JWARP  Vol.6 No.15 , November 2014
Problems in Water Environmental Control—Sense and Nonsense in Measurement of Water Protection
Abstract: Water environmental control and process refinement inside a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) is fundamentally based on sampling, analysis and on-line measurements on water and sludge streams. The problems related to an accurate and reliable control and thus an efficient water protection are addressed in the following. Four different crucial points whenever a sampling and control scheme is planned: 1) Where should a sampling and on-line measurement take place? 2) When should sampling take place? 3) How should the sampling and on-line measurement take place? 4) Which variables should be controlled? Examples are given from different plants demonstrating ways to address the questions. Especially the relevance of the adopted parameter BOD (Biochemical Oxygen Demand) is discussed. It is finally suggested to even abandon the use of BOD as consent variable in favor of on-line measurement of Suspended Solids, Nitrogen and Phosphorous.
Cite this paper: Morling, S. (2014) Problems in Water Environmental Control—Sense and Nonsense in Measurement of Water Protection. Journal of Water Resource and Protection, 6, 1381-1389. doi: 10.4236/jwarp.2014.615127.

[1]   European Union (1991) Council Directive 91/271/EEC Concerning Urban Waste Water Treatment.

[2]   Alcontrol Analysis Protocols.

[3]   Olsson, U. (2005) Confidence Intervals for the Mean of a Log-Normal Distribution. Journal of Statistics Education, 13.

[4]   Morling, S. (2001) Performance of an SBR-Plant for Advanced Nutrient Removal, Using Septic Sludge as a Carbon Source. Water, Science and Technology, 43, 131-138.

[5]   Morling, S. (2008) Nitrogen Removal Efficiency and Nitrification Rates at the Sequencing Batch Reactor in NowyTarg, Poland. VATTEN, 2.

[6]   Karlsson, I. (1996) Environmental and Energy Efficiency of Different Sewage Treatment Systems. Water, Science and Technology, 34, 203-211.

[7]   Helsinki Commission (2007) Background Information on Costs for the Revised Proposal from Sweden Concerning More Stringent Demands Regarding Discharges of Phosphorus from Waste Water Treatment Plants.

[8]   Umble, A.K. (2010) Nutrients and Technologies That Remove Them. Indiana Water Environment Association.