ENG  Vol.8 No.9 , September 2016
Failure Analysis of Ceramic Substrates Used in High Power IGBT Modules
Abstract: High voltage power modules are used in numerous applications to build high power converters. Technically, these modules are made of different materials and among them, dielectric materials are organic and inorganic. Organic insulators (gels) are used to avoid corona discharges in the vicinity of connecting wires and high voltage dies (diodes and transistors) and to protect them from moisture and contaminants. Inorganic insulators (ceramic substrates) are used to insulate the high voltage which dies from the grounded elements and to transfer heat to the heat sink. Despite being used since the late 90s, there is a lack of fundamental knowledge about the electrical properties of these substrates. Consequently, manufacturers tend to assure the reliability by over sizing them. As there are no clear rules for how to do that, failures occur, leading to the converter shutdown. The aim of this study is to bring new information about the understanding of the dielectric strength of ceramic materials used in these modules. We have focused our work on the correlation between the mechanical and the dielectric properties of ceramics by using relevant experiments. We provide new information about the impact of existing cracks on the ceramic dielectric failure, according to the electromechanical breakdown model. Our conclusions bring crucial information about the precautions to be taken during manufacturing and implementation of these substrates in power modules to reduce the likelihood of the particular causes of failure.
Cite this paper: Jouini, Z. , Valdez-Nava, Z. and Malec, D. (2016) Failure Analysis of Ceramic Substrates Used in High Power IGBT Modules. Engineering, 8, 561-571. doi: 10.4236/eng.2016.89052.

[1]   Chasserio, N., Guillemet-Fritsch, S., Lebey, T. and Dagdag, S. (2009) Ceramic Substrates for High-Temperature Electronic Integration. Journal of Electronic Materials, 38, 164-174.

[2]   Diaham, S., Locatelli, M.-L. and Valdez-Nava, Z. (2011) Dielectrics for High Temperature SiC Device Insulation: Review of New Polymeric and Ceramic Materials. In: Mukherjee, M., Ed., Silicon Carbide-Materials, Processing and Applications in Electronics Devices, Chapter 17 in, Intech, 409-430.

[3]   Benmansour, A., Azzopardi, S., Martin, J.-C. and Woirgard, E. (2006) Failure Mechanism of Trench IGBT under Short-Circuit after Turn-Off. Microelectronics and Reliability, 46, 1778-1783.

[4]   Azzopardi, S. (1998) Contribution à la caractérisation et à a modélisation de l’IGBT en vue d’une hybridation destinée à fonctionner à température élevée pour le véhicule électrique. PhD Thesis, Bordeaux 1 University, Bordeaux Cedex.

[5]   Ciappa, M. (2002) Selected Failure Mechanisms of Modern Power Modules. Microelectronics Reliability, 42, 653-667.

[6]   Coquery, G., Lefranc, G., Litcht, T., Lallemand, R., Seliger, N. and Berg, H. (2003) High Temperature Reliability on Automotive Power Modules verified by Power Cycling Tests up to 150°C. Microelectronics reliability, 43, 1871-1876.

[7]   Lefranc, G., Licht, T., Schults, H.J., Beinert, R. and Mitic, G. (2000) Reliability Testing of High Power Multi-Chip IGBT Modules. Microelectronics Reliability, 40, 1659-1663.

[8]   Ramminger, S., Turkes, P. and Wachutka, G. (1998) Crack Mechanism in Wire Bonding Joints. Microelectronics Reliability, 38, 1301-1305.

[9]   Woirgard, E. (1992) Contribution à l’étude d’une intégration hybride adaptée à l’électronique automobile. PhD Thesis, Bordeaux 1 University, Bordeaux Cedex.

[10]   Herr, E., Frey, T., Schlegel, R., Stuck, A., Zehringer, R. and Deleonibus, S. (1997) Substrate-to-Base Solder Joint Reliability in High Power IGBT Modules. Microelectronics and Reliability, 37, 1719-1722.

[11]   Khatir, Z. and Lefebvre, S. (2000) Thermal Analysis of High Power IGBT Modules. Proceedings of the 12th International Symposium on Power Semiconductor Devices and ICs Proceedings, Toulouse, 22-25 May 2000, 271-274.

[12]   Rizzi, M. (2008) Contribution à l’étude de la fiabilité des modules de puissance pour application automobile. PhD Thesis, Bordeaux 1 University, Bordeaux Cedex.

[13]   Fabian, J.H., Hartmann, S. and Hamidi, A. (2005) Analysis of Insulation Failure Modes in High Power IGBT Modules. 40th IAS Annual Meeting Conference Record of the 2005 Industry Applications Conference, Hong Kong, 2-6 October 2005, 799-805.

[14]   Breit, F., Malec, D. and Lebey, T. (2002) Investigations on DC Conductivity and Space Charge in Silicone Gel. 2002 Annual Report Conference on Electrical Insulation and Dielectric Phenomena,USA, 20-24 October 2002, 48-51.

[15]   Lebey, T., Malec, D., Bley, V. and Breit, F. (2003) Contribution to the Dimensioning of The Different Insulating Materials Used in High Voltage Power Electronics Module Manufacturing. The 5th International Conference on Power Electronics and Drive Systems, Singapore,17-20 November 2003, 55-59.

[16]   Malec, D., Dinculescu, S. and Lebey, T. (2000) Aging of Ceramic Materials in Power Electronic Substrates. 2000 Annual Report Conference on Electrical Insulation and Dielectric Phenomena, Victoria, 15-18 October 2000, 604-607.

[17]   Decup, M., Malec, D. and Bley, V. (2009) Impact of a Surface Laser Treatment on the Dielectric Strength of α-Alumina. Journal of Applied Physics, 106, Article ID: 094103.

[18]   Yoshimura, M. and Bowen, H.K. (1981) Electrical Breakdown Strength of Alumina at High Temperatures. Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 64, 404-410.

[19]   Carabajar, S., Olagnon, C., Fantozzi, G. and Le Gressus, C. (1995) Relations between Electrical Breakdown Field and Mechanical Properties of Ceramics. 1995 Annual Report Conference on Electrical Insulation and Dielectric Phenomena, Virginia Beach, 22-25 October 1995, 278-281.

[20]   Fothergill, J.C. (1991) Filamentary Electromechanical Breakdown. IEEE Transactions on Electrical Insulation, 26, 1124-1129.

[21]   Zeller, H.R. and Schneider, W.R. (1984) Electrofracture Mechanics of Dielectric Aging. Journal of Applied Physics, 56, 455-459.

[22]   Malec, D., Bley, V., Talbi, F. and Lalam, F. (2010) Contribution to the Understanding of the Relationship between Mechanical and Dielectric Strengths of Alumina. Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 30, 3117-3123.

[23]   Touzin, M., Goeuriot, D., Fitting, H.J., Guerret-Piécourt, C., Juvé, D. and Tréheux, D. (2007) Relationships between Dielectric Breakdown Resistance and Charge Transport in Alumina Materials—Effects of the Microstructure. Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 27, 1193-1197.

[24]   Dupont, L., Zoubir, K., Lefebvre, S. and Bontemps, S. (2006) Effects of Metallization Thickness of Ceramic Substrates on the Reliability of Power Assemblies under High Temperature Cycling. Microelectronics Reliability, 46, 1766-1771.