OJPS  Vol.9 No.1 , January 2019
Independent Redistricting Commissions and Electoral Competition in the US House of Representatives
Author(s) James de Vault
This paper analyzes whether redistricting commissions impact electoral competition in the US House of Representatives. Data from the last three redistricting cycles are used to estimate a fixed-effects regression model that controls for state and time invariant effects. The model shows that independent redistricting commissions enhance electoral competition and that this effect has become stronger since the introduction of these commissions in Arizona and California. The model also shows that other types of redistricting commissions as a whole produce districts that are no more competitive than those produced by partisan-controlled legislative redistricting.
Cite this paper
Vault, J. (2019) Independent Redistricting Commissions and Electoral Competition in the US House of Representatives. Open Journal of Political Science, 9, 1-16. doi: 10.4236/ojps.2019.85001.
[1]   Abramowitz, A. I., Alexander, B., & Gunning, M. (2006). Incumbency, Redistricting, and the Decline of Competition in U.S. House Elections. The Journal of Politics, 68, 75-88.

[2]   Besley, T., & Preston, I. (2007). Electoral Bias and Policy Choice: Theory and Evidence. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 122, 1473-1510.

[3]   Bracco, E. (2013). Optimal Districting with Endogenous Party Platforms. Journal of Public Economics, 104, 1-13.

[4]   Cain, B. E. (2012). Redistricting Commissions: A Better Political Buffer? Yale Law Journal, 121, 1808-1844.

[5]   Carson, J. L., & Crespin, M. H. (2004). The Effect of State Redistricting Methods on Electoral Competition in United States House of Representatives Races. State Politics and Policy Quarterly, 4, 455-469.

[6]   Carson, J. L., Crespin, M. H., & Williamson, R. D. (2014). Reevaluating the Effects of Redistricting on Electoral Competition, 1972-2012. State Politics and Policy Quarterly, 14, 165-177.

[7]   Chen, J., & Rodden, J. (2013). Unintentional Gerrymandering: Political Geography and Electoral Bias in Legislatures. Quarterly Journal of Political Science, 8, 239-269.

[8]   Coate, S., & Knight, B. (2007). Socially Optimal Redistricting: A Theoretical and Empirical Exploration. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 122, 1409-1471.

[9]   Cottrill, J. B., & Peretti, T. J. (2013). Gerrymandering from the Bench? The Electoral Consequences of Judicial Redistricting. Election Law Journal: Rules, Politics, and Policy 12, 261-276.

[10]   Friedman, J. N., & Holden, R. T. (2008). Optimal Gerrymandering: Sometimes Pack but Never Crack. The American Economic Review, 98, 113-144.

[11]   Jacobson, G. C. (2013). The Politics of Congressional Elections (8th ed.). New Haven: Yale University Press.

[12]   Lublin, D., & McDonald, M. P. (2006). Is It Time to Draw the Line? The Impact of Redistricting on State House Elections. Election Law Journal, 5, 144-157.

[13]   Mann, T. E. (2016). We Must Address Gerrymandering.

[14]   Maskett, S. E., Winburn, J., & Wright, G. C. (2012). The Gerrymanders Are Coming! Legislative Redistricting Won’t Affect Competition or Polarization Much, No Matter Who Does It. PS: Political Science & Politics, 45, 39-43.

[15]   McDonald, M. P. (2004). A Comparative Analysis of Redistricting Institutions in the United States, 2001-02. State Politics and Policy Quarterly, 4, 371-395.

[16]   McDonald, M. P. (2006). Drawing the Line on District Competition. PS: Political Science & Politics, 39, 91-94.

[17]   Owen, G., & Grofman, B. (1988). Optimal Partisan Gerrymandering. Political Geography Quarterly, 7, 5-22.

[18]   Sherstyuk, K. (1998). How to Gerrymander: A Formal Analysis. Public Choice, 95, 27-49.

[19]   Winburn, J. (2011). Does It Matter If Legislatures or Commissions Draw the Lines? In G. Moncrief (Ed.), Reapportionment and Redistricting in the West (pp. 137-160). Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.

[20]   Yoshinaka, A., & Murphy, C. (2011). The Paradox of Redistricting: How Partisan Mapmakers Foster Competition but Disrupt Representation. Political Research Quarterly, 64, 435-447.

[21]   Washington, E. L. (2011). Do Majority Black Districts Limit Blacks’ Representation? The Case of the 1990 Redistricting (Working Paper No. 17099). National Bureau of Economic Research.