Assessment of Performance Based Road Maintenance Practices in Nepal

Abhiman Das  Mulmi

doi:10.4236/ojce.2016.62021

Abhiman Das Mulmi

Abstract: Roads are the major asset of any country and to conserve them maintenance is essential. The delay of maintenance works can lead the road in the stage of expensive rehabilitation and reconstruction. In Nepal, Department of Roads (DoR) is responsible for maintenance of strategic roads of country. The maintenance practice of the road under Department of Road is predominantly based on Strengthen Maintenance Division Process where several maintenance activities like Routine maintenance, Recurrent Maintenance, Periodic Maintenance and Emergency Maintenance are planned and carried out. The maintenance work is based on traditional quantity and unit price based short term maintenance contracts, where maintenance of physical works is outsourced. Client demands the contractor what work is to be done, when to be do it and the extent of the work. The contractor is paid on the basis of a defined output or quantity accomplished, and the schedule of the rates. DoR engineers required full time supervision of work. Pilot based performance based maintenance practice of road started in Nepal in 2003. The study assesses performance road maintenance practices of road maintenance in Nepal on the basis of the framework of cost efficiency, level of service effectiveness and quality of service. The study concluded that implementation of Performance Based Maintenance Contract (PBMC) was not successful in Nepal as Road Asset condition was not maintained to performance standard. One of the reasons is the weak service delivery of contractor alongside weak contract enforcement from the road agency.

Keywords: Road Maintenance, Performance Based Maintenance, Cost Efficiency, Contract Management

Cite this paper: Mulmi, A. (2016) Assessment of Performance Based Road Maintenance Practices in Nepal. Open Journal of Civil Engineering, 6, 225-241. doi: 10.4236/ojce.2016.62021.

References

[1] DoR (2013) Road Statistics of Strategic Road Network. Department of Roads, Kathmandu

[2] DoR (2013) Road Condition Survey Data. Department of Roads, Kathmandu.

[3] DoR (2007) Sector Wide Road Programme and Priority Investment Plan. Department of Roads, Kathmandu.

[4] DoR (2006) Program Document, Strengthened Maintenance Divisions Program, Project Phase III July 2002-June 2006. Department of Roads, Kathmandu.

[5] DoR (2005) Contract Agreement Volume I and II, Conditions of Contract and Specification, Performance Based Maintenance Component (MRM Km 218+000-293+000) Contract No, RMDP/PBMC/ICB01. Department of Roads, Kathmandu.

[6] DoR (2005) Review and Strategic Assessment of the Strengthened Maintenance Divisions Program. Final Mission Report, Department of Roads, Kathmandu.

[7] William, H. (2009) Performance Based Contracting for Maintenance, a Synthesis of Highway Practice. Transportation Research Board, Washington DC

[8] Gunter, Z. (2011) Cutting Costs and Improving Quality through Performance Based Management and Maintenance Contracts—The Latin American and OECD Experiences. University of Birmingham, Birmingham, Senior Road Executives Programme April 2011.

[9] Sultana, M., Rahman, A. and Chowdhary, S. (2012) An Overview of Issue to Be Consider before Introducing Perfor-mance Based Road Maintenance Contract. International Journal of Civil, Environmental, Structural, Construction and Architectural Engineering, 6, 137-142.

[10] DoR (2005) Contract Agreement Volume 2, Conditions of Contract Specification, Performance Based Maintenance Component (MRM Km 824+280-880+280) Contract No, RNDP/LCB/PBM/1. Department of Roads, Kathmandu.

[11] DoR (2005) Contract Agreement Volume 2, Conditions of Contract Specification, Performance Based Maintenance Component (MRM Km 880+280-932+280) Contract No, RtNDP/LCB/PBM/2. Department of Roads, Kathmandu

[12] DoR (2005) Contract Agreement Volume 2, Conditions of Contract Specification, Performance Based Maintenance Component (MRM Km 932+280-982+280) Contract No, RNDP/LCB/PBM/3. Department of Roads, Kathmandu

[13] DoR (2005) Contract Agreement Volume 2, Conditions of Contract Specification, Performance Based Maintenance Component (MRM Km 982+280-1029+020) Contract No, RNDP/LCB/PBM/4. Department of Roads, Kathmandu

[14] DoR (2005) Contract Agreement Volume I and II, Conditions of Contract and Specification, Performance Based Maintenance Component (MRM Km 293+000-367+630) Contract No, RMDP/PBMC/ICBC02. Department of Roads, Kathmandu

[15] Piñero, J.C. (2003) A Framework for Monitoring Performance-Based Road Maintenance. PhD Dissertation, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg.

[16] DoR (2010) Surface Distress survey and Road Roughness survey Data , 2001/02, 2002/03, 2003/04, 2004/05, 2005/06, 2006/07, 2007/08, 2008/09, 2009/10 Highway Management Information System Unit. Department of Roads, Kathmandu.

[17] DoR (2010) Integrated Annual Road Maintenance Plan (IARMP) FY 2004/05, FY 2005/06, FY 2006/07, FY 2007/08, FY 2008/09, FY 2009/2010 Maintenance Branch. Department of Roads, Kathmandu.