JMMCE  Vol.4 No.5 , September 2016
Extender Properties of Some Nigerian Clays
ABSTRACT
The extender properties of some Nigeria clays have been studied. The local clays were characterized using X-ray fluorescence and scanning electron microscope. The physico-chemical properties of the clays were evaluated using ASTM standards. The physico-chemical characterization of the local clays gave the following results: specific gravity (2.54 and 2.49), oil absorption (51.0 and 59.0 g/100g), refractive index (1.7 and 2.0) and pH (5.1 and 4.8) for Nsu and Ihitte-Uboma clays respectively. Compositional analysis showed that the clays consisted predominantly of silica (SiO2) and aluminium oxide (Al2O3) in high proportions with the other constituents present in very small proportions. The clays were stable to heat and insoluble in toluene, methanol, ethanol, 2-propanol, chloroform and hydrochloric acidexcept for their slight solubility in acetic acid. The colour of the clays was not affected in cold or when heated except for slight colour change observed in the presence of hydrochloric acid when heated. The particle morphology of the clays indicated the presence of sub-angular platelet of varying sizes. The optimum calcination temperature of the clays was determined to be 850°C for use in oil-based paints. The clays can be used in gloss paints, rubber and plastic composites and as an adsorbent with improved properties.

1. Introduction

Clays has been used indispensably as extenders in architectural and industrial paints, and other industries such as in agriculture, in construction as a building material, in oil industry as drilling muds to protect the cutting bit while drilling, filtering and deodorizing agents in the refining of petroleum, in clarifying water and wine, in purifying sewage as an adsorbent, in textile and sugar industries to remove colour and other impurities, and in the paper, plastics, and rubber industries as fillers [1] . Titanium dioxide (TiO2) is the most widely used prime pigment in coatings to ensure that appropriate service properties of paints are obtained due to the relatively high refractive index it possesses which is the main advantage for providing these properties [2] while calcined clays has the disadvantage of low hiding power. The combination of these individual pigment properties will help overcome their disadvantages.

However, TiO2 requires long processing, including grinding, levigation, chemical treatments, etc. from ore to final stage resulting to significant loss of materials [3] . Thus, processed pigments like TiO2 are expensive and are not indigenously available and this has led to increases in the cost of the resultant coating products.

Nowadays, calcined clays which are of low cost and environmentally friendly are considered alternatives to TiO2 in paint making. The calcination of clays, generally at high temperatures has crucial effects on the morphology of clays which results to improved coating properties. The calcination of clays leads to the creation of air voids and this results to good crack and scrub resistance, low sheen, decreases in the specific gravity of clays and improvement in the hiding power of paints [4] [5] . Calcined clays are used in paints not only because of their high chemical resistance but also, the form and the charge distribution of their particles which have a positive impact on final coatings products. Furthermore, calcined clays affect paint thixotropy thereby ensuring better paint processing properties. The plate-like structure and aspect ratios of calcined clays give rise to reinforcing layer structure with improved properties. Fine calcined clay acts as a spacer for TiO₂ particles and this enhances scattering coefficient of TiO₂ pigments, with enhanced paint dry film opacity [6] . Calcined clays affect rheology, sedimentation and thixotropy and give better processing properties to coatings. Thus, the light scattering coefficient of the TiO₂ pigments is increased providing enhanced opacity, especially in dry paint films. The calcination process does not only cause dehydration but particles agglomeration.

Calcination of clays results to changes in the clay structure, physiochemical properties and composition of the clay minerals [7] . These concomitant changes can be varied from one clay mineral group to another and also, the particle size and heating regime. Raising the temperature to dehydration level leads to loss of adsorbed water thereby causing the alteration of the macro and micro-porosity of the clay minerals. This results to the collapse of interlayer spaces, and a reduction of cation exchange capacity (CEC). The partial loss of the adsorbed and hydration water can increase the hydrophilicity and surface acidity of the clay [8] . Additionally, calcination of clays results to stabilization of the clay to maintain important permanent properties. Initially, in the dehydration stage, the adsorbed and hydrated water and impurities attached to the clay particles are removed. This results in weight loss of the clay particles and an increased surface area, an indication of more sites for adsorption. Further heating leads to dehydroxylation and if heating is continued beyond dehydroxylation, the clay structure and the surface functional groups are altered [9] .

Wibowo [10] studied the effects of calcination temperatures (350˚C - 650˚C) on the catalytical properties of basic clay and found that the basic clay calcined at 450˚C exhibited an optimum activity when used together with tetramethylammonium hydroxide (TMAOH). Ahmed [11] studied the differences in the performances of natural kaolin, thermally treated kaolin (calcined kaolin), and chemically treated kaolin in alkyd based paint in the protection of steel. The study showed that calcined kaolin performed better in the protection of steel than kaolin, while chemically treated kaolin varied in its performance according to the concentration of the modifier used. The result suggested that kaolin could be used as a reinforcing agent in making other polymer composites such as rubber, and plastic composites. Ewulonu [12] synthesized and characterized local clay-titanium dioxide core-shell extender pigment using simple chemical technique and found that they combined the properties of both the local clays and titanium dioxide. This study is aimed at understanding the impact of clay morphology and integrating the concept of calcination of local clays for cost effective paint formulation.

2. Materials and Method

2.1. Materials

The local clays used in this study were sourced from two different locations, Nsu in Ehime Mbano Local Government Area and Etiti in Ihitte-Uboma Local Government Area within the South-Eastern region of Nigeria.

2.2. Preparation of the Extender Pigments

The local clays (Nsu and Ihitte-Uboma clays) were hand dug from the deposit area and sundried. Impurities were removed from the clay before crushing. The crushed clay samples were calcined for three hours at the following temperatures 550, 650, 750, 850, and 950˚C respectively and stored for subsequent studies. The clay samples calcined at different temperatures were each sieved to 0.075 mm clay particle size and later, alkyd paint samples were formulated with each calcined clay sample, Table 1. Each of the prepared paint samples was subjected to a drying test, a very important factor driven by trends in modern architectural paints for end consumer which enabled the determination of the optimum calcination temperature of the clays.

2.3. Characterization of the Extender Pigments

The uncalcined clays and extender pigments (calcined clays) were analyzed for major oxides contents using Munipal 4 Energy Dispersive X-ray fluorescence spectrometer (EDXRF). A scanning electron microscope (SEM; JEOL JX 840), a microanalyzer electron probe was also used in this study to estimate the particle shapes of the clays and the extender pigments. The ASTM international standard was used to characterize the extender pigments for specific gravity (ASTM D153-84), oil absorption (ASTM D281- 12), refractive index (ASTM D 1208-96), hydrogen ion concentration (ASTM D 1208- 96), and chemical reactivity (ASTM D34-08).

Table 1. Formulation of Alkyd paints using local calcined clays.

*P/B = pigment to binder ratio.

3. Results and Discussion

3.1. Determination of the Optimum Calcination Temperature of the Clays

The results obtained the from the drying studies of paints formulated with the calcined clays presented in Table 2 show that both Nsu and Ihitte-Uboma clays formulated paints exhibited through-dry times of 210 and 201 min respectively for the formulations with local clays calcined at 850˚C. The surface-dry times of Nsu and Ihitte-Uboma clays formulated paints for clay calcined at 850˚C are 105, and 103 min respectively. Similarly, for the local clays calcined at 950˚C, the surface-dry times of the applied paint samples are 100 and 102 min respectively for Nsu and ihitte-uboma local clays. From energy consumption considerations, a very important factor in the processing industry, since the surface-dry times at 850˚C and 950˚C for the local clays are very similar, the temperature of 850˚C should represent the optimum calcination temperature for the local clays as the paints formulated with the clays calcined at 850˚C had good drying properties. It is important to note that trends in modern architectural paints is driven by two factors, namely, lower volatile organic compound (VOC) emission and, arguably, the most important is the end-consumers who are asking for long lasting, easier to use products that have quicker drying properties.

3.2. Particle Size Analysis

The particle size distribution (PSD) of the local clays was analyzed using the dry sieving method in accordance with ASTM D422-63. The results show that the greater portion of the clays were of particles less or equal to 0.30 mm and which were found to be the major particles present in the clays as shown in Figure 1. According to British Soil Classification System (BS 5930, 1981), both clays are classified as medium sand under coarse grain soil. Therefore 0.075 mm clay particle size was used in the characterization of the extender pigments and subsequent analysis.

3.3. Property Evaluation of the Extender Pigments

The physical-characterization of the extender pigments are illustrated graphically in

Table 2. Drying properties of calcined local clays formulated alkyd paints.

*NC = Nsu clay; IU = Ihitte-Uboma clay; EP = Extender pigment.

Figure 1. Particle size distribution of nsu and ihitte-uboma clay samples.

Figure 2. The local clays have the following physical properties: pH (5.1 and 4.8), oil absorption (59 and 51), refractive index (1.7 and 2.0) [13] and specific gravity (2.54 and 2.49) respectively for Nsu and Ihitte-Uboma clays. According to US Department of Agriculture on classification of soil pH both clays are strongly acidic in nature. Hare and Beck [14] had reported a pH that ranged from 4.5 - 7 for kaolin. The pH of some extenders are talc 9 - 9.5, commercial whiting 8.74, fly ash 8.15 [15] [16] , and industrial waste clay 7.88 [17] . The oil absorption of extender pigments depends chiefly on the particle size, the surface area of the pigment, with lower particle sizes being associated with increased oil absorption. Oil absorption is the minimum quantity of oil required to convert a given mass of pigment to a coherent uniform paste [18] . The oil absorption value obtained in this study is in agreement with the result obtained by Odozi et al. [15] for Okigwe-Mbano clay (60.0). The high oil absorption recorded for the two local clays is an indication that more base resin may be required in the paint formulation. The oil absorption of some extenders are fly ash 19.0, China clay 30 - 60, barytes 10 - 14, and

Figure 2. Physical characterization of extender pigment.

talc 25 - 35 [19] . Also other values reported include, calcium carbonate 6 - 30, talc 30 - 45, mica 50 - 70, and kaolin 25 - 50 [15] . The specific gravity values obtained compared to that reported by Hare and Beck [14] for 2.6. Generally, pigments having low specific gravity generally exhibit low settling tendencies, high oil absorptions, and high tinting strengths in paints [20] . The refractive indices of some extenders are: barytes (1.64), commercial whiting (1.58), and talc (1.40) [20] . Others are commercial whiting 1.65, mica 1.59, and kaolin 1.57 [19] . The refractive indices of extenders have great influence on the scattering power of paints. Generally, extenders do not enhance the true opacity or colour of the coating film. The low refractive indices of some extenders are responsible for the poor opacity exhibited in solvent paints [20] . The low specific gravity obtained in this study is an indication that the local clays can be used in high proportions without having any adverse effect in the bulk density of the formulated paint. The specific gravity of some conventional extender pigments are barytes (4.25 - 4.5), china clay (2.6), mica (2.8 - 2.85), talc (2.65), and whiting (2.7) [20] .

3.4. Compositional Analysis

The X-ray fluorescence (XRF) determinations on the uncalcined and calcined (850˚C) local clays are presented in Table 3. These data are illustrated graphically in Figure 3. The result indicates the presence of silica (SiO2) and aluminium oxide (Al2O3) in high proportions while the other constituents are present in very small proportions. The SiO2 content of uncalcined and calcined Nsu clay was found to be lower than that of Ihitte-Uboma clay while the reverse was the case for Al2O3 and TiO2 contents. The Nsu local clay was found to contain 57.52% SiO2, 25.29% Al2O3, and 0.85% TiO2 while Ihitte-Uboma local clay contained 63.09% SiO2, 20.90% Al2O3, and 0.60% TiO2 respectively. The high proportion of silica and aluminium oxide in the clays is indicative of the kaolinite nature of the clays and the basis for the type of clay to be used for the production of clay paint [21] . The oxide contents (SiO2 and Al2O3) of the calcined clays were generally found to be higher than the uncalcined clays. The increase in the oxide contents with calcination at high temperature (850˚C) as observed in this study is an indication of more sites for adsorption. The oxide contents (SiO2 and Al2O3) of some

Table 3. XRF analysis of nsu and ihitte-uboma local clays.

Figure 3. Chemical composition of nsu and ihitte-uboma clays.

Nigerian clays are Obowo clay 67.08%, 21.6% and Ihitte-Uboma clay 56.4%, 29.3% [12] , Ibere clay 52.06%, 27.87% and Oboroclay 60.21%, 19.05% [22] , Mayo-Belwa clay 59.8%, 7.08% [23] , Omankwo Afikpo clay 87.13%, 6.70%; Okposi clay 53.04%, 19.70% [19] . The presence of the unreacted oxides in the clays in indicative that paint formulated with the clays will function as anti-corrosive paints since the unreactive oxides will slow down the diffusion of corrosive species thereby delaying the phenomenon of corrosion in painted surface [14] .

3.5. Chemical Reactivity

The effects of heat on the solubility and colour stability of the local clays was studied and was shown in Table 4 and Table 5. The results show that Nsu and Ihitte-Uboma clays were not soluble in methanol, toluene, Ethanol, chloroform, 2-propanol and hydrochloric acid except for the slight solubility of the clays observed in acetic acid.

Generally, the colour of the clays were not affected in the media investigated either in the cold or when heated. However, Nsu and ihitte-Uboma clays exhibited slight colour change in the presence of hydrochloric acid on heating. Therefore, paints formulated with these clays may not be suitable for use in hydrochloric prone environment. The same recommendation applies for the clays in acetic acid (CH3COOH) prone environments.

3.6. Morphological Analysis

The morphology of the clays obtained from scanning electron microscope (SEM) are shown in Figure 4 and Figure 5. The SEM micrograph of uncalcined Nsu clay (Figure 4(a)) shows alternate structures with grains of metallic impurities imbedded in the matrix base in chains of irregular structures. Also, seen in the figure are some dark sec-

Table 4. Effect of chemical media on reactivity of nsu clay.

Table 5. Effect of chemical media on reactivity of ihitte-uboma clay.

(a) (b)

Figure 4. (a) SEM micrograph of uncalcinednsu clay, (b) SEM micrograph of calcined nsu clay.

(a) (b)

Figure 5. (a) SEM micrograph of uncalcinedihitte-uboma clay, (b) SEM micrograph of calcined ihitte-uboma clay.

tions indicating the presence of carbonaceous materials or cracks within the clay morphology. The SEM micrograph of calcined Nsu clay Figure 4(b) shows the presence of sub-angular platelet with sharp edges of varying sizes. From the SEM analysis studied, the calcined Nsu clay was determined to contain a total of 67 particles (Table 6). The SEM micrograph of uncalcined Ihitte-Ubomaclay in Figure 5(a) shows the presence of uniform texture having more distribution of metal oxides in the matrix in the form of regular shapes rather than elongated chains (of irregular shapes) as present in uncal-

Table 6. Particle properties of nsu clay 1 image with a total of 67 particles.

cined Nsu clay. Figure 5(b) is the SEM micrograph of calcined Ihitte-Uboma clay showing the presence of sub-angular platelet with rounded edges of different sizes. The clay was determined to contain a total 53 particles from SEM analysis (Table 7). The particle properties of the clays presented in Table 6 and Table 7 are illustrated graphically in Figure 6 and Figure 7. The figures indicated that the surface area of both clays increased with increases in volume. The particle shape of an extender affects its parking efficiency and the hiding power Ewulonu et al. [12] . The angular-shaped particles observed in this study will contribute to increased paint viscosity due to their low particle-to-particle distance which will restrict the movement of the molecules when used in paint formulation. The plates observed in this study will not only exert reinforcing effects but also reduce the clay’s water and gas permeability. This has the applicability to imparting good anticorrosive properties and special appearances to paints when used in paint formulations. The low aspect ratio (length to diameter ratio) and elongation observed in this study provides a reinforcing layer structure of the clays and has other advantages on the applied paint film durability such as high gloss, high opacity, increased hardness and consequently improved abrasion (crack and scrub) resistance when used in paint formulations.

4. Conclusion

The two Nigerian local clays, Nsu and Ihitte-Uboma clays have been analyzed to be inorganic clays, acidic, and composed mainly of silica (SiO2), and aluminium oxide

Table 7. Particle properties of ihitte-ubomaclay 1 image with a total of 53 particles.

Figure 6. Particle properties of calcined Nsu clay.

(Al2O3) in higher proportions with the other constituents present in small proportions. The oxides were seen to increase with increased calcination temperature which indi- cated improved adsorption property of the clays. The low specific gravities of the clays are indicative that more of the extender pigments can be incorporated in paints without adverse effect on the resultant paint product. The high refractive index of the clays in-

Figure 7. Particle properties of calcined ihitte-uboma clay.

dicates improved gloss property of the clays and hence can be used in gloss paints. The high oil absorption of Nsu and Ihitte-Uboma clays indicates more resin demand without compromising other coating properties. The clays were stable to heat and insoluble in the chemical media studied except for their slight solubility in acetic acid and slight colour change with hydrochloric acid when heated. The optimum calcination temperature of Nsu and Ihitte-Uboma clays was determined to be 850˚C for use in oil-based paints. The clays are indigenously available and easy to process with little loss of material. It is expected that the clays, Nsu and Ihitte-Uboma clays should find utilization in the surface coatings industry as this will reduce the cost and dependence on imported extender pigments and also overcome the disadvantage of paint film degradation caused by titanium dioxide.

Cite this paper
Chukwujike, I. and Igwe, I. (2016) Extender Properties of Some Nigerian Clays. Journal of Minerals and Materials Characterization and Engineering, 4, 279-291. doi: 10.4236/jmmce.2016.45025.
References
[1]   Obaje, S.O., Omada, J.I. and Dambatta, U.A. (2013) Clays and Their Industrial Applications: Synoptic Review. International Journal of Science and Technology, 3, 264-270.

[2]   Paint Quality Institute (PQI, 2010). www.paintquality.com

[3]   Morgans, W.M. (1990) Outlines of Paint Technology. Edward Arnold, London, 43-51.

[4]   McGuffog, R. (1995) The Use and Advantage of Modified Clay in Improving Dispersion in Solvent Based Paints. ECC International Europe, Cornwall.

[5]   Ciullo, P.A. (1996) Industrial Minerals and Their Uses: Westwood. Noyes Publication, Saddle River, 125-136.

[6]   Gerhard, Z. (2007) China Clay in Paints, Coatings and Printing Inks. Chemical Technology, 6, 1-4.

[7]   Tan, O., Yilmaz, L. and Zaimoglu, A.S. (2004) Variation of Some Engineering Properties of Clays with Heat Treatment. Material Letters, 58, 1176-1179. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.matlet.2003.08.030

[8]   Heller-Kallai, L. (2006) Thermally Modified Clay Minerals In: Bergaya, Ed., Handbook of Clay Sciences, 168.

[9]   Steudel, A., Batenburg, L.F., Fischer, H.R., Weidler, P.G. and Emmerich, K. (2009) Alteration of Non-Swelling Clay Minerals and Magadiite by Acid Activation. Applied Clay Science, 44, 95-104.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.clay.2009.02.001

[10]   Wibowo, T.Y., Abdulllah, A.Z. and Zakaria, R. (2011) Effect of Calcination Temperature and Tmaoh on Catalytic Activity of Basic Clay. Journal of Applied Sciences, 11, 3619-3624.
http://dx.doi.org/10.3923/jas.2011.3619.3624

[11]   Ahmed, N.M. (2013) Comparative Study on the Role of Kaolin, Calcined Kaolin and Chemically Treated Kaolin in Alkyd-Based Paint for Protection of Steel. Pigment and Resin Technology, 42, 3-14.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/03699421311288715

[12]   Ewulonu, C.M., Igwe, I.O. and Onyeagoro, G.N. (2016) Synthesis and Characterization of Local Clay-Titanium Dioxide Core-Shell Extender Pigments. Journal of Coatings Technology and Research.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11998-016-9786-4

[13]   Chukwujike, I.C., Nwakpa, S.O. and Odo, J.U. (2015) Studies on the Extender Pigments of Some Selected Local Clays in Nigeria. International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research and Development, 2, 161-166.

[14]   Hare, C. and Beck, R. (2001) Coating System Design. Alberta, Canada Retrieved on 5 April 2015 from buccaneercoatings.com.

[15]   Tiwari, S. and Saxena, M. (1999) Use of Fly Ash in High Performance Industrial Coating. British Corrosion Journal, 34, 184-191. http://dx.doi.org/10.1179/000705999101500824

[16]   Odozi, T.O., Dore, R. and Onu, C.O. (1986) Paint Extenders Based upon Indigenous Clay. Journal of Nigerian Society of Chemical Engineering, 5, 34-40

[17]   Anyiam, C.K. and Igwe, I.O. (2012) Studies on the Use of an Industrial Waste Clay in Alkyd Paint Formulations. International Journal of Academic Research, 4, 306.

[18]   Vanderbilt, R.T. (2013) An Introduction to Mineral Fillers for Paints and Coatings.
www.vanderbiltminerals.com.

[19]   Igwe, I.O. and Ezeamaku, L.U. (2010) The Use of Local Clays in Alkyd Paint Formulation. Malaysian Polymer Journal, 5, 81-94.

[20]   Boxall, J. and von Fraunhofer, J.A. (1986) Concise Paint Technology. Chemical Publishing, New York.

[21]   Raheem, A. and Olowu, O.A. (2013) Production of Household Paint Using Clay Materials. International Journal of Engineering Research and Applications, 3, 85-93.

[22]   Mark, U. (2010) Characterization of Ibere and Oboro Clay Deposits in Abia State, Nigeria for Refractory Applications. International Journal of Natural and Applied Sciences, 6, 296- 305.

[23]   Haruna, M.K., David, O.P. and Timothy, M.C. (2014) Characterization of Mayo-Belwa Clay. Thesis Submitted to the Department of Chemical Engineering, Federal University of Technology, Yola.

 
 
Top