Received 7 December 2015; accepted 13 February 2016; published 16 February 2016
The fuzzy set theory has been widely used in various fields of modern society since it proposed by Zadeh  in the 1960s. The main idea of this theory is the extension from the characteristic function taking the value of 0 or 1 to the membership function which can take any value from the closed interval. However, in the increasingly complex socio-economic environment, there are different degrees of hesitation on comprehension and cognition, which can’t make a valid judgment. Therefore, the traditional fuzzy set cannot be used to completely describe all the information in such problems. Atanassov  expands Zadeh’s fuzzy set theory with the concept of intuitionistic fuzzy set (IFS), which is characterized by a membership function, a non-membership function and a hesitation function  . Since IFS can describe the uncertainty and the essence of fuzzy, it has been widely concerned and applied. The research on the application of intuitionistic fuzzy sets are mainly focused on the fields of multi-attribute decision making   and pattern recognition   . Many scholars have applied IFS to the cluster analysis, which generates the research of intuitionistic fuzzy cluster analysis (IFCA). At present, the research on the IFCA is still not perfect. In IFCA, the core of this problem is to obtain the proximity degree of two intuitionistic fuzzy vectors, which is the similarity degree in IFS. With the different forms, this paper discusses the problem of structuring similarity degree. Zhang  proposes an intuitionistic fuzzy similarity degree with an intuitionistic fuzzy number (IFN) and obtains the results by constructing intuitionistic fuzzy similarity matrix (IFSM), intuitionistic fuzzy equivalent matrix (IFEM) and l-cutting matrix of IFEM, while the similarity degree is not easy to calculate. Chen  proposes an intuitionistic fuzzy clustering method based on set valued statistics, and the similarity degree is represented by an IFN. The method is also complex in calculation.
This paper constructs a new similarity degree that is based on the distance of the membership degree, non- membership degree and hesitation degree. Then, considering the risk factors  , the matrix is transformed from the IFSM with membership degree and non-membership degree to fuzzy similarity matrix with only membership degree. The advantage of this method is that the calculation is simple and it is easily operated. The attribute weights of each index are considered, which make the formula more scientific and reasonable. The correctness of the method is proved in theory, and the validity is demonstrated by an example.
2. Intuitionistic Fuzzy Set Theory
Definition 1  . An IFS is an object having the following form:
which is characterized by a membership function:
and a non-membership function:
with the condition:
, for all,
where and are called a membership degree and a non-membership degree of x in A.
Moreover, for each IFS A in X, if
, for all
then is called an hesitation degree of x to A. Obviously,
, for all.
In particular, if
, for all
then A reduces to Zadeh’s fuzzy set. Thus, fuzzy sets are the special cases of IFSs.
is called an intuitionistic fuzzy number(IFN), where
Let be the set of all IFNs. Obviously, is the largest IFN, and is the smallest IFN. The physical interpretation of is “the vote for resolution is 5 in favor, 3 against and 2 abstentions”.
Atanassov proposed the inclusion relationship of two IFSs  .
Let and be two IFSs, then:
(1), if and only if, and;
(2), if and only if, and.
Definition 2  . Let be a matrix with orders, if is an IFN, then Z is called intuitionistic fuzzy matrix (IFM).
Definition 3  . If is an IFM and satisfies the following conditions:
(2) Symmetry:, i.e., , then Z is called intuitionistic fuzzy similarity matrix (IFSM).
Definition 4  . Let, where be the set of all IFNs on X, and.
If satisfies the following conditions:
(1) is a IFN;
(2) if and only if;
(4) If, then and.
Then, is called thesimilarity degree of IFSs.
3. Fuzzy Clustering Analysis Based on IFSM
In the problem of multi-attribute decision making, is a scheme set, and
is an attribute set. The is called intuitionistic fuzzy decision-making matrix, where
is the attribute value of scheme in the attribute. Weight reflects the important degree of each index in the evaluation results, so it is very important to give proper weight for each index in the rationality of the evalu-
ation results. Let be the attribute weight set of each evaluation index.
The attribute values of scheme and scheme, respectively, are
For convenience, the membership degree distance and non-membership degree distance between and
are denoted as and. Let
Theorem 1. Let and be two IFSs, then is called the IFSD between and.
Proof: According to the 4 conditions in Definition 4, the process of this proof are as follows:
(1) Since, we have, and since, we get.
Hence, we have. Similarly, we get.
Thus, and, i.e.,.
Therefore, is an IFN.
(2) When, we have.
Therefore, we get.
(3) Since and.
Thus, we have.
(4) If, then and.
And since, and
. So, we have.
Similarly, we can obtain.
Hence, we have and.
Thus, we can get and.
To sum up, the proof is completed.
Therefore, the intuitionistic fuzzy similarity degree between two schemes can be obtained by the Theorem 1, which can get the IFSM of the schemes. Thereinto, is an IFN. (The subscript of the three formulas are modified) (Combine the content of section 3 with section 2). As an IFN is composed with membership degree, non-membership degree and hesitation degree. The hesitation degree is considered to be a part of the membership degree and non-membership degree, that is . Thus, the similarity degree can be transformed from an IFN to fuzzy number, that is
there into, is a risk factor. Therefore, the IFSM can be transformed into a fuzzy similarity matrix. We can conduct clustering analysis with this fuzzy similarity matrix through the method of l-cutting matrix.
4. Empirical Analysis
In this paper, we select a case from Literature  , which is that a car market wants to classify the five kinds of different vehicles. Each vehicle has six factors as the evaluating terms, which contained fuel consumption, friction, price, comfort, design and safety. The each car’s characteristic information is represented by an IFN, as shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Characteristic information for each car.
4.1. Constructing Intuitionistic Fuzzy Similarity Matrix
In the problem of multi-attribute decision making, the evaluation results are impacted by each attribute index on different extent, so it is necessary to give a reasonable weight coefficient for each index. The weights of the six evaluation factors are obtained via the intuitionistic fuzzy entropy calculating the weights’ method proposed by Szmidt Eulalia  . The weight of each index is .
By the formula of Theorem 1, we can get a five orders IFSM with five different vehicles between each pair of similarity degree:
, there into,
4.2. Fuzzy Clustering Analysis Based on IFSM
In order to make the IFCA more convenient, the value of similarity degree is transformed from IFN to fuzzy numbervia Equation (1):, which can make the IFCA turn into fuzzy clustering analysis. Let be the risk factor, the new similarity degree is made of 50% hesitation degree and 50% membership degree. We will get the fuzzy similarity matrix that is calculated by equation:
. The fuzzy similarity matrix is:.
The results of the fuzzy clustering analysis through maximal tree method are shown in Figure 1.
The results of clustering analysis are as follows:
Cutting off, 5 different cars are divided into 5 categories, and the clustering result is:; Cutting off, the clustering result is:; Cutting off, the clustering result is:; Cutting off, the clustering result is:; Cutting off, the clustering result is:.
From the above results, it is clear that the clustering method proposed in this paper and the literature  are based on the intuitionistic fuzzy similarity formula, and the clustering results are represented for intuitionistic fuzzy similarity matrix. Although there are some differences in the corresponding values, the trend of elements in the matrix is same. The final clustering results are roughly the same as that of the literature  , which shows that the new similarity degree is effective. But the method proposed in this paper is more comprehensive and reasonable than the method in literature  , and it is simpler and easier to operate than the method in literature  .
Figure 1. The maximum tree cluster map.
To sum up, we can see that the new similarity degree proposed in this paper is correct and effective, and it has the following advantages:
(1) With the form of IFN, the information of the data is fully extracted;
(2) Taking into account the weight of the index attribute, the calculation results are more reasonable;
(3) The new similarity degree takes into account the membership degree and the non-membership degree, and it fully extracts the information provided by the intuitionistic fuzzy numbers;
(4) Computational process is simple and easy to operate.
This paper proposes a new method to compute intuitionistic fuzzy similarity degree. The formula is not only considered with the weight of each index attribute but also expressed by an IFN. It makes the information fully extracted. Meanwhile, the computational process is simple and convenient. Considering the risk factor, we obtain IFSM through the new similarity degree. Then, the IFSM is converted to a fuzzy similarity matrix. Finally, we get the result of cluster analysis through the method of maximum tree. In this paper, we prove the correctness of the new similarity degree and illustrate the validity and rationality of the method with an example. This method extends the research space of the intuitionistic fuzzy similarity degree.
Supported by China West Normal University special funding for basic scientific research business expenses (no.14C004), Social Science Programming general Program of Nan Chong city (no.NC2013B027).
 Li, D.F. (2011) The GOWA Operator Based Approach to Multi-Attribute Decision Making Using Intuitionistic Fuzzy Sets. Mathematical and Computer Modeling, 53, 1182-1196. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.mcm.2010.11.088
 Dymova, L.D. and Sevastjanov, P. (2010) An Interpretation of Intuitionistic Fuzzy Sets in Terms of Evidence Theory: Decision Making Aspect. Knowledge-Based Systems, 23, 772-782. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.knosys.2010.04.014