OJN  Vol.4 No.12 , November 2014
Shared Decision-Making after Implementation of the Chronic Care Model (CCM)—An Evaluative Approach
Abstract: Background: In paternalistic models, healthcare providers’ responsibility is to decide what is best for patients. The main concern is that such models fail to respect patient autonomy and do not promote patient responsibility. Aim: To evaluate mental healthcare team members’ perceptions of their own role in encouraging elderly persons to participate in shared decision-making after implementation of the CCM. The CCM is not an explanatory theory, but an evidence-based guideline and synthesis of best available evidence. Methods: Data were collected from two teams that took part in a focus group interview, and the transcript was analysed by means of qualitative thematic analysis. Results: One overall theme emerged—Preventing the violation of human dignity based on three themes, namely, Changing understanding and attitudes, Increasing depressed elderly persons’ autonomy and Clarifying the mental healthcare team coordinator’s role and responsibility. The results of this study reveal that until recently, paternalism has been the dominant decision-making model within healthcare, without any apparent consideration of the patient perspective. Community mental healthcare can be improved by shared decision-making in which team members initiate a dialogue focusing on patient participation to prevent the violation of human dignity. However, in order to determine how best to empower the patient, team members need expert knowledge and intuition.
Cite this paper: Holm, A. , Lyberg, A. , Berggren, I. and Severinsson, E. (2014) Shared Decision-Making after Implementation of the Chronic Care Model (CCM)—An Evaluative Approach. Open Journal of Nursing, 4, 824-835. doi: 10.4236/ojn.2014.412088.

[1]   World Health Organization (2001) Mental Health: New Understanding, New Hope. World Health Report, Geneva.

[2]   Charles, C., Gafni, A. and Whelan, T. (1997) Shared Decision Making in the Medical Encounter: What Does It Mean? (Or, It Takes at Least Two to Tango). Social Science & Medicine, 44, 681-692.

[3]   Whitney, S.N., McGuire, A.L. and McCullough, L.B. (2003) A Typology of Shared Decision Making, Informed Consent, and Simple Consent. Annual of Internal Medicine, 140, 54-59.

[4]   Flottorp, S.A., Jamtvedt, G., Gibis, B. and McKee, M. (2008) Using Audit and Feedback to Health Professionals to Improve the Quality and Safety of Health Care.

[5]   Davidson, L. (2005) Recovery, Self-Management and the Expert Patient Perspective. Journal of Mental Health, 1, 25-35.

[6]   Cribb, A. and Entwistle, V.A. (2011) Shared Decision Making: Trade-Offs between Narrower and Broader Conceptions. Health Expectation, 14, 210-219.

[7]   Drake, R.E. and Deegan, P.E. (2009) Shared Decision Making Is an Ethical Imperative. Psychiatric Services, 60, 1007.

[8]   Koch, T., Jenkin, P. and Kralik, D. (2004) Chronic Illness Self-Management: Locating the “Self”. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 48, 484-492.

[9]   Loh, A., Simon, D., Wills, Kriston, I., Niebling, W. and Härter, M. (2007) The Effects of a Shared Decision-Making Intervention in Primary Care of Depression: A Cluster-Randomized Controlled Trial. Patient Education and Counselling, 67, 324-332.

[10]   Patel, S.R. and Bakken, S. (2010) Preferences for Participation in Decision-Making among Ethnically Diverse Patients with Anxiety and Depression. Community Mental Health Journal, 46, 466-473.

[11]   International Council of Nurses (ICN) (2000) Code of Ethics for Nurses. ICN, Geneva.

[12]   Tee, S., Lathlean, J., Herbert, L., Coldham, T., East, B. and Johnson, T.J. (2007) User Participation in Mental Health Nurse Decision-Making: A Co-Operative Enquiry. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 60, 135-145.

[13]   Marshall, S.S., Haywood, K.L. and Fitzpatrick, R. (2005) Patient Involvement and Collaboration in Shared Decision Making: A Structured Review to Inform Chronic Disease Management. Report from the Patient-Reported Health Instruments Group to the Department of Health.

[14]   Wagner, E.H., Glasgow, R.E., Davis, C., Bonomi, A.E., Provost, L., McCulloch, D., Carver, P. and Sixta, C. (2001) Quality Improvement in Chronic Illness Care: A Collaborative Approach. Joint Commission Journal on Quality Improvement, 27, 63-80.

[15]   Holm, A.L. and Severinsson, E. (2013) Surviving Depressive Ill-Health: A Systematic Qualitative Review of Older Persons’ Narratives. Nursing & Health Sciences, 16, 131-140.

[16]   Holm, A.L. and Severinsson, E. (2013) Interdisciplinary Team Collaboration during Discharge of Depressed Older Persons—A Norwegian Qualitative Implementation Study. Nursing Research and Practice, 2013, Article ID: 794743.

[17]   Holm, A.L. and Severinsson, E. (2013) Reflections on the Ethical Dilemmas Involved in Promoting Self-Management. Nursing Ethics, 21, 402-413.

[18]   Lyberg, A., Holm, A.L., Lassenius, E., Berggren, I. and Severinsson, E. (2013) Older Persons’ Experiences of Depressive Ill-Health and Family Support. Nursing Research and Practice, 2013, Article ID: 837529.

[19]   Unützer, J., Rubenstein, L., Katon, W.J., Tang, L.Q., Duan, N.H., Lagomasino, I.T. and Wells, K.B. (2001) Two-Year Effects of Quality Improvement Programs on Medication Management for Depression. JAMA Psychiatry, 58, 935-942.

[20]   Wagner, E.H., Austin, B.T., Davis, C., Hindrash, M., Schaefer, J. and Bonomi, A. (2001) Improving Chronic Illness Care: Translating Evidence into Action. Health Affairs, 20, 64-78.

[21]   Coulter, A., Parsons, S. and Askham, J. (2008) Where Are the Patients in Decision-Making about Their Own Care? World Health Organization, World Health Organization 2008 and World Health Organizaiton, on Behalf of the European Observatory Health Systems and Policies 2008.

[22]   Holm, A.L. and Severinsson, E. (2012) Chronic Care Model for the Management of Depression: Synthesis of Barriers to, and Facilitators of Success. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 21, 513-523.

[23]   Holm, A.L., Lyberg, A., Lassenius, E., Berggren, I. and Severinsson, E. (2013) Older Persons’ Lived Experiences of Depression and Self-Management. Issues in Mental Health Nursing, 34, 757-764.

[24]   Park, E.J. (2012) An Integrated Ethical Decision-Making Model for Nurses. Nursing Ethics, 19, 139-159.

[25]   Simon, J.S., Aguar, L., Kunz, N.R. and Lei, D. (2004) Extended-Release Venlafaxine in Relapse Prevention for Patients with Major Depressive Disorder. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 38, 249-257.

[26]   Stacey, D., Menard, P., Gaboury, I., Jacobsen, M., Sharif, F., Ritchie, L. and Bunn, H. (2008) Decision-Making Needs of Patients with Depression: A Descriptive Study. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 15, 287-295.

[27]   Van de Bovenkamp, H. and Trappenburg, M. (2009) Reconsidering Patient Participation in Guideline Development. Health Care Analysis, 17, 198-216.

[28]   Church, J., Saunders, D., Wanke, M., Pong, R., Spooner, C. and Dorgan, M. (2002) Citizen Participation in Health Decision-Making: Past Experience and Future Prospects. Journal of Public Health Policy, 23, 12-32.

[29]   Polit, D.F. and Beck, C.T. (2012) Nursing Research: Generating and Assessing Evidence for Nursing Practice. Wolters Kluwer Health, Philadelphia.

[30]   Rolfe, G. (2005) Validity, Trustworthiness and Rigour: Quality and the Idea of Qualitative Research. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 53, 304-310.

[31]   Liamputtong, P. (2011) Focus Group Methodology Principles and Practice. Sage, London.

[32]   Rolfe, G. (2005) The Deconstructing Angel: Nursing, Reflection and Evidence-Based Practice. Nursing Inquiry, 12, 78-86.

[33]   Rolfe, G. (2006) Judgements without Rules: Towards a Postmodern Ironist Concept of Research Validity. Nursing Inquiry, 13, 7-15.

[34]   Denzin, N.K. and Lincoln, Y.S. (1994) Handbook of Qualitative Research. Sage Publications, London.

[35]   Bryman, A. and Burgess, R.G. (1994) Analyzing Qualitative Data. Routledge, London.

[36]   Rithcie, J. and Lewis, J. (2003) Qualitative Research Practice: A Guide for Social Science Students and Researchers. Sage, London.

[37]   Pope, C., Ziebland, S. and Mays, N. (2000) Qualitative Research in Health Care. Analysing Qualitative Data. British Medical Journal, 320, 114-116.

[38]   Sandelowski, M. (2001) Focus on Research Methods. Whatever Happened to Qualitative Description? Research in Nursing & Health, 23, 334-340.<334::AID-NUR9>3.0.CO;2-G

[39]   Polit, D.F. and Beck, C.T. (2010) Essentials of Nursing Research: Appraising Evidence for Nursing Practice. Wolters Kluwer/Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Philadelphia.

[40]   World Medical Association (2008) Declaration of Helsinki. Ethical Principles for Medical Research Involving Human Subjects, 2008.

[41]   Tee, S.R. and Lathlean, J.A. (2004) The Ethics of Conducting a Cooperative Inquiry with Vulnerable People. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 47, 536-543.

[42]   Northern Nurses’ Federation (NNF) (2003) Ethical Guidelines for Nursing Research in the Nordic Countries.

[43]   Barker, P. (2011) Mental Health Ethics: The Human Context. Routledge, Abingdon.

[44]   Clever, S.I., Ford, D.E., Rubenstein, L.V., Rost, K.M., Meredith, L.S., Sherbourne, C.D., et al. (2006) Primary Care Patients’ Involvement in Decision-Making Is Associated with Improvement in Depression. Medical Care, 44, 398-405.

[45]   Montori, V.M., Gafni, A. and Charled, C. (2006) A Shared Treatment Decision-Making Approach between Patients with Chronic Conditions and Their Clinicians: The Case of Diabetes. Health Expectations, 9, 25-36.

[46]   Ofstad, H. (1961) An Inquiry into the Freedom of Decision. Norwegian Universities Press, Oslo.

[47]   Henriksen, E. and Rosenqvist, U. (2003) Contradictions in Elderly Care: A Descriptive Study of Politicians’ and Managers’ Understanding of Elderly Care. Health & Social Care in the Community, 11, 27-35.

[48]   Beauchamp, T.L. and Childress, J. (2013) Principles of Biomedical Ethics. 7th Edition, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

[49]   Birmingham, J. (2009) Patient Choice in the Discharge Planning Process. Professional Case Management, 14, 296-309.

[50]   Spence, K. (2011) Ethical Advocacy Based on Caring: A Model for Neonatal and Paediatric Nurses. Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health, 47, 642-645.

[51]   Martinsen, K. and Eriksson, K. (2009) To See and to Realize, through Various Forms of Evidence. Akribe, Oslo. (In Swedish and Norwegian)

[52]   Magnusson, A., Severinsson, E. and Lützèn, K. (2003) Reconstructing Mental Health Nursing in Home Care. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 43, 351-359.

[53]   Berggren, I. and Severinsson, E. (2003) Nurse Supervisors’ Actions in Relation to Their Decision-Making Style and Ethical Approach to Clinical Supervision. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 41, 615-622.

[54]   Bégat, I.B. and Severinsson, E. (2001) Nurses’ Reflections on Episodes Occurring during Their Provision of Care—An Interview Study. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 38, 71-77.

[55]   Berggren, I. (2005) Ethics in Clinical Nursing Supervision. An Analysis of Fundamental Ethical Issues of Clinical Nursing Supervision, with Special Reference to Ethical Decision Making. University of Oslo, Oslo. (Dissertation)

[56]   Cornelissen, E., Mitton, C. and Sheps, S. (2011) Knowledge Translation in the Discourse of Professional Practice. International Journal of Evidence Based Healthcare, 9, 184-188.

[57]   Erikson, K. (2006) The Suffering Human Being. Nordic Studies Press, Chicago.

[58]   Redman, B.K. (2005) The Ethics of Self-Management Preparation for Chronic Illness. Nursing Ethics, 12, 361-369.

[59]   Hoffman, T.C., Légaré, F., McNamara, K., McCaffery, K., Trevena, L.J., Hudson, B., Glasziou, P.P. and Del Mar, C.B. (2014) Shared Decision Making: What Do Clinicians Need to Know and Why Should They Bother? Medical Journal of Australia, 201, 35-39.

[60]   Kitzinger, J. (2005) Focus Group Research: Using Group Dynamics to Explore Perceptions, Experiences and Understandings. In: Holloway, I., Ed., Qualitative Research in Health Care, Open University Press, Berkshire, 56-70.

[61]   Smithson, J. (2008) Focus Groups. In: Alasuutari, P., Bickman, L. and Brannen, J., Eds., Handbook of Social Research Methods, Sage, Thousand Oaks, 357-430.

[62]   Morgan, D.L. (2002) Focus Group Interviewing. In: Gubrium, J.F. and Holstein, J.A., Eds., Handbook of Interviewing Research: Context & Method, Sage, Thousand Oaks, 141-159.

[63]   Hopkins, P.E. (2007) Thinking Critically and Creatively about Focus Groups. Area, 39, 528-535.