Health  Vol.5 No.10 , October 2013
An autonomous model of health care: Are third parties really needed?
Show more

This proposal offers a novel approach to the organization and financing of health care and is explored for its impact on the current United States system as the most prominent outlier regarding excessive cost in relation to value. The unique nature of health as a private and common good as well as a foundation for equal opportunity has eluded satisfactory management through either market forces or government intervention. The remedy is an independent, citizen-carried cooperative administrative structure, whose members own and apply their aggregate assets for their own benefit according to democratic principles. Citizens are assessed at a collectively approved rate of equitable tax deductions proportionate to their means for a designated health care fund. The resulting single payer guarantees standardization of services and reimbursements with an expanding emphasis on outcome towards optimum population health. Transparency ensures parity and flexibility for diversity and a goal of personalized medicine. All persons are enrolled on the basis of their civil status as beneficiaries. A close partnership between integrated providers and patients is practiced towards an affordable balance between investment in and value of services. Thus financing is a closed loop and therefore the most effective cost control mechanism at the individual and collective levels. Other than a regulatory and oversight function of government, the traditional third parties, namely employers, insurers and public subsidizing entities, are no longer required for catering to individual health care needs. Useful functions of existing institutions are transitioned into direct collective consumer control. Far reaching positive social, economic and political consequences are explored. The principles of this new approach have general societal appeal.

Cite this paper: Frangenberg, E. (2013) An autonomous model of health care: Are third parties really needed?. Health, 5, 1590-1600. doi: 10.4236/health.2013.510215.

[1]   (2012) Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.

[2]   McKinsey Center for US Health System Reform (2010) Accounting for the cost of US health care. Pre-reform trends and the impact of the recession. McKinsey & Company.

[3]   Martin, A.B., Lassman, D., Washington, B. and Catlin, A. (2012) Growth in US health spending remained slow in 2010; Health share of gross domestic product was unchanged from 2009. Health Affairs, 31, 208-219.

[4]   Auerbach, D.I. and Kellermann, A.L. (2011) A decade of health care cost growth has wiped out real income gains for an average US family. Health Affairs, 30, 1630-1636.

[5]   Anderson, G.F. and Frogner, B.K. (2008) Health spending in OECD countries: Obtaining value per dollar. Health Affairs, 27, 1718-1727.

[6]   Banks, J.M., Marmot, M., Oldfield, Z. and Smith, J.P. (2006) Disease and disadvantage in the United States and in England. Journal of the American Medical Association, 295, 2037-2045.

[7]   Nolte, E., and McKee, C.M. (2008) Measuring The Health Of Nations: Updating An Earlier Analysis. Health Affairs, 27, 58-71.

[8]   Davis, K.D., Schoen, C. and Stremikis, K. (2010) Mirror, mirror on the wall: How the performance of the US health care system compares internationally, 2010 update. The Commonwealth Fund, 23, 2010.

[9]   De Navas-Walt, C., Proctor, B.D. and Smith, J.C. (2011) US Census Bureau. Current populations reports, P60-239. Income, poverty and health insurance coverage in the United States: 2010. US Government Printing Office, Washington DC.

[10]   Lasser, K.E., Himmelstein, D.U. and Woolhandler, S. (2006) Access to care, health status, and health disparities in the United States and Canada: Results of a cross-national population-based survey. American Journal of Public Health, 96, 1300-1307.

[11]   Sampath, P. and Wilson, D. (2012) A case study and state of science review: Private versus public healthcare financing. Global Journal of Health Science, 4, 118-123.

[12]   Denier, Y. (2008) Mind the gap! Three approaches to scarcity in health care. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 11, 73-87.

[13]   Reid, T.R. (2010) The healing of America. Penguin Books, New York.

[14]   Frangenberg, E.H. (2011) A good samaritan inspired foundation for a fair health care system. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 14, 73-79.

[15]   Goodman, J.C. and Musgrave, G.L. (1992) Patient power: Solving America’s health care crisis. Cato Institute, Washington DC.

[16]   Health Care Finance News (2011) Deloitte: Employers expect employees will pay more for health care benefits.

[17]   Himmelstein, D.U., Thorne, D., Warren, E. and Woolhandler, S. (2009) Medical bankruptcy in the United States, 2007: Results of a national study. The American Journal of Medicine, 122, 741-746.

[18]   McKinsey Center for U.S. Health System Reform (2011) Accounting for the cost of US health care. Pre-reform trends and the impact of the recession. McKinsey & Company.

[19]   Woolhandler, S., Campbell, T. and Himmelstein, D.U. (2000) Costs of health care administration in the United States and Canada. New England Journal of Medicine, 349, 768-775.

[20]   Pethokoukis, J. (2009) US health care system wastes $800 billion a year.

[21]   Institute of Medicine (2012) Best care at lower cost: The path to continuously learning health care in America.

[22]   Internal Revenue Service Data Book 2011 (2012) Internal Revenue Service, Publication 55B, Washington DC.

[23]   Busse, R. and Riesberg, A. (2000) Health care systems in transition, Germany. European Observatory on Health Care Systems, 39-51.

[24]   Holahan, J. (2011) The 2007-09 recession and health insurance coverage. Health Affairs, 30, 145-152.

[25]   Congressional Budget Office (2012) Estimates for the insurance coverage provisions of the affordable care act updated for the recent supreme court decision.

[26]   Cutler, D.M., Davis, K. and Stremikis, K. (2010) The impact of health reform on health system spending. Issue Brief. Commonwealth Fund Pub. 1405, 88, 1-14.

[27]   Tanner, M.D. (2011) Bad medicine: A guide to the real costs and consequences of the new health care law. The Cato Institute, Washington DC.

[28]   Wilson, N.W. (2012) Chaos in western medicine: How issues of social professional status are undermining our health. Global Journal of Health Science, 4, 1-19.

[29]   McMahon, L.F. and Chopra, V. (2012) Health care cost and value. Journal of the American Medical Association, 307, 671-672.

[30]   American Board of Internal Medicine Foundation (2012) Choosing Wisely.

[31]   Concato, J. (2012) Is it time for evidence-based medicine? The Journal of the American Medical Association, 307, 1641-1643.

[32]   Golub, R.M. and Fontanarosa, P.B. (2012) Comparative effectiveness research. Journal of the American Medical Association, 307, 1643-1645.

[33]   Emanuel, E.J. and Pearson, S.D. (2012) Physician autonomy and health care reform. Journal of the American Medical Association, 307, 367-368.

[34]   Bodenheimer, T. and Grumbach, K. (2012) Understanding health policy. A clinical approach. 6th Edition, McGraw Hill, New York.

[35]   Enthoven, A.C. (2009) Integrated delivery systems: The cure for fragmentation. The American Journal of Managed Care, 15, S284-S290.

[36]   Emanuel, E.J. (2012) Why accountable care organizations are not 1990s managed care redux. Journal of the American Medical Association, 307, 2263-2264.

[37]   Smart Card Alliance HealthCare Council (2011) Getting to meaningful use and beyond: How smart card technology can support meaningful use of electronic health records.

[38]   Legato, M.J. (2006) The plot thickens. Gender Medicine, 3, 243-245.

[39]   Millenson, M.L. (2006) The promise of personalized medicine: A conversation with Michael Svinte. Health Affairs, 25, w54-w60.

[40]   Topol, E. (2012) The creative destruction of medicine. New York: Basic Books.

[41]   US Department of Health and Human Services (2011) News release. National Library of Medicine launches medline plus connect.

[42]   Schlesinger, M. (2004) Reprivatizing the public household? Medical care in the context of American public values. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 29, 969-1004.

[43]   Daniels, N. (2001) Justice, health, and health care. The American Journal of Bioethics, 1, 2-16.

[44]   Mello, M.M. and Brennan, T.A. (2001) The controversy over high-dose chemotherapy with autologous bone marrow transplant for breast cancer. Health Affairs, 20, 101-117.

[45]   Perry, P.A. and Hotze, T. (2011) Oregon’s experiment with prioritizing public health care services. Virtual Mentor, 13, 241-247.

[46]   Engelhardt, H.T. (1996) The foundations of bioethics. Oxford University Press, New York.

[47]   Rawls, J. (1971) A theory of justice, 302. Harvard University Press, Cambridge.

[48]   Hsia, R.Y., Kothari, A.H., Srebotnjak, T. and Maselli, J. (2012) Health care as a ‘market good’? Appendicitis as a case study. Archives of Internal Medicine, 172, 818-819.

[49]   Kavey, R.W., Daniels, S.R., Lauer, R.M., Atkins, D.L., Hayman, L.L. and Taubert, K. (2003) American Heart Association guidelines for primary prevention of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease beginning in childhood. Circulation, 107, 1562-1565.

[50]   Thorpe, K.E. (2005) The rise in health care spending and what to do about it. Health Affairs, 24, 1436-1445.

[51]   Goetzel, R.Z., Guindon, A.M., Turshen, J.I. and Ozminskowski, R.J. (2001) Health and productivity management: Establishing key performance measures, benchmarks and best practices. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 43, 10-17.

[52]   Agus, D. (2010) The end of illness. Simon & Schuster, New York.

[53]   Hadler, N.M. (2011) Rethinking aging. The University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill.

[54]   Ostrom, E. (1990) Governing the commons. Cambridge University Press, New York.

[55]   Fuchs, V.R. and Schaeffer, L.D. (2012) If accountable care organizations are the answer, who should create them? Journal of the American Medical Association, 307, 2261-2262.

[56]   Ostrom, E. (1990) Governing the commons. Cambridge University Press, New York, 29.

[57]   Ostrom, E. (1990) Governing the commons. Cambridge University Press, New York, 90-102.

[58]   Indiana University (2012) Rippel foundation awards grant to Ostrom, IU research center, to apply insights to health care.

[59]   Brownell, K.D. and Warner, K.E. (2009) The perils of ignoring history: Big tobacco played dirty and millions died. How similar is big food? The Milbank Quarterly, 87, 259-294.

[60]   McGee, G. (2000) The perfect baby. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Lanham.

[61]   Putnam, R. (2000) Bowling alone. Simon & Schuster, New York.

[62]   Berkman, L.F. and Glass, T. (2000) Social integration, social networks, social support and health. In: Berkman, L.F. and Kawachi, I., Eds., Social Epidemiology, Oxford University Press, New York, 158-162.

[63]   Olson, M. (1971) The logic of collective action: Public goods and the theory of groups. 2nd Edition, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 64.

[64]   Ziebland, S. and Wyle, S. (2012) Health and illness in a connected world: How might sharing experiences on the Internet affect people’s health? The Milbank Quarterly, 90, 219-249.

[65]   US Department of Health and Human Services (2011) Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act; establishment of consumer operated and oriented plan (CO-OP) program. Federal Register, 76, 77392-77394.

[66]   Gardiner, T., Neece, R. and Mendelevitz, M. (2012) Realizing health reform’s potential: Innovative strategies to help consumer operated and oriented plans (CO-OPs) compete in new insurance marketplaces. The Commonwealth Fund.

[67]   Berwick, D.M. and Hackbarth, A.D. (2012) Eliminating waste in US health care. Journal of the American Medical Association, 307, 1513-1515.