ABSTRACT The effect of blank/punch diameter ratio (draw ratio) in deep drawing on earing for different
gauges of Al 1200 sheet was studied. Using 60, 62, 64 and 65mm diameter circle blanks and
33mm diameter punch die, fully annealed Al 1200 sheets of gauge thicknesses 0.6 to 2.0mm were
subjected to deep drawing on an ErrichsenR cup drawing machine.
The results showed that with increase in sheet thickness, the smaller is the draw ratio that would
draw the sheet. For 0.6-0.9mm sheet thickness, cups were drawn with draw ratios of 60/33 to
65/33. For sheet thicknesses of 1.2-1.58mm, only 60/33 and 62/33 draw ratios were observe to
draw cups. Earing was observed to generally increase with increasing draw ratio using the same
sheet thickness. It was also observed that for thinner sheets (0.6-0.9mm), using the same draw
ratio, earing increased with increasing sheet thickness. For thicker sheets (1.2-1.58mm) earing
was observed to decrease with increasing sheet thickness. After that, there was an increase for
deep-drawn 2mm thick sheet.
Higher draw ratios were observed to draw deeper cup depths with minimal earing. The depth of
cups drawn with 65/33 draw ratio was observed to be about 28% more than those drawn with
60/33 draw ratio with an increase in earing of only 0.84% for 0.6mm thick sheet and 1.2% for
0.9mm thick sheets. Earing was also observed to increase by 1.64% for the 2mm thick sheet that
had undergone grain growth over the fine grained one.
Cite this paper
O. Oluwole, C. Anyaeche and O. Faola, "Effect of Draw Ratio and Sheet Thickness on Earing and Drawability of Al 1200 Cups," Journal of Minerals and Materials Characterization and Engineering, Vol. 9 No. 5, 2010, pp. 461-470. doi: 10.4236/jmmce.2010.95032.
 Polmear I. J., (1981): Light alloys, metallurgy of he light metals, Advanced Arnold
Publishers, London 2nd Edition, Pp 76-79, 104 – 105.
Oluwole O.O, Ajayi.J.A, Olorunniwo.O.E and Sofoluwo.A.A(2002) ‘Texture and Structure
of Cold-Rolled and Temper-Annealed Al 1200’ NSE Technical Transactions 37(2);53-69.
Aderibigbe. D.A , Oluwole.O.O, Olorunniwo.O.E, Atanda, P.O and Ogundare.O(2006)
‘Earing Characteristics of Cold-Rolled and Temper –Annealed Al 1200’ Journal of Applied
Sciences, INSINET, 6(15),3103-3109
Baker A.M. (1977): Comparison of Mechanical properties for temper-rolled and temperannealed
strips of Aluminium 1100, CES Aluminium and Brass, America Society of metals,
U.S.A. Vol III, 1 – 12.
Aderibigbe. D.A and Sowole.O(1989) ‘Effects of Temper Annealing Temperatures and
Times on the Mechanical Properties of Cold-Worked Al 1200’ Journal of Engineering
Reserch JER-1(1); 49-59.