IJMPCERO  Vol.6 No.2 , May 2017
Patient-Specific QA of Spot-Scanning Proton Beams Using Radiochromic Film
Abstract: Radiochromic film for spot-scanning QA provides high spatial resolution and efficiency gains from one-shot irradiation for multiple depths. However, calibration can be a tedious procedure which may limit widespread use. Moreover, since there may be an energy dependence, which manifests as a depth dependence, this may require additional measurements for each patient. We present a one-scan protocol to simplify the procedure. A calibration using an EBT3 film, exposed by a 6-level step-wedge plan on a Proteus®PLUS proton system (IBA, Belgium), was performed at depths of 18, 20, 24 cm using Plastic Water® (CIRS, Norfolk, VA). The calibration doses ranged from 65 - 250 cGy (RBE) (relative biological effectiveness) for proton energies of 170 - 200 MeV. A clinical prostate + nodes plan was used for validation. The planar doses at selected depths were measured with EBT3 films and analyzed using one-scan protocol (one-scan digitization of QA film and at least one film exposed to a known dose). The gamma passing rates, dose-difference maps, and profiles of 2D planar doses measured with EBT3 film and IBA MatriXX-PT, versus the RayStation TPS calculations were analyzed and compared. The EBT3 film measurement results matched well with the TPS calculation data with an average passing rate of ~95% for 2%/2 mm and slightly lower passing rates were obtained from an ion chamber array detector. We were able to demonstrate that the use of a proton step-wedge provided clinically acceptable results and minimized variations between film-scanner orientation, inter-scan, and scanning conditions. Furthermore, for relative dosimetry (calibration is not done at the time of experiment), it could be derived from no more than two films exposed to known doses (one could be zero) for rescaling the master calibration curve at each depth. The sensitivity of the calibration to depth variations has been explored. One-scan protocol results appear to be comparable to that of the ion chamber array detector. The use of a proton step-wedge for calibration of EBT3 film potentially increases efficiency in patient-specific QA of proton beams.
Cite this paper: Chan, M. , Chen, C. , Shi, C. , Li, J. , Tang, X. , Li, X. and Mah, D. (2017) Patient-Specific QA of Spot-Scanning Proton Beams Using Radiochromic Film. International Journal of Medical Physics, Clinical Engineering and Radiation Oncology, 6, 111-123. doi: 10.4236/ijmpcero.2017.62011.

[1]   Paganetti, H. and Bortfeld, T. (2006) Proton Beam Radiotherapy—The State of the Art. In: Schlegel, T.B.W. and Grosu, A.L., Eds., New Technologies in Radiation Oncology, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 345-363.

[2]   Das, I.J. and Paganett, H. (2015) Principles and Practice of Proton Beam Therapy, AAPM Monograph No. 37. Medical Physics Publishing Inc., Madison.

[3]   International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements (2007) Prescribing, Recording, and Reporting Proton-Beam Therapy (ICRU Report 78). Journal of the International Commission on Radiation Units, 7, No. 2.

[4]   Arjomandy, B., Sahoo, N., Zhu, X.R., et al. (2009) An Overview of the Comprehensive Proton Therapy Machine Quality Assurance Procedures Implemented at The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center Proton Therapy Center-Houston. Medical Physics, 36, 2269-2282.

[5]   Sahoo, N., Sawakuchi, G.O., Gillin, M.T. and Zhu, X.R. (2016) Radiation Dosimetry of Proton Beams, Chapter 6. In: Rath, A.K. and Sahoo, N., Eds., Particle Radiotherapy, Springer India, New Delhi, 77-94.

[6]   Zhao, L. and Das, I.J. (2010) Gafchromic EBT Film Dosimetry in Proton Beams. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 55, N291-N301.

[7]   Farr, J.B., Mascia, A.E., His, W.C., et al. (2008) Clinical Characterization of a Proton Beam Continuous Uniform Scanning System with Dose Layer Stacking. Medical Physics, 35, 4945-4954.

[8]   Gillin, M.T., Sahoo, N., Bues, M., et al. (2010) Commissioning of the Discrete Spot Scanning Proton Beam Delivery System at The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Proton Therapy Center, Houston. Medical Physic, 37, 154-163.

[9]   Schwarz, M., Algranati, C., Widesott, L., Farace, P., et al. (2016) Clinical Pencil Beam Scanning: Present and Future Practices. In: Rath, A.K. and Sahoo, N., Eds., Particle Radiotherapy, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 95-110.

[10]   Lomax, A.J., Boehringer, T., Coray, A., et al. (2001) Intensity Modulated Proton Therapy: A Clinical Example. Medical Physics, 28, 317-324.

[11]   Dietlicher, I., Casiraghi, M., Ares, C., et al. (2014) The Effect of Surgical Titanium Rods on Proton Therapy Delivered for Cervical Bone Tumors: Experimental Validation Using an Anthropomorphic Phantom. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 59, 7181-7194.

[12]   Mackin, D., Li, Y., Taylor, M.B., et al. (2013) Improving Spot-Scanning Proton Therapy Patient Specific Quality Assurance with HPlusQA, a Second-Check Dose Calculation Engine. Medical Physics, 40, Article ID: 121708.

[13]   Mackin, D., Zhu, X.R., Poenisch, F., et al. (2014) Spot-Scanning Proton Therapy Patient-Specific Quality Assurance: Results from 309 Treatment Plans. International Journal of Particle Therapy, 1, 711-720.

[14]   Hui, C.K., Robertson, D., Alsanea, F. and Beddar, S. (2015) Fast Range Measurement of Spot Scanning Proton Beams Using a Volumetric Liquid Scintillator Detector. Journal of Biomedical Physics and Engineering, 1, Article ID: 025205.

[15]   Molinelli, S., Mairani, A., Mirandola, A., et al. (2013) Dosimetric Accuracy Assessment of a Treatment Plan Verification System for Scanned Proton Beam Radiotherapy: One-Year Experimental Results and Monte Carlo Analysis of the Involved Uncertainties. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 58, 3837-3847.

[16]   Zhu, X.R., Poenisch, F., Song, X.F., et al. (2011) Patient-Specific Quality Assurance for Prostate Cancer Patients Receiving Spot Scanning Proton Therapy Using Single-Field Uniform Dose. International Journal of Radiation Oncology, Biology, Physics, 81, 552-559.

[17]   Arjomandy, B., Tailor, R., Anand, A., et al. (2010) Energy Dependence and Dose Response of Gafchromic EBT2 Film over a Wide Range of Photon, Electron, and Proton Beam Energies. Medical Physics, 37, 571-576.

[18]   Angellier, G., Gautier, M. and Herault, J. (2011) Radiochromic EBT2 Film Dosimetry for Low-Energy Proton Therapy. Medical Physics, 38, 6171-6177.

[19]   Arjomandy, B., Tailor, R., Zhao, L., et al. (2012) EBT2 Film as a Depth-Dose Measurement Tool for Radiotherapy Beams over a Wide Range of Energies and Modalities. Medical Physics, 39, 912-921.

[20]   Sorriaux, J., Kacperek, A., Rossomme, S., et al. (2013) Evaluation of Gafchromic® EBT3 Films Characteristics in Therapy Photon, Electron and Proton Beams. Physica Medica, 29, 599-606.

[21]   Carnicer, A., Angellier, G., Gerard, A., et al. (2013) Development and Validation of Radiochromic Film Dosimetry and Monte Carlo Simulation Tools for Acquisition of Absolute, High-Spatial Resolution Longitudinal Dose Distributions in Ocular Proton Therapy. Radiation Measurements, 59, 225-232.

[22]   Gambarini, G., Regazzoni, V., Artuso, E., Giove, D., Mirandola, A. and Ciocca, M. (2015) Measurements of 2D Distributions of Absorbed Dose in Proton Therapy with Gafchromic EBT3 Films. Applied Radiation and Isotopes, 104, 192-196.

[23]   Chan, M.F., Chen, C.C., Li, J., et al. (2016) One-Scan Protocol: Verifying the Delivery of Spot-Scanning Proton Beam. Medical Physics, 43, 3501.

[24]   Lewis, D., Micke, A., Yu, X. and Chan, M.F. (2012) An Efficient Protocol for Radiochromic Film Dosimetry Combining Calibration and Measurement in a Single Scan. Medical Physics, 39, 6339-6350.

[25]   Chen, C.C., Chang, C., Moyers, M.F., Gao, M. and Mah, D. (2016) Technical Note: Spot Characteristic Stability for Proton Pencil Beam Scanning. Medical Physics, 43, 777-782.

[26]   Mayer, R., Lin, L.Y., Fager, M., Douglas, D., McDonough, J. and Carabe, A. (2015) Proposed Linear Energy Transfer Areal Detector for Protons Using Radiochromic Film. Review of Scientific Instruments, 86, Article ID: 044301.

[27]   Reinhardt, S., Hillbrand, M., Wilkens, J.J. and Assmann, W. (2012) Comparison of Gafchromic EBT2 and EBT3 Films for Clinical Photon and Proton Beams. Medical Physics, 39, 5257-5262.

[28]   Reinhardt, S., Wurl, M., Greubel, C., et al. (2015) Investigation of EBT2 and EBT3 Films for Proton Dosimetry in the 4-20 MeV Energy Range. Radiation and Environmental Biophysics, 54, 71-79.

[29]   Kirby, D., Green, S., Palmans, H., et al. (2010) LET Dependence of Gafchromic Films and an Ion Chamber in Low Energy Proton Dosimetry. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 55, 417-433.

[30]   Vadrucci, M., Esposito, G., Ronsivalle, C., et al. (2015) Calibration of GafChromic EBT3 for Absorbed Dose Measurements in 5 MeV Proton Beam and 60Co γ-Rays. Medical Physics, 42, 4678-4684.

[31]   Perles, L.A., Mirkovic, D., Anand, A., Titt, U. and Mohan, R. (2013) LET Dependence of the Response of EBT2 Films in Proton Dosimetry Modeled as a Bimolecular Chemical Reaction. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 58, 8477-8491.

[32]   Park, S.A., Kwak, W., Yoon, M.G., et al. (2011) Dose Verification of Proton Beam Therapy Using the Gafchromic EBT Film. Radiation Measurements, 46, 717-721.

[33]   Battaglia, M.C., Schardt, D., Espino, J.M., et al. (2016) Dosimetric Response of Radiochromic Films to Protons of Low Energies in the Bragg Peak Region. Physical Review Accelerators and Beams, 19, Article ID: 064701.

[34]   Chan, M.F., Lewis, D. and Yu, X. (2014) Is It Possible to Publish a Calibration Function for Radiochromic Film? International Journal of Radiation Oncology, Biology, Physics, 3, 25-30.

[35]   Castriconi, R., Ciocca, M., Mirandola, A., et al. (2016) Dose-Response of EBT3 Radiochromic Films to Proton and Carbon Ion Clinical Beams. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 62, 377-393.

[36]   Reinhardt, S., Wuerl, M., Greubel, C., et al. (2015) Dependence Correction of Radiochromic Films for Application in Low Energy Proton Irradiation. Medical Physics, 42, 3458.

[37]   Fiorini, F., Kirby, D., Thompson, J., et al. (2014) Under-Response Correction for EBT3 Films in the Presence of Proton Spread out Bragg Peaks. Physica Medica, 30, 454-461.

[38]   Doran, S.J., Pellicioli, P., Adamovics, J. and Brauer-Krisch, E. (2016) Enhanced Method for Determining the Low-LET Saturation Dose of PRESAGE. Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on 3D Radiation Dosimetry, Galveston, 7-10 November 2016.

[39]   Devic, S., Aldelaijan, S., Alrumayan, F., et al. (2013) Radiochromic Film as a Dosimetric Tool for Low Energy Proton Beams. Proceedings of Cyclotrons 2013, Vancouver, 16-20 September 2013, WEPSH007.

[40]   Piermattei, A., Miceli, R., Azario, L., et al. (2000) Radiochromic Film Dosimetry of a Low Energy Proton Beam. Medical Physics, 27, 1655-1660.