CE  Vol.6 No.8 , May 2015
A Study Identifying Biological Evolution-Related Misconceptions Held by Prebiology High School Students
Students bring a diverse array of ideas about natural events to their science classes, and many of these ideas are often at variance with the scientifically accepted views. Numerous studies have identified multiple biological evolution-related misconceptions held by select groups of students. Collectively, these studies repeatedly indicate that students with varying educational backgrounds have difficulties accurately understanding the concepts of evolution. Because scientific literacy in the field of biology necessitates a basic understanding of evolution concepts and theory, students’ possession of biological evolution-related misconceptions is problematic. The focus of this study was to identify the types and prevalence of such misconceptions within a state’s public high schools’ prebiology students and to correlate those findings with demographic variables. Some 993 students enrolled in their initial high school biology course during the 2010-2011 academic years in one of 42 Oklahoma public high schools served as this study’s unit of analysis. The Biological Evolution Literacy Survey which presents 23 biological misconception statements grouped into five categories, served as the research tool for identifying students’ misconceptions, calculating conception index scores, and collecting demographic data. Multiple statistical analyses were performed to identify statistically significant (p < 0.05) relationships between variables related to students’ number and types of misconceptions. Analysis revealed that participants possess a mean 43.9% rate of understanding of those biological evolution concepts presented in the BEL Survey combined with a 39.1% mean misconception rate. A statistically significant difference in participants’ BEL Survey mean index scores when related to biological evolution knowledge self-rating was also disclosed. Strategies for identifying and eliminating students’ misconceptions are offered. Misconceptions of biological evolution were prevalent within this student population and the findings corroborate the literature that reports a strikingly high prevalence of biological evolution-related misconceptions in students at all levels, from elementary pupils to university science majors.

Cite this paper
Yates, T. and Marek, E. (2015) A Study Identifying Biological Evolution-Related Misconceptions Held by Prebiology High School Students. Creative Education, 6, 811-834. doi: 10.4236/ce.2015.68085.
[1]   Almquist, A. J., & Cronin, J. E. (1988). Fact, Fancy, and Myth on Human Evolution. Current Anthropology, 29, 520-522.

[2]   Alters, B. J., & Alters, S. M. (2001). Defending Evolution: A Guide to the Creation/Evolution Controversy. Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett.

[3]   Alters, B. J., & Nelson, C. E. (2002). Perspective: Teaching Evolution in Higher Education. Evolution, 56, 1891-1901.

[4]   Anderson, D. L., Fisher, K. M., & Norman, G. J. (2002). Development and Evaluation of the Conceptual Inventory of Natural Selection. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 39, 952-978.

[5]   Beardsley, P. M. (2004). Middle School Student Learning in Evolution: Are Current Standards Achievable? American Biology Teacher, 66, 604, 606-607, 609-612.

[6]   Berkman, M. B., Pacheco, J. S., & Plutzer, E. (2008). Evolution and Creationism in America’s Classrooms: A National Portrait. PLoS Biology, 6, e124.

[7]   Berkman, M. B., & Plutzer, E. (2010). Evolution, Creationism, and the Battle to Control America’s Classrooms. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

[8]   Berkman, M. B., & Plutzer, E. (2011). Defeating Creationism in the Courtroom, but Not the Classroom. Science, 331, 404-405.

[9]   Berra, T. M. (1990). Evolution and the Myth of Creationism: A Basic Guide to the Facts in the Evolution Debate. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

[10]   Bishop, B. A., & Anderson, C. W. (1986). Evolution by Natural Selection: A Teaching Module. Occasional Paper 91, East Lansing, MI: Institute for Research on Teaching, Michigan State University, ERIC No. ED272383.

[11]   Bishop, B. A., & Anderson, C. W. (1990). Student Conceptions of Natural Selection and Its Role in Evolution. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 27, 415-427.

[12]   Bizzo, N. M. V. (1994). From Down House Landlord to Brazilian High School Students: What Has Happened to Evolutionary Knowledge on the Way? Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 31, 537-556.

[13]   Bransford, J. D., Brown, A. L., & Cocking, R. R. (Eds.) (2000). How People Learn. Washington DC: National Academy Press.

[14]   Brem, S. K., Ranney, M., & Schindel, J. (2002). Perceived Consequences of Evolution: College Students Perceive Negative Personal and Social Impact in Evolutionary Theory. Science Education, 87, 181-206.

[15]   Brumby, M. (1979). Problems in Learning the Concept of Natural Selection. Journal of Biological Education, 13, 119-122.

[16]   Brumby, M. (1984). Misconceptions about the Concept of Natural Selection by Medical Biology Students. Science Education, 68, 493-503.

[17]   Chan, K. S. (1998). A Case Study of Physicist’s Conceptions about the Theory of Evolution. Annual Meeting of the National Association of Research and Science Teaching, San Diego, April 1998.

[18]   Chinsamy, A., & Plagányi, &EGRAVE;. (2007). Accepting Evolution. Evolution, 62, 248-254.

[19]   Clough, E. E., & Wood-Robinson, C. (1985). How Secondary Students Interpret Instances of Biological Adaptation. Journal of Biological Education, 19, 125-130.

[20]   Creedy, L. J. (1993). Student Understandings of Natural Selection. Research in Science Education, 23, 34-41.

[21]   Cunningham, D. L., & Wescott, D. J. (2009). Still More “Fancy” and “Myth” than “Fact” in Students’ Conceptions of Evolution. Evolution: Education and Outreach, 2, 505-517.

[22]   Dagher, Z. R., & BouJaoude, S. (1997). Scientific Views and Religious Beliefs of College Students: The Case of Biological Evolution. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 34, 429-445.

[23]   Dagher, Z. R., & BouJaoude, S. (2005). Students’ Perceptions of the Nature of Evolutionary Theory. Science Education, 89, 378-391.

[24]   Darwin, C. (1872). On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection (6th ed.). London: Murray.

[25]   Deadman, J. A., & Kelly, P. J. (1978). What Do Secondary School Boys Understand about Evolution and Heredity before They Are Taught the Topics? Journal of Biological Education, 12, 7-15.

[26]   Demastes, S. S., Settlage, J., & Good, R. G. (1995). Students’ Conceptions of Natural Selection and Its Role in Evolution: Cases of Replication and Comparison. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 32, 535-550.

[27]   Dobzhansky, T. (Ed.) (1973). Nothing in Biology Makes Sense Except in the Light of Evolution. American Biology Teacher, 35, 125-129.

[28]   Donnelly, L. A., & Boone, W. J. (2007). Biology Teachers’ Attitudes Toward and Use of Indiana’s Evolution Standards. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 44, 236-257.

[29]   Duit, R., &Treagust, D. F. (2003). Conceptual Change: A Powerful Framework for Improving Science Teaching and Learning. International Journal of Science Education, 25, 671-688.

[30]   Evans, E. M. (2000). The Emergence of Beliefs about the Origins of Species in School-Age Children. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 46, 221-254.

[31]   Evans, E. M. (2001). Cognitive and Contextual Factors in the Emergence of Diverse Belief Systems: Creation versus Evolution. Cognitive Psychology, 42, 217-266.

[32]   Evans, E. M., Spiegel, A. N., Gram, W., Frazier, B. N., Tare, M., Thompson, S. et al. (2010). A Conceptual Guide to Natural History Museum Visitors’ Understanding of Evolution. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 47, 326-353.

[33]   Ferrari, M., & Chi, M. T. H. (1998). The Nature of Naïve Explanations of Natural Selection. International Journal of Science Education, 20, 1231-1256.

[34]   Futuyma, D. J. (1995). Science on Trial: The Case for Evolution. Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates.

[35]   Futuyma, D. J. (1998). Evolutionary Biology (3rd ed.). Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates.

[36]   Geraedts, C. L., & Boersma, K. T. (2006). Reinventing Natural Selection. International Journal of Science Education, 28, 843-870.

[37]   Greene Jr., E. D. (1990). The Logic of University Students’ Misunderstanding of Natural Selection. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 27, 875-885.

[38]   Gregory, T. R. (2009). Understanding Natural Selection: Essential Concepts and Common Misconceptions. Evolution: Education and Outreach, 2, 156-175.

[39]   Guralnick, D. B. (Ed.) (1980). New World Dictionary of the American Language (2nd College ed.). New York: Simon and Schuster.

[40]   Halldén, O. (1988). The Evolution of the Species: Pupil Perspectives and School Perspectives. International Journal of Science Education, 10, 541-552.

[41]   Hokayem, H., & BouJaoude, S. (2008). College Students’ Perceptions of the Theory of Evolution. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 45, 395-419.

[42]   Institute of Education Sciences National Center for Educational Statistics (2010a). Digest of Education Statistics Appendix b: Definitions.

[43]   Institute of Education Sciences National Center for Educational Statistics (2010b). Common Core of Data.

[44]   Institute of Education Sciences National Center for Educational Statistics (2010c). State Education Data Profiles.

[45]   Isaak, M. (2003). Five Major Misconceptions about Evolution. The TalkOrigins Archive.

[46]   Jensen, M. S., & Finley, F. N. (1995). Teaching Evolution Using Historical Arguments in a Conceptual Change Strategy. Science Education, 79, 147-166.

[47]   Jensen, M. S., & Finley, F. N. (1996). Changes in Students’ Understanding of Evolution Resulting from Different Curricular and Instructional Strategies. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 33, 879-900.

[48]   Jiménez-Aleixandre, M. P. (1992). Thinking about Theories or Thinking with Theories? A Classroom Study with Natural Selection. International Journal of Science Education, 14, 51-61.

[49]   Jiménez-Aleixandre, M. P., & Fernández-Pérez, J. (1987). Selection or Adjustment? Explanations of University Biology Students for Natural Selection Problems. In J. D. Novak (Ed.), Proceedings of the Second International Seminar on Misconceptions and Educational Strategies in Science and Mathematics (Vol. 2, pp. 224-232). Ithaca, NY: Department of Education, Cornell University.

[50]   Jungwirth, E. (1975). The Problem of Teleology in Biology as a Problem of Biology Teacher Education. Journal of Biological Education, 9, 243-246.

[51]   Kampourakis, K., & Zogza, V. (2007). Students’ Preconceptions about Evolution: How Accurate Is the Characterization as “Lamarckian” When Considering the History of Evolutionary Thought? Science & Education, 16, 393-422.

[52]   Kampourakis, K., & Zogza, V. (2008). Students’ Intuitive Explanations of the Causes of Homologies and Adaptations. Science & Education, 17, 27-47.

[53]   Kampourakis, K., & Zogza, V. (2009). Preliminary Evolutionary Explanations: A Basic Framework for Conceptual Change and Explanatory Coherence in Evolution. Science & Education, 18, 1313-1340.

[54]   Kelemen, D., & Rosset, E. (2009). The Human Function Compunction: Teleological Explanation in Adults. Cognition, 111, 138-143.

[55]   Lawson, A. E. (1994). Research on the Acquisition of Science Knowledge: Epistemological Foundation of Cognition. In D. I. Gabel (Ed.), Handbook of Research on Science Teaching and Learning (pp. 131-176). New York: Macmillan.

[56]   Lawson, A. E., & Thompson, L. D. (1988). Formal Reasoning Ability and Misconceptions Concerning Genetics and Natural Selection. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 25, 733-746.

[57]   Liu, X. (2004). Using Concept Mapping for Assessing and Promoting Relational Conceptual Change in Science. Science Education, 88, 373-396.

[58]   Lord, T., & Marino, S. (1993). How University Students View the Theory of Evolution. Journal of College Science Teaching, 22, 353-357.

[59]   Losh, S. C., Travani, C. M., Njoroge, R., Wilke, R., & Mcauley, M. (2003). What Does Education Really Do? Educational Dimensions and Pseudoscience Support in American General Public, 1979-2001. Skeptical Inquirer, 27, 30-36.

[60]   Marek, E. A., Carrington, M., Everson, D. P., Johnson, A., & Mescolotto, L. M. (2006). Why We Shouldn’t ‘Teach the Controversy’ in Science. Forum on Public Policy: Forum on Public Policy Online, 3, 7 p.

[61]   Mayr, E. (1982). The Growth of Biological Thought: Diversity, Evolution and Inheritance. Cambridge: Belknap Press of Harvard.

[62]   Mayr, E. (2001). What Evolution Is. New York: Basic Books.

[63]   Mazur, A. (2004). Believers and Disbelievers in Evolution. Politics and the Life Sciences, 23, 55-61.

[64]   McComas, W. F. (2006). Investigating Evolutionary Biology in the Laboratory. Dubuque, IA: Kendall/Hunt.

[65]   Mead, L. S., & Scott, E. C. (2010a). Problem Concepts in Evolution Part I: Purpose and Design. Evolution: Education and Outreach, 3, 78-81.

[66]   Mead, L. S., & Scott, E. C. (2010b). Problem Concepts in Evolution Part II: Cause and Chance. Evolution: Education and Outreach, 3, 261-264.

[67]   Meir, E., Perry, J., Herron, J. C., & Kingsolver, J. (2007). College Students’ Misconceptions about Evolutionary Trees. American Biology Teacher, 69, e71-e76.

[68]   Mintzes, J. J., & Wandersee, J. H. (1998). Research in Science Teaching and Learning: A Human Constructivist View. In J. J. Mintzes, J. H. Wandersee, & J. D. Novak (Eds.), Teaching Science for Understanding: A Human Constructivist View (pp. 59-92). San Diego, CA: Academic Press.

[69]   Mintzes, J. J., Wandersee, J. H., & Novak, J. D. (2001). Assessing Understanding in Biology. Journal of Biological Education, 35, 118-124.

[70]   Modell, H., Michael, J., & Wenderoth, M. P. (2005). Helping the Learner to Learn: The Role of Uncovering Misconceptions. American Biology Teacher, 67, 20-26.

[71]   Morrison, J. A., & Lederman, N. G. (2003). Science Teachers’ Diagnosis and Understanding of Students’ Preconceptions. Science Education, 87, 849-867.

[72]   National Academy of Sciences (1998). Teaching about Evolution and the Nature of Science. Washington DC: National Academy Press.

[73]   National Academies of Science (NAS) (2008). Science, Evolution, and Creationism. Washington DC: The National Academies Press.

[74]   National Research Council (NRC) (1996). National Science Education Standards. Washington DC: National Academy Press.

[75]   National Research Council Committee on Undergraduate Science Education (1997). Science Teaching Reconsidered: A Handbook. Washington DC: National Academy Press.

[76]   Nehm, R. H., Poole, T. M., Lyford, M. E., Hoskins, S. G., Carruth, L., Ewers, B. E. et al. (2009). Does the Segregation of Evolution in Biology Textbooks and Introductory Courses Reinforce Students’ Faulty Mental Models of Biology and Evolution? Evolution: Education and Outreach, 2, 527-532.

[77]   Nehm, R. H., & Reilly, L. (2007). Biology Majors’ Knowledge and Misconceptions of Natural Selection. BioScience, 57, 263-272.

[78]   Nehm, R. H., & Schonfeld, I. S. (2007). Does Increasing Biology Teacher Knowledge of Evolution and the Nature of Science Lead to Greater Preference for the Teaching of Evolution in Schools? Journal of Science Teacher Education, 18, 699-723.

[79]   Nelson, C. E. (2008). Teaching Evolution (and All of Biology) More Effectively: Strategies for Engagement, Critical Reasoning, and Confronting Misconceptions. In Evolution vs. Creationism in the Classroom: Evolving Student Attitudes Symposium (pp. 213-225). New York: Oxford University Press.

[80]   Novak, J. D. (2002). Meaningful Learning: The Essential Factor for Conceptual Change in Limited or Inappropriate Propositional Hierarchies Leading to Empowerment of Learners. Science Education, 86, 548-571.

[81]   Oklahoma State Department of Education (2009a). 2009-2010 Oklahoma Directory of Education. Oklahoma City, OK: Oklahoma State Department of Education.

[82]   Oklahoma State Department of Education (2009b). Graduation—Oklahoma Requirements for High School.

[83]   Oklahoma State Department of Education (2009c). Priority Academic Student Skills.

[84]   Palmer, D. H. (1999). Exploring the Link between Students’ Scientific and Nonscientific Conceptions. Science Education, 83, 639-653.

[85]   Passmore, C., & Stewart, J. (2002). A Modeling Approach to Teaching Evolutionary Biology in High Schools. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 39, 185-204.

[86]   Paz-y-Mińo, C. G., & Espinosa, A. (2009). Assessment of Biology Majors’ versus Nonmajors’ Views on Evolution, Creationism, and Intelligent Design. Evolution: Education and Outreach, 2, 75-83.

[87]   Pedersen, S., & Halldén, O. (1992). Intuitive Ideas and Scientific Explanations as Parts of Students’ Developing Understanding of Biology: The Case of Evolution. European Journal of Psychology of Education, 9, 127-137.

[88]   Petto, A. J., & Mead, L. S. (2008). Misconceptions about the Evolution of Complexity. Evolution: Education and Outreach, 1, 505-508.

[89]   Prinou, L., Halkia, L., & Skordoulis, C. (2008). What Conceptions Do Greek School Students Form about Biological Evolution? Evolution: Education and Outreach, 1, 312-317.

[90]   Ridley, M. (1996). Evolution (2nd ed.). Cambridge: Blackwell Scientific.

[91]   Robbins, J. R., & Roy, P. (2007). The Natural Selection: Indentifying and Correcting Non-Science Student Preconceptions through an Inquiry-Based, Critical Approach to Evolution. American Biology Teacher, 69, 460-466.

[92]   Rutledge, M. L., & Warden, M. A. (2002). High School Biology Teachers’ Knowledge Structure, Acceptance, and Teaching of Evolution. American Biology Teacher, 64, 21-28.

[93]   Sadler, T. D. (2005). Evolutionary Theory as a Guide to Socioscientific Decision Making. Journal of Biological Education, 39, 68-72.

[94]   Samarapungavan, A., & Wiers, R. W. (1997). Children’s Thoughts on the Origin of Species: A Study of Explanatory Coherence. Cognitive Science, 21, 147-177.

[95]   Scott, E. C. (2004). Evolution vs. Creationism: An Introduction. Los Angeles, CA: University of California.

[96]   Settlage, J. (1994). Conceptions of Natural Selection: A Snapshot of the Sense-Making Process. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 31, 449-457.

[97]   Shermer, M. (2006). Why Darwin Matters. New York: Henry Holt and Company.

[98]   Shtulman, A. (2006). Qualitative Differences between Na?ve and Scientific Theories of Evolution. Cognitive Psychology, 52, 170-194.

[99]   Sinatra, G. M., Brem, S. K., & Evans, E. M. (2008). Changing Minds? Implications of Conceptual Change for Teaching and Learning about Biological Evolution. Evolution: Education and Outreach, 1, 189-195.

[100]   Smith, C. M., & Sullivan, C. (2007). The Top 10 Myths about Evolution. Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books.

[101]   Southerland, S. A., Abrams, E., Cummins, C. L., & Anzelmo, J. (2001). Understanding Students’ Explanations of Biological Phenomena: Conceptual Frameworks or P-Prims? Science Education, 85, 328-348.

[102]   Spindler, L. H., & Doherty, J. H. (2009). Assessment of the Teaching of Evolution by Natural Selection through a Hands-On Simulation. Teaching Issues and Experiments in Ecology, 6, 1-20.

[103]   Stern, L., & Ben-Akiva, I. (2007). Tails’ Inheritance: Challenging Secondary School Students’ Ideas about the Inheritance of Acquired Traits. American Biology Teacher, 69, 76-79.

[104]   Sundberg, M. D., & Dini, M. L. (1993). Science Majors vs. Nonmajors: Is There a Difference? Journal of College Science Teaching, 22, 299-304.

[105]   Tamir, P., & Zohar, A. (1991). Anthropomorphism and Teleology in Reasoning about Biological Phenomena. Science Education, 75, 57-67.

[106]   Trowbridge, J. E., & Wandersee, J. H. (1994). Identifying Critical Junctures in Learning in a College Course on Evolution. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 31, 459-473.

[107]   U.S. Census Bureau (2009). American Community Survey.

[108]   U.S. Census Bureau (2010). Regions and Divisions.

[109]   Wandersee, J. H., Mintzes, J. J., & Novak, J. D. (1994). Research in Alternative Conceptions in Science: Part II Learning. In D. L. Gabel (Ed.), Handbook of Research on Science Teaching and Learning (pp. 177-210). New York: Macmillan.

[110]   Weld, J., & McNew, J. C. (1999). Attitudes toward Evolution. Science Teacher, 66, 27-31.

[111]   Wescott, D. J., & Cunningham, D. L. (2005). Recognizing Student Misconceptions about Science and Evolution. Mountain Rise, 2, 1-8.

[112]   Wilson, J. A. (2001). Pseudoscientific Beliefs among College Students. Reports of the National Center for Science Education, 21, 9-13.

[113]   Yates, T., & Marek, E. A. (2011). A Regional Study of the Types and Prevalence of Biological Evolution-Related Misconceptions Held by Public Secondary School Biology Teachers. International Conference of the National Association for Researchers in Science Teaching, Orlando, 3-6 April 2011.