem  . It may arise from the geometry of the lattice or from a quenched random distribution of positive (ferromagnetic) and negative (anti-ferromagnetic) bonds. For instance, one of the canonical models of frustrated systems is the two-dimensional Ising model. A large number of authors  -  have studied the canonical model with p = 0.5 on a square lattice considering various assumption. The spin glass behavior occurs at zero temperature and continues to exist at a critical probability as investigated in  -  . However, a few investigations have developed by extending the method to calculate the spin correlation at zero temperature directly, and the results have obtained by extrapolating the zero-temperature results. Moreover, one may be calculated the ground state free energy and entropy for very large lattice by applying the     Pfaffian matrix method, which appears to capture the essence of the physics of the system. Ali and Poulter  have studied the spin-correlations functions of the fully frustrated Ising model and the Ising spin glass on a square lattice. Blackman and Poulter  have investigated that the phase transition of the fully frustrated system is at zero temperature.
Being motivated above the discussion, the purpose of this paper is to present some computational results for the critical behavior of the Villain model  brought about in a two-dimensional fully frustrated Ising system by introducing ferromagnetic defects. The antiferromagnetic bonds are replaced instead of ferromagnetic bonds in each unit cell randomly. Some of the results are obtained in different form as the antiferromagnetic bonds increase in the considered model, which are relevant to a particular line of research on spin glass. Spin glass is also characterized by frustration and randomness. There have been a number of studies that have sought to introduce randomness into an initially non-random frustrated system by means of defects. The starting model is fully frustrated with a highly degenerate ground state and the replacement of magnetic sites with a non-magnetic species reduces frustration but inserts randomness. There is a transition from the Villain model to spin glass phase, which is characterized by finite size effect of entropy. Therefore, the paper is organized as follows: model equations and formalism to study the thermodynamic quantity entropy are given in Section 2. The result of this work that comes from extrapolating of entropy is discussed in Section 3. Finally, the conclusion is drawn in Section 4.
2. Model Equations and Formation
To study the critical behavior of the Villain model, the two dimensional fully frustrated Villain model  can be written in the Hamiltonian form as
where is the nearest-neighbor interaction of spins and is a plaquette lattice with spins. The product of the bonds around each plaquette of the system is negative, that is. There are also many different ways to do this process which most of them gauge invariant. The exchange of interactions are uncorrelated quenched random variables taking into account the values of. The lattice is cylindrically wounded on the periodic boundary condition. The model is fully frustrated initially and its ground states are highly degenerates. Furthermore, the ferromagnetic and anti- ferromagnetic species are completely interacted in much visible system. Moreover, the anti-ferromagnetic interaction may be produced the frustration in the given system. In such system, the replacement of ferromagnetic bond with anti-ferromagnetic bond can be reduced the frustration. The frustration of the system can also lead to the spin glass phase at zero temperature      due to defect bonds. Therefore, the probability of nearest neighbor bond distribution      of the system may be written as
where is the defect concentration of bond and.
On the other hand, the partition function for the nearest neighbor Ising two dimensional Villain model can be expressed as
where are the degeneracies of the excited states, is the ground sate energy and is the ground state degeneracy, respectively. The entropy can be evaluated for the given system considering the following formulae as
Finally, the entropy  may be extrapolated to an infinite lattice for a lattice of size and may be defined as
where is the value of the lattice, is the entropy in the limit and is the coefficients of extrapolated entropy.
3. Results and Discussion
The results are investigated from the two-dimensional Villain model by replacing the anti-ferromagnetic bonds on the square lattice to employ the Pfaffian approach in the perturbation theory. The square lattices of size are considered with the range of concentration of negative bonds as. The ground-state entropy of the Villain model is obtained accurately in the thermodynamic limit. To investigate the critical behavior of the Villain model, the data are collected and averaged over number of random samples are presented graphically with physical interpretation. The error bars are indicated uncertainties in the figures equal to two standard deviations that is a 95.4% confidence interval. The uncertainties are subjected to provide in curve fitting by empolying the Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm   . The ground-state entropy with periodic boundary conditions are obtained for the mentioned concentration at different sizes () and 104 disorder realizations for as well as 5000 disorder for considering one replacement of ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic bonds creates one disorder.
Figure 1 shows the ground-state entropy of the Villain model for the lattice sizes, and. It is seen that the ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic bonds are fully satisfied in each unit cell, but the concentration of anti-ferromagnetic bond is zero percents. The error bar is not
visible because the aforementioned model is non-random. It is also seen from Figure 1 that the value of entropy is more accurate at, that is, whereas the exact value  is 0.2915. Figure 2 shows that the line fit Equation (5) of entropy crosses parallel to the horizontal line at for. The ground-state entropy for, fitting Equation (5) with
Figure 1. The ground-state entropy for Villain model, fitting Equation (5) with quality of the line fit, gradient and different lattice sizes L.
Figure 2. The ground-state entropy for, fitting Equation (5) with quality of the line fit, gradient, and quality of the line fit, gradient,. Here the entropy with error bar for and are almost same.
quality of the line fit, gradient, and quality of the line fit, gradient, is shown in Figure 3. It is clearly seen from Figure 3 that the entropy turns more flat as. Figure 4 shows the ground-state entropy for by fitting Equation (5)
Figure 3. The ground-state entropy for, fitting Equation (5) with quality of the line fit, gradient, and quality of the line fit, gradient,.
Figure 4. The ground-state entropy for, fitting Equation (5) with quality of the line fit, gradient and quality of the line fit, gradient,.
with the quality of the line fit, , and, ,. Figure 5 depicts the ground-state entropy for with the quality of the line fit, , and, ,. Moreover, Figure 6 exhibits the ground-state entropy for with the quality of the line fit, , and, ,. It is observed from Figures 4-6 that the gradient for small L decreases with increasing gradient for larger L at to 0.015. Finally, Figure 7 is showed that the entropy is in good agreement of spin glass for and of Ref.  in the thermodynamic limit.
Figure 5. The ground-state entropy for, fitting Equation (5) with quality of the line fit, gradient, and quality of the line fit, gradient,.
Figure 6. The ground-state entropy for, fitting Equation (5) with quality of the line fit, gradient, and quality of the line fit, gradient,.
Figure 7. The ground-state entropy for, fitting Equation (5) with quality of the line fit, gradient and different lattice sizes L.
A numerical computational technique via perturbation method is employed to investigate the critical point of Villain model due to the exchange ferromagnetic defects bond. It is clearly observed that the entropy has behaved different character in the low concentration regime of the Villain model of its line fit at the thermodynamic limit. The two phases, one of which is Villain phase and other one is spin glass phase, are investigated in considered system. The enhanced critical point 0.012 of the two phases is obtained for zero gradients, which is shown in Figure 3. The entropy of the Villain model and canonical spin glass at the thermodynamic limit is also in good agreement with the earlier investigations.
The authors are grateful to the authority of Chittagong University of Engineering & Technology (CUET). The authors also would like to thanks Professor Dr. Julian Poulter for valuable advice during the research work.