JSS  Vol.3 No.9 , September 2015
How Many Learning Disabled Are There? The Rhetorical Power of Statistics in the Is-raeli Discourse on Learning Disabilities
Author(s) Ofer Katchergin*
ABSTRACT
The intention of this article is to problematize the current understanding of learning disabilities by scrutinizing the historical and social context in which they are embedded. The first part of the article lays out theoretical assertions from various fields: sociology of knowledge, rhetoric of science, rhetoric of statistics and historical critical discourse analysis. Integrating these constructionist approaches and through a short historical presentation of the evolution of the discourse and the various critiques that are developed from it, the article reveals the obscurity that surrounds the concept of learning disabilities. In the second part, the article examines one important idiom which forms the basis for the Israeli disabilities discourse: the statistical one which deals with the percentage of disabled persons in the population. Through an analysis of major texts of the Israeli disabilities field and interviews with professionals, it becomes clear how central statistical assertions are shaped into “scientific facts”, even when their scientific foundations are quite shaky. The article’s aim is to contribute to the development of a more complex disabilities discourse by uncovering its social, historical and cultural contexts. Another aim is to raise awareness to possible uses of statistical knowledge as a discursive and rhetorical tool.

Cite this paper
Katchergin, O. (2015) How Many Learning Disabled Are There? The Rhetorical Power of Statistics in the Is-raeli Discourse on Learning Disabilities. Open Journal of Social Sciences, 3, 155-166. doi: 10.4236/jss.2015.39022.
References
[1]   Wong, B.Y.L., Graham, L., Hoskyn, M. and Berman, J., Eds. (2008) The ABCs of Learning Disabilities. 2nd Edition, Elsevier Academic Press, San Diego.

[2]   Kavale, K.A. and Forness, S.R. (1985) The Science of Learning Disabilities. College-Hill, San Diego.

[3]   Sleeter, C.E. (1986) Learning Disabilities: The Social Construction of a Special Education Category. Exceptional Children, 53, 46-54.

[4]   National Center for Learning Disabilities (2014) The State of Learning Disabilities. 3rd Edition, New York.

[5]   Hedd, S. (1990) Learning Disabilities—Young and Adults: Parental Expectations and Conflicts in the Family. Master Thesis, Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv. [In Hebrew]

[6]   Naiman, R. (2006) Educational Intervention for the Advancement of Pupils with Learning Disabilities. Ministry of Education. [In Hebrew]

[7]   Heiman, T. (2000) Learning Disabilities. The Open University, Tel-Aviv. [In Hebrew]

[8]   Lyon, G.R. (1996) Learning Disabilities. In: Marsh, E. and Barkley, R., Eds., Child Psychopathology, Guilford Press, New York, 390-434. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1602494

[9]   Best, J. (2001) Damned Lies and Statistics: Untangling Numbers from the Media, Politicians, and Activists. University of California Press, Berkeley.

[10]   Spear-Swerling, L. and Sternberg, R.J. (1998) Curing Our “Epidemic” of Learning Disabilities. Phi Delta Kappan, 79, 397-401.

[11]   Berger, P.L. and Luckman, T. (1971) The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge. Harmondsworth, Penguin Books, Middlesex.

[12]   Sismondo, S. (2010) An Introduction to Science and Technology Studies. 2nd Edition, Wiley-Blackwell, Malden.

[13]   Gergen, K. (Ed.) (2001) Social Construction in Context. Sage Publications, London.

[14]   Swidler, A. and Arditi, J. (1994) The New Sociology of Knowledge. Annual Review of Sociology, 20, 305-329. http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev.so.20.080194.001513

[15]   Bourdieu, P. (1988) Homo Academicus. Polity, Cambridge.

[16]   Foucault, M. (1967) Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the Age of Reason. Mentor Books, London.

[17]   Foucault, M. (1980) Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 1972-1977. Gordon, C. (Ed.), Random House, New York.

[18]   Latour, B. and Woolgar, S. (1986) Laboratory Life: The Social Construction of Scientific Facts. Princeton University Press, Princeton.

[19]   Lynch, M. (1993) Scientific Practice and Ordinary Action: Ethnomethodological and Social Studies of Science. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[20]   Shapin, S. (1995) Here and Everywhere: Sociology of Scientific Knowledge. Annual Review of Sociology, 21, 289- 321. http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev.so.21.080195.001445

[21]   Bazerman, C. (1988) Shaping Written Knowledge: The Genre and Activity of the Experimental Article in Science. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison.

[22]   Gross, A.G. (1990) The Rhetoric of Science. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.

[23]   Gilbert, G.N. and Mulkey, M. (1984) Opening Pandora’s Box: A Sociological Analysis of Scientists’ Discourse. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[24]   Hacking, I. (1990) The Taming of Chance. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

[25]   McCloskey, D. (1993) Rhetoric within the Citadel: Statistics. In: Willard, C.A. and Goodnight, G.T., Eds., Public Argument and Scientific Understanding, 485-490.

[26]   John, I.D. (1992) Statistics as Rhetoric in Psychology. Australian Psychologist, 27, 144-147. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00050069208257601

[27]   Bury, M.R. (1986) Social Constructionism and the Development of Medical Sociology. Sociology of Health and Illness, 8, 137-169. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/1467-9566.ep11340129

[28]   Conrad, P. (1992) Medicalization and Social Control. Annual Review of Sociology, 18, 209-232. http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev.so.18.080192.001233

[29]   Zola, I. (1978) Medicine as an Institution of Social Control. Sociological Review, 20, 487-504. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-954X.1972.tb00220.x

[30]   Petrina, S. (2006) The Medicalization of Education: A Historiographic Synthesis. History of Education Quarterly, 46, 503-531. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-5959.2006.00030.x

[31]   Sleeter, C.E. (1995) Radical Structuralist Perspectives on the Creation and Use of Learning Disabilities. In: Skrtic, T.M., Ed., Disability and Democracy: Reconstructing Special Education for Postmodernity, Teachers College Press, New York, 153-165.

[32]   Fuchs, D., Fuchs, L.S., Mathes, P.G., Lipsey, M.W. and Roberts, P.H. (2001) Is “Learning Disabilities” Just a Fancy Term for Low Achievement? A Meta-Analysis of Reading Differences between Low Achievers with and without the Label. Paper Presented at the Office of Special Education Program’s LD Initiative Conference, Washington DC, 27-29 August 2001.

[33]   Gerber, M.M. and Semmel, M.I. (1984) Teacher as Imperfect Test: Reconceptualizing the Referral Process. Educational Psychologist, 19, 137-148. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00461528409529290

[34]   Katchergin, O. (2014) “Learning-Disabilities” as a “Black Box”: On the Different Conceptions and Constructions of a Popular Clinical Entity in Israel. Culture Medicine & Psychiatry, 38, 669-699. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11013-014-9398-3

[35]   Lyon, G.R. (1987) Severe Discrepancy: Theoretical, Psychometric, Developmental and Educational Issues. Learning Disabilities Research, 3, 10-11.

[36]   Mercer, C.D., King-Sears, P. and Mercer, A.R. (1990) Learning Disabilities Definitions and Criteria Used by State Education Departments. Learning Disability Quarterly, 13, 141-152. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1510657

[37]   Gottlieb, J., Alter, M., Gottlieb, B.W. and Wishner, J. (1994) Special Education in Urban America: It’s Not Justifiable for Many. The Journal of Special Education, 27, 453-465. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/002246699402700406

[38]   Katchergin, O. (2009) Studying (in) Disorder: Sociological Perspective on Learning Disabilities in Israel. PhD Dissertation, Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv. (In Hebrew)

[39]   MacMillan, D.L., Siperstein, G.M. and Gresham, F.M. (1996) A Challenge to the Viability of Mild Mental Retardation as a Diagnostic Category. Exceptional Children, 62, 356-371.

[40]   Shepard, L., Smith, M.L. and Vojir, C.P. (1983) Characteristics of Pupils Identified as Learning Disabled. American Educational Research Journal, 20, 309-331. http://dx.doi.org/10.3102/00028312020003309

[41]   Brantlinger, E. (1997) Using Ideology: Cases of Nonrecognition of the Politics of Research and Practice in Special Education. Review of Educational Research, 67, 425-459.
http://dx.doi.org/10.3102/00346543067004425

[42]   Lerner, J.W. (1985) Learning Disabilities: Theories, Diagnosis, and Teaching Strategies. 4th Edition, Houghton Mifflin, Boston.

[43]   Bateman, B. (1974) Educational Implications of Minimal Brain Dysfunction. Reading Teacher, 27, 662-688.

[44]   Coles, G.S. (1987) The Learning Mystique: A Critical Look at Learning Disabilities. Pantheon Press, New York.

[45]   Algozzine, R. (1985) Low Achiever Differentiation: Where’s the Beef? Exceptional Children, 52, 72-75.

[46]   Lyon, G.R., Fletcher, J.M., Shaywitz, S.E., Shaywitz, B.A., Torgesen, J.K., Wood, F.B., Schulte, A. and Olson, R. (2001) Rethinking Learning Disabilities. In: Finn Jr., C.E., Rotherham, A.J. and Hokanson Jr., C.R., Eds., Rethinking Special Education for a New Century, Thomas B. Fordham Foundation, Washington DC, 259-287.

[47]   Skrtic, T.M. (1999) Learning Disabilities as Organizational Pathologies. In: Sternberg, R.J. and Spear-Swerling, L., Eds., Perspectives on Learning Disabilities: Biological, Cognitive, Contextual, Westview Press, Boulder, 193-226.

[48]   Christensen, C.A. (1999) Learning Disability: Issues of Representation, Power and the Medicalization of School Failure. In: Sternberg, R.J. and Spear-Swerling, L., Eds., Perspectives on Learning Disabilities: Biological, Cognitive, Contextual, Westview Press, Boulder, 227-249.

[49]   Scriven, M. (1985) Comments on Gene Glass. Paper Presented at the Wingspread National Invitational Conference on Public Policy and the Special Education Task Force of the 1980s, Cited in Hallahan, D.P., Kauffman, J. and Lloyd, J., Introduction to Learning Disabilities, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs.

[50]   Finlan, T.G. (1994) Learning Disability: The Imaginary Disease. Bergin & Garvey, Westport.

[51]   McKnight, R.T. (1982) The Learning Disability Myth in American Education. Journal of Education, 164, 351-359.

[52]   Poplin, M.S. (1988) The Reductionistic Fallacy in Learning Disabilities: Replicating the Past by Reducing the Present. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 21, 389-400.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/002221948802100702

[53]   Skrtic, T.M. (2005) A Political Economy of Learning Disabilities. Learning Disability Quarterly, 28, 149-155. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1593616

[54]   McDermott, R., Goldman, S. and Varenne, H. (2006) The Cultural Work of Learning Disabilities. Educational Researcher, 35, 12-17. http://dx.doi.org/10.3102/0013189x035006012

[55]   Dudley-Marling, C. (2004) The Social Construction of Learning Disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 37, 482-489. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/00222194040370060201

[56]   Artiles, A. (2004) The End of Innocence: Historiography and Representation in the Discursive Practice of Learning Disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 37, 550-555. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/00222194040370061001

[57]   Reid, D.K. and Valle, J.W. (2004) The Discursive Practice of Learning Disability. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 37, 466-481. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/00222194040370060101

[58]   Zuriff, G.E. (2007) The Myths of Learning Disabilities. In: Curren, R., Ed., Philosophy of Education: An Anthology, Blackwell Publishing, Hoboken, 291-297.

[59]   Ayalon, H. and Margalit, M. (2004) Concessions in Matriculation Exams to Pupils with Learning Disabilities: The Role of School Policy. Megamot, 43, 242-265. (In Hebrew)

[60]   Artman, L. (2007) Dizzying Success: Learning Disabilities Diagnosis in the Field of Reading. Education and Its’ Environment, 29, 67-81. (In Hebrew)

[61]   Artman, L. (2011) The Diagnoses Industry. HedHa’Chinuch, 6, 77-79. (In Hebrew)

[62]   Katchergin, O. (2012) So What Is This Thing Called “Learning Disability”? A Discussion of the Definition and Its’ Implications. Dvarim, 5, 67-82. (In Hebrew)

[63]   Katchergin, O. (2012) Between Negative Stigma (Cultural Deprivation) and Positive Stigma (Learning Disability): The Historical Development of Two Special Education Tracks. Culture Medicine & Psychiatry, 36, 679-711. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11013-012-9281-z

[64]   Katchergin, O. (2013) “The Good Parent” and “the Other Parent”: Othering and Social Exclusion in Professional Discourse Regarding Learning-Difficulties. Dvarim, 6, 77-98. (In Hebrew)

[65]   Levy, R. (2009) Yeledyihudi: Ha-zekhutveha-etgarle-tapelbo: Tipulmeshulav bi-yeladimimlekuyotlemidah be-mis- geret ha-sherut ha-psikhologihinukhi be-iryatYerushalayim. Ashalim, Jerusalem. (In Hebrew)

[66]   Ong-Dean, C. (2009) Distinguishing Disability: Parents, Privilege, and Special Education. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

[67]   McLaughlin, M. and Owings, M.F. (1993) Relationships among States’ Fiscal and Demographic Data and the Implementation of P.L. 94-112. Exceptional Children, 59, 247-261.

[68]   Smith, M.L. (1982) How Educators Decide Who Is Learning Disabled. Charles C. Thomas, Springfield.

[69]   Hammill, D.D. (1990) On Defining Learning Disabilities: An Emerging Consensus. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23, 74-84. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/002221949002300201

[70]   Sanders, M. (1984) Clinical Assessment of Learning Problems. Ha’Poalim Library. (In Hebrew)

[71]   Hallahan, D.P. and Keogh, B.K. (Eds.) (2001) Research and Global Perspectives in Learning Disabilities: Essays in Honor of William M, Cruikshank. L. Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah.

[72]   Armstrong, T. (1987) In Their Own Way: Discovering and Encouraging Your Child’s Personal Learning Style. Jeremy P. Tarcher, Inc., Los Angeles.

[73]   Siegel, E. and Gold, R. (1982) Educating the Learning Disabled. Macmillan, New York.

[74]   Winzer, M.A. (1993) The History of Special Education: From Isolation to Integration. Gallaudet University Press, Washington DC.

[75]   Ministry of Education and Culture (2003) Concessions in Ways of Examinations to Internal Learning Disabled Examinees. General Director Circular—Standing Orders 64/4 (2), Jerusalem. (In Hebrew)

[76]   National Joint Committee on Learning Disabilities (NJCLD) (1994) Learning Disabilities: Issues on Definition-Re- vised. In: NJCLD, Ed., Collective Perspectives on Issues Affecting Learning Disabilities, Pro-Ed, Austin, 61-66.

[77]   American Psychiatric Association (1994) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 4th Edition, American Psychiatric Association, Washington DC.

[78]   Binshtok, O. (2007) A Guide to Parents of Pupils with Learning Disabilities. Ministry of Education. (In Hebrew)

[79]   Kavale, K.A. and Forness, S.R. (1995) The Nature of Learning Disabilities: Critical Elements of Diagnosis and Classification. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah.

[80]   Peterson, K.M.H. and Shinn, M.R. (2002) Severe Discrepancy Models: Which Best Explains School Identification Practices for Learning Disabilities? School Psychology Review, 31, 23-33.

[81]   Kashti, Y. (2009) More than a Quarter of High School Pupils in Israel Get Concessions in the Matriculation Examinations. Ha’aretz, 9 December 2009. (In Hebrew) www.haaretz.co.il/news/education/1.1293988

[82]   Valmer, T. (2010) Learning Disabled Empire: Well-Off Get More. Ynet, 17 December 2010. (In Hebrew) www.ynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-3995197,00.html

[83]   Leibowitz Dar, S.H. (2004) Learning Disabilities Epidemic Is Spreading in Tel-Aviv. Ha’aretz, 2 February 2004. (In Hebrew) www.haaretz.co.il/misc/1.943296

[84]   Kalka, A. (2007) The Learning Disabilities.

[85]   Arazi, S.H. (1970) Learning Disabilities among Children with Brain Damage—Clinical Diagnosis. Child Development, 1, 10-23. (In Hebrew)

[86]   Birch, G. (1970) The Brain-Damage Problem among Children. Child Development, 1, 3-11. (In Hebrew)

[87]   Ayalon, O. (1970) Emotional Inhibitions in Learning to Read. Child Development, 1, 28-37. (In Hebrew)

[88]   Kidron, R. (1972) Remarks Regarding the Paper of Dr. Shifra Arazi “Learning Disabilities among Children with Brain Damage—Clinical Diagnosis”. Child Development, 1, 24-27. (In Hebrew)

[89]   Kidron, R. (1988) Reading, A Diagnostic-Didactic Test. Ministry of Education and Culture, the Pedagogical Secretariat, the Special Education Department, Jerusalem. (In Hebrew)

[90]   Kidron, R. (1990) Ram—Example of Diagnosis and Analysis of a Reading Case. Ministry of Education and Culture, Special Education Department with Nitzan Association. Nitzan, Tel-Aviv. (In Hebrew)

[91]   Arieli, M., Kashti, Y. and Shalsky, S. (Eds.) (1997) The Education and Teaching Lexicon. Ramot, Tel-Aviv. (In Hebrew)

[92]   Haver, D. (1990) “Doesn’t Like to Read”: Multi-Dimensional Treatment of Learning-Disabilities. Ramot, Tel-Aviv. (In Hebrew)

[93]   Feldman, D., Lahav-Danieli, Y. and Haimovitz, S.H. (2007) The Accessibility of the Israeli Society for Persons with Disabilities on the Threshold of the 21th Century. Ministry of Law, Jerusalem. (In Hebrew)

[94]   Margalit, M. (1997) Report of the Committee for Assessing the Abilities of Learning Disabled Pupils. Ministry of Education, Jerusalem. (In Hebrew)

[95]   Rahmani, L. (1985) Brain and Learning: Process and Disabilities. Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv. (In Hebrew)

[96]   Darin, A. (1984) Neuropsychology and the Exceptional Child. Oranim, Haifa. (In Hebrew)

[97]   Sharan, S.H. and Sharan (1969) Learning Disabilities and Their Correction. Ha’Poalim library, Tel-Aviv. (In Hebrew)

[98]   Falk, B. (1992) The Correlation between Categorical Memory and Categorical Thinking among Diagnosed Learning Disabled Children. Bar Ilan University, Ramat-Gan. (In Hebrew)

[99]   Ministry of Education. Retrieved in 20 June 2007.
http://cms.education.gov.il/EducationCMS/Units/Special/HaagafBepeula/NetuneyKitot/KitotTalmidim.htm

[100]   Margalit, M., Molcho, E. and Danino, M. (2002) Examination Concessions to Pupils with Learning Disabilities: Surveying of the Research and Implications. Educational Counseling, 11, 48-63. (In Hebrew)

[101]   Regev, R. (2004) Academic Self Efficacy as Mediating between Learning Disabilities, Past Achievements, Parents and Teachers Beliefs in Students Ability, and Future Achievements. Master Thesis. Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv. (In Hebrew)

[102]   Balgur, R. (1991) Clarifications and Disagreements Regarding Dyslexia. Megamot, 34, 301-316. (In Hebrew)

[103]   Krampf, A. (2011) The Metaphysics of the Fact: The Social Measurement in Historical and Comparative Perspective. In: Hakak, Y., Kacen, L. and Krumer-Nevo, M., Eds., The Limits of Quantification: Critical Perspectives on Measuring and Grading People, Their Behaviors and Achievements, Ben-Gurion University, Be’ersheva. (In Hebrew)

[104]   Porter, T.M. (1995) Trust in Numbers: The Pursuit of Objectivity in Science and Public Life. Princeton University Press, Princeton.

[105]   Roeh, I. and Feldman, S. (1984) The Rhetoric of Numbers in Front-Page Journalism: How Numbers Contribute to the Melodramatic in the Popular Press. Text & Talk, 4, 347-368. http://dx.doi.org/10.1515/text.1.1984.4.4.347

[106]   Best, J. (1993) Threatened Children: Rhetoric and Concern about Child-Victims. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

[107]   Van Dijk, T. (2000) New(s) Racism: A Discourse Analytical Approach. In: Cottle, S., Ed., Ethnic Minorities and the Media, Open University Press, Philadelphia, 211-226.

 
 
Top