Health  Vol.6 No.12 , June 2014
Which Socio-Economic Factors Influence Patients’ Choice to Opt for the ED or the GPC during Out-of-Hours: An Explorative Study in Flanders
Abstract: Background: Overcrowding of emergency departments (ED) during out-of-hours health care is a common problem in many Western countries. An appealing alternative for ED’s is the general practices cooperatives (GPC): regional networks of GP’s during the out-of-hours. The aim of this study is to investigate the socio-economic determinants of patients’ choice to opt for one of both health care providers. Methods: We gathered patient level data between May and December 2012 in Flanders (Belgium) from three emergency departments and three general practices cooperatives. Chi square analyses were used in order to study the bivariate relationship between opting for a health care facility (ED or GPC) and various socio-economic factors. To determine the independent association, a logistic regression analysis was conducted. Results: Self-referral to the ED is significantly associated with: being male, being younger, being less educated, having a (lower educated) partner and living in a rural area. Conclusion: The results of this study show that opting for the ED during the out-of-hours is, in general, related to a lower socio-economic status. Therefore the government should focus on patients with a lower socio-economic status when disseminating information on the organisation of health care with an emphasis on the accessibility of the primary health care during out-of-hours. To meet the needs for health care during these out-of-hours, a possible solution could be an integrated facility of GPC and ED with one access to medical care for all patients.
Cite this paper: Detollenaere, J. , Verlinde, E. , Willems, S. and Blezer, J. (2014) Which Socio-Economic Factors Influence Patients’ Choice to Opt for the ED or the GPC during Out-of-Hours: An Explorative Study in Flanders. Health, 6, 1361-1367. doi: 10.4236/health.2014.612167.

[1]   Moll van Charante, E.P., Van Riet, G. and Bindels, P.J.E. (2007) Self-Refferrals to the A&E Department during Out-of-Hours: Patients’ Motives and Characteristics. Patient Education and Counseling, 70, 256-265.

[2]   Afilalo, J., Marinovich, A., Afilalo, M., Colacone, A., Léger, R., Unger, B. and Giguère, C. (2004) Nonurgent Emergency Department Patient Characteristics and Barriers to Primary Care. Academic Emergency Medicine, 11, 1302-1310.

[3]   Brim, C. (2008) A Descriptive Analysis of the Non-Urgent Use of Emergency Departments. Nurse Researcher, 15, 72-88.

[4]   Bamezai, A. Melnick, G. and Nawathe, A. (2005) The Cost of an Emergency Department Visit and Its Relationship to Emergency Department Volume. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 45, 483-490.

[5]   Gourbin, C. et al. (2005) KCE rapport, Evaluatie van forfaitaire persoonlijke bijdrage op het gebruik van spoedgeval-lendienst. KCE Reports, 19A.

[6]   Philips, H. (2010) Out-of-Hours Primary Care in Belgium. Dissertation for the Degree of Doctor in Medical Sciences, Faculty Medicine. University of Antwerp, Antwerp.

[7]   Van Uden, C.J.T., Winkens, R.A.G., Wesseling, G., Fiolet, H.F.B.M., van Schayck, O.C.P. and Crebolder, H.F.J.M. (2005) The Impact of a Primary Care Physician Cooperative on the Caseload of an Emergency Department: The Maastricht Integrated Out-of-Hours Service. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 20, 612-617.

[8]   Giesen, P., Franssen, E., Mokkink, H., van den Bosch, W., van Vugt, A. and Grol, R. (2006) Patients Either Contacting a General Practice Cooperative or Accident and Emergency Department out of Hours: A Comparison. Emergency Medicine Journal, 23, 731-734.

[9]   Wens, J., Mortelmans, L.J.M., Verhoeven, V., Philips, H., Remmen, R. and van Royen, P. (2005) Use of Emergency Departments by Primary Care Patients. European Journal of General Practice, 11, 78-80.

[10]   Padgett, D.K. and Brodsky, B. (1992) Psychosocial Factors Influencing Non-Urgent Use of the Emergency Room: A Review of the Literature and Recommendations for Research and Improved Service Delivery. Social Science & Medicine, 35, 1189-1997.

[11]   Philips, H., Remmen, R., De Paepe, P., Buylaert, W. and Van Royen, P. (2010) Out of Hours Care: A Profile Analysis of Patients Attending the Emergency Department and the General Practitioner on Call. BMC Family Practice, 11, 88.

[12]   Liu, T., Sayre, M.R. and Carleton, S.T. (1999) Emergency Medical Care: Types, Trends, and Factors Related to Nonurgent Visits. Academic Emergency Medicine, 6, 1147-1152.

[13]   Weber, E.J., Showstack, J.A., Hunt, K.A., Colby, D.C. and Callaham, M.L. (2005) Does Lack of a Usual Source of Care or Health Insurance Increase the Likelihood of an Emergency Department Visit? Results of a National Population-Based Study. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 45, 4-12.

[14]   Zuckerman, S. and Shen, Y.C. (2004) Characteristics of Occasional and Frequent Emergency Department Users: Do Insurance Coverage and Access to Care Matter? Medical Care, 42, 176-182.

[15]   Fidela, S.J., Li, H., Henneman, P.L., Smithline, H.A., Santoro, J.S., Provost, D. and Maynard, A.M. (2005) A Descriptive Study of Heavy Emergency Department Users at an Academic Emergency Department Reveals Heavy ED Users Have Better Access to Care Than Average Users. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 31, 139-144.

[16]   Weber, E.J., Showstack, J.A., Hunt, K.A., Colby, D.C., Grimes, B., Bacchetti, P. and Callaham, M.L. (2008) Are the Uninsured Responsible for the Increase in Emergency Department Visits in the United States? Annals of Emergency Medicine, 52, 108-115.

[17]   Den Boer-Wolters, D., Knol, M.J., Smulder, K. and De Wit, N.J. (2010) Frequent Attendance of Primary Care Out-of-Hours Services in the Netherlands: Characteristics of Patients and Presented Morbidity. Family Practice, 27, 129-134.

[18]   Gerkens, S., et al. (2010) Het Belgisch Gezondheidssysteem in 2010. KCE Reports.

[19]   Moll van Charante, E.P., Van Steenwijk-Opdam, P.C.E. and Bindels, P.J.E. (2007) Out-of-Hours Demand for GP Care and Emergency Services: Patients’ Choices and Referrals by General Practitioners and Ambulance Services. BMC Family Practice, 8, 46.

[20]   Remmen, R., et al. (2007) Huisartsenwachtposten in Vlaanderen: Wat zijn de randvoorwaarden? Huisarts Nu, 36, 397-401.

[21]   Philips, H., Rotthier, P., Meyvis, L. and Remmen, R. (2011) Gebruik en toegankelijkheid van de eerstelijnsgezondheid-szorg. Hoe bepalend is de sociaal-economische situatie in Antwerpen? Huisarts Nu, 40, 327-362.

[22]   Andersen, R. and Newman, J.F. (2005) Societal and Individual Determinants of Medical Care Utilisation in the United States. The Milbank Quarterly, 83, 1-28.

[23]   Giesen, P., Franssen, E., Mokkink, H., van den Bosch, W., van Vugt, A. and Grol, R. (2007) Medische zorg buiten kantooruren: De huisartsenpost of de spoedeisende eerste hulp? Huisarts en Wetenschap, 50, 338-343.