CUS  Vol.4 No.2 , June 2016
Insurgent Urbanism, Citizenship and Surveillance in Kampala City: Implications for Urban Policy in Uganda
Abstract: A great deal of work has been done on the nature of rights and the definitions of citizenship. However, little work has been done that explores how people perceive their citizenship rights and how they act on these perceptions especially in growing cities. High and low intensity protests have inscribed their presence and voice in Kampala city’s streets, thereby becoming integral components of the city landscape. The paper uses critical urban theory, insurgent urbanism and citizenship as its conceptual framework to: 1) examine the terrain of struggle and militancy and, how Kampala residents engage with the state beyond formal processes; and, 2) assess government surveillance actions aimed at (de) constructing of citizenship in the city. The paper illuminates these questions and elaborates the notion of insurgent urbanism using Mabira forest demonstrations, September 2009 Buganda riots, and Walk-to-Work’ (W2W) protests in Kampala City. The paper argues that the currents of militancy are very active across the city and the institutionalization and planning for insurgent claims and associated government responses in the broader urban policy terrain across the country.
Cite this paper: Mukwaya, P. (2016) Insurgent Urbanism, Citizenship and Surveillance in Kampala City: Implications for Urban Policy in Uganda. Current Urban Studies, 4, 195-224. doi: 10.4236/cus.2016.42014.

[1]   Acen, C. (2011). Letter from Kampala: Besigye in Hospital after Brutal Police Beating.

[2]   Aine, K. (2016). UCC: We Shut down Social Media to Prevent Terrorism.

[3]   Akaki, T. (2011). Mabira Forest Giveaway: A Path to Degenerative Development. Bloomington, IN: iUniverse Inc.

[4]   Aljazeera (2011). Protests in Sub-Saharan Africa.

[5]   Alvarez, S. E., Dagnino, E., & Escobar, A. (Eds.). (1998). Cultures of Politics/Politics of Cultures: Revisioning Latin American Social Movements. Boulder: West view Press

[6]   Ampurire, P. (2016). Museveni Promises to Scrap “Idle and Disorderly” Law.

[7]   Ansley, F. (2010). Constructing Citizenship without a license: The Struggle of Undocumented Immigrants in the USA for Livelihoods and Recognition. Studies in Social Justice, 4, 165-178.

[8]   Asiimwe, A. (2009). When Buganda Turned Violent. New African, 480, 42.

[9]   Athumani, H. (2011). Activists Threaten to Institute Private Prosecution of IGP.

[10]   Avuni, A. (2011). Living in Kampala Slum: A Socio-Economic Analysis in Ten Informal Settlements of Kampala. Kampala—Uganda, 2011, No. 3. Kampala: John Paul II Justice and Peace Centre.

[11]   Bagala, A. (2012a). Government Pays Irish PR firm Shs. 2bn to Clean Image Dented by Walk to Work. Saturday Monitor.

[12]   Bagala, A. (2012b). Government Now Bans A4C.

[13]   Bagala, A. (2012c). Civil Society Condemns A4C Ban.

[14]   Baker, B. (2015). Unchanging Public Order Policing in Changing Times in East Africa. Journal of Modern African Studies, 53, 365-389.

[15]   Barkan, J. D. (2011). Uganda: Assessing Risks to Stability. Washington DC: Centre for Strategic and International Studies.

[16]   Batanda, J. (2011). 2011: The Year of the Ugandan Protester.

[17]   Bender, J. (2014). These are the countries that have destabilized the most over the past 3 months. (Last accessed 21 January 2016)

[18]   Benyon, J., & Solomos, J. (1988). The Simmering Cities: Urban Unrest during the Thatcher Years. Parliamentary Affairs, 41, 402-422.

[19]   Besigye, K. (2011). 25 Years of Broken Promises.

[20]   Bisiika, A. (2016). The Besigye Menace, lumpen Proletariat and Lumpen Militariat.

[21]   Body-Gendrot, S. (2011). Disorder in World Cities: Comparing Britain and France.

[22]   Bratton, M., & van de Walle, N. (1992). Popular Protest and Political Reform in Africa. Comparative Politics, 24, 419-442.

[23]   Brenner, N. (2009). What Is Critical Urban Theory? City, 13, 198-207.

[24]   Butagira, T. (2012a). Police Commandoes Are Bangi Smoker. Sunday Monitor, January 22, 2012 Pages 1-3. Kampala: Monitor Publications.

[25]   Butagira, T. (2012b). Security Chiefs Split on Crushing Demos.

[26]   Calhoun, C. (1995). Rethinking Critical Theory. C. Calhoun, Critical Social Theory, 1-42.

[27]   Child, K. (2009). Civil society in Uganda: The Struggle to Save the Mabira Forest Reserve. Journal of Eastern African Studies, 3, 240-258.

[28]   Clancy, P. (2014). Freshwater Politics in Canada. University of Toronto Press. Toronto.

[29]   Clarke, J. (2011). Journalists under Siege in Uganda. Mail and Guardian Online.

[30]   Conroy-Krutz, J., & Logan, C. (2012). Museveni and the 2011 Ugandan Election: Did the Money Matter? The Journal of Modern African Studies, 50, 625-655.

[31]   Davis, M. (1992). City of Quartz: Excavating the Future in Los Angeles. New York: Vintage Books

[32]   Ddembe, D. (2011). The Lunatics Are in Charge of the Asylum—Uganda.

[33]   Ddungu, M. E. (2011). Besigye’s Tormentor “Hides” in Cop School.

[34]   Dear, M., & Flusty, S. (1998). Postmodern Urbanism. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 88, 50-72.

[35]   East Africa’s Journalists Association (2011). EAJA Cautions against Stringent Broadcast Media Regulation.

[36]   Economist (2009). Kingdom Come.

[37]   Emorut, F., & Magara, D. (2012). Government Warns Walk to Work Protesters.

[38]   European Parliament (2010). Uganda: Journalists under Threat: End Intimidation of Rural Media and Amend Repressive Laws before 2011 Elections.

[39]   Feinstein, G. B. (2011). Social Unrest in Uganda. Gloria Baker Feinstein Blog.

[40]   Freedom House (2012). Countries at Crossroads 2012: Uganda.

[41]   Golooba-Mutebi, F., & Hickey, S. (2013). Investigating the Links between Political Settlements and Inclusive Development in Uganda: Towards a Research Agenda. ESID Working Paper No. 20.

[42]   Goodfellow, T. (2010). The Bastard Child of Nobody? Anti-Planning and the Institutional Crisis in Contemporary Kampala. Crisis States Research Centre Working Paper Series No. 2. London School of Economics.

[43]   Goodfellow, T. (2011). The Institutionalization of “Noise” and “Silence” in Urban Politics: Case Studies from East Africa. Working Paper Number 188. QEH Working Paper Series—QEHWPS188. London: Department of International Development. London School of Economics and Political Science.

[44]   Goodfellow, T. (2014). Legal Maneuvers and Violence: Law Making, Protest and Semi-Authoritarianism in Uganda. Development and Change, 45, 753-776.

[45]   Greste, P. (2009). Royal Riots Expose Uganda Tensions.

[46]   Guweddeko, F. (2013). Radio Free Buganda.

[47]   Gyezaho, E. (2012a). Condemnation Grows over Police Shooting at Journalist.

[48]   Gyezaho, E. (2012b). We’re Back to the Dark Days, Says Tumwine.

[49]   Harvey, D. (2012). Rebel Cities: From the Right to the City to the Urban Revolution. Veso Books.

[50]   Helle, S. E., & Rakner, L. (2014). Grabbing an Election: Abuse of State Resources in the 2011 Elections in Uganda. In T. Soreide and A. Williams (Eds.), Corruption, Grabbing and Development: Real World Challenges (pp. 161-171). Cheltenham and Northampton (MA): Edward Elgar Publishing.

[51]   Helle, S. E., Makara, S., & Skage, I. A. (2011). When Elections Consolidate Power. The Futile Fight of the Ugandan Opposition in the 2011 Elections. CMI Brief, 10.

[52]   Holston, J. (1998). Spaces of Insurgent Citizenship. In L. Sandercock (Ed.), Making the Invisible Visible, A Multicultural Planning History (pp. 37-56). London: University of California Press.

[53]   Honig, P. (2014). Civil Society and Land Use Policy in Uganda: The Mabira Forest Case. Africa Spectrum, 2, 53-77.

[54]   Howard A. M. (2003). Cities in Africa, Past and Present: Contestation, Transformation, Discourse. Canadian Journal of African Studies/Revue Canadienne des études Africaines, 37, 197-235.

[55]   Human Rights Watch (2010). A Media Minefield: Increasing Threats to Freedom of Expression in Uganda. New York. Human Rights Watch.

[56]   Human Rights Watch (2012). Uganda: Country Summary. New York. Human Rights Watch.

[57]   Independent (2010). 2009 Buganda Crisis. Independent Magazine (pp. 1-4). 22 December 2009, Kampala, Uganda.

[58]   Insider (2014). DPP: Arinaitwe Was Right to Brutally Arrest Besigye.

[59]   Insider (2016). EU: Uganda EC Not Transparent, UCC Just Unreasonable.

[60]   International Crisis Group (2012). Uganda: No Resolution to Growing Tensions. Africa Report, No. 187.

[61]   Isin, E. F. (Ed.) (2000). Democracy, Citizenship and the Global City. London: Routledge.

[62]   Izama, A., & Wilkerson, M. (2011). Uganda: Museveni’s Triumph and Weakness. Journal of Democracy, 22, 64-78.

[63]   John Paul II Justice and Peace Centre (2013). The State and Cultural Institutions in Uganda: Buganda and Bunyoro Kingdoms. Kampala: John Paul II Justice and Peace Centre.

[64]   Kabeer, N. (2002). Citizenship, Affiliation and Exclusion: Perspectives from the South. IDS Bulletin, 33, 12-23.

[65]   Kagumire, R. (2011). Both Uganda’s Protesters and Its Government Draw Lessons from Egypt Revolution. Africa Monitor.

[66]   Kakuba, S. J. (2015). Political Violence in Plural Democracies: A Comparative Study of Uganda and KENYA. In S. S. Ercetin (Ed.), Chaos, Complexity and Leadership 2014. Berlin: Springer.

[67]   Kalinge-Nyago, O. (2011a). Why Uganda’s Youth Seek Their Own New Political Direction.

[68]   Kalinge-Nyago, O. (2011b). Uganda Now Looks like Mobutu’s Zaire.

[69]   Kalyegira, T. (2011a). The problem in Uganda Is the Economy, Silly. Kampala Dispatch.

[70]   Kalyegira, T. (2011b). A Hammer and a Gun—Analysis by Timothy Kalyegira.

[71]   Kampala Dispatch (2011). Inspector General of Police accuses Activists for Change of Training Terrorists. Kampala Dispatch: Uganda’s News Monthly.

[72]   Kashambuzi, E. (2015). Uganda: Gen. Museveni’s and NRM’s 30 Years of Failure and Why Opposition Must Boycott the Vote.

[73]   Kato, J. (2016). Besigye Tormentor Gilbert Arinaitwe Redeployed.

[74]   Khisa, M. (2016a). Museveni Is an Illegitimate President-Elect.

[75]   Khisa, M. (2016b). Thinking about Post-Museveni Uganda.

[76]   Khisa, M. (2016c). Our Arrogant Rulers Need Salvation.

[77]   Kibanja, G. M., Kajumba, M. M., & Johnson, L. R. (2012). Ethno-Cultural Conflict in Uganda: Politics Based on Ethnic Divisions Inflame Tensions across the Country. In D. Landis, & R. D. Albert (Eds.), Handbook of Ethnic Conflict: International Perspectives (pp. 403-435). Berlin: Springer Sciences and Business Media.

[78]   Kigambo, G. (2011). Kiboko Squad Investigation Reveals too Little.

[79]   Kitaka Kaaya, S. (2012). A4C Activists Rally Ankole to Overthrow Museveni This Year. The Observer Newspaper.

[80]   Kizito, A. (2015). The Post-Independence Conflicts in Uganda: A Manifestation of the Classical Imperialistic Divide and Rule Policy of the British Colonial Administration in Uganda. Developing Country Studies, 5, 56-75.

[81]   Kizza, J. (2016). Social Media, Polls: Government Assures Public on Security.

[82]   Kjaer, A. M., & Katusiimeh, M. (2012). Growing but Not Transforming: Fragmented Ruling Coalitions and Economic Developments in Uganda. DIIS Working Paper 2012:07. Copenhagen: Danish Institute for International Studies.

[83]   Knudsen, A.-M. S. (2007). The Right to the City: Spaces of Insurgent Citizenship among Pavement Dwellers in Mumbai, India. UCL Development Planning Unit Working paper No. 132.

[84]   Kock, de. P. (2011). Buckshot and Police Batons in Kampala. In: Institute for Security Studies (2011). The Price of Protest. Issue 13, 2011. Pretoria/Tshwane.

[85]   Lamarca, M. G. (2010). Institutionalizing Insurgent Claims. Towards “Good” Planning? Journal of Landscape Studies, 3, 77-86.

[86]   Lefebvre, H. (1991). The Production of Space. (D. Nicholson-Smith, Trans.). Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.

[87]   Lehman-Wilzig, S., & Ungar, M. (1985). The Economic and Political Determinants of Public Protest Frequency and Magnitude: The Israeli Experience. International Review of Modern Sociology, 15, 63-80.

[88]   Lindemann, S. (2010). Exclusionary Elite Bargains and Civil War Onset: The Case of Uganda. Crisis States Working Paper (Series 2), 76.

[89]   Lister, R. (1997). Citizenship: Feminist Perspectives. New York: New York University Press.

[90]   Lofland, L. H. (2000). Urbanity, Tolerance and Public Space: The Creation of Cosmopolitans. In L.
Deben, W. Heinemeijer, & D. van der Vaart (Eds.), Understanding Amsterdam: Essays on Economic Vitality, City Life and Urban Form (pp. 143- 160). Amsterdam, the Netherlands: Het Spinhuis.

[91]   Lubwama, S. (2012). Mengo Demands Apology from Government over Buganda Riots.

[92]   Lubwama, S. (2016). Sejusa Warns NRM on Coups, Uprisings.

[93]   Mabala, R. (2015). Public Order Management Act: Bad Law or Poor Enforcement?

[94]   Makara, S. (2010), Deepening Democracy through Multipartyism: The Bumpy Road to Uganda’s 2011 Elections. Africa Spectrum, 45, 81-94.

[95]   Mamdani, M. (2011). Walk to Work in a Historical Light.

[96]   Mamdani, M. (2012). What Walk to Work Needs to Succeed.

[97]   Marcuse, P. (2005). The “Threat of Terrorism” and the Right to the City. Fordham Urban Law Journal.

[98]   Masiga, F. (2012). Are Demonstrations the Only Language Left t to Ugandans? Sunday Monitor, 8 January 2012, Page 14. Kampala: Monitor Publications.

[99]   Mbazira, C. (2013). Service Delivery Protests, Struggle for Rights and the Failure of Democracy in South Africa and Uganda: Parallels and Divergences. SAJHR 29: 251-275

[100]   Miraftab, F., & Wills, S. (2005). Insurgency and Spaces of Active Citizenship: The Story of Western Cape Anti-Eviction Campaign in South Africa. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 25, 200-217.

[101]   Mitchell, D. (2003). The Right to the City: Social Justice and the Fight for Public Space. New York: The Guilford Press.

[102]   Mivule, K. (2009). The Buganda Crisis, Technology, and Failure of Uganda’s News Media.

[103]   MRT (2009) Refugee Review Tribunal Australia.

[104]   Mugabe, F. (2016). How Government Has Controlled Communication during Polls.

[105]   Mugagga, C. (2012). Why Is the NRM Government Not Paying What Is Due in Rents to Buganda?

[106]   Mugerwa, Y., & Naturinda, S. (2011). Price Protesters Are Terrorists, Says Government.

[107]   Mugisha, A. (2011a). Walk to Work—Day One.

[108]   Mugisha, A. (2011b). Crackdown on Ugandan Activists When Walking to Work Became a Crime of Treason.

[109]   Mugisha, A. (2011c). On Monday We Walk.

[110]   Mukama, E. (2016). Free Kizza Besigye!—Ghetto President Bobi Wine.

[111]   Mulumba, B. D. (2011). Uganda on the Eve of 50: The Legitimacy Challenge. Aid, Autocrats, Plunder and an Independence—Era Jinx. Africa Institute of South Africa. Briefing No. 50.

[112]   Muniini, M. (2016). Munini Mulera’s Letter on NRM 30 Years in Power.

[113]   Murumba, G. (2011). Time Magazine Worried about Museveni’s Sanity.

[114]   Musaala, A. (2016). Fr. Musaala to Besigye: Did I Visit the Next PRESIDENT of Uganda?

[115]   Museveni, Y. (2007). Why I Support Mabira Forest Giveaway to Mehta Group.

[116]   Museveni, Y. (2011). Factors behind NRM’s Victory. New Vision Newspaper.

[117]   Mutaizibwa, E. (2012). Inspired by Arab Spring, A4C Ruffled Government Feathers. The Observer

[118]   Mwenda, A. (2012). Media Seduced by Museveni’s Mabira Decoy.

[119]   Nampewo, C. (2013). Saving Mabira Rainforest: Using Public Interest Litigation in Uganda to Save Mabira and Other Rainforests, 40 B.C. Envtl. Aff. L. Rev. 523.

[120]   Naturinda, S. (2011). NRM Moves to Scrap Constitutional Bail.

[121]   Ndushabandi, C. (2016). Museveni Endorses Besigye Arrest; Threatens Tighter Social Media Controls.

[122]   Nemeth, J. (2009). The Closed City: Downtown Security Zones and the Loss of Public Space.

[123]   Nemeth, J. (2010). Security in Public Space: An Empirical Assessment of three US Cities. Environment and Planning A, 42, 2487-2507.

[124]   Njoroge, J. (2012). Museveni Says He Will Crush Lawless Civilians.

[125]   Nyanzi, S. (2016). I Will Give Kayihura My Sumbusa If….

[126]   Observer (2016). Rethink election crime preventer.

[127]   Odoobo-Bichachi, C. (2012a). Political Jesters Telling Museveni What Others Can’t? The Observer Newspaper.

[128]   Odoobo-Bichachi, C. (2012b). A4C Should Stay off Museveni’s Bloody Path.

[129]   Odoobo-Bichachi, C. (2012c). Public Order Should Reflect All Interests.

[130]   Okeowo, A. (2011). Uganda Burning. The New Yorker.

[131]   Oloka Onyango, J. (2014). Laws on Public Order, Gays and “Miniskirts” Are Birds of a Feather.

[132]   Omach, P. (2010). Political Violence in Uganda: The Role of Vigilantes and Militias. Journal of Social, Political and Economic Studies, 35, 429-449.

[133]   Ostby, G. (2010). In-Migration, Inequality and Urban Violence: City Level Evidence from African and Asian Household Surveys. The Climate Change and Security Conference, Trondheim, 21-24 June 2010, 1-12.

[134]   Otim, D. (2011). Mama Mabira’ Vows to Take Museveni Head on.

[135]   Red Pepper (2012). Opposition, Government See-Saw Accusations over Ariongo Murder.

[136]   Red Pepper (2016). Notorious Gilbert Arinaitwe Who Smashed Besigye’s Car Back in Action.

[137]   Republic of Uganda (2013). The Public Order Management Act, 2013.

[138]   Rubongoya, J. B. (2007). Regime hegemony in Museveni’s Uganda: Pax Musevenica. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

[139]   Sassen, S. (2001). Global City: New York, London, Tokyo. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

[140]   Sassen, S. (2010). When the City Itself Becomes a Technology of War. Theory, Culture & Society 2010 (SAGE, Los Angeles, London, New Delhi, and Singapore), 27, 33-50.

[141]   Sassen, S. (2011). Why Riot Now? Newsweek Magazine.

[142]   Semuwemba, A. K. (2009). Bimeeza Should Never Have Been Banned in Uganda. Abbey Kibirige Semuwemba Blog.

[143]   Serunkuma, Y. (2016). Besigye’s Voters Must Be Missing the 1980s Museveni.

[144]   Soja, E. (1996). Thirdspace: Journeys to Los Angeles and Other Real-and-Imagined Places. Oxford: Blackwell

[145]   Ssekira, E. (2016). Report Details Link between Crime Preventers and NRM.

[146]   Ssempala, R. (2016). State Attacks on Media Must Stop.

[147]   Ssemuju, N. I. (2012). Musisi Wants to Be ED and Lord Mayor?

[148]   Ssenyonga, A., & Lule, J. (2012). Besigye, A4C Officials at Kololo for Rally. New Vision.

[149]   Sunrise (2015). Police Brutality; History of Impunity Erodes Public Trust.

[150]   Suransky, C., Klooster, H. V., & Seela, U. (2009). Uganda Riots Revisited: A Conversation with Emily Drani and John de Coninck. Pluralism Working Paper No. 4. Kosmopolis Institute, Utrecht, and Hivos, The Hague The Netherlands

[151]   Tabachnik, S. (2011). Bills, Bribery and Brutality: How Rampant Corruption in the Electoral System Has Helped Prevent Democracy in Uganda. Independent Study Project (ISP) Collection. Paper 1204.

[152]   Taw, J. M., & Hoffman, B. (1995). The Urbanization of Insurgency: The Potential Challenge to US Army Operations. Santa Monica: RAND.

[153]   Thompson, G. (1992). Colonialism in Crisis: The Uganda Disturbances of 1945. African Affairs, 91, 605-624.

[154]   Titeca, K., & Onyango, P. (2012) The Carrot and the Stick: The Unlevel Playing Field in Uganda’s 2011 Elections. In: F. Reyntjens, S. Vandeginste, & M. Verpoorten (Eds.), L’Afrique des Grands Lacs. Annuaire 2011-2012 (pp. 111-130). Paris: L’Harmattan.

[155]   Tugume, G. (2016). Hope Mwesigye: Crime Preventers Operating like Interahamwe.

[156]   Tumushabe, A. & Rumanzi, P. (2016). Museveni Defends NRM Victory, Dismisses Rigging Allegations.

[157]   Tumwine, A., & Kato, J. (2016). Army, Police Search Vehicles to and Kampala.

[158]   Twinoburyo, S. (2011a). Deconstructing Museveni’s Nairobi Interview.

[159]   Twinoburyo, S. (2011b). All Those Who Care for Uganda Should Adopt a Regime-Change Policy.

[160]   Vasher, N. (2011). Museveni’s Centralization of Power: The Political Economy of Development in Uganda. Electronic Theses and Dissertations. Paper 671. Denver, CO: University of Denver.

[161]   Walukuka, J. D. (2015). Uganda Journalists Union Condemns Andrew Lwanga’s Assault by Police.

[162]   Walusimbi, R. (2016). Relationship between Police, Media Should Be Professional.

[163]   WaMucoori, P. M. (2010). Kayihura, Kiboko Squad and the Sugar Thief.

[164]   Warigia, B., & Camp, L. J. (2013). Protecting the Internet from Dictators: Technical and Policy Solutions to Ensure Online Freedoms. The Innovation Journal: The Public Sector Innovation Journal, 18.

[165]   Wasswa, S. (2015). Leave Gilbert Bwana Alone—Police Warns Media.

[166]   World Bank (2015). The Growth Challenge: Can Ugandan Cities Get to Work. Uganda Economic Update (5th ed.). Report Number 94622, Washington DC: World Bank.

[167]   Young, I. M. (1990). Justice and the Politics of Difference. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

[168]   Zerah, M.-H., Lama-Rewal, T. S., Dupont, V., & Chaudhuri, B. (2011). Right to the City and Urban Citizenship in the Indian Context. In: UNESCO, Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship (pp. 1- 11). New Delhi: United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization and Centre de Sciences Humaines.