OJOG  Vol.11 No.5 , May 2021
Maternal Mortality in Two Reference Hospitals in the City of Yaounde (Cameroon): Epidemiological, Clinical and Prognostic Aspects
Abstract: Objectives: The objective of this work was to determine the epidemiological, clinical and prognostic aspects of maternal mortality (MM) in the city of Yaounde. Methods: We conducted a descriptive cross-sectional study with retrospective data collection of maternal deaths according to the World Health Organization (WHO) definition, from January 1, 2017 to December 31, 2019, in two tertiary centers of Yaounde: The Yaounde Gynaeco-Obstetric and Paediatric Hospital (YGOPH) and the Yaounde Central Hospital (YCH). Results: During the study period, 208 maternal deaths were identified, with 4/5 (78.4%) from referred cases. The MM ratio was 1532.8 per 100,000 live births (LB) vs. 609.5 per 100,000 live births at YCH and YGOPH respectively. The Main causes where haemorrhage (49%) followed by hypertensive diseases and their complications (21.2%), maternal mortality was associated with 50% of cases of foetal or neonatal deaths (57.4% in YCH vs 28.3% in YGOPH, P < 0.001). Health service systems were related to MM. Conclusion: Our study shows a large increase in maternal mortality ratios in YCH and YGOPH maternities since 2017. The main causes of MM found were haemorrhage followed by hypertensive diseases. These causes can be prevented. Our health systems should be improved if we want to significantly reduce the maternal mortality ratio.

1. Introduction

The World Health Organization (WHO) defines maternal mortality in the tenth revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10) as “the death of a woman during pregnancy or within 42 days of its termination, regardless of duration or location, from any cause determined or aggravated by pregnancy or pregnancy-related causes, but not accidental or malicious” [1]. Approximately 830 women die every day worldwide from preventable causes related to pregnancy and childbirth [2]. Central Africa is home to three of the countries with the highest mortality rates in the world: Central African Republic with 882 per 100,000 live births, Chad with 856 per 100,000 live births and Nigeria with 814 per 100,000 live births [3]. According to the recent Demographic Health Survey in Cameroon (EDSC-V), the maternal mortality rate dropped from 728 in 2004-2011 to 467 in 2012-2018 per 100,000 live births, i.e. a reduction of 51.9% [4]. These overwhelming figures, mentioned above, show that maternal mortality is a major and urgent public health problem in developing countries, particularly in Central Africa. And even if we note a decrease in the maternal mortality rate in Cameroon since 2004, it appears that it remains a matter of concern for our society. Many risk factors for MM have already been identified by various studies: age, parity, age-parity combination, low socio-economic status, singlehood and in some cases marriage (too many children, too early, too late and too close together). The authors’ objective was to determine maternal mortality in two tertiary centers in Yaounde with a high attendance potential.

2. Material and Method

2.1. Framework

The two hospitals that are the subject of our study are major structures of obstetric care in the city.

The Yaounde Gynaeco-Obstetric and Paediatric Hospital is a reference health facility created in 2002 and specialises in the care of mothers and children. Its gynaecology-obstetrics department has a capacity of 34 inpatient beds, three delivery tables, four operating theatres with two laparoscopy columns, and an admission room adjacent to the delivery room. The service carries out an average of 3015 deliveries per year. In an environment marked by limited financial resources and the absence of social security, obstetric emergencies benefited during the study period from the permanent availability of surgical and anaesthetic teams. The medical team consisted of eleven obstetrician-gynaecologists, three permanent anaesthetists, a general practitioner, nurses and midwives at the time of the study. They provide a permanent on-call service in their respective departments and are assisted by residents from their respective specialties.

The Yaounde central hospital is a reference hospital, created in 1930 and functional in 1933. Its maternity ward is very well attended, divided into two parts, namely Clinic A and Clinic B. The maternity ward carries out an average of 3664 deliveries per year. Its medical team at the time of the study consisted of eleven gynaecologist-obstetricians, two anaesthetist-animators, a permanent general practitioner, residents in gynaecology-obstetrics and anaesthesia-animation, four nurses specialised in reproductive health, four state-registered nurses, thirty-nine licensed nurses.

The supply of essential medicines and consumable materials is ensured by the pharmacy of each of these two hospitals. Their availability is uncertain, requiring direct financial participation by the patients. It should also be noted that both hospitals have a blood bank.

2.2. Methods

This was a descriptive cross-sectional study with retrospective data collection that was carried out in the two above mentioned hospitals. All maternal deaths meeting the WHO’s definition that occurred between 1st January 2017 and 31st December 2019 were included. The data collected on a data sheet concerned socio-demographic variables; age, occupation, ethnicity, education level, marital status, occupation, time of entry, place of origin, referring facility, transport condition, mode of admission, reason for referral or reason for admission if patient not referred... Clinico-obstetrical variables; Gravida, parity Family history, term of pregnancy, pregnancy follow-up, uterine height, uterine contractions, fetal heart sounds, pervaginal bleeding, Bishop score, state of membranes and amniotic fluid, presentation, date and time of death, time to care... The main aetiologies and variables related to the circumstances of death; Causes of death, identified risk factors, time of death... as well as factors contributing to maternal death and fetal prognosis; Community and health service factors, status of the newborn, avoidability of death. We took inspiration from some survey templates used in similar studies, which we tested and adapted to our context. All survey were anonymous and confidential. Prior authorisation had been obtained from the National Ethics Committee and the management of both hospitals. The data were then computerised and analysed using CSPro 7.3 and Excel 2016 softwares.

3. Results

3.1. Frequencies (Figure 1)

During the study period we recorded 155 and 53 maternal deaths in YCH and YGOPH maternity wards respectively. During the same period, 10,112 and 8695 live births (LB) were respectively registered in these 2 maternity hospitals, giving a maternal mortality ratio of 1532.8 and 609.5 per 100,000 LB respectively. The evolution of maternal mortality ratios over the last 3 years is presented in Figure 1. During the last three years, the maternal mortality ratio was higher in YCH (1532.8 per 100,000 LB). It was higher in YCH in 2019 (1997.6 per 100,000 LB) and in YGOPH in 2018 (746.5 per 100,000 LB).

Figure 1. Trends in the maternal mortality ratio by year. * = Yaounde Central Hospital; ** = Yaounde Gynaeco-Obstetric and Paediatric Hospital.

3.2. Socio-Demographic Characteristics (Table 1)

Table 1. Distribution of maternal deaths by age and marital status.

a = Yaounde Central Hospital; b = Yaounde Gynaeco-Obstetric and Paediatric Hospital; c = Not informed; d = Waitress, secretary, nurse, receptionist, telecom consultant, concierge, babysitter, marketing assistant, tax auditor, beautician, hotel manager, civil servant, call-box operator.

Of the 208 maternal deaths identified during the study period. 27.4% were aged between 30 and 34 years, while adolescents (age < 20 years) made up 8.2% of our sample with a significant difference in the two hospitals. Furthermore, 5.2% of our deaths involved women aged 40 and over. 65.5% were not officially married and 51.7% were housewives without paid employment. In terms of obstetrical history, maternal death seemed to occur more often among women who had already given birth to 1 to 3 children (65.6%).

The average age in the population of our study was 28.8 ± 6.8 with extremes ranging from 15 to 49 years. The mean ages were 28.3 ± 6.6 and 30.2 ± 7.2 respectively for YCH and YGOPH (P = 0.081). The most represented age group was that of [30 - 35 years old], i.e. 27.4% (27.7% for YCH vs. 26.4% for HGOPY, P = 0.993). While adolescent girls (age < 20 years) made up 8.2% of our sample with a significant difference in both hospitals (10.3% in YCH vs. 1.9% in YGOPH, P < 0.001). In addition, 57.2% were married and 40.9% were housewives without paid employment, with no significant difference in the two hospitals.

3.3. Obstetrical Characteristics and Pregnancy Follow-Up (Table 2)

Table 2. Obstetrical history and pregnancy follow-up.

a = Yaounde Central Hospital; b = Yaounde Gynaeco-Obstetric and Paediatric Hospital Yaounde; c = Antenatal Care; d = District Medical Centre; e = District Hospital; f = health centre; g = Not informed.

In terms of obstetrical history, the mean parity in the population of our study was 2.4 ± 2.1 with extremes ranging from 0 to 9; i.e. a mean parity of 2.5 ± 2.1 and 2.2 ± 1.9 for YCH and YGOPH respectively (P = 0.469). The paucipara were the most represented (30.3%) of cases of maternal death: (28.4% for YCH vs 35.8% for YGOPH, P = 0.307). In our series, 76% of the women who died had not completed the minimum of 4 Antenal cares (ANCs) recommended by the WHO, with no significant difference in the two hospitals. More specifically, almost half of the patients, i.e. 42.8%, had no prenatal follow-up (44.5% at YCH vs. 37.7% at YGOPH; P = 0.389). 50% of patients who had made their prenatal visits did so in private health centres (i.e. 50% in YCH vs 63.6% in YGOPH; P = 0.220).

3.4. Admission Context (Table 3)

Table 3. Distribution of maternal deaths by context of admission.

a = Yaounde Central Hospital; b = Yaounde Gynaeco-Obstetric and Paediatric Hospital; c = District Medical Centre; d = District Hospital; e = health centre; f = Not informed; g = Peripheral Venous Line.

In our series, 78.4% of the women who died were referred, of which 80% were referred in YCH and 71.6% in YGOPH. Among these patients, 37.5% were referred from a private health centres (35.5% to YCH vs 43.4%; P = 0.304). The most common mode of transport used for reported deaths was taxi in 36.1% (41.9% to YCH vs. 18.9%; P = 0.003). Finally, 43.8% of the women who died did not have a Peripheral Venous Line (43.2% in YCH vs. 45.3%; P = 0.794).

3.5. Etiologies of Maternal Death (Table 4)

Direct obstetrical causes were the most frequent with 175 cases (84.1%). The frequency of obstetrical causes was fairly constant in both hospitals, 84.5% in YCH and 83% in HGOPY. Haemorrhage was the first direct obstetric cause of maternal death in 49% with a significant difference in the two hospitals: (55.5% in YCH and 30.2% in YGOPH; P < 0.001). The second direct obstetrical cause of maternal death was represented by illnesses and complications related to hypertension in 21.2% of cases, with a significant difference between the two hospitals: (15.5% at YCH and 35.8% at YGOPH; P = 0.002). Pre-eclampsia and eclampsia were predominantly represented with 11.1% in both hospitals. Encephalopathy was the first indirect obstetrical cause of maternal death in 7 cases, i.e. 3.4% (2.6% in YCH and 5.7% in YGOPH; P = 0.283).

Table 4. Distribution by direct and indirect obstetric causes.

a = Yaounde Central Hospital; b = Yaounde Gynaeco-Obstetric and Paediatric Hospital; c = Disseminated Intravascular Coagulation Consumptive Coagulopathy; d = Ectopic Pregnancy; e = HyperBlood Pressure; f = Hemolysis Elevated Liver enzymes and low platelets; g = Acute oedema of the lung; h = Thromboembolic Venous Diseases. i = Necroticohemorrhagic Pancreatitis; Renal Neoplasia; Meningitis on Pregnancy; Meningitis; Ovarian Burkitt Lymphoma; Severe Hypokalemia; Seizure Disorder; Complications of Diabetes; Metastatic Breast Cancer; j = Not informed.

3.6. Factors Contributing to Death and Fetal or Neonatal Prognosis (Table 5)

Table 5. Distribution according to factors contributing to death and fetal or neonatal prognosis.

a = Yaounde Central Hospital; b = Yaounde Gynaeco-Obstetric and Paediatric Hospital; c = Not informed.

The majority of these factors contributing to the occurrence of maternal deaths were related to health services in 101 women who died, i.e. 51.5% with: 57.9% to YCH and 33.3% to YGOPH (P = 0.005). Among the cases of maternal deaths reported, there were 104 cases of foetal or neonatal deaths, i.e. 50%, with a significant difference in the 2 hospitals (57.4% in YCH and 28.3% in YGOPH; P < 0.001).

4. Discussion

4.1. Frequencies

The maternal mortality ratio of YCH is 2.5 times higher than that of YGOPH and 3.8 times higher than the national MM ratio of 406 per 100,000 LB [4]. While the maternal mortality ratio of YGOPH is 1.5 times higher than the national ratio. However, these ratios found in our two maternity wards are overestimated and do not reflect the reality of these services as they are centres that receive referrals from all over Yaoundé, and therefore it is difficult to extrapolate. Compared to other countries, these ratios are lower than those found by Abdourhamane M. et al. in Mali and Garba M. et al. in Niger who found 2856.35 and 2640 per 100,000 LB respectively [5] [6].

4.2. Socio-Demographic Characteristics

The majority of the deceased women in our sample were between the ages of 30 and 34. Our rate is higher than those of Ahbibi A. in Morocco et al. and Tebeu et al. in the far north of Cameroon, which found 10% and 15.9% respectively for this same age group [7] [8]. Very few adolescent girls were affected by maternal mortality in our series, with a significantly higher rate in YCH. These results could be explained by the fact that fertility among Cameroonian women in this age group remains high [4].

Married women and housewives made up the majority of deaths in our series. In fact, socio-economic level and marital status are known risk factors for maternal mortality [9] [10]. In our study, the care of women without income generating activities was largely dependent on a spouse who was often financially limited.

4.3. Obstetrical Characteristics and Pregnancy Follow-up

According to Bouhoussou MK et al. the incidence of maternal mortality increases as one moves from pauciparitis to multiparity, and from multiparity to high multiparity [11]. The average parity in the population in our study was 2.4 ± 2.1 with extremes ranging from 0 to 9. This result was similar to that of Ahbibi A. et al. [7], with almost half of the patients (42.8%) having achieved no ANC. These were women who had generally not been detected for pregnancy-related conditions and were therefore at risk of maternal mortality. This rate is close to that of Samake S. et al. in Mali [12] who found 48.38% of cases. Unattended pregnancy is a risk factor. Several authors agree that antenatal care significantly reduces the maternal death rate [7] [10].

4.4. Admission Context

The majority of our sample was referred from the surrounding private health centres. This finding was similar to those of Ahbibi A. et al. in Morocco and Mayi-Tsonga S. et al. in Gabon [7] [13]. Referrals thus appear to be more incriminated in all the deaths recorded, due to the serious condition of the patients on their arrival, and would have contributed to increasing the MM ratio in these two hospitals. Moreover, the deceased patients had been evacuated, in most cases without accompanying measures. This could be due to the insufficient qualification of certain health workers working in the referral centres in the management of serious pathologies. This worsens the prognosis for the survival of these patients.

4.5. Etiologies of Maternal Death

The causes of maternal death in the 208 cases collected during our study were divided into two categories, according to the tenth revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10) [1]: Deaths by direct obstetric causes were by far the most frequent in 84.1% of cases, with a fairly constant rate in the two hospitals studied. Haemorrhage caused the most deaths, followed by hypertension and its complications, infections and complications of anaesthesia. More specifically; At YGOPH, the leading cause of maternal death was represented by hypertensive diseases and their complications, followed by haemorrhage. Whereas in YCH, the leading cause of maternal death was represented by haemorrhage, followed by hypertensive diseases and their complications. This finding would suggest that haemorrhagic conditions would be better managed at YGOPH, whereas hypertensive conditions would be better managed at YCH. A number of African authors have made a similar observation [8] [13] [14]. These findings may be related to the low socio-economic status of the referred patients, lack of optimal antenatal follow-up or adequate surveillance during labour and postpartum, and sometimes also to the difficulty in obtaining blood for transfusion. From these figures, it appears that YCH has difficulties in managing hemorrages, while YGOPH has more difficulties in managing hypertensive diseases.

Encephalopathy was the leading indirect obstetric cause of maternal deaths in 3.4% of cases. This finding was different from those of Mayi-Tsonga S. and Tebeu PM. who found complications related to HIV infection in 31.25% and 9.5% of cases respectively. This could be explained by the significant regression in the prevalence of the infection.

4.6. Factors Contributing to Death

Although more pronounced at the HCY, it was found that slightly more than half of the cases of maternal death among those reported were related to the health services. This finding could be explained by the fact that the obstetrics and gynaecology unit at the YCH suffers from a considerable shortage of human resources, thus not allowing for prompt, efficient care and optimal monitoring. In addition, it was also noted that the blood bank in both hospitals was unable to provide the various blood products necessary for the management of critical cases.

4.7. Limits of the Study

The limitations of our study were essentially based on the poor maintenance and availability of the physical files of deceased patients. Indeed, the files in our hospitals are neither computerised nor always complete. As a result, they can be lost due to a poor archiving system, as is the case at the YCH, or due to the fact that when there is a maternal death, the files are handled by a multitude of players.

5. Conclusion

The maternal mortality ratio remains very high in the two hospitals studied, with a relatively increasing trend over the last three years. More specifically, this ratio is 2.5 times higher at YCH than at YGOPH. Maternal mortality mainly concerned young, unemployed women. The absence of ANC is a factor favouring maternal mortality. The main aetiologies of maternal deaths were haemorrhages followed by hypertensive diseases and their complications. More specifically, these aetiologies were dominated by haemorrhage in YHC and hypertensive diseases in YGOPH. The majority of deaths were largely related to health services. Fetal and perinatal mortality was high in half of the cases. Most of these differences can be explained on one hand by the fact that the YCH is the largest reference center in the city, and on the other hand its human resources and its technical facilities are in deficit compared to the YGOPH. This highlights the weakness of our health system, which still requires a lot of improvements.

Authors’ Contributions

Kamga designed the study, collected and analyzed the data. Kamga, Fouelifack, Fouedjio and Mesumbe wrote the manuscript. Foumane oversaw the process from conception to submission of the manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final version of the manuscript.

Survey Sheet

Date: …/…/…. Date of patient’s admission: …/…/…..

Cite this paper: Kamga Talom, A., Ymele, F.F., Nzene, E.M., Fouedjio, J. and Foumane, P. (2021) Maternal Mortality in Two Reference Hospitals in the City of Ya- ounde (Cam-eroon): Epidemiological, Clinical and Prognostic Aspects. Open Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 11, 610-625.

[1]   OMS (1995) Classification Statistique Internationale des Maladies et des Problèmes de santé Connexes, Dixième révision. Organisation Mondiale de la Santé, Genève Vol. 2, 139-141.

[2]   Alkema, L., Chou, D., Hogan, D., Zhang, S., Moller, A.B., Gemmill, A. et al. (2016) Global, Regional and National Levels and Trends in Maternal Mortality between 1990 and 2015, with Scenario Based Projections to 2030: A Systematic Analysis by the UN Maternal Mortality Estimation Inter-Agency Group. The Lancet, 387, 462-474.

[3]   Alastair, A., Shadi, S., Haja, W. and Sophie, W. (2017) Observatoire de la santé mondiale: La réduction de la mortalité maternelle dans les pays en développement. Bulletin de l’Organisation Mondiale de la Santé, 378, 12-30.

[4]   Institut National de la Statistique (INS) et ICF (2020) Enquête Démographique et de Santé du Cameroun 2018. Yaoundé, Cameroun et Rockville, Maryland, USA : INS et ICF: 377-385.

[5]   Abdourhamane, M. (2008) Etude de la mortalité maternelle dans le service de Gynéco-Obstétrique du CHU Gabriel Touré, de l’épidémiologie à l’audit. Thèse de Médecine, Bamako 2008-08M305 : 58-69.

[6]   Garba, M., Nayama, M., Alio, A.P., Holloway, M.L., Hamisu, B.S. and Salihu, H.M. (2011) Maternal Mortality in Niger: A Retrospective Study in a High Risk Maternity. African Journal of Medicine and Medical Sciences, 40, 393-397.

[7]   Ahbibi, A. (2015) La mortalité maternelle en réanimation obstétricale: Etude rétrospective de 123 cas. Thèse Med., Université Cadi Ayyad Faculté de Médecine et de Pharmacie de Marrakech, Marrakech.

[8]   Tebeu, P.M., Ngassa, P., Kouam, L., et al. (2007) Maternal Mortality in Maroua Provincial Hospital, Cameroon (2003-2005). West Indian Medical Journal, 56, 502-507.

[9]   Romero-Gutiérrez, G., Espitia-Vera, A., Ponce-Ponce de León, A.L. and Huerta-Vargas, L.F. (2007) Risk factors of Maternal Death in Mexico. Birth, 34, 21-25.

[10]   Tajik, P., Nedjat, S., Afshar, N.E., Changizi, N., Yazdizadeh, B., Azemikhah, A., et al. (2012) Inequality in Maternal Mortality in Iran: An Ecologic Study. International Journal of Preventive Medicine, 3, 116-121.

[11]   Bouhoussou, M.K., Djanhan, Y., Boni, S., Kone. N. and Toure, C.K. (1992) La Mortalité maternelle à Abidjan en 1988. Médecine d’Afrique Noire, 39, 480-484.

[12]   Samake, S. (2004) Mortalité maternelle et l’Anesthésie Réanimation dans les services de gynécologie-obstétrique de l’HNPG, l’HNGT et le CS Réf Com V. Thèse de doctorat en medicine, Bamako, 35.

[13]   Mayi-Tsonga, S., Ndombi, I., Oksana, L., Methogo, M., Diallo, T. and Mendome, G. (2008) Mortalité maternelle à Libreville (Gabon): état des lieux et défis à relever en 2006. Cahiers Santé, 18, 193-197.

[14]   Koudjou, T.L.B. (2008) Etude de la mortalité maternelle dans les services de gynécologie-obstétrique et d’anesthésie-réanimation au CHU du Point “G”: à propos de 73 cas. Thèse Med., Faculté de Médecine, de Pharmacie et d’Odonto-Stomatologie, Bamako.