NR  Vol.5 No.10 , July 2014
Ecosystem-Based and Community-Based Model Integration to Designate Coral Reef No-Take Marine Protected Areas: A Case Study from Puerto Rico
ABSTRACT
Ecosystem-based management and community-based participation in governance of Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) have been identified as key elements to improve management success, local stakeholder support, and compliance with regulations. However, both are often rarely achieved, resulting in poor MPA governance, support and success. A quantitative assessment of the spatio- temporal change (1997-2012) of coral reef fish communities within Arrecifes La Cordillera Natural Reserve in northeastern Puerto Rico was carried out. We also identified community expectations of and support for the designation of a network of small no-take MPAs within the reserve’s boundaries. A holistic approach employing biophysical and socioeconomic methods was used as part of a participatory model to identify priorities for the designation of candidate no-take MPAs. Populations of the most important fishery-targeted species showed a significant temporal decline, particularly in areas subjected to intense recreational activities and spearfishing. Most groupers (Serranidae), snappers (Lutjanidae), barracudas (Sphyraenidae), and some parrotfishes (Scaridae) were nearly absent at most sites. Most individuals belonged to smaller size categories. Herbivores represented the majority of the total fish biomass, suggesting strong fishing impacts on apex predators. Fish declines also occurred after two massive coral bleaching events in 1998 and 2005 that were followed by mass coral mortalities, suggesting combined negative impacts of fishing and climate change. A no-take MPA designation was supported by 80% of the artisanal fishermen, 73% of the concessionaires (i.e., SCUBA diving, charter boats), and 52% of registered vessel operators. Stakeholders agreed that coral reef conditions in the reserve had declined over time, as well as water quality which affected reef health and fisheries. Stakeholders did not recognize climate change and sea surface warming as threats to coral reefs and fisheries. Nonetheless, stakeholder perceptions of candidate no-take MPA sites remarkably matched those identified through fish counts. This study also highlighted the pervasive views held by many stake-holders concerning MPA management and enforcement, and recommended that any no-take MPA designation process considers improving stakeholder participation, understanding of management objectives, actions, and accomplishments, and building stakeholders trust. The integration of ecosystem-based and community-based participatory models may be critical to foster improved support of no-take MPAs and foster a long-term community-based integration to develop and implement mitigation strategies for climate change impacts in novel future scenarios.

Cite this paper
Hernández-Delgado, E. , Shivlani, M. and Sabat, A. (2014) Ecosystem-Based and Community-Based Model Integration to Designate Coral Reef No-Take Marine Protected Areas: A Case Study from Puerto Rico. Natural Resources, 5, 538-560. doi: 10.4236/nr.2014.510049.
References
[1]   Roberts, C.M. and Polunin, N.V.C. (1993) Marine Reserves: Simple Solutions to Managing Complex Fisheries? AMBIO, 22, 363-368.

[2]   Roberts, C.M. (1995) Rapid Build-Up of Fish Biomass in a Caribbean Marine Reserve. Conservation Biology, 9, 815826.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1046/j.1523-1739.1995.09040815.x

[3]   Bohnsack, J.A. (1998) Application of Marine Reserves to Reef Fisheries Management. Australian Journal of Ecology, 23, 298-304.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1442-9993.1998.tb00734.x

[4]   Roberts, C.M., Bohnsack, J.A., Gell, F., Hawkins, J.P. and Goodridge, R. (2001) Effects of Marine Reserves on Adjacent Fisheries. Science, 294, 1920-1923.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/science.294.5548.1920

[5]   Roberts, C.M., Branch, G., Bustamante, R.H., Castilla, J.C., Dugan, J., Halpern, B.S., Lafferty, K.D., Leslie, H., Lubchenco, J., McArdle, D., Ruckelshaus, M. and Warner, R.R. (2003) Application of Ecological Criteria in Selecting Marine Reserves and Developing Reserve Networks. Ecological Applications, 13, S215-S228.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1890/1051-0761(2003)013[0215:AOECIS]2.0.CO;2

[6]   McClanahan, T.R., Marmane, M.J., Cinner, J.E. and Kiene, W.E. (2006) A Comparison of Marine Protected Areas and Alternative Approaches to Coral-Reef Management. Current Biology, 16, 1408-1413.

[7]   Stobart, B., Warwick, R., González, C., Mallol, S., Díaz, D., Renones, O. and Goni, R. (2009) Long-Term and Spillover Effects of a Marine Protected Area on an Exploited Fish Community. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 384, 47-60.
http://dx.doi.org/10.3354/meps08007

[8]   Burke, L. and Maidens, J. (2004) Reefs at Risk in the Caribbean. WRI, Washington DC.

[9]   Hawkins, J.P. and Roberts, C.M. (2004) Effects of Artisanal Fishing on Caribbean Coral Reefs. Conservation Biology, 18, 215-226.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1523-1739.2004.00328.x

[10]   Paddack, M.J., Reynolds, J.D., Aguilar, C., Appeldoorn, R.S., Beets, J., Burkett, E.W., Chittaro, P.M., Clarke, K., Esteves, R., Fonseca, A.C., Forrester, G.E., Friedlander, A.M., García-Sais, J., González-Sansón, G., Jordan, L.K.B., McClellan, D.B., Miller, M.W., Molloy, P.P., Mumby, P.J., Nagelkerken, I., Nemeth, M., Navas-Camacho, R., Pitt, J., Polunin, N.V.C., Reyes-Nivia, M.C., Robertson, D.R., Rodríguez-Ramírez, A., Salas, E., Williams, I.D., Wormald, C.L., Watkinson, A.R. and Coté, I.M. (2009) Recent Region-Wide Declines in Caribbean Reef Fish Abundance. Current Biology, 19, 1-6.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2009.02.041

[11]   Jones, G.P., McCormick, M.I., Srinivasan, M., Eagle, J.V. and Paine, R.T. (2004) Coral Decline Threatens Fish Biodiversity in Marine Reserves. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 101, 8251-8253.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0401277101

[12]   Pratchett, M.S., Munday, P.L., Wilson, S.K., Graham, N.A.J., Cinner, J.E., Bellwood, D.R., Jones, G.P., Polunin, N.V.C. and McClanahan, T.R. (2008) Effects of Climate-Induced Coral Bleaching on Coral-Reef Fishes—Ecological and Economic Consequences. Oceanography and Marine Biology: An Annual Review, 46, 251-296.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1201/9781420065756.ch6

[13]   Pratchett, M.S., Hoey, A.S. and Wilson, S.K. (2014) Reef Degradation and the Loss of Critical Ecosystem Goods and Services Provided by Coral Reef Fishes. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 7, 37-43.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cosust.2013.11.022

[14]   Selig, E.R., Casey, K.S. and Bruno, J.F. (2012) Temperature-Driven Coral Decline: The Role of Marine Protected Areas. Global Change Biology, 18, 1561-1570.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2486.2012.02658.x

[15]   Appeldoorn, R.S. and Lindeman, K.C. (2003) A Caribbean-Wide Survey of Marine Reserves: Spatial Coverage and Attributes of Effectiveness. Gulf and Caribbean Research, 14, 139-154.

[16]   Aguilar-Perera, A., Scharer, M. and Valdés-Pizzini, M. (2006) Marine Protected Areas in Puerto Rico: Historical and Current Perspectives. Ocean and Coastal Management, 49, 961-975.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2006.08.011

[17]   Montilla-Despiau, I. (2012) Evaluación Rápida del Arrecife de Isla Verde e Impactos Ambientales Presentes. M.Sc. Thesis, Environmental Affairs Graduate School, Universidad Metropolitana, San Juan, 1-132.

[18]   Matos-Caraballo, D. (2009) Lessons Learned from the Puerto Rico’s Commercial Fishery, 1988-2008. Proceedings of the Gulf and Caribbean Fisheries Institute, 61, 123-129.

[19]   Hernández-Delgado, E.A. and Sabat, A.M. (2000) Ecological Status of Essential Fish Habitats through an Anthropogenic Environmental Stress Gradient in Puerto Rican Coral Reefs. Proceedings of the Gulf and Caribbean Fisheries Institute, 51, 457-470.

[20]   Bejarano-Rodríguez, I. (2006) Relationships between Reef Fish Communities, Water and Habitat Quality on Coral Reefs. M.Sc. Thesis, University of Puerto Rico, Mayagüez, 51.

[21]   Hernández-Delgado, E.A. (2000) Effects of Anthropogenic Stress Gradients in the Structure of Coral Reef Epibenthic and Fish Communities. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Puerto Rico, San Juan, 330.

[22]   Alcala, A.C., Bucol, A.A. and Nillos-Kleiven, P. (2008) Directory of MarineReserves in the Visayas, Philippines. Foundation for the Philippine Environment and Silliman University-Angelo King Center for Research and Environmental Management (SUAKCREM), Dumaguete City, 1-178.

[23]   Bohnsack, J.A. and Bannerot, S.P. (1986) A Stationary Visual Census Technique for Quantitatively Assessing Community Structure of Coral Reef Fishes. NOAA Technical Report NMFS, 41, 1-15.

[24]   Shannon, C.E. and Weaver, W. (1948) The Mathematical Theory of Communication. University of Illinois Press, Urbana, 1-117.

[25]   Pielou, E.C. (1966) The Measurement of Diversity in Different Types of Biological Collections. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 13, 131-144.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0022-5193(66)90013-0

[26]   Clarke, K.R. and Warwick, R.M. (2001) Change in Marine Communities: An Approach to Statistical Analysis and Interpretation. 2nd Edition, PRIMER-E, Ltd., Plymouth Marine Laboratory, Plymouth.

[27]   Anderson, M.J., Gorley, R.N. and Clarke, K.R. (2008) PERMANOVA for PRIMER: Guide to Software and Statistical Methods. PRIMER-E, Plymouth.

[28]   Bray, J.R. and Curtis, J.T. (1957) An Ordination of the Upland Forest Communities of Southern Wisconsin. Ecological Monographs, 27, 325-349.
http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/1942268

[29]   Agar, J.J., Waters, J.R., Valdés-Pizzini, M., Shivlani, M., Murray, T., Kirkley, J.E. and Suman, D. (2008) US Caribbean Fish Trap Fishery Socioeconomic Study. Bulletin of Marine Science, 82, 315-331.

[30]   United States National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) (2001) Benthic habitats of Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands. CD ROM, NOAA, National Ocean Service, National Centers for Coastal Ocean Science Biogeography Program, Silver Spring.

[31]   CSA Group (2005) Evaluación, Delimitación y Análisis de los Usos en los Habitáculos Marinos Dentro de la Reserva Natural Arrecifes La Cordillera. Informe Final al Departamento de Recursos Naturales y Ambientales, 1-125.

[32]   Departamento de Recursos Naturales y Ambientales (DRNA) (2007) Plan de Manejo de la Reserva Natural Arrecifes de La Cordillera, Fajardo. PR Department of Natural and Environmental Resources, San Juan, 1-88.

[33]   Salm, R.V., Clark, J. and Siirila, E. (2000) Marine and Coastal Protected Areas: A Guide for Planners and Managers. 3rd Edition, International Union for the Conservation of Nature, Washington DC.
http://dx.doi.org/10.2305/IUCN.CH.2000.13.en

[34]   Russ, G.R. and Alcala, A.C. (1989) Effects of Intense Fishing Pressure on an Assemblage of Coral Reef Fishes. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 56, 13-27.
http://dx.doi.org/10.3354/meps056013

[35]   Scheffer, M., Carpenter, S. and De Young, B. (2005) Cascading Effects of Overfishing Marine Systems. Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 20, 579-581.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2005.08.018

[36]   Jones, E., Gray, T. and Umponstira, C. (2009) The Impact of Artisanal Fishing on Coral Reef Fish Health in Hat Thai Mueang, Phang-Nga Province, Southern Thailand. Marine Policy, 33, 544-552.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2008.12.003

[37]   Stallings, C.D. (2009) Fishery-Independent Data Reveal Negative Effect of Human Population Density on Caribbean Predatory Fish Communities. PLoS ONE, 4, e5333.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0005333

[38]   McManus, J.W., Menez, L.A.B., Kesner-Reyes, K.N., Vergara, S.G. and Ablan, M.C. (2000) Coral Reef Fishing and Coral-Algal Phase Shifts: Implications for Global Reef Status. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 57, 572-578.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1006/jmsc.2000.0720

[39]   O’Leary, J.K., Potts, D.C., Braga, J.C. and McClanahan, T.R. (2012) Indirect Consequences of Fishing: Reduction of Coralline Algae Suppresses Juvenile Coral Abundance. Coral Reefs, 31, 547-559.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00338-012-0872-5

[40]   Rogers, C.S. and Miller, J. (2006) Permanent “Phase Shifts” or Reversible Declines in Coral Cover? Lack of Recovery of Two Coral Reefs in St. John, US Virgin Islands. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 306, 103-114.
http://dx.doi.org/10.3354/meps306103

[41]   Miller, J., Muller, E., Rogers, C., Waara, R., Atkinson, A., Whelan, K.R.T., Patterson, M. and Witcher, B. (2009) Coral Disease Following Massive Bleaching in 2005 Causes 60% Decline in Coral Cover on Reefs in the US Virgin Islands. Coral Reefs, 28, 925-937.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00338-009-0531-7

[42]   Eakin, C.M., Morgan, J.A., Smith, T.B., Liu, G., Alvarez-Filip, L., Baca, B., Bouchon, C., Brandt, M., Bruckner, A., Cameron, A., Carr, L., Chiappone, M., James, M., Crabbe, C., Day, O., De la Guardia-Llanso, E., DiResta, D., Gilliam, D., Ginsburg, R., Gore, S., Guzmán, H., Hernández-Delgado, E.A., Husain, E., Jeffrey, C., Jones, R., Jordán-Dahlgren, E., Kramer, P., Lang, J., Lirman, D., Mallela, J., Manfrino, C., Maréchal, J.P., Mihaly, J., Miller, J., Mueller, E., Muller, E., Noordeloos, M., Oxenford, H., Ponce-Taylor, D., Quinn, N., Ritchie, K., Rodríguez, S., Rodríguez-Ramírez, A., Romano, S., Samhouri, J., Schmahl, G., Steiner, S., Taylor, M., Walsh, S., Weil, E. and Williams, E. (2010) Caribbean Corals in Crisis: Record Thermal Stress, Bleaching and Mortality in 2005. Plos ONE, 5, e13969.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0013969

[43]   Hernández-Pacheco, R., Hernández-Delgado, E.A. and Sabat, A.M. (2011) Demographics of Bleaching in the Caribbean Reef-Building Coral Montastraea annularis. Ecosphere, 2, art9, 1-13.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1890/ES10-00065.1

[44]   Edmunds, P.J. (2013) Decadal-Scale Changes in the Community Structure of Coral Reefs of St. John, US Virgin Islands. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 489, 107-123.
http://dx.doi.org/10.3354/meps10424

[45]   Planque, B., Fromentin, J.M., Cury, P., Drinkwater, K.F., Jennings, S., Perry, R.I. and Kifani, S. (2010) How Does Fishing Alter Marine Populations and Ecosystems Sensitivity to Climate? Journal of Marine Systems, 79, 403-417.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jmarsys.2008.12.018

[46]   Bellwood, D.R., Hughes, T.P., Folke, C. and Nystrom, M. (2004) Confronting the Coral Reef Crisis. Nature, 429, 827833.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature02691

[47]   Hughes, T.P., Linares, C., Dakos, V., Van de Leemput, I.A. and Van Nes, E.H. (2013) Living Dangerously on Borrowed Time during Slow, Unrecognized Regime Shifts. Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 28, 149-155.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2012.08.022

[48]   Aronson, R.B., Macintyre, I.G., Precht, W.F., Murdoch, T.J.T. and Wapnick, C.M. (2002) The Expanding Scale of Species Turnover Events on Coral Reefs in Belize. Ecological Monographs, 72, 233-249.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1890/0012-9615(2002)072[0233:TESOST]2.0.CO;2

[49]   Graham, N.A.J., Bellwood, D.R., Cinner, J.E., Hughes, T.P., Norstrom, A.V. and Nystrom, M. (2013) Managing Resilience to Reverse Phase Shifts in Coral Reefs. Frontiers in Ecology and Environment, 11, 541-548.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1890/120305

[50]   Williams, I.D. and Polunin, N.V.C. (2000) Differences between Protected and Unprotected Reefs of the Western Caribbean in Attributes Preferred by Dive Tourists. Environmental Conservation, 27, 382-391.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0376892900000436

[51]   Agardy, T. (2000) Information Needs for Marine Protected Areas: Scientific and Societal. Bulletin of Marine Science, 66, 875-888.

[52]   Bunce, L., Gustavson, K., Williams, J. and Miller, M. (1999)The Human Side of Reef Management: A Case Study Analysis of the Socioeconomic Framework of Montego Bay Marine Park. Coral Reefs, 18, 369-380.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s003380050215

[53]   Kelleher, G. (1999) Guidelines for Marine Protected Areas. International Union for the Conservation of Nature, Gland, Switzerland.

[54]   National Research Council (NRC) (2001) Marine Protected Areas: Tools for Sustaining Marine Ecosystems. National Academy Press, Washington DC.

[55]   Suman, D.O., Shivlani, M.P. and Milon, J.W. (1999) Perceptions and Attitudes Regarding Marine Reserves: A Comparison of Stakeholder Groups in the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary. Ocean and Coastal Management, 42, 1019-1040.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0964-5691(99)00062-9

[56]   Weible, C.M. (2008) Caught in a Maelstrom: Implementing California Marine Protected Areas. Coastal Management, 36, 350-373.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/08920750802266387

[57]   Murray, T.J. and Associates (2007) Socio-Economic Baseline Development: Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary, Fishing Years 1998-2006.
http://sanctuaries.noaa.gov/science/socioeconomic/floridakeys/pdfs/commfishpan7and8.pdf

[58]   Day, J. (2008) The Need and Practice of Monitoring, Evaluating and Adapting Marine Planning and Management— Lessons from the Great Barrier Reef. Marine Policy, 32, 823-831.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.marpol.2008.03.023

[59]   Shivlani, M. (2008) Characterization of Stakeholder Uses in Marine Protected Areas in Support of Establishing Limits of Acceptable Change: Five Case Studies in the Coastal and Marine Natural Reserve System of Puerto Rico. Unpublished Manuscript.

[60]   Helvey, M. (2004) Seeking Consensus on Designing Marine Protected Areas: Keeping the Fishing Community Engaged. Coastal Management, 32, 173-190.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/08920750490276236

[61]   Weible, C., Sabatier, P.A. and Lubell, M. (2004) A Comparison of a Collaborative and Top-Down Approach to the Use of Science in Policy: Establishing Marine Protected Areas in California. The Policy Studies Journal, 32, 187-207.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1541-0072.2004.00060.x

[62]   Valdés-Pizzini, M. (1990) Fishermen Associations in Puerto Rico: Praxis and Discourse in the Politics of Fishing. Human Organizations, 49, 164-173.

[63]   National Academy of Public Administration (NAPA) (2000) Protecting our National Marine Sanctuaries: A Report by the Center for the Economy and the Environment. NAPA, Washington DC.

[64]   Delaney, J.M. (2003) Community Capacity Building in the Designation of the Tortugas Ecological Reserve. Gulf and Caribbean Research, 14, 163-169.

[65]   Walmsley, S.F. and White, A.T. (2003) Influence of Social, Management and Enforcement Factors on the Long-Term Ecological Effects of Marine Sanctuaries. Environmental Conservation, 30, 388-407.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0376892903000407

[66]   McConney, P., Pomeroy, R. and Mahon, R. (2003) Guidelines for Coastal Resource Co-Management in the Caribbean: Communicating the Concepts and Conditions that Favour Success. Caribbean Coastal Co-Management Guidelines Project. Caribbean Conservation Association, Barbados, 1-56.

[67]   Naumann, S., Davis, M., Munang, R., Andrews, J., Thiaw, I., Alverson, K., Mumba, M., Kavag, L. and Han, Z. (2013) The Social Dimension of Ecosystem-Based Adaptation. Policy Brief 12, United Nations Environment Program, New York.

[68]   Badalamenti, F., Ramos, A.A., Voultsiadou, E., Sánchez-Lizaso, J.L., D’Anna, G., Pipitone, C., Mas, J., Ruiz-Fernández, J.A., Whitmarsh, D. and Riggio, S. (2000) Cultural and Socio-Economic Impacts of Mediterranean Marine Protected Areas. Environmental Conservation, 27, 110-125.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0376892900000163

[69]   Graham, N.A.J., Cinner, J.E., Norstrom, A.V. and Nystrom, M. (2014) Coral Reefs as Novel Ecosystems: Embracing New Futures. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 7, 9-14.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cosust.2013.11.023

[70]   Hernández-Delgado E.A., Ramos-Scharrón, C.E., Guerrero, C., Lucking, M.A., Laureano, R., Méndez-Lázaro, P.A. and Meléndez-Díaz, J.O. (2012) Long-Term Impacts of Non-Sustainable Tourism and Urban Development in Small Tropical Islands Coastal Habitats in a Changing Climate: Lessons Learned from Puerto Rico. In: Kasimoglu, M., Ed., Visions for Global Tourism Industry-Creating and Sustaining Competitive Strategies, InTech Publications, Rijeka, 357-398.
http://www.intechopen.com/books/visions-for-global-tourism-industry-creating-and-sustaining-competitive-strategies/long-term-impacts-of-non-sustainable-tourism-and-urban-development-in-tropical-coastal-habitats-in-a

[71]   Rogers, C.S. (1990) Responses of Coral Reefs and Reef Organisms to Sedimentation. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 62, 185-202.
http://dx.doi.org/10.3354/meps062185

[72]   Nowlis, J.S., Roberts, C.M., Smith, A.H. and Siirila, E. (1997) Human-Enhanced Impacts of a Tropical Storm on Nearshore Coral Reefs. AMBIO, 26, 515-521.

[73]   Larsen, M.C. and Webb, R.M.T. (2009) Potential Effects of Runoff, Fluvial Sediment, and Nutrient Discharges on the Coral Reefs of Puerto Rico. Journal of Coastal Research, 25, 189-208. http://dx.doi.org/10.2112/07-0920.1

[74]   Ramos-Scharrón, C.E., Amador, J.M. and Hernández-Delgado, E.A. (2012) An Interdisciplinary Erosion Mitigation Approach for Coral Reef Protection—A Case Study from the Eastern Caribbean. In: Cruzado, A., Ed., Marine Ecosystems, InTech Publications, Rijeka, 127-160.
http://www.intechopen.com/articles/show/title/an-interdisciplinary-erosion-mitigation-approach-for-coral-reef-protection-a-case-study-from-the-eas

 
 
Top