Received 10 March 2016; accepted 14 June 2016; published 17 June 2016
Urbanized and industrialized areas are known to be subjected to high concentrations of air pollutants  . Atmospheric pollution is the main result of different components such as heavy metals, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), particulate matter (PM0.1, PM2.5 and PM10) and organic components, which can originate from various sources.
The main sources in the urban environment are road traffic and industrial activity  . Air pollution is a serious threat to human health  such as cardiovascular effects and respiratory tract problems  .
Current physico-chemical techniques for the determination and monitoring of air quality are expensive for developing cities  like Abidjan, Côte d’Ivoire, where air quality strategies are ineffective  . Alternatively, methods based on biomonitoring approach are cheap  . The plants can be used as passive bio-monitors in the urban environment to indicate the environmental quality   .
Atmospheric pollutants can induce changes in leaf structure and physiology  . This variation in structural and physiological leaf properties affects leaf reflectance, transmittance and absorptance   .
The use of spectral and remote sensing techniques for detection of plant stress is based on the assumption that stress factors interfere with leaf structural and physiological properties, influencing the spectral leaf characteristics that can be detected in the different regions of the electromagnetic spectrum   .
The objective of this study is the evaluation of leaf reflectance parameters in the visible spectrum as an indicator for assessing urban environment quality and the investigation of species leaf susceptibility to air pollution from one season to another.
2. Material and Methods
2.1. Study Area and Experimental Set-Up
The city of Abidjan (5˚00'N - 5˚30'N, 3˚50'W - 4˚10'W), Côte d’Ivoire, with distinct land use classes and spatially varying habitat quality  , was chosen as the study area. The study area has a tropical climate with a major rainy season (May-July), a minor rainy season (September-November), and two dry seasons in between.
Abidjan is characterized by a high level of industrialization and urbanization. The city has a significant growing old automobile park, of which 70% are secondhand vehicles. Many parks and green spaces were preserved in the city, but these parks disappear quickly due to urbanization. Actually, Abidjan is one of the most polluted cities of sub-Saharan Africa.
Samples were collected in areas with contrasting environment quality. We sampled in industrial zones (2 sites) and in parks (2 sites) which were relatively far away from traffic and industrial activity. Sampling locations were determined based on the availability of plant species tested.
2.2. Study Species
We have chosen Ficus benjamina L. as a study species because of its homogeneous spatial distribution in the city. F. benjamina is a tropical dicotyledonous belonged to the family Moraceae. It is an evergreen tree with several spreading branches from the base, with oval and glossy leaves of 2 - 5 cm wide. This tree species is hypostomatous (i.e., it only have stomata on the abaxial leaf surface) with dorsiventral structure (i.e., the adaxial surface is adjacent to the palisade parenchyma layer, while the abaxial surface is adjacent to the spongy mesophyll layer). Moreover, the leaves of F. benjamina have abaxial wax and smooth cuticle.
2.3. Sampling and Leaf Reflectance Measurements
Two sampling locations were selected at each site according to accessibility and geographical distribution criteria. At each sampling location 2 trees were selected. We sampled 9 mature and undamaged leaves from each tree at a height between 1.5 m and 2.5 m above ground level. Sampling campaign was conducted during six month on the same trees species. A first sampling campaign was conducted from February until April 2012 for major dry season. The mean air temperature during this period was 28.3˚C, air humidity was 83%, precipitation was 43.18 mm and mean wind speed was 11.7 m∙s−1. A second campaign was organized from May until July 2012 for major rainy season. The mean air temperature during this period was 26˚C, while air humidity was 89.2%. Precipitation and mean wind speed were respectively 375.91 mm and 12 m∙s−1. Overall, we sampled 432 leaves.
The field level leaf reflectance measurements were performed under standard illumination conditions using a field illumination set up as described by Khavanin Zadeh et al.  . A Canon EOS 550D, RGB reflex camera equipped with a zoom lens (EF-S 18 - 55 mm f/3.5-5.6 IS) was used and mounted on the field illumination setup. The inner side of the setup is coated with non-reflecting black paint, intended to avoid indirect illumination (stray light) of the target as much as possible, thus avoiding multiple scattering conditions as much as possible. The camera is locked on top of the leaf reflectance measurement setup with a camera mounting cylinder. The setup allows keeping the distance between the camera objective and the target leaf surface constant throughout all measurements. In setup, the illumination of a leaf is performed with two warm-white LED light sources (Ostar, 2005) which, during field campaigns, can be fed with the electric power of a fully charged battery. The maximum peak wavelength for the red, green and blue of LEDs is 645, 550 and 490 nm, respectively. In the device, a removable grid made of transparent thin nylon wire, is used to flatten as well as fix a leaf at the bottom of the setup. Immediately after sampling of the leaves from the sample trees, imagery was acquired from both the adaxial and abaxial sides of a sampled leaf. The measurement time for tree leaf harvesting and the imaging of both leaf sides, takes less than 5 minutes. We converted leaf imagery after transfer to a computer platform, into R (Red), G (Green) and B (Blue) 1-byte grey images. Leaf reflectance has been computed for both the upper (adaxial) and lower (abaxial) leaf surfaces. By superimposing a polygon on the leaf surface, a leaf mask is obtained. We define this polygon as the leaf region of interest (ROI) for reflectance determinations by using ENVI 4.4 (Research Systems, Boulder, Colorado, USA). Leaf reflectance (in percentage) is computed for the R, G, and B spectral bands using the leaf R, G and B digital numbers () and the white reference target panel digital number () according to Equation (1)  .
and are, respectively, leaf and white reference target reflectance for band λ (nm), with λ indicating the R, G or B spectral band. and are leaf ROI digital number and white reference target (range: 0 - 255), respectively.
Leaf reflectance variation can indicate environmental stress difference between land use classes studied.
2.4. Dorsiventral Leaf Reflectance Correlation (DLRC) and Normalized Dorsiventral Asymmetry Index (NDAI)
DLRC expresses the relationship between the adaxial and abaxial leaf reflectance which is characterized by the slope and the coefficient of determination obtained from the linear regression analysis between abaxial and adaxial leaf reflectance.
Dorsiventral leaf reflectance asymmetry can be quantitatively defined with NDAI, which is defined as a linear combination of the leaf reflectances at both the adaxial and abaxial leaf sides   as defined in Equation (2):
and indicate abaxial (ab) and adaxial (ad) leaf reflectance for the same spectral band, respectively.
NDAI as well as DLRC can be affected both by changes in leaf structural as well as physiological characteristics caused by environment quality.
2.5. Species Leaf Susceptibility to Air Pollution from Season to Season
Species leaf susceptibility to air pollution from season to season was determined by NDAI variation from major dry season (February-April) to major rainy season (May-July) in industrial zones and parks in different visible spectral bands.
2.6. Statistical Analysis
All data were analyzed using Statistica software, version 7.1 (StatSoft Inc., 1984-2005). The normality of the data was tested with a Shapiro-Wilk test. Descriptive statistics, including mean and standard deviation were calculated for leaf reflectance parameters. Means were compared by using a one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) procedure and a Tukey-HSD test. Linear regression analysis was performed to identify the relationship between adaxial and abaxial leaf reflectance. Species leaf susceptibility to air pollution from season to season was assessed using the Student-t-test. Differences were considered significant at p < 0.05.
3. Results and Discussion
3.1. Leaf Reflectance
F. benjamina leaf reflectance values for both leaf sides are higher in Parks (P) in comparison with industrial zones (IZ) for all spectral bands according to Table 1. This tendency is confirmed by the observations of Kha- vanin Zadeh et al.  for Carpinus betulus L. in two contrasting urban environments (suburban green and Indus- trial habitats) in the city of Gent, Belgium. It might be related to structural responses of the leaves to air pollu- tion in IZ. Indeed, Dineva  reported in the industrial district Kremikovtzi, Bulgaria, a decreasing of Acer platanoides L. leaf thickness. Carter  demonstrated a correlation between leaf reflectance and leaf thickness for the wavelength range between 400 and 700 nm. We observed a statistically significant difference (Tukey- HSD test: p = 0.035) in leaf reflectance among IZ and P. This difference was pronounced at adaxial side in the blue band as shown in Table 1. An explanation for this one might be the higher exposure of adaxial leaf surfaces (see Figure 1) to urban air pollution  that can lead to epidermal erosion of adaxial leaf side  , consequently
Table 1. Mean (± standard deviation) of leaf reflectance (%) in industrial zones and parks in the spectral bands studied. Mean values on each column in the same spectral band followed by different letters are significantly different (p < 0.05).
Figure 1. Leaf morphology for Ficus benjamina L.
decreasing leaf thickness. Arriaga et al.  used epidermal characters as bioindicators of environmental pollution and stated that width of upper epidermal cells of F. benjamina were higher in periurban area and lower in urban area in the metropolitan area of Buenos Aires, Argentina. On the other hand, several authors  -  report that leaf reflectance for the blue band is affected by leaf internal structure, and less so by chlorophyll content  . On the other hand it could be that also the waxy leaf surface properties of F. benjamina  affect abaxial leaf reflectance which might lead to an increase in specular and a decrease diffuse leaf reflectance  resulting in lower differences in abaxial leaf reflectance between P and IZ (see Table 1). Khavanin Zadeh et al.  came to a similar conclusion for the adaxial leaf side for non-hairy Tilia sp. (non-hairy referred to the absence of trichomes on the leaf surface) in polluted compared to less polluted urban environment.
3.2. Normalized Dorsiventral Asymmetry Index (NDAI)
Table 2 shows that NDAI is higher in industrial zones (IZ) compared to parks (P) for all spectral bands. These values are statistically significant between land use classes for the blue and red bands (Tukey-HSD test: p < 0.05).
For F. benjamina, NDAI showed a different behavior than leaf reflectance in land use classes. It significantly decreased in P and increased in IZ for the red and blue bands. Khavanin Zadeh et al.  observed NDAI significantly increased in green area compared to industrial area for hairy Tilia sp. (hairy referred to the presence of trichomes on the leaf surface), while the reverse was observed for C. betulus (with a ridged leaf surface) by Khavanin Zadeh et al.  for the same study area. These authors related the different results for the NDAI index to different morphological and physiological response of the leaves against air pollution in an urban area. They observed that specific leaf area (SLA, area of leaf divided by its dry mass) significantly increased (considering that normally higher SLA indicates lower leaf thickness) in C. betulus because of air pollution, while it does not change for hairy Tilia sp. Inversely, they observed that relative chlorophyll content significantly decreased in polluted area for hairy Tilia sp. while it does not change for C. betulus. The authors concluded that NDAI seems to be species-dependent. Taylor et al.  reported that Tilia sp. are relative sensitive to air pollution, while C. betulusis identified as a relative insensitive species. This trend for C. betulus seems to be similar for F. benjamina. Indeed, according to Tra Bi et al.  , F. benjamina was categorized as intermediate tolerant species to air pollution. The identification and categorization of plants into sensitive and tolerant groups indicates that they differently react to air pollution  . Considering results of abovementioned studies, we can suggest that NDAI seems to be more sensitive to leaf structural changes than to biochemical changes for F. benjamina induced by air pollutants.
3.3. Dorsiventral Leaf Reflectance Correlation (DLRC)
The linear regression between abaxial and adaxial leaf reflectance show strong and higher correlation (R2 ˃ 0.50, p < 0.05) in industrial zones (IZ) compared to parks (P) for all spectral bands, while the slopes of the linear relation are lower in P than IZ except for green band (Figure 2).
As illustrated in Figure 2, DRLC representing R squared and the slope of the linear relation was significantly highest in IZ land use class. This result is in agreement with the findings of Khavanin Zadeh et al.  . These
Table 2. Mean (±standard deviation) of Normalized Difference Asymmetry Index (NDAI) in industrial zones and parks in the spectral bands studied. Mean values followed by different letters are significantly different (p < 0.05) between industrial zones and parks in the same spectral band.
Figure 2. Dorsiventral Leaf Reflectance Correlation (DLRC) in industrial zones (IZ) and parks (P) for the spectral bands studied. Error bars represent standard errors on the individual points.
authors recorded that DRLC shows a more stable variation than NDAI in polluted sites for the species considered, and that it seems to be species-independent. DLRC increasing in blue and red bands in IZ might be a direct reflection of environmental pollution impact on the abaxial versus the adaxial leaf reflectances  .
According to Dineva  and Brakke et al.  , dorsiventral leaf properties in many leaves is an important characteristic in photosynthesis and gas exchange, and can be affected by air pollution. Indeed, gaseous pollutants mostly enter through the stomata  , which for F. benjamina are located on the abaxial side  . Therefore, it seems that spongy parenchyma is more sensitive to gas exchange than palisade parenchyma, and consequently it is more susceptible to damage from gaseous pollutants  . This susceptibility is confirmed by an increasing abaxial reflectance leading to an increased DLRC, which might be explained by a decreasing chlorophyll content and anatomical changes in the spongy parenchyma such as decreased intercellular spaces and a thinner layer of spongy parenchyma  -  . For instance, Johnson et al.  reported that under adaxial illumination, palisade mesophyll acts to propagate light into the spongy mesophyll and that light propagation is inhibited when illuminated from the leaf side opposite the palisade layer (under abaxial illumination). Thereby a decreasing in intercellular spaces and a thinner layer of spongy parenchyma leads to a reduction in the light path length through this layer, causing the abaxial leaf reflectance to become more affected by the palisade than the spongy parenchyma layer  , consequently increasing abaxial reflectance. Moreover, Carter and Knapp  demonstrated that a lower leaf chlorophyll content leads to a higher leaf reflectance, and thus an increase of DLRC.
3.4. Species Leaf Susceptibility to Air Pollution from Season to Season
Species leaf susceptibility to air pollution from season to season was determined by NDAI seasonal variation. The results show that NDAI values are higher for major rainy season (MRS) compared to major dry season (MDS) in parks (Figure 3(a)) and industrial zones (Figure 3(b)) for all spectral band. The difference were more pronounced in parks in the red band (Student-t-test: t0.05 = −8.537, p = 0.001) (Figure 3(a)).
Figure 3. Seasonal variation on the air quality determined through Normalized Dorsiventral Asymmetry Index (NDAI) values in parks (a) and industrial zones (b) in the spectral bands studied. MDS: Major dry season, MRS: major rainy season, *: Significant difference, p < 0.01. Error bars are standard deviation.
NDAI seasonal showed same trends from one land use class to another, higher in the MRS and lower in the MDS, but significantly in parks as observed in (Figure 3(a)). These observations might be probably due to leaf surface characteristic and habit. Urbat et al.  demonstrated that rainfall cannot remove all deposited PM, as particles can be permanently trapped in the surface wax layer during wax development. This process might be important for F. benjamina. Moreover, this species is an evergreen species, keeping its leaves during several years, resulting in a longer time increase in leaf SIRM, as was observed by Lehndorff et al.  for Pinus nigra. This might increase changes in leaf structure from one season to another.
Leaf reflectance as well as NDAI and DLRC in the visible spectral bands can be good indicators to estimate differences in urban environment quality. Results revealed effects of air pollution on anatomical and physiological leaf characteristics in IZ in comparison with P. NDAI significant increasing during the major rainy season probably indicated that F. benjamina leaf structure changes were increased from one season to another, and was probably related to species. These results make it possible to consider an operational approach for assessing and monitoring of urban environment quality based on biomonitoring technique and an active remote sensing. However, the suitability of these results still requests some further research such as anatomical studies in tropical area.
The second author is a beneficiary of a mobility grant from the Belgian Federal Science Policy Office (BELSPO) co-funded by the Marie Curie Actions from the European Commission. This work was support by grants of Foundation David and Alice Van Buuren (Université Libre de Bruxelles) for digital camera purchase as well as University of Antwerp (Prof. Roeland Samson) and “Vlaamse Interuniversitaire Raad” for the reflectance mea- surement setup making and Ivorian institution “Programme d’ Appui Stratégique à la Recherche Scientifique” (PASRES) to the third author. We also thank the city council of “District Autonomed’ Abidjan” for their as- sistance in achieving field data.
 Kardel, F., Wuyts, K., Maher, B.A., Hansard, R. and Samson, R. (2011) Leaf Saturation Isothermal Remanent Magnetization (SIRM) as a Proxy for Particulate Matter Monitoring: Inter-Species Differences and In-Season Variation. Atmospheric Environment, 45, 5164-5171.
 Petroff, A., Mailliat, A., Amielh, M. and Anselmet, F. (2008) Aerosol Dry Deposition on Vegetative Canopies. Part I: Review of Present Knowledge. Atmospheric Environment, 42, 3625-3653.
 Moreno, E., Sagnotti, L., Dinarès-Turell, J., Winkler, A. and Cascella, A. (2003) Biomonitoring of Traffic Air Pollution in Rome Using Magnetic Properties of Tree Leaves. Atmospheric Environment, 37, 2967-2977.
 Gombert, S., Asta, J. and Seaward, M.R.D. (2006) Lichens and Tobacco Plants as Complementary Biomonitors of Air Pollution in the Grenoble Area (Isere, Southeast France). Ecological Indicators, 6, 429-443.
 Barima, Y.S.S., Angaman, D.M., N’Gouran, K.P., Koffi, N.A., Kardel, F., De Cannière, C. and Samson, R. (2014) Assessing Atmospheric Particulate Matter Distribution Based on Saturation Isothermal Remanent Magnetization of Herbaceous and Tree Leaves in a Tropical Urban Environment. Science of the Total Environment, 470-471, 975-982.
 Balasooriya, B.L.W.K., Samson, R., Mbikwa, F., Vitharana, W.A.U., Boeckx, P. and Van Meirvenne, M. (2009) Bio-Monitoring of Urban Habitat Quality by Anatomical and Chemical Leaf Characteristics. Environmental and Experimental Botany, 65, 386-394.
 Beckett, K.P., Freer, P.H. and Taylor, G. (1998) Urban Woodlands: Their Role in Reducing the Effects of Particulate Pollution. Environmental Pollution, 99, 347-360.
 Cox, R.M. (2003) The Use of Passive Sampling to Monitor Forest Exposure to O3, NO2 and SO2: A Review and Some Case Studies. Environmental Pollution, 126, 30-311.
 Neinhuis, C. and Barthlott, W. (1998) Seasonal Changes of Leaf Surface Contamination in Beech, Oak, and Ginkgo in Relation to Leaf Micro Morphology and Wettability. New Phytologist, 138, 91-98.
 Efi, L., Drilias, P., George, K. and Manetas, P. (2005) Nondestructive Assessment of Leaf Chemistry and Physiology Through Spectral Reflectance Measurements May Be Misleading When Changes in Trichome Density Co-Occur. New Phytologist, 165, 463-472.
 Khavanin Zadeh, A.R., Veroustraete, F., Wuyts, K., Kardel, F. and Samson, R. (2012) Dorsi-Ventral Leaf Reflectance Properties of Carpinus betulus L.: An Indicator of Urban Habitat Quality. Environmental Pollution, 162, 332-337.
 Khavanin Zadeh, A.R., Veroustraete, F., Buytaert, J.A.N., Dirckx, J. and Samson, R. (2013) Assessing Urban Habitat Quality Using Spectral Characteristics of Tilia Leaves. Environmental Pollution, 178, 7-14.
 Wang, H., Shi, H., Li, Y., Yu, Y. and Zhang, J. (2013) Seasonal Variations in Leaf Capturing of Particulate Matter, Surface Wettability and Micromorphology in Urban Tree Species. Frontiers of Environmental Science and Engineering, 7, 579-588.
 Barnes, J.D., Davison, A.W. and Booth, T.A. (1988) Ozone Accelerates Structural Degradation of Epicuticular Wax on Norway Spruce Needles. New Phytologist, 110, 309-318.
 Gitelson, A.A. and Merzlyak, M.N. (1998) Remote Sensing of Chlorophyll Concentration in Higher Plant Leaves. Advances in Space Research, 22, 689-692.
 Sims, D.A. and Gamon, J.A. (2002) Relationships between Leaf Pigment Content and Spectral Reflectance across a Wide Range of Species, Leaf Structures and Developmental Stages. Remote Sensing of Environment, 81, 337-354.
 Campbell, P.K.E., Middleton, E.M., McMurtrey, J.E., Corp, L.A. and Chappelle, E.W. (2007) Assessment of Vegetation Stress Using Reflectance or Fluorescence Measurements. Journal of Environmental Quality, 36, 832-845.
 Klimko, M. and Truchan, M. (2006) Morphological Variability of the Leaf Epidermis in Selected Taxa of the Genus Ficus L. (Moraceae) and Its Taxonomic Implications. Acta Societatis Botanicorum Poloniae, 75, 309-324.
 Holmes, M.G. and Keiller, D.R. (2002) Effects of Pubescence and Waxes on the Reflectance of Leaves in the Ultraviolet and Photosynthetic Wavebands: A Comparison of a Range of Species. Plant, Cell and Environment, 25, 85-93.
 Taylor, O.C., Tompson, C.R., Tingey, D.T. and Reinert, R.A. (1975) Oxides of Nitrogen. In: Mudd, J.B. and Kozlowsi, A., Eds., Responses of Plants to Air Pollution, Academic Press, University of California, 121-139.
 Tra Bi, Z.F., Angaman, D.M., Barima, Y.S.S. and Dongui, B.K. (2015) Evaluation of Air Pollution Tolerance Indices of Four Ornamental Plants Arranged along Roadsides in Abidjan (Côte d’Ivoire). International Journal of Environmental Monitoring and Analysis, 3, 22-27.
 Brakke, T.W., Wergin, W.P., Erbe, E.E. and Harnden, J.M. (1993) Seasonal Variation in the Structure and Red Reflectance of Leaves from Yellow Poplar, Red Oak, and Red Maple. Remote Sensing of Environment, 43, 115-130.
 Neubert, A., Kley, D., Wildt, J., Segschneider, H.J. and Forstel, H. (1993) Uptake of NO, NO2 and O3 by Sunflower (Helianthus annus L.) and Tobacco Plants (Nicotiana tabacum L.): Dependence on Stomatal Conductivity. Atmospheric Environment, 27, 2137-2145.
 Koffi, N.A., Barima, Y.S.S., Angaman, D.M. and Dongui, B.K. (2014) Les Caractéristiques des Stomates des Feuilles de Ficus benjamina L. Comme Bioindicateurs Potentiels de la Qualité de l’Air Dans la Ville d’Abidjan (Côte d’Ivoire). Journal of Applied Biosciences, 78, 6675-6684.
 Carreras, H.A., Canas, M.S. and Pignata, M.L. (1996) Differences in Responses to Urban Air Pollutants by Ligustrum lucidum Ait and Ligustrum lucidum Ait f. Tricolor (Rehd.) Rehd. Environmental Pollution, 93, 211-218.
 Pignata, M.L., Gudino, G.L., Caneas, M.S. and Orellana, L. (1999) Relationship between Foliar Chemical Parameters Measured in Melia azedarach L. and Environmental Conditions in Urban Areas. Science of the Total Environment, 244, 85-96.
 Evans, L., Kirstene, A. and Jennings, N. (1996) Relationship between Anatomical Characteristics and Ozone Sensitivity of Leaves of Several Herbaceous Dicotyledonous Plant Species at Great Smoky Mountains National Park. Environmental and Experimental Botany, 36, 413-420.
 Gratani, L., Crescente, M.F. and Petruzzi, C. (2000) Relationship between Leaf Life-Span and Photosynthetic Activity of Quercus ilex Polluted Urban Areas (Rome). Environmental Pollution, 110, 19-28.
 Gravano, E., Giulietti, V., Desotgiu, R., Bussotti, F., Grossoni, P., Gerosa, G. and Tani, C. (2003) Foliar Response of an Ailanthus altissima Clone in Two Sites with Different Levels of Ozone-Pollution. Environmental Pollution, 121, 137-146.
 Johnson, D.M., Smith, W.K., Vogelmann, T.C. and Brodersen, C.R. (2005) Leaf Architecture and Direction of Incident Light Influence Mesophyll Fluorescence Profiles. American Journal of Botany, 92, 1425-1431.
 Urbat, M., Lehndorff, E. and Schwark, L. (2004) Biomonitoring of Air Quality in the Cologne Conurbation Using Pine Needles as a Passive Sampler-Part I: Magnetic Properties. Atmospheric Environment, 38, 3781-3792.
 Lehndorff, E., Urbat, M. and Schwark, L. (2006) Accumulation Histories of Magnetic Particles on Pine Needles as Function of Air Quality. Atmospheric Environment, 40, 7082-7096.