BLR  Vol.5 No.1 , March 2014
Voice of Jacob Hand of Esau: Appraising the Role of Chief Executives and Party Leaders in Impeachment Processes in Nigeria
Abstract: As a three-tier government that Nigeria is, three legislatures exist and all have the impeachment powers that have been grossly abused: The National Assembly, the state assembly and the local legislative council. A close study of their activities, regarding impeachment duties, shows a consistent bias in the ways they exercise these powers particularly at the National and state levels. Prior to fourth republic only once did states (Kaduna and Kano) assemblies have gut to impeach a governor and a deputy Governor—Alhaji Balarabe Musa and Bibi Faruk—since 1979 when Nigeria began the practice of Presidential system of government. In the present Fourth Republic not less than five Governors have been impeached, although three of them had been reversed by judicial review. At the national level, it has always been a mere threat against the chief executive but not so with the leadership of the National Assembly. It is even worse at the local level. It is curious however, to find that the victims of true impeachment powers have always been the powerless deputies and the leaderships of the legislatures at the various levels of government. Even in these, the process through which these powers are exercised is often characterised by corruption of different categories such as bribery and coercion leading to perversion of due process to attain the nefarious goals. The study shows that often those behind the impeachments are the chief executives and party leaders who goad the members of the legislatures to embark on such constitutional but perverted acts.
Cite this paper: Olasupo, F. (2014). Voice of Jacob Hand of Esau: Appraising the Role of Chief Executives and Party Leaders in Impeachment Processes in Nigeria. Beijing Law Review, 5, 7-21. doi: 10.4236/blr.2014.51002.

[1]   Adebanjo, A. (2001). Deadly Battles in the State: Tired of the Meddling Political Godfathers, Many Governors Strike for Freedom by Taking on Their Former Mentors. Tell of July 9, 23

[2]   Adeyemo, W. (2002). Endangered Species: Lagos State deputy governor, Kofoworola Bucknor-Akerele, Resigns Her Position as Some of Her Colleagues Face Testing Time in Their States. Tell of December 30, 48.

[3]   Agboola, M. A. (2007). 10 Lawmakers Back out of Fresh Plot to Impeach Dariye. Jos. Friday, May 4. URL: Copy.

[4]   Aiyetan, D. (2001). Nigeria’s New Dictators: Nigeria May Have Attained Democratic Rule, But across the Nation, at All Levels of Government, the New Men at the Helm of Affairs Still Carry on the Business of Governance in an Authoritarian Manner Reminiscent of the Long Years of Military Rule. Tell of December 17, 48.

[5]   Aham, U. (2002). Controversial Impeachment: Controversy Trails the impeachment of Enugu State House of Assembly speaker, Abel Chukwu. TheNews of August 26, 45.

[6]   Aja, U. (2001). A Tale of Two Speakers. Source of December 24, 29.

[7]   Akinrosoye, I., & Mukwuzi, M. (2005). Bitter Impeachment: Chief Abiodun Aluko Is Impeached as Deputy Governor of Ekiti State in Controversial Circumstances. TheNews of October 10, 39.

[8]   Akinsanya, A. A., & Ayoade J. A. A. (2005). Readings in Nigerian Government and Politics (p. 177). Ijebu-Ode, Ogun State: Gratia Associates International.

[9]   Akinkuotu, A. (2007). Impeachment, Their Impeachment. Tell of March 26, 5.

[10]   Albert, I. O. (2008). Section 4 Appendix. In Y. Yusufu, S. Egwu, U. O. Udenta, T. Lakoju, R. Nwikkwor, O. Olaniyan, B. Eluma, & T. Oyewo (Eds.), Conflict Tracking Dossier: A Quarterly Review, Issue (pp. 70, 72 and 82). Ibadan: Stirling-Horden Publishers LTD.

[11]   Anza, P. (2005). Collapse of a Plot: Th1e Impeachment Plot in the House of Representatives against President Olusegun Obasanjo Loses Steam Following High-Level Political Horse Trading. Newswatch of May 30, 22.

[12]   Asaju, T. (2001). A Fighter and a Runner. Newswatch of April 30, 28.

[13]   Ashaka, K. (2006). Balarabe Musa Warns: One day Obasanjo Will Suspend N. Assembly. 13.

[14]   Azinge, E., (2002). Legislative Adjudication: Uses and Abuses. In C. F. Okolocha (Ed.), Issues and Processes in Legislation: With a Forward by Anyim Pious Anyim (p. 166). Benin City: UNIBEN Press.

[15]   Binniyat, L. (2013). Confusion in Kaduna over Purported Impeachment of Speaker. Vanguard Newspaper, September 25, 2.

[16]   Fabowale, Y., Bamidele, R. Adeoti, A., & Raheem, T. (2006).

[17]   Fagbadebo, O. (2007). Judicial Review of Impeachment procedure: Implication for Democratic Stability in Nigeria. In The Annual Meeting of the International Society of Political Psychology (p. 5). Classical Chinese Garden, Portland, Oregon.

[18]   Fawole, A. (2007). National Assembly as Pillar of Democracy. The Westerner of January 21, Back Page.

[19]   Federal Republic of Nigeria (1992) Handbook on Local Government Administration (p. 10). Abuja: Office of the Vice-President.

[20]   International Society of Political Psychology, Classical Chinese Garden. (Portland, Oregon USA, July 04 2007. Not available. 2009-05-24.

[21]   Ikhariale, M. (2002). The Impeachment Myth Versus the Nigerian Reality Nov.

[22]   Iyinbo, O. (2007). Nigeria’s Impeachment Saga: Democracy on the Legislature’s Butcher Block.


[24]   Jason, P. (2006). The Weighty Side of Impeachment. Vanguard Newspaper of October 31, 5.

[25]   Laleye, D. (2009). Niger New Speaker Resigns: Ma’ali Now Speaker. Nigerian Tribune of June 17, 5.

[26]   Laleye, D. (2009) IBB Denies Plot to Remove Niger Gov. Nigerian Tribune of June 17, 6.

[27]   Madunagu, E. (2003). Impeachment in Nigeria. http://www.nigerdeltacongress.Com/iarticles/Impeachment_in_nigeria.htm

[28]   Majebi, E. (2009).

[29]   Nwikwor, R., (2008). Analysis of Tracked Media Reports in Idasa. In Conflict Tracking Dossier: A Quarterly Review (Issue 9, p. 45). Ibadan: Stirling-Horden Publishers Ltd.

[30]   Nwosu, S. (2006). Winners and Loosers Emergency Rule in Ekiti State. Saturday, 21 October 2006, URL: Copy.

[31]   Obasi, S. (2006). Coup at Dawn: Peter Obi, Governor of Anambra State Impeached at a Controversial Early Morning Session of the State House of Assembly November 2. Newswatch of November 13, 52.

[32]   Obe, E. (2002). Royal Fathers Ban Enugu Assembly from Sitting. The Punch of August 29, 11.

[33]   Ogunleye, G. (2003). Godfather Politics and the Drama in Anambra. Saturday Punch of July 9.

[34]   Ogbemudia, O. B. (2013). Otaru Saves Council Boss from Impeachment. The Nation on Sunday of November 23, 76.

[35]   Ojewale, O. (2005). Atiku’s Rough Road to 2007. Tell of October 31, 22.

[36]   Olasupo, F. A. (2005). National Question and Politics at the Local Level. In W. O. Alli (Ed.), Political Reform Conference, Federalism and the National Question in Nigeria (p. 142). Nigeria: Nigerian Political Science Association.

[37]   Olasupo, F. A. (2009). Due Process Corruption in Public Services in Nigeria: Local Government as a Case Study. In O. Aborisade, & I. O. Aransi (Eds.), Public Administration in Nigeria (p. 33). Charlotte, NC: Catawba Publishing Company.

[38]   Olayeni, K. (2009). Ogun Assembly Mischievous over My Appointment. The Compass of May 17, 15.

[39]   Olasupo, F. A. (2011). Power Struggle and Impeachment as Means to an End: Osun State as a Case Study, 1999-2003. In M. O. A. Alabi (Ed.), Unbroken Legacy of Service: Speaker Bello’s Twelve Years under Three Administrations in Osun (p. 5). Ilorin: Intellectual Research Institute.

[40]   Onu, N. (2008). Plot to Impeach Anambra Speaker Thickens. The Nation of March.

[41]   Orintunsin, J. (2009). Niger Speaker Removed over Poor Performance. The Nation of June 10, 9.

[42]   Oseheye, O. (2009). Council Leader Reinstated. The Nation of October 5, 12.

[43]   Osun State. The Laws of Osun State of Nigeria. Vol. 4 CAPS 68-96 LEG-OSU, (England: Antony Rowe Limited, Bumper Farm, Chippenham, Wiltshire. Authorised by the Government of Osun State of Nigeria to print the Laws of Osun State). 271-272.

[44]   Orji, A. (2009). Council in Crisis over Removal of Leader. The Nation of June 10, 8.

[45]   Owolabi, Y. (2002). Ige Haunts Omisore. Tell of December 30, 41.

[46]   Tsenzughul, A. (2009). Bauchi Deputy Governor Deserves Impeachment: The Deputy Did Not Contest and Win Election, but the Governor Did. It Is Necessary the Deputy Follows His Boss. The Nation of June 24, 6.

[47]   Ugbolue, H. (2002). Gunning for the President. The News of August 26, 20.

[48]   Umanah, O. (2000). LG Boss Suspended in Delta. Sunday Punch of April 2, 35.

[49]   Utomwen, D. (2007). Clinging on Desperately: The Speaker of the House of Representatives, Patricia Olubunmi Etteh Fights Hard to Survive. The News of October 22, 49.

[50]   Wood, G. S. (1992). Democracy and the American Revolution. In J. Dunn (Ed.), Democracy the Unfinished Journey 508 BC to 1993 (p. 91). New York: Oxford University Press Inc.

[51]   Yishau, O. (2009). Aliu vs Kure: A Battle IBB Could Not Settle: Despite the Intervention of Two Former Heads of State, Ibrahim Babangida and Abdulsalami Abubakar, Niger State Governor Babangida Aliu and His Predecessor, Abdulkadir Kure Sinks Deeper into the Trenches. The Nation of June 19, 9.